Jaitley compares Indira Gandhi to Hitler


New Delhi, Jun 25 (IANS): Union Minister Arun Jaitley on Monday compared former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, who imposed Emergency, to Hitler, stating that both used the Constitution "to transform democracy into dictatorship".

Jaitley, whose second blog of a three-part series coincided with the 43rd anniversary of imposition of the Emergency, also noted that unlike the German dictator, Gandhi went ahead to transform India into a "dynastic democracy".

"Both Hitler and Gandhi never abrogated the Constitution. They used a republican Constitution to transform democracy into dictatorship," he said.

The BJP leader said Gandhi imposed Emergency under Article 352, suspended fundamental rights under Article 359 and claimed that disorder was planned by the opposition.

Jaitley said Hitler, who became the German Chancellor on January 30, 1933, got his President to invoke Article 48 of the country's Constitution which gave emergency powers for the "protection of people in the State".

"The decree giving emergency powers put restrictions on personal liberty, free speech... The pretext for imposition of Emergency was that on February 27, 1933, German Parliament House, known as 'Reichstag', had been set on fire.

"Hitler claimed that it was a communist conspiracy to burn Government buildings and museums. Thirteen years later, in the Nuremberg trials, it was established that Reichstag fire was the handiwork of Nazis and Goebbels had conceived it."

He said Hitler arrested most opposition MPs.

"Indira Gandhi arrested most opposition MPs and, therefore, procured, through their absence, a two-third majority of members present and voting and enabling the passage of several obnoxious provisions through Constitution amendments," Jaitley said.

The BJP leader said the 42nd Amendment diluted the power of High Courts to issue writ petitions, "a power which Dr. (B.R.) Ambedkar had said was the very heart and soul of India's Constitution".

"They also amended Article 368 so that a Constitution amendment was beyond judicial review. There were a few things that Hitler did not do which Gandhi did.

"She prohibited the publication of Parliamentary proceeding in the media. The law which gave mandate to the media for publishing Parliamentary proceedings was popularly known as the Feroze Gandhi Bill," he said.

Since Hitler's own election has been set aside, he had no change to make in this regard.

"Gandhi amended both the Constitution and the Representation of People Act. The Constitution amendment made the election of the Prime Minister non-justiciable before a court.

"The Representation of People Act was retrospectively amended to insert those provisions so that the invalid election of Gandhi could be validated by changes in law."

He said amendments to the constitution made during Emergency were later reversed by the Janata Party government.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • geoffrey, hat hill

    Tue, Jun 26 2018

    Mrs Gandhi's most decisive action was 1971 - splitting Pakistan into two which kept Paj in their place until Kargil (BJP government).

    Mrs Gandhi never went on blowing her trumpet about 1971for the rest for her life, like Feku and gang does about the much hyped surgical strikes, authenticity of which is still remains a question mark especially in the light of UNO's denial about it.

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Lily Grace D Silva, Mangalore/Mumbai/Dubai

    Tue, Jun 26 2018

    Mr.Jaitley, you are suppose to take good rest.
    Now about emergency, the topic you are taking, we can only say, its happening now. What was at the time of Late Mrs. Indira Gandhi, it may the necessary step taken, and we people were safe and in peace among all caste and creed.

    Have you really seen what is happening in each corner of this country? Please, now stop criticizing the living and dead and start doing something for the welfare of the people of this country. We the people of this country peace and harmony among people.

    DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rita, Germany

    Tue, Jun 26 2018

    Why this issue now?During htis emergency time I came to India first time and I didnt have much problem .Only rice was not available to buy in shops,but we managed to get somehow.I think time now is worse than emergency time.One cant compare Indira to Hitler.Hitler was a military man.

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • leslie, udupi

    Tue, Jun 26 2018

    Facts are sacred
    Comments are free
    No leader was killed between 1975 to 77
    Lots of bad elements went inside
    Had idli sambar and came out
    But Modi ensured surgical killings by Godhra
    Madam captain is also out today
    Kuch na kaho
    Kuch Bi na kaho

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Ayes. P, kuda/ksa

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    Indira is better.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • mahesh, Mangalore

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    The first thing you need to know about emergency is -
    During emergency, Fundamental Rights are suspended. This means that the state can take any action and people have no recourse. During emergency thousands of people from the opposition were arrested and put behind bars without a trial. The press had absolutely no freedom to report. There was extreme censorship. Extreme measures like forced mass sterilization were conducted. The state policies were implemented completely.
    This in short is what happened in Emergency.

