Cong to Amitabh: Do you Endorse Modi's 'role' in Gujarat Riots?


NEW DELHI, Mar 29 (PTI): Firing a salvo at Amitabh Bachchan, Congress on Monday asked whether he endorses Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi's "role" in the 2002 "pogrom" or condemns it.

"Does he (Amitabh) condemn the role of Narendra Modi in the 2002 Gujarat pogrom of 2002 or he endorses it?...What does he say about the Gujarat massacre and fake encounters that took place since Modi took over," Congress spokesperson Manish Tewari asked at a briefing here.

His salvo at the brand ambassador of Gujarat came after Modi hit out at Congress, saying those opposing Bachchan were "taliban of untouchability".

Tewari said "if he (Bachchan) is sensible and right-thinking, he will come out strongly against it (the riots)."

He said Bachchan "should not build the Chinese Wall between Modi and the sands of Rann of Kutch by justifying" brand ambassadorship of Gujarat.

Tewari said the Congress' Gujarat unit had raised important questions and the central unit endorses those concerns.

Earlier, Union Information and Broadcasting Minister Ambika Soni lashed out at Modi for dubbing Bachchan's opponents as taliban, saying he was a "frustrated" Chief Minister after his marathon questioning by the SIT in connection with a post-Godhara riots case.

"I can understand Modi is feeling very, very frustrated because for the first time in 63 years, a Chief Minister elected by the people of the country is being made to stand before the Special Investigating Team for about 10 hours in a question and answer session," the Congress leader said on the sidelines of a function by Seva Dal, a party wing, here.

"This has apparently frustrated him to use the word Taliban in a light and flippant manner. Those who have been victims of Taliban, know what Taliban is. He has used the word Taliban so lightly. He should make such statements with some seriousness," she said.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • malcolm, Mangalore / Valsad-Gujarat

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    Dear Shahanawaz Kukkikatte,
    Your Comment itself is a eye opener this time . It is the fact that Gujrati people ( all religion) already came out from 2002 incidents as sikhs came out from 1984 incidents. No takers here in Gujarat for One sided blaming.In Our country we have 2 brands - Cong and BJP. The BJP barnd items - Gujrat riots , Kandamal , Pub attack , Farmers Shoot , Church attack , Babri demo etc - There are more takers for this . But The Cong Brands - 1984 sikh Butchering , Oil for food natvar scam , kashmiri pundit,emergency , Gorkha - Naga - Ulfa problems , corruption , spectrum , ND tiwari, naxalism , allowing to perform puja at babri masjid - No takers at all in this democratic nation . How sad...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Arun CK, Mangalore Dubai

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    Mr Shanawaz
    Then what is the proof about Modi's role in Gujrath Riots ?..Where is the proof for that ?..Is he proven guilty ?...Is he indicted. Any TOm Dic or Harry can complain and open a FIR againstr anyone in India. But that doesnt make them a culprit. If anyone beleieves in law should agree that Modi is not criminal untill now. Atleast Supreme court is not under anyones control to indict him. Please make your stand firm about proof for eveything.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Miss.Suman, Dubai

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    Please dont bring The Great Mother Theresa into your dirty political comments. Got itt..?!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • yousuf, Gangolli-KSA

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    Once again, Shahnawazm kukkikatte, there is a saying in urdu " AQALMAND KO ISHARA KAAFI HOTA HAI". If you cannot it's up to you bhai. I can't argue with you.I gave up. Viewers like NAGESH NAYAK will appreciate yr comments. KEEP IT UP.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Gladson, Brahmavar

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    Manish Tewary is spot on just as he is most of the times. Amitab has to clear what is he endorsing? Is he endorsing a part of Gujrath or Gujrath as a whole? Is he brand ambassador of Gujrath industries, Amul, development or also the ambassador of Gujrath as a complete entity? If he is called an ambassador of Gujrath, then it means that he endorses Gujrath completely wherever he goes. When one takes Gujrath as one entity no one can just ignore the infamous Godhra. Remember Amir Khan endorsing Coca Cola. When he was asked whether he knows about the harm Coca Cola causes, he was mum.

