LG-AAP row: Notification illegal, says Subramanium


New Delhi, May 23 (IANS): The central government's notification giving Lt. Governor Najeeb Jung the final say in posting and transfer of Delhi government bureaucrats is "illegal and constitutional", former solicitor general Gopal Subramanium has said.

In his opinion that was sought by Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal over the Narendra Modi government's decree, the senior counsel said: "It singularly lacks propriety when the president is still seized with the question."

"It is illegal and unconstitutional; and presumably, it has been issued without the requisite presidential approval," he added.

The nine-page opinion addressed to the chief minister was sent on Friday.

The home ministry on Thursday issued a notification saying that public order, land, police and services will be under the purview of the Lt Governor.

The decree was issued following an ongoing tussle between the AAP government and Lt Governor Najeeb Jung over the appointment and transfer of bureaucrats. Both had approached the president.

 

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Lokesh, Mangalore

    Sun, May 24 2015

    Shankar, Mangalore
    'Former' solicitor general's comments on this issue is irrelevant.

    Yes.. Shakar's comments always RELEVANT since he is the most educated Indian living.

    DisAgree [3] Agree [8] Reply Report Abuse

  • RSRB, Kundapura / Singapore

    Sun, May 24 2015

    Jossey Saldanha, NY

    BJP is still there?
    Based on your comments, I thought BJP is no more.
    Please do not confuse us...

    DisAgree [3] Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • Mangalurian, Mangaluru

    Sun, May 24 2015

    An elected Government to a state is exactly like a Board is to a company.

    Just as the board is supreme, so is the elected Government in a democracy. The bureaucracy and other appointed personnel are just a tool of the elected Government.

    But the notifications given by the Central Government to the Delhi Government insist that, so long as Delhi is concerned, it is the Bureaucracy and appointed persons who will dictate terms to the elected Government.

    The Bureaucracy and the elected Government are not accountable to people. We all know that.

    But the two supreme leaders of the Central Government, who managed to win 3 seats in Delhi, are not interested in these details!

    They want to make all the appointments in Delhi.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [9] Reply Report Abuse

  • Elroy, Karkala

    Sun, May 24 2015

    I feel the constitution is a big comedy book ever. Neither it helping in Law order of criminals nor the politicians. Big shots are taken to the court and they come out like heroes. Its a comedy for others. It can only put a poor fellow inside jail. Our PMs visit lot of countries till now none of them tried to implement or study the law and order system of other countries. We still follow 1947 laws. We dont have brains to implement a law system which addresses the crimes of today. No government wants to look on them. Even the people dont accept a honest persons rising like Kejriwal. You can see the comments here indicate that. There is a difference between chaiwala and a IIT graduate. At least value his education dont comment nonsense. If somebody is standing beyond something with true intention support him. Dont use Indian mentality everywhere. This mentality is killing our nation

    DisAgree [3] Agree [10] Reply Report Abuse

  • Krishna, karkala

    Sun, May 24 2015

    Kejri wal and Sasodia proposed two names ( K K Shrama and Shakuntala Gamlin) which in legal terms means they are Ok with either of these become acting chief secretary.
    If Shakuntala Gamlin is corrupt, why did Kujli propose her name?
    LG s one of them and Kujli cries foul?
    LG s Shakuntala Gamlin based on her seniority and track record.

    This is an insult to LG. AAP is on failure path. They do not believe in collaborative working, LG is first citizen of Delhi.
    Kujli is responsible for the crisis. He blames Modi for everything.

    DisAgree [27] Agree [6] Reply Report Abuse

  • Gudana, mangalore

    Sun, May 24 2015

    Bjp is digging its own grave...its matter of time...

    DisAgree [5] Agree [25] Reply Report Abuse

  • Shankar, Mangalore

    Sun, May 24 2015

    'Former' solicitor general's comments on this issue is irrelevant.

    DisAgree [25] Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse

  • Krishna, karkala

    Sun, May 24 2015

    Sooner or later Kejriwal's arrogance and ego will destroy him

    DisAgree [26] Agree [6] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr Indian, Mlore/London

    Sun, May 24 2015

    What about your 56 inch chest feku? Not egoistic? Anyone with a average IQ should understand that talking about chest size in a election campaign is as egoistic and stupid as it gets.blind bhakths still don't understand!

