Family Claims Doctors' Negligence Cost Infant's Death, Hospital Denies Charges


Family Claims Doctors' Negligence Cost Infant's Death, Hospital Denies Charges

Pics: Spoorthi Ullal
Daijiworld Media Network – Mangalore (PS)
 
Mangalore, Jun 17:
Chaos prevailed at the Advanced Paediatric Care unit of Wenlock hospital after a mother who lost her baby alleged that doctors and the hospital staff were responsible for her daughter's death.

Sumitra and Yuvraj had initially admitted their daughter Moksha to a hospital in Kalladka in Bantwal after she started vomiting severely on June 11. Doctors there referred her to the Advanced Pediatric Care unit of Wenlock hospital in Mangalore. On June 12 the doctors here found defects in the lungs of the baby and put her on ventilators.

As per hospital in-charge Dr Shantaram Baliga, the baby was brought to the hospital in a very critical condition. He said that there was no negligence on the part of the doctors or the hospital staff. The baby was also diagnosed with epilepsy, he added.

The hospital has resident doctors round the clock. He ruled out allegations that PG students, and not experienced doctors, handled critical cases.
 
Regional medical director Saroja said that after the ICU unit opened at the hospital, death rate had increased as patients were being brought in critical condition. In such cases, the patients are usually beyond treatment. In just two days, three infants died in the ICU unit, as they were already in critical stages while being admitted, she said.

Earlier, Keshava, uncle of the deceased infant alleged that there were no doctors to handle Moksha's case, and when they requested the duty doctors to call their seniors, it was the PG students who came to treat her. The hospital staff too did not care to answer their queries, he said.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Dr, B.S. baliga, Mangalore

    Mon, Jun 20 2011

    Dear Wilma Thank you for the good advise. For your information I have spent more than 2 hrs for 2 days including visits at night thinking for the baby and have spent at least 10 minutes explaining the condition to the father 2 days before death and expressed the incurable nature of the disease. later i have spent at least 30 minutes to explain the condition to father and his team later mother and her aunt. I feel betrayed for helping them out of the way. I can not help if they are not ready to accept the reality.
    Earlier on the second day mother went 'berserk' abusing people around .....

    Even now we have sent the samples of blood and urine to Delhi from where it will be sent to Japan for analysis and diagnosis. we are interested to solve the problem so that the family can have better future.
    In return we are being battered from all sides!! What a reward !!!

    DisAgree [1] Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • wilma, vaz

    Mon, Jun 20 2011

    Dr.baliga I do appreciate child was brought in critical condition but did you had a time to sit with parents for 5minutes and explain to them how critical childs condition is/ in mangalore we have best of hospitals and best of doctors but no one respects each other please haven sake poor people are as well humanbeings since they did not have inup money hence approched to Govt hospital but do not forget they have intelligent and skill to understand like rich people. please hence forth give training to all the medical staff about proper communication and take verbal or written consent before caring the patient. everyone loves their life.

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • jaidev, mangalore/uk

    Sun, Jun 19 2011

    I note varied comments to the incident. I have a few comments to make.
    1. It is really unfortunate that this has happened. My heart felt condolences to the parents and the family.
    2. Has anybody thought what the doctors go through when you loose a child whom you have treated and always acted in the best interest of the child. I know of at a few professionals who had to seek help to cope with the stress. At the end of he day we are human beinggs and deal with emotions as well.
    3.Responsible role by the media helps a great deal during such situations.
    4.Good communication with parents as pointed out by saikiran gopalkaje is also vital.
    5. You will get fatalities especially in a tertiary centre as only those cases that cannot be managed or have not responded to treatment in the primary and secondary care come to such insititutions.
    6. Vomting can be a presenting symtom of a simple condition called gastroenteriis to more serious problems which could be fatal.Please do not speculate without knowing the facts.
    7. lastly i wish we had a crystal ball where we could possibly type in the childs name and date of birth and symptoms and we could get a magic answer. Sadly medicine is not like that and death is an unfortunate outcome though.

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • JOACKIM MENDONCA, Mumbai / Saudi Arabia

    Sun, Jun 19 2011

    This is very sad news for us, also for their family. It's means this is naglience of doctor, bcoz we know in india most of the doctor's are unproffessionl. Most of the doctors are educated, no doubt of it. But most doctors are not passed in their exem. After they are bribing to department to get Doctor's Certificate, same like Air Pilots. After they are murdering humans in their professional period. Be careful, when you are entering the Medicare, Just checkout any professional or expirience doctors are there or no. This my small advise to you all. Please take care of you and your family. THIS IS MY INDIA.... JAI HO....