    DisAgree [8] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • 57"Chest, Mangalore

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    BJP blind dumb Bhakt talking about Fundamental Rights, What a Joke!?!?!?..First of all do you respect and observe fundamental rights of those Indians oppose you. You are against constitution. You want to rewrite constitution of India. Present situation in India of 4 years is worse than 2 months of emergency in 1976.

    DisAgree Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • Jenifer, Mangalore

    Tue, Jun 26 2018

    Mr.Mahesh,

    Because Indira was HITLER, she handled Pakistan and Zia-Ul-Haq in a way it/he should have been. She made East Pakistan into Bangladesh. That is why, India is India today, not engulfed by Pakistan on both ends. She meticulously handled so many wars with neighbours, today our soldiers are martyred more everyday but the borders are still porous.

    If you want approve of her to handling the hardcore on the outer side of the nation, she will surely be the same to the inner forces too ? Well, she accepted the result given by the people for her Hitler-giri - she was ousted. She survived in the opposition and came defiant and her next government was mellowed down. Not that he was like Idi-Ameen or Saddam - she brought many reforms too. What India is today, is because of the scheme her government brought. You guys who question 'What the previous government did since independence' will never be there after 2019 because all that she didn't do to harm the nation in all those years is done in just one term of Modi.

    One example ? Demonetization ! It did not bring any goodies that the gentleman anticipated. No black money confiscation, no stoppage of in-flow of fake currency, no stoppage of terror funding. Only that the Middle class people who deposited beyond 2.5 L are getting IT notices and the nation incurred several millions to print new noted as well as to discard demonetized currency..

    Oh Yes ! BJP Offices nationwide got their black money converted and Bihar elections funding by non-BJP parties was curtailed. Rest, all cow, cow, cow. Export cow, but protect her within when the citizens want some cheap meat. Nothing else.

    DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • mahesh, Mangalore

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    Anyone who is defending the emergency doesn't seem to get it.
    Sad.

    DisAgree [10] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • j.anata, Mangaluru / Bengaluru

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    Congress is the party that imposed EMERGENCY in India for 2 long years!

    DisAgree [5] Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • PEDDA GUNDA, MANGALURU

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    Indira Gandhi and Modi nowhere matching even entire BJPeeee and RSS personalities ( including todays congress guys )

    Indira is Indira and she was just synonymous of BHARAT MATHA // Hey jooten jaitely or kately dont even dream about her persona !

    DisAgree [2] Agree [15] Reply Report Abuse

  • Bethala, Big Banyan Tree

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    Agreed, but we have Idi Amin today at the helm.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [20] Reply Report Abuse

  • gabriel, sagar

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    What is said about the events of nearly 40 years ago is nothing but the repetition that is taking place amidst us at this present times. Honorable minister is self-projecting the reflection of the present governance.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [12] Reply Report Abuse

  • Bennaje, Mumbai

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    Jootley should check with people today who is the real Hitler? Indira Gandhi laid her life for our country. How many of your chelas from RSS including yourself, PM and Omitji are ready to sacrifice your life for our country? Have guts? The real Hitler is todays trio - PM, Omitji and Jootley. Collectively, you looted India, took 2 more Modi's as PM's delegates out of the country safely, created worst communal atmosphere in India since Independence and ensured EVM's are in your pockets and you have the guts to call Indiraji as a Hitler? Wash your face with Goddess Cow and have some dung as your food as your brains are filled with nothing but cow dung. By the way anyone who reads my comment should check this website: https://youtu.be/QJpXxlaAf8U or IndiaEVM.org to learn how BJPEE cheated every Indian voter.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [22] Reply Report Abuse

  • mahesh, Mangalore

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    The very fact that You are talking against Modi and not getting arrested and put in jail means we have a free press and freedom of speech.
    Dont defend Emergency.

    DisAgree [16] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • Bennaje, Mumbai

    Tue, Jun 26 2018

    Mahesh, since Modi is not putting me behind the bars, probably you should do the job for him!

    By the way, what we have today is undeclared emergency which is worse than emergency.

    Today, free hand is given to the dirtiest scum to do what they want - rape small kids to ripe old grandma's, lynch, attack tourists especially single lady tourists and kill them. Attack religious places, suffocate minorities. Target selective raids, hold the entire press for ransom. Loot middle class and lower class people by taxing them to death....and the list goes on added to that run the biggest IT cell to tarnish and eliminate opposition so that the Hitler can rule with iron hand. I will not be surprised, if this rule continues, you too will be scorched by the heat forget the fire. Mahesji...use your brains, keep your eyes wide open.