    DisAgree [3] Agree [6] Reply Report Abuse

  • Krishna, karkala

    Sun, May 24 2015

    Kejriwal known for his drama.
    He always behaves like a victim. On the contrary he the main culprit of all the crisis.
    LG had ed Shakuntal Gamin based on her seniority and track record.
    There is no favor or politics in LG's decision.
    It only ego of Kujli was hurt.
    LG is just following the text book of constitution.

    Kejri should understand the meaning of constitution and he is not above it.
    He has no business to insult LG or the honest IAS officer Shakuntala Gamlin.

    If Kejri continues fight with IAS officer the entire system will collapse.He will never be able govern the state.

    If he wants to function Kejri should keep his ego aside try to sort out the difference of with LG.

    DisAgree [24] Agree [6] Reply Report Abuse

  • Sachidanand Shetty, Mundkur/Dubai

    Sun, May 24 2015

    Why you want to consult former solicitor general? Of course he will say unconstitutional….unless he became solicitor general again

    DisAgree [25] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • Santan Mascarenhas, Kinnigoli/Mumbai

    Sun, May 24 2015

    Aye bhai, zara dheke chalo

    O, big brother BJP
    Look around what you do

    In this circus called sarkar
    There is no one, big or small

    Everyone has to respect all
    Law of land applies to all

    We came crying & will go crying
    What we do only we be carrying

    Wishing your and Kejriwal sarkar
    Love and respect for each other

    DisAgree [5] Agree [28] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr S kamath, Mumbai

    Sun, May 24 2015

    See how the media is painting the story .It was LG and Kejri who went to President for solution of their conflict .President sought opinion from Home ministery .Home ministry had to write a letter which will be stamped by President and then sent to CM of Delhi .This is as per constituition and Media is portraying as Rajnath singhs letter to Kejri.

    DisAgree [28] Agree [10] Reply Report Abuse

  • Langoolacharya., Belman/Washington,DC.

    Sun, May 24 2015


    Dr S kamath, Mumbai,

    President of India can ask Supreme Court its legal opinion directly...if he thinks this is a dispute between Union and State...

    ...JH...

    DisAgree [3] Agree [29] Reply Report Abuse

  • Vincent Rodrigues, Katapadi/B'lore

    Sun, May 24 2015

    Better allow the elected government to rule Delhi and the Governor to do the duty as his counter parts in other states do.

    DisAgree [4] Agree [27] Reply Report Abuse

  • Eric Coelho, Mangalore

    Sun, May 24 2015

    BJP at Centre came to power in May, 2014 and the 1st achievement they had is to curtail the powers of Delhi ACB. Their 2nd achievement was to pass another notification on May 22, 2015 further curtailing the powers of Delhi Govt. Both these notifications/achievement are illegal and fraud on the constitution. But AAP will never stand by it and will go ahead with their work side lining the notifications. The 3rd achievement of BJP at centre was all Jumlas i.e., U Turn party. People now have clearly understood that modi and BJP are nothing a party of liars, jumlas and U turn. I hope in Bihar election the people will vote for sensible leaders. In Delhi the country needed a tough leader and the Delhi people right elected AK. To handle people who are corrupted and hard core thieves who rob people taxes AK is the best leader. He has said "Till hell I will chase corrupted people". BJP and congress are feeling the heat because all their business contracts through Delhi government has come to a stand still. There used to be touts outside secretariats, RTO stopped, hafta by police stopped, hafta at check post stopped, water mafia stopped. Just imagine the huge revenue that these leaders used to make and within 100 days stopped. Great going AAP to teach corrupted leaders in BJP and congress

    DisAgree [5] Agree [28] Reply Report Abuse

  • Krishna, karkala

    Sun, May 24 2015

    Dear Mr Coehlo

    The LG of Delhi did nothing wrong.
    He has been asked to one of the two candidates recommended by the Kejriwal government.

    LG ed Shakuntala Gamlin.

    How could AK make an issue out it.

    If Ms Gamlin had a tinted career she should not have been recommended.

    AK is an immature fool.
    He should learn to respect others. He has shown most civilized behaviour towards woman IAS officer which totally unacceptable as a CM

    DisAgree [5] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • Krishna, karkala

    Sun, May 24 2015

    "illegal and constitutional", former solicitor general Gopal Subramanium has said......