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • JOACKIM MENDONCA, Mumbai / Saudi Arabia

    Sun, Jun 19 2011

    This is very sad news for us, also for their family. It's means this is naglience of doctor, bcoz we know in india most of the doctor's are unproffessionl. Most of the doctors are educated, no doubt of it. But most doctors are not passed in their exem. After they are bribing to department to get Doctor's Certificate, same like Air Pilots. After they are murdering humans in their professional period. Be careful, when you are entering the Medicare, Just checkout any professional or expirience doctors are there or no. This my small advise to you all. Please take care of you and your family. THIS IS MY INDIA.... JAI HO....

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Aby, Udupi

    Sun, Jun 19 2011

    @ DIANE.. Dearest Madam..Kindly please note being an Indian you should not say such statements.. And before you comment of our health care system just think twice and read well regrading the health policies and planning into them.. You will be suprised to see how ignorant you are of your own country.. and being outside the system its easy to criticize the system..You Be the change you want to see and then all will change..You are always welcome into system and change it , rather than commenting on it..A visit to Mangalore, ie RAPCC will shatter all your preconceived shallow opinion of your state and country..

    DisAgree [1] Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • leo, M'lore/Doha

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    Feel pity on the doctors...what do u mean by critial conditions...that means there is no hope for life in Wenlock ????
    send all the new learning staff to somalia and kenya

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr Prashant Kini K, Mangalore

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    @ Mr Alwyn, General statements like these are not acceptable. Do take a peek within your mind and think for a moment, can every patient be saved ? Although doctors work with that aim, its not humanly possible , otherwise we wouldn be mortals !!

    Do visit the hospital once & speak to the patients, if this one patient's bystander are dissatisfied, you'll find 20 more who'll vouch for the doctors.

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr Subhodh, Bantwal

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    Mr Alwyn...plllllllzzzzzzzzzz open ur brain....think before u talk.Its not some comedy show its a serious issue.Before pointing at others ask urself how many poor u have helped.If u r literate plz think like one ....dont do antipublicity without knowin anythin of hospital...i m sure when u r dear ones r sick u will go to a doctor not a butcher..think again with all senses ...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Diane, canada

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    such negligence can occur in india 100 percent and the hospitals wants to cover their back by saying that the students did not attend the baby

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Godwin Mendonca, Mangalore/Saudi

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    So sad to here this... I dont think its Dr, mistake. Omiting Causes sever Dehydration. This is one of the main causes of Infant death.Parents should know some immidiate treatments like ORS, at least it will give some strength to infant. i also went through with same situation. immidiate action saved my baby. any small problem immidiate consult Docters. Dont wait for ur home remedies.. its verry hard to parents to digest this pain. in shock they are blaming docters... Media should not highlight this.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Saikiran Gopalakaje, Sullia/UK

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    Dear all,
    My following comments are general. 1. The main reason for clashes between patients' families and hospital staff is because of poor communication by the staff.
    2. Dealing with families who have lost their loved ones needs very high level of training in communication skills - Every action, facial expression, words we choose brings out different reaction from the grieving person. Being honest and open in explaining to the family about what happened to the child in a way they can understand - without using medical jargons, using local language is important.
    3. Not all doctors are good at communication -This is a fact and clinical teachers in medical colleges need to accept/recognise this fact.
    More specifically,
    If the child had inborn error of metabolism(problem with substances handling energy reactions in the body) and had decompensated (beyond the stage of repair) there is very little one can do in late stages. Doctors and advanced hospitals cannot play God and it is unfair to attack them without knowing the facts.
    I do hope hospital looks at setting up a bereavement team (if not already present)including trained counsellors, senior paediatricians, senior nurses who can deal with these situations quickly before it gets to a 'mob'ocracy.
    My sincere thanks to the dedicated hospital staff for looking after the seriously ill infant for several days and my heartfelt condolences to the family.
    Dr. Saikiran Gopalakaje

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Queeni, Bejai/Mangalore

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    Are there any parents who publish or call the media to publish when their little infants lives were saved by the doctors from the critical illnesses ? You don't find any! then why blame anyone?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Aiden,