    Just as a person endorsing a product, endorses the product entirely, a person endorsing a state does endorse the state in whole and not in part. If he is endorsing in part, he cannot be called the brand ambassador of state. Rather call him ambassador of Amul or a district or whatever it is. Just as a CM of the state is CM for entire state and not limited to a part of it, to a particular religion, creed, faith or industry, a brand ambassador too cannot deny that is representing the entire state. Amitab should come clear in this matter since he is an icon and every icon is answerable to the society which has made him an icon. If AmItab says that he is not endorsing Godhra, it also means that he is not endorsing Gujrath because just as development and industries are part of Gujrath, religious intolerance & divide has become part of Gujrath post Godhra. Hope he is not in for another Big B (Big Blunder)

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Shammi, Karnataka

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    Amitabh is a great Actor,but HE IS NOT GREAT HUMAN BEING.By becoming Ambassador of Gujrath ,he is not giving ANY alms to them.   IN INDIA SO FAR I FOUND ONLY 1 GREAT HUMAN BEING WHO WAS NOT IN THE CATEGORY OF JEALOUSY,EGO,GREEDY N MANY MORE.
    SHE WAS ICON OF INDIA-DATS MOTHER THERESA.I AGREE BY BIRTH SHE WAS NT INDIAN,BUT SHE STRUGGLED FOR INDIANS.
    THOSE WHO SAY 'AMITABH' IS ICON OF INDIA ARE JUST INSULTING MOTHER THERESA N HER DEEDS.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Joseph F. Gonsalves, Bannur,Puttur/Mangalore

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    Dear Mr. Nagesh Nayak,
    Answer the following:
    1) Why did you feel guilty when I mentioned about Hemamalini?
    2) Do I comment Amitab Bachan is good or bad and I have just mentioned about all the cine starts including Amitab Bachan. Read my comments properly (even a child will also understand).
    3) When an actor, cricketer, poet acting well/playing well, writing well which means he may be good or bad and I am not a judge to judge Amitabbachan is good/bad and Hemamaline is good or bad.
    4) When some or more people are fans of cine actors which doesn’t mean I/people have to follow those cine stars (Peoples likeness and right).
    5) You are an agent of bjp and you just act like only an agent of bjp but I am only a supporter of congress and I have pointed out both bjp’s and congress weak points.
    6) Use some commonsense and do not write blindly.
    7) Are you a south Indian or a north Indian or an INDIAN. or only Karanataka person, lover of kannada those who rule bjp and supporters are only Indians? Kindly explain.
    8) Finally, All the cine stars and politicians are evading tax to government. Only the government salaried people are paying accurate tax payment.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ASHOK, Udupi/Dubai

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    Mr. Shahnawaz kukkikatte, dubai/udupi - nothing left , you answered all the questions. Thank you.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • l.Fernandes, goa/mumbai

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    Bollywood stars says I LOVE MUMBAI,who has given me love,money,gold,cars,bunglow and lifestyle.But what have they given back to Mumbai?By not being an ambassador of Mumbai or building a charitable hospital like Tatas to the people of Maharashtra?How much has Amitabh Bachaan given back to Maharashtra or for India by looking after a village for their
    needs.Can he not donate one crore he gets per episode of TV shows to India.Why has he deserted his good friend(brother) Amar Singh?He should be loyal to his image of a star.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Lokanath.D, Bantwal/Iran

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    Now it is the time for congress,globe is round.once upon a time Big B was a congress MP,when that time what he was done to society,it was good for the society,now he is a saffron ambassidar for Gujarath,so it is is not digisting to cong.Massacre ...it is big joke...1984 sikh massacre...will cong endorse....the responsible person was suppose to be the cong MP candiate for the last general election if there was no oppostion from sikh community.ultimatly voters endorsement is final and supreme in democracy.This is great India.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ramesh, udupi/dubai

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    I didn't expect this from Congress Party. Those who are supporting congress now relaized that both congress & BJP are political party. they can reach what ever the level to get power. I just want one answer from congress if Amitabh was a brand ambassador of congress ruled state same issue will raise what happened in mumbai.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • shahnawaz kukkikatte, dubai/udipi

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    Mr Yousuf/KSA,


    Can you make it clear to me whether or not Mr Bachhan endorsed blood shed and violence in Gujarat. If yes, please give me the proof, then I will change my opinion on him. Until I see the proof I will not change my opinion on him. At the same time you have right for your opinion and I respect it. As far as I know, Mr Bachhan only endorsed the economic development and not blood path.

    By the way what do you say about Kashmir???

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • RAMESH, GUJARAT, DUBAI

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    MR.Amitab you are a great hero and actor you don't make a simple problem in our country, please go back Gujarat.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sudhir, Kundapur/USA

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    Lata Mangeshkar is singing the theme song for the celebration of Swarnim Gujarat celebration (50 years of Gujarat formation). Lets see what CON party will say then

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sudhir, Mangalore

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    If Modi cant become ambassador of Gujrat then noone should become ambassador of Delhi because after Indira Gandhis death even delhi people killed so many sikhs under congress govt. Why this double standard from Congress. I know all congressmen will not support but when Madam Sonia gives order all congressmen accept her word .

