Mangalore: 18 Cattle Killed, One Person Injured as Transport Vehicle Overturns

Sat, Apr 07 2012 08:02:00 AM

Mangalore: 18 Cattle Killed, One Person Injured as Transport Vehicle Overturns

Pics: Spoorthi Ullal / Brijesh Garodi
Daijiworld Media Network - Mangalore (PS/BG)

Update - 10.20 am

Mangalore, Apr 7: In new information coming in regarding the accident at Kottara on Saturday April 7 that killed 18 cattle, it is now confirmed that one person was injured and two managed to escape from the spot.

Sources said that Bajrang Dal activists, on receiving prior information on the cattle trafficking, chased the vehicle from Panambur, and forcibly stopped it at Kottara. The driver of the vehicle, in a bid to escape, took reverse and hit a mound of mud on the road side and lost control, resulting in the vehicle turning over.

Two of three people in it managed to escape, while the injured man remained inside.

Initial report

As many as 18 cattle were killed and two persons injured after a vehicle transporting the cattle overturned at Kottara here on Saturday April 7.

It is said that the cattle were being illegally taken from Jokatte to Central Market.

Sources said that the vehicle was being chased by Bajrang Dal activists, and turned turtle after the driver lost control due to high speed.

It may be recalled that on April 5, a group of Bajrang Dal activists had stopped a vehicle carrying cattle. The persons involved in it had fled the place and the cattle were handed over to the police.

Follow Daijiworld News Network on

Comment on this article

mukesh poojary, mangalore
Mon, Apr 09 2012
All commentors pls note this entire tragedy happened only bcoz these theifs carried cows illegally, dont comment blindly as this happens due to BD or people who sells cows, these people dont knw as these as theifs catches cows from sheds and fields u knw? We BD save these cows bcz we worship that and police will not take action against them, not only BD if police chases them also same thing hapens intension is not to kill cows its to save cows ok this operation will continue in DK

DisAgree [23] Agree [10] Reply Report Abuse
stan, dubai
Mon, Apr 09 2012
Very surprising???? transporting 18 cattle in a van is inhuman. and transporting 18 schoolchildren in a Rickshaw is human. BD please take action against these Rickshaw's

DisAgree [3] Agree [26] Reply Report Abuse
Melvin, Australia
Mon, Apr 09 2012
In the name of saving these cattle's, Bajrangdal has caused this accident by chasing this vehicle, resulting in the death of 18 cattle and injuring the 3 persons.

Dear Bajrangdal activists are you not human. Dont you have any concern for human lives. You could have killed these people from your stupid so called save cattle movement ( or whatever you call it). Thank God these people are still alive at this moment.

Do you rate these cattle more than human beings?

Shame you Bajrangdal activists. If you cannot give life to a human, please do not try to take it.

DisAgree [7] Agree [17] Reply Report Abuse
sunil pereira, neermarga
Mon, Apr 09 2012
Very sad news .selling god to make money on the other hand

DisAgree [5] Agree [10] Reply Report Abuse

Steevan, Mangalore/Dubai
Sun, Apr 08 2012
The police have to arrest who sell this cows/cattle, instead of arresting those who supply. Then only this Bajarang dal or those who against for these type of activities will know, who is real culprits are? Its not the Muslims sell but surely its others religion people sell these cattle to kill. Here blame simply cums on Muslims since they kill the cattle and sell beef.

DisAgree [14] Agree [31] Reply Report Abuse
Ram Shetty, Mangalore/Mumbai
Sun, Apr 08 2012
This accident would have not happened if Bajrang Dal would have followed them till their final destination or informed the Police department or the CID's...We all should blame Bajrang Dal for killing our Gomatha.

DisAgree [19] Agree [101] Reply Report Abuse
Girish Kumar, Mangalore
Sun, Apr 08 2012
It is so suprising that why and how come only Bajrang Dal and the News agency people gets all these information with the exact car's information with exact sketch from where it is going to pass and why not the Police?

DisAgree [4] Agree [58] Reply Report Abuse
Girish Kumar, Mangalore
Sun, Apr 08 2012
It is so suprising that why and how come only Bajrang Dal and the News agency people gets all these information with the exact car's information with exact sketch from where it is going to pass and why not the Police?

DisAgree [7] Agree [33] Reply Report Abuse
Sayed Kaleem, Udupi/Dubai
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Absolute Bajrangi,s they killed their own 18 God,s, what is the gain who won what did these fools proved.

DisAgree [29] Agree [123] Reply Report Abuse
Alwyn, Canada
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Hey Jude, inteligent question for such idiots like Harsh Malhotra. Very nice.