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    We need to remember that there are very few very well qualified experienced

    doctors and often forget that they are human beings too and take them for granted.
    You cant expect them to work 24x7 and as far as I know most of them are

    overworked & stressed out. In this case its just that the parents couldnt accept the loss and needed someone to blame. Its human nature.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr Anil Shetty, Mangalore

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    While the death of the child is unfortunate and tragic, blaming the doctors is totally unfair. Lets examine the facts logically, first the Child was referred from Bantwal, that would mean the child's condition was very serious otherwise the child would have been admitted in Bantwal itself, secondly the age of the child- 2 months, an age when the vulnerability of the patient is much more when compared to an older patient, the fact that the child was put on a ventilator indicates the child's condition had worsened and the prognosis would have been poor, whenever a child is put on a ventilator every doctor highlights the seriousness of the situation and the child is put on the ventilator only after the consent of the parents.

    Knowing this background blaming the untimely death of the infant on the Doctors is illogical and insensitive, for us every life is precious, no one or no profession values life as much as we do but we simply cannot succeed everytime, there are times when despite our best efforts we cannot save patients and we grieve and understand the emotional outbursts of the patients, but for the media to show up only when there is a tragic death and provide a platform for people to vent their anger in a emotionally volatile situation is very disheartening.

    DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr.B.S.Baliga, mangalore

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    I am very well aware of the case and the efforts Dear friend. Mr. Alwyn You are invited to visit the hospital and talk to patients who are being treated and see how they are cared. when did you visit this hospital? Please do not generalize the statements regarding doctors.
    And take back the last sentence which is not in a good taste.

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Valson Mendonsa, Mangalore/USA

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    Dr.Kiran Baliga @
    Dr. B.S.Baliga,@
    Dr. Arunachalam Kumar@
    Dr. Subhodh shetty@
    Dr Prashant Kini K.
    Dear Doctors,
    I do agree with you all your statements,you must have personally saved so many lives in your career that has been completely forgotten by the media.I feel personally.. here the issue not on healthcare Industry but whole system .. for that corrupt government is responsible.

    DisAgree [1] Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Robert Tauro, Kadri, Mangalore

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    While my heart goes out to the grieving parents, I feel that blaming the doctors for every infant death has become the order of the day. I see Dr. Shantaram Baliga in the picture above and I feel under his guidance the medical team must have done their best to save the child.

    Recently a friend of mine lost his small child and the news of it shook all his near and dear ones. In this case too the doctors who treated the child were the victims of the bad mouths. But the grieving father who spoke at the funeral put an end to all these speculations when he thanked the doctors profusely for trying their best to save his child.
    I sincerly pray that God may give enough strength to these parents to bear their child's loss and enough wisdom to media and and other people to avoid sensationalising the issue. It can only increase parent's grief and lower doctors' morale.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr Prashant Kini K, Mangalore

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    Heart felt condolences to the grieving family. Inspite of mammoth efforts on the part of hospital staff & the family, baby could not be saved.
    Most of the children that get referred to the ICU of this hospital are in critical condition and get referred because they require specialized care. Many a times these children would have already received some treatment in the peripheral centre & are sent here for further management in critical condition.

    This type of reaction from the parents is quite common & they usually need some time to come to terms with the loss.

    However the media should play a more responsible role rather than sensationalizing such incidents.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr. Subhodh shetty, Bantwal

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    Its quiet disappointing to hear such nonsense.There is no hospital where patients dont die.Not all diseases are curable and even morons will know that.Media should use their brains not kidneys for thinking. Grief of patient party could be understood but to make such antipublicity about a system without knowing true facts is rubbish.Its a refferal center and many critical cases come in dying state, still many have survived due to care and monitoring round the clock. Ventilators, NICU for sick newborns, modern monitors, expensive drugs etc. provided free of cost for the poor, who can never afford these leading to death of their children.