    It is hard to understand the meaning of solicitor General's statement. Is he trying to say that Constitution is illegal. >

    DisAgree [24] Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse

  • gm, mlur

    Sun, May 24 2015

    Read complete sentence then comment.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [18] Reply Report Abuse

  • SAMPATH, KARWAR

    Sat, May 23 2015

    FOR GOOD GOVERNANCE AND CLEAN GOVERNMENT DELHI CM ARVIND KEJRIWAL MAY BE OUR NEXT "PM" GOOD PERFORMANCE IN DELHI

    DisAgree [3] Agree [25] Reply Report Abuse

  • ibrahim/yanbu, ksa

    Sat, May 23 2015

    BJP must take revenge at least in this way know? So Aravind will loose. Jung will be in upper hand

    DisAgree [4] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • G.Fernandes, Mangalore/UAE

    Sat, May 23 2015

    Both the opposition parties in centre playing a dirty game with the help of LG. They are scared of Muffler man. The true colour will shine soon. Mr Kejriwal is on right track and a talented man. No party/Governance can break the constitutional rules and amendments. BJP will dig its own grave.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [19] Reply Report Abuse

  • Valerian D'souza, Udupi / Mumbai

    Sat, May 23 2015

    In the wake former solicitor general Gopal Subramanium's statement, it reveals how greedy and power hungry Lt. Governor Najeeb Jung and Narendra Modi government is.
    They have exposed them all over India and the world.
    And moreover they say, India's image has changed all over the world.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [23] Reply Report Abuse

  • Declan, Mumbai

    Sun, May 24 2015

    Valerian,
    LG Najeeb Jung may be a Congress appointee but as of now he is nothing more than a puppet in the hands of the Modi/BJP government who have demonstrated their greed for power.
    I dont think Jung is greedy for his post. He is just following orders. He just wants his job and therefore he is obeying the BJP high command.
    BJP are unable to counter AAP's popularity in Delhi hence they are doing whatever they can to discredit the AAP.

    DisAgree [5] Agree [20] Reply Report Abuse

  • Sethu, Manalore

    Sat, May 23 2015

    Modi and BJP is busy celebrating first anniversary in power. If they continue to pay scant respect to constitution and democratically elected bodies, celebration of second anniversary will remain a mirage. Ten Modys together cannot revive the party in future. Notwithstanding the recent damage control exercise conducted by the Mody loyalists, anti-people legislation has already taken its toll and has moved BJP away from people. For arm-twisting AAP Government and fooling the Delhi voters, BJP may have to further pay a heavy price!!!!!

    DisAgree [1] Agree [16] Reply Report Abuse

  • Anil, dubai

    Sat, May 23 2015

    I think the home ministry and the home minister needs to read, understand and educate themselves about indian constitution. Let them know now its not chaddi constitution to go the way they want. Shame on central government who is talking big fekuism without little basic knowledge of constitutional rights. Pitty on people who voted for feku chaddi party going behind blindly with orange colour.....all that glitters Iis not gold and all all white is not milk.

    DisAgree Agree [17] Reply Report Abuse

  • ca girishkk, m'lore/dxb

    Sat, May 23 2015

    It is Goliath(NDA) vs David(AAP) fight.., and everyone knows who wins the fight...,

    DisAgree Agree [23] Reply Report Abuse

  • Jossey Saldanha, NY

    Sat, May 23 2015

    WHERE DO WE DUMP BJP ...

    DisAgree [1] Agree [21] Reply Report Abuse

  • Langoolacharya., Belman/Washington,DC.

    Sat, May 23 2015

    People,

    This notification shows Pettiness and moral bankruptcy of BJP and its leadership nothing else...

    They will get a kick on their butt in 2019...have no doubt's about it...

    Only AAP and Kejriwal can teach BJP a good lesson...

    ...JH...