    I too voted for Modi in 2014 and I am laughing at my owns stupidity.

    DisAgree Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • RonRon, udupi

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    had she alive, this guy wouldn't have courage to stand near to that brave lady.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [22] Reply Report Abuse

  • Sheikh M, Mangalore

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    Jaitley ,
    Remember 3000 people murdered in Gujarath on 2002 , Did you forget so soon ?
    The title under Modi's name, No one born to replace Modi

    DisAgree Agree [19] Reply Report Abuse

  • HENRY MISQUITH, Bahrain

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    If so then who is Jootly. A person who cannot win an election commenting on Indira Gandhi's emergency. You are looser Jootly, get proper treatment for your mind.

    DisAgree Agree [19] Reply Report Abuse

  • S. Francis, udupi

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    A person whose leader and his party itself is a follower of Mussolini & Hitlers fascist ideology, is now tells the world that Indira Gandhi was like Hitler. Jaitley, if you say Indira Gandhi was like hitler, then what your leaders is, who has controlled all the media, EC, CBI, Judiciary, IT. Can we say he is ruling the government in democratic way. You people want to hide your failure by passing such derogatory comments, so that you will succeed in diverting the core issues what Indians are facing. You destroyed the whole Indian Economy and now trying to divert peoples mind. But remember, Indians are not fools. You can fool the fools, but not the intelligent.

    DisAgree Agree [17] Reply Report Abuse

  • mahesh, Mangalore

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    In India, "the Emergency" refers to a 21-month period from 1975 to 1977 when Prime Minister Indira Gandhi had a State of Emergency declared across the country. the Emergency was in effect from 25 June 1975 until its withdrawal on 21 March 1977.
    For much of the Emergency, most of Gandhi's political opponents were imprisoned and the press was censored.
    And Also following things happened -
    Detention of people by police without charge or notification of families
    Abuse and torture of detainees and political prisoners
    Use of public and private media institutions, like the national television network.
    Forced sterilisation.
    Destruction of the slum and low-income housing in the Turkmen Gate and Jama Masjid area of old Delhi.
    Large-scale and illegal enactment of law

    DisAgree [8] Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • geoffrey, hat hill

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    The lady with steel nerves always walked her talk. Notwithstanding some extremities during emergency, hundreds of smugglers and black marketeers were incarcerated at the same time, unlike what we see today- fraudsters' safe exit with the loot is facilitated followed by fake promises to bring them to book.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [16] Reply Report Abuse

  • mahesh, Mangalore

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    You probably didn't understand what it meant to be under emergency.
    Blind faith to a family leads to this.

    DisAgree [12] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • ayes p., kudla/ksa

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    That was declared emergency and present situation is undeclared emergency

    DisAgree Agree [19] Reply Report Abuse

  • mahesh, Mangalore

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    There is no such thing as undeclared.
    its either there or not.

    DisAgree [13] Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ayes. P, kuda/ksa

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    Everybody knows declared or undeclared except bhakts.

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Ronald D, Udupi

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    Jootlyji, how long you people will keep crying about her? She solved Punjab problem in a stroke. If she was alive for couple of more decades, Kashmir problem was non existent!! She taught Paki's an ever lasting memory and lesson!! You do any circus...you can not defame her!
    India has never seen a bold lady like Indira and may not be easy in near future too! Such powerful and courageous person is born once in few centuries!!!! She was well educated too!

    DisAgree Agree [17] Reply Report Abuse

  • 57"Chest, Mangalore

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    Today we are living in a worst emergency situation than 43 years ago. That emergency was much better than today's BJP's emergency like situation. There was progress, accountability and much better law and order situation and people were disciplined compared today's BJP's communal, scam, corruption, criminal and dictatorial ideological rule of cow govt. For minorities and anti BJP people it's dooms day and are living in hell.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [44] Reply Report Abuse

  • Flavian, Mangaluru/Kuwait

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    And you people (BJP) is winning elections by bringing religioun (Hindutva) & Cow sentiments in the main stream.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [39] Reply Report Abuse

  • Flavian, Mangaluru/Kuwait

    Mon, Jun 25 2018

    If Indira Gandhi was alive, she would have rewarded you with a right gift to remember life long! Were you hiding in rat hole that time ?

    DisAgree [2] Agree [41] Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Jaitley compares Indira Gandhi to Hitler



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.