    The hospital RAPCC is doing a very noble job and saving many poor. Such idiotic antipublicity without knowing true story will only harm the needy patients.Its an excellent hospital with trained nurses and experienced confident doctors and such craps cant break their moral.RAPCC will surely save millions of poor in future and they have done in the past ...cheers to RAPCC

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr. Arunachalam Kumar, Mangalore

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    While I fully empathize and commiserate with the grief parents of the unfortunate child have gone through, I for one, not even for a moment doubt the integrity and diligence of the pediatricians at Wenlock Hospital. The Advanced Center setup there has saved hundreds of criticaly ill children and has estavlished nationwide repuation as one of the better child care units operating from agovernemnt hospital.
    As pointed out by other commentors, most if not all children brought to the Advanced Center are already in a serious state and more often tahn not, many succumb despite last ditch and desperate measures.
    I personally know most pediatricians at Wenlock and am ceratin they give a hundred percent. I also know this for sure, as this cver unit saved my (then) infant daughter's life when she wasgravely ill and comatose. I appeal to the unit to continue the good work they have done over the decades.
    Once again, I join the many who felt sorry for the unfortunate death of an innocent child and hope the grieving parents summmon strength to bear what must be an irreplaceable loss

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • S N SHETTY , DOHA /BARKUR

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    Poor medical facility in Udupi Manipal and Magalore now a days.
    lots of students are working in hospital on full time duty . same thing happened 1 month before when i was on vacation back in udupi,3 students in operation area and 1 senior doctor. this student talk to patients relatives like what is written in there collage book. When a student told me something wrong (u have ready for everything I can’t give any promise that everything will be fine, my mom was with me she collapse there itself) I shout on her and asked her who is in charge or senior doctor over here than she told in charge is want to her home she will be back. When in charge came she explained me properly than I am ok .but wht that student told is wrong .

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • alwyn sequeira, kulshekar

    Sat, Jun 18 2011

    Dear dr.balliga agreed that the child was bought in a critical state but are u really sure that u had experienced doctors there forget the media ask ur own conscience whether u hav carried on ur duty bec now a days we really feel scared to go to doctors forget wenlock hospital but even pvt hospitals as most of them do not respect their own profession only money matters not life, pls dont speak of the good u do for its ur profession and u are paid for it instead try to accept mistakes and mend ur selves and be faithful in ur work

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr. B.S.Baliga, Mangalore

    Fri, Jun 17 2011

    The print and electronic media unfortunately sensationalizes news which has negative impact on the system. None of the reporters took opinion from parents of other children who are being treated in the hospital before concluding!.
    They had the the best opportunity to find the facts!.
    After death of close relatives it is normal for any individual to react and this is described in 3 stages - Denial, Grief, and Acceptance. At the stage of denial relatives would accuse the treating doctors , hospital staff, the facilities etc and this process is termed as "projection". Unfortunately many a times media highlights such reactions

    All the facts about treatment of a patient would be available in the case records for scrutiny. Alternatively it should be made as medico-legal case and investigations need to be carried out by the police or judicial system. The media should refrain from sensationalizing allegations by the aggrieved party as such news has "negative impact" on the public health system
    I am yet to come across any coverage by the print or electronic media of the good work done by the doctors in the hospital.There are thousands of families who can certify the quality of care in the hospital.

    I remember very few occasions when the media has come to help mobilize funds for treatment of the needy children of poor families despite our request!

    Nevertheless such incidences does not deter the doctors to reach out and continue service

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr.Kiran Baliga, Bantwal

    Fri, Jun 17 2011

    It is quite disheartening that doctors are targeted in such circumstances.RAPCC is one of the best Paediatric care center in Mangalore with the best team of paediatricians and in house residents round the clock.In a tertiary referral center, due to late referrals and critical terminal stages death is sometimes inevitable, after all doctors can give in their best, but not play god. Media has got to play a more responsible role in such cases.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Valson Mendonsa, Mangalore/USA

    Fri, Jun 17 2011

    About 15,000 people die every single in whole of India due to Un-afforable medication or Doctor's negligence, so.. this issue is not new, you guys are busy issues on religion and dirty politics.. rather than fighting to save the life of millions every years in India.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Mr R Sequeira, Mangalore/UK

    Fri, Jun 17 2011

    Indeed its a sad news that a baby was lost. But its wrong to blame it on the doctors as they do not control life & death but try their best to save a life. They are blamed for something which is not under their control. Looking at the news article it seems that the baby had multiple systemic problems which did not respond to the treatment. Certainly this family needs an explanation and lessons must be learnt to provide an even better care in5 the future. May God give strength to this family.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • vasant raj, udupi/Abudhabi

    Fri, Jun 17 2011

    Very sad news.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Family Claims Doctors' Negligence Cost Infant's Death, Hospital Denies Charges



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.