    DisAgree [8] Agree [103] Reply Report Abuse

  • vellano1, Mumbai

    Sat, May 23 2015

    HAHA..we will cross that bridge when we come to it!

    but are you going by what Gopal subramaniam says..? he is not even soli sorabjee kind of authoritarian voice!.. this Gopal, has heart burn because, he was never allowed to be Supreme court judge by NDA!and just see how many faux pass he has made when he was ASG himself! the triuvantapuram vault case itself is clear example, what a messy suggestion he gave to the govt of the day back then!... in any case, let Kejri contest this in supreme court, to have a clear understanding!. in last few days, he has hurled series of accusation against LG, transfers, IAS cadre , central govt, Modi and everyone! truth is , he wont last till 2019! finding ways to run away!... and If he ever completes 2 years, just by being there, forget doing any work or accomplishing his promises, JUST STAY AS Cm for 2 more years.. I will VOTE CONGRESS, forver in my life!! (which I never know I will ever do)!

    DisAgree [26] Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • Langoolacharya., Belman/Washington,DC.

    Sun, May 24 2015

    vellano1, Mumbai,

    Arvind Kejriwal is not Modi or Rajnut...he single handedly built AAP party with few dedicated people...he is much more smart than them...

    Vajpayee and Advani built BJP...even Jan Sangh was there even prior to that...Modi and Rajnut joined an existing party...

    An elected CM of a non-full fledged state Delhi is not slave of PM or HM ...watch special session of assembly of Delhi assembly on Tuesday and Wednesday...I am sure he will make Modi and BJP fully naked in front of the nation... and your BJP wont be able to even file a Gadkari like defamation suite, because he has immunity from prosecution for whatever he says in assembly...

    Worst thing one can do in life (and BJP is doing here) is underestimating your enemies...and you and BJP is doing exactly the same...you will know where BJP stands when this is completely unfolded...

    ...JH...

    DisAgree [3] Agree [31] Reply Report Abuse

  • Krishna, karkala

    Sun, May 24 2015

    Arvind Kejriwal is not Modi or.....Languchray.

    AAP is built by Anna Hazare & Prashant Bushan.

    Kejri kicked them out sat in the Prime seat.

    DisAgree [22] Agree [4] Report Abuse

  • ca girishkk, m'lore/dxb

    Sun, May 24 2015

    Krishna,
    Anna & Prashant bushan were the BJP/RSS proxies/spy's (FEKU volunteers).
    AAP handled them well & shown them the door where they can better fit.

    DisAgree [3] Agree [17] Report Abuse

  • Declan, Mumbai

    Sun, May 24 2015

    ca girishkk, m'lore/dxb
    Absolutely true, Anna, PB (Prashant Bhushan), KB (Kiran Bedi) & VK Singh turned out to be BJP agents !
    There is doubt on Kumar Vishwas's loyalty as well. I hope it turns out to be untrue but only time will tell.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [13] Report Abuse

  • vellano1, Mumbai

    Sun, May 24 2015

    that is the reason, you wont understand Democracy, cadre based parties, party structure! guess it is too much for you, as you have seen family owned congress all along! BJP and Jan sangh are ideology and ppl just carry forward ideology and leaders with trust in it are chosen!... Kejriwal kinds are Hitlers nazi party.. use people and throw them once ur dream comes true!.. u will see more of it in few days..

    I am happy though, that he is succesful, because, his success is at expense of congress! vhe vhe vhe.. Congis supported him during AAP1 and later cut his funds, once he became a monster in AAP2 time! he got funds from arab sheikhs and OYC, so now he is decimating congress totally!.. congress which once ruled delhi for 15 yrs with sheila is struggling for its revival, forget other states like bihar, UP, where there is no base for it! But kejri looks good to you all cos, he is irritating MODI! he was once a badboy when UPA was in power!..

    I am happy that he has called a urgent session, not to pass lokpal, but to bitch about Modi and Jung! Even more happy since, there are no tress inside assembly and no one will create "Suicide drama" and his aaptards will be sitting at home instead of creating ruckus!.. No Dharna whatsoever!... best part of Kejri is "before people start complaining and protests about their demands, he himself does a demand protest at his higher ups" seeing which ppl sy, marne do yaar, ye khud fasa hai, humein kya help karega!.. so he has made a "CM post" helpless, just cos of his ego! vhe vhe vhe

    DisAgree [5] Agree [2] Report Abuse

  • Justin, Malegaon

    Sun, May 24 2015

    Langool your the best buddy!

    DisAgree [2] Agree [21] Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: LG-AAP row: Notification illegal, says Subramanium



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.