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ISMAIL K PERINJE, PERINJE/YANBU-KSA

    Tue, Mar 30 2010

    Amitab is public figure and he should maintain his caliber.The issue is not between cong and Amitab but Amitab and public.He is pucca politician and by profession he is an actor.By accepting Guj and Kerala (later withdrwan the proposal by Kerala Govt)brand ambassadar,I think he simply belives in his bank balance.(Communist/Sanghparivar don't mind)

    He is a great actor but not model ambassadar of any kind.Cong asked him a good question and it's his duty to clear the stand.One of the reader mentioned,he is not corrupt and him I want remind him he was involeved in a land grabing case in UP by fraudlent means and when it was exposed he returned to govt.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Tony Pinto, Manglore - Mumbai

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    Stupid question from Congress seems Mr.Amitabh participated in RIOTS activities very POOR show from Congress Next election Congress will have to go on GOD BLESSING

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • safdar, Manglore

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    Amitabh is a acter he is paying for this.which he is acting Know is he is losing is respect and Idol

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • yousuf, Gangolli KSA

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    Mr.Alvera Alvares Mumbai, really appreciate yr comments. Mr.Shanawaz Pls do not repeat yr phylosophy again and again. Just comment briefly. First of all try to differciate between common man and the celebreties and his responsibilities towards the common man. He is the icon of the nation. He cannot heart the sentiments of millions of people around the world. He must be watchfull for his each and every commitment.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sunny, UAE

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    Comments by Mr. Shahnavaz Kukkikatte are correct and says it all. This non-issue became a issue due to Congress high command's allergy with Big B.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • nagesh nayaK, bangalore

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    HI,Joseph F. Gonsalves, Bannur, Puttur/ Mangalore, LIKE CONGRESS & GANDHI FAMILY YOU ALSO FURSTRATED. ISSUE IS ABOUT SHRI.AMITABHJI & YOU IN FRUSTRATION COMMENTING ABOUT HEMAMALINI.
    IF WE TALK ABOUT NORTH POLE & YOU COMMENT ABOUT SOUTH POLE.
    CAN YOU TELL ME WHY SONIA & FAMILY ARE SO AFRAID OF GREAT INDIAN SHRI AMITAB BACHCHAN.

    CONGRESS IS TRYING TO SNATCH FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS OF SHRI.AMITABH BACHCHAN & WHOLE COUNTRY IS BEHIND A GREAT STAR.
    DURING EARTH HOUR PROGRAMME IN DELHI CONGRESS HAS REMOVED SHRI.AJITABH BACHCHANS PLACARDS & REMOVED HIS MESSAGES FROM THE PROGRAMME.
    WHAT CONGRESS WANTS TO SETTLE THE SCORE WITH SHRI.AMITAB BACHCHAN & FAMILY.
    AT THE END SHAMEFULL CONGRESS WILL DEFEAT.
    JAI HO AMITABHJI.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Vera Alvares, Mumbai

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    Amitabh may be a great actor, but that does not make him a good human being. We have never seen or heard him condemn any injustice in the country or stand up for the oprressed classes. He has never used his clout to stop persecution of the hapless citizens. Does his heart beat for India's millions? From his track record we learn that he jumps at opportunites that make him richer, more powerful, more famous....UP main kami nahi!( sic!) Indeed now he has become Gujarat ambassador aligning himself with Modi who has an image as the hardliner in BJP party. Amitabh must tell the people if he agrees with Modi's views and past actions.
    We never heard a word out of him when the genocide was being carried out against innocents and pregnent women in Gujarat or when Orissa was burning. He is seen only by the side of powerful people, phot-ops to show how popular he is....!Indians are so gullible anyone who can hit a ball with a bat or anyone who can clown on the screen is made into an icon....!
    By selling hair oil, pens and so many other ridiculous objects in TV ads Amitabh is making himself the laughing stock of the society. This image of a salesman is so demeaning and does not go well with an 'ambassador''s image! Anything for money?
    Congress is justified in asking him to take a stand if he wants to be Modi's messenger. He simply cannot take it as another monetary assignment and overlook the facts- progrom to annihilate Muslims in the state... does he approve of it?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • judy, Mumbai/Mangalore

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    Readers Please note, Every one in this country knows that Mr. Bachhan is a Super star and he is paid for his acting, Now he is the Ambassador of Gujarat also paid for that, Now if Congress wants Mr, Bachhan to endorse Congress pay him his Salary he will do his work dont mix the politics everywere please

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Charles D'Mello, Pangala

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    Mr.Amitabh Bachchan is a learned man. He need not endorse the riots, but he always endorse the good things done buy Mr. Modi.....First of all, all the politicians shall follow his non corruption policy....How many politicians are working for the people/state/country like him..??????

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • anil, bangalore

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    Whatever modi is a dirty politician.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • manish, canada

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    Amitabh has the liberty to chooose who ever he thinks is right. Just because he was a ex congressmen doesnt mean he need to get a certificate from congress to whom he meets or endorse. Amitabh knows who r good and eveil politicians.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • abdul sathar habibullah , Belapu, Kaup./Sharjah

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    yeh dosti modi hum nahi chodenge
    chodenge dum agar tera 2002 ka hath na chodenge. teri jan meri jan meri jan aesa apna pyar basanthi ko bhi bulayenge maya wati ke sath.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • manish, mangalore

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    Which is happened in2002 is really bad,but what happended after Indira Gandhis death killing so many innocent Sikhs is good? now nobody is answering. Every people talking one side.Some people are trying to show here very honest,truthfull and good,about Amithab he is an actor.that is his personalchoice whom did meet and what to do.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • abdul sathar, belapu udupi

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    Mr. Amitab I think your relation with modi is not new. before 2002 you are in the same boat. So it is right decision of Congress who fire you. being a screen person it is not giving any shoba to u.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Manjunatha Bangera, Kasaragodu/Bengaluru

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    Why this politics over Amitabh? He is just paying the price for being an ex-congressman."Does he (Amitabh) condemn the role of Narendra Modi in the 2002 Gujarat pogrom of 2002 or he endorses it?"...Does it mean that people who are in congress endorse 1984 sikh massacre?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • GIREESH SHETTY, MANGALORE DUBAI

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    IT JUST PROVES CONGRESS'S FRUSTATION TO GET TO POWER IN GUJRATH. DESPITE SO MUCH COMBINED EFFORT THEY COULDNT DEFEAT MODI.LONG LIVE MODI AND GOD BLESS GUJRATH AND KARNATAKA FROM CONGRESS IN FUTURE.OTHERWISE DAY IS NOT FAR WHEN TALIBAN WILL BE ROAMING IN MLORE ROADS.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Joseph F. Gonsalves, Bannur, Puttur/ Mangalore

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    Recently a robber robbed 60 lakhs worth of gold and cash from Mrs. Hemamalin's house. The income tax department must raid all cine stars houses for evading tax payments to the government.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • shahnawaz kukkikatte, dubai/udupi

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    Mr Yousuf/KSA, Mr Bachhan is not MOdis ambassador. He is Gujarat'brand ambassador. Neither he represents BJP nor MOdi. Neither Mr Bachhan endorsed Gujarat riots nor he has done anything wrong. Neither Bachhan has supported MOdi's role in the killing nor he defended him. This is a game of politics. Eversince Mr Bachhan fell out from Gandhi family, this type of attacks were common on Bachhan.

    The sad part is that now Bachhan represented Gujarat as its brand ambassador, people like you got an opportunity to criticise him. I am surely a critic of Modi whose hands are red with muslim blood. No law would forgive him. But to criticise Mr Bachhan for representing Gujarat is wrong. Gujarat doesnt belong to Modi or BJP alone. It belongs to Indians of all communities. I know Modi is an evil and mouth ka saudagar. To equate Bachhan with Modi is totally wrong.

    You are biased in your prejudice. Please call spade a spade. What do you say about Kashmir, where thousands of hindus are displaced. Do you endorse it. No. Like we dont endorse what Modi has done in Gujarat, same way we should not endorse what Muslims have done to Kashmiri Pandits. National unity is first. Modi cant achieve this unity by his devide and rule policy and kashmiris too are following Modi. For national unity, equality of all is key factor. Though I am against Modi, certainly I am not against Bachhan.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • yousuf, Gangolli KSA

    Mon, Mar 29 2010

    Thanks Daiji for this article which is I think perfect right on target answer to Mr.Shanawaz Kukkikatte's earlier comments.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Cong to Amitabh: Do you Endorse Modi's 'role' in Gujarat Riots?



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.