Jude, Mangalore Dubai

Saturday, April 07, 2012

Hars Malhotra, Please tell me what punishment you propose for
1) Corruption
2) Female foeticide
3) Rape of minors
4) rape
5) dowry burning/murder
6) Child marriage
7) instigation of riots in the name of religion

Please sort these burning issues first and then come to go matha.

Finally you might enjoy being ruled by a mass murderer, most of the country does not.

DisAgree [14] Agree [65] Reply Report Abuse
lawrence, abudabi mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
MR H Maihothra Gouhathya is a big sin means Bajarangi did this in this incident so who will fanish them

DisAgree [7] Agree [45] Reply Report Abuse
NASRULLA, MANGALORE /DUBAI
Sat, Apr 07 2012
I feel BD guys should start working with FBI.They get all information in advance.

DisAgree [7] Agree [51] Reply Report Abuse
Suresh P, mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Well said Rakesh shetty, they are not human beings.

DisAgree [7] Agree [15] Reply Report Abuse
Arshad kadli, Bhatkal /Al Khobar
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Ismail,
Yes I condemned inhuman transportation of animals because it is against my religion and also law of land.
At the same time I am questioning the very incidents itself because they claim people ran away which appears to be illogical.
In yesterday's case it is faster to run in their vehicle rather than running after abandoning vehicle.
And today it is hard to beieve that BD could not chase people from a overturned vehicle.
Read comment fully before commenting.

DisAgree [5] Agree [19] Reply Report Abuse

MA, Kateel
Sat, Apr 07 2012
very much heartbroken pictures, this shouldnt happen , police as to take care innocent lives
MA
Kateel H1N1

DisAgree [6] Agree [9] Reply Report Abuse
shahnawaz kukkikatte, udupi/udupi
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Why BD some times back submitted tender to the auction of Bunder beef slaughter house???? BD please answer>>. This is high profile drama enacted and managed by sangh parivar to malign minorities and seek vote banks in the coming election..BD how much money have been given to you to stage manage the show... What happened to the driver of lorry.. If he dies, is BD going to take care of the family of the dead driver????

DisAgree [26] Agree [94] Reply Report Abuse
KRPrabhu, Kudla/Bengaluru
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Moolu narepini yenkulanchnakulu mande daanthinakulu maatra.Mande ittinakuleg bete kelasa undu!!!

DisAgree [9] Agree [36] Reply Report Abuse
shahab / Dubai, Kasaragod
Sat, Apr 07 2012
This is BD pre plan drama to show off they are savers of GO Matha unfortunately drama ended in 18 cattle's lives

DisAgree [14] Agree [79] Reply Report Abuse
Joseph F. Gonsalves, Bannur, Puttur / Mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
How will these animal Gods will manage powerful men and women if these Gods cannot cannot protect themselves. Ridiculous.

The prices of meat such as chicken/lamb, beef, pork in the market has been skyrocketed due to which unreachable to a common man. The government should not waste time in making free flow of meat in the market. Withdraw permits to cow slaughter houses and make free so that any person can slaughter the cattle anywhere, anytime, place irrespective of time and space and see the results, the beef prices will be so cheap and immediately prices other meat such as chicken, lamb and pork will fall instantly.

Why illegal is going on because there are restrictions. Remove restrictions so that illegal transportations or illegal slaughters will never happen whatsoever. I sincerely urge Chief Minister D.V. Sadananda Gowda to remove permit systems for cow slaughter houses with immediate effect.

DisAgree [28] Agree [74] Reply Report Abuse
ziyan, Udupi/Dubai
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Why GO MATHA cannot protect him self ?.

DisAgree [34] Agree [70] Reply Report Abuse
zameer, m'lore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
surprise very surprise!two cattle incidents with in two days that too in same kottara lady hill area!its a RSS conspiracy to get cow slaughter bill passed. i am sure these cows are killed by bajrangi and they were carrying in a tempo with their own driver.. .for them its not a big deal since they killed 59 karasevaka (human beings) in godhra to make a gujarath riot plot....

DisAgree [22] Agree [54] Reply Report Abuse
ISMAIL.K.PERINJE, PERINJE-YANBU/KSA
Sat, Apr 07 2012
you condemned inhuman method of cattle transportation, why can't condemn BD for taking law in to their own hand? BD is responsible for all these acciedents/confusions/law and order problems in undivided DK/Udupi/BhatkaI....

If so called association/dals taking law in to their own hand, then why police and court?Yes, yesterday reported something else today another thing!! But Bajrangis and police may manipulate incidents as for their tune/convenace.!!!

DisAgree [17] Agree [53] Reply Report Abuse
Gladson, Brahmavar
Sat, Apr 07 2012
How BD decides which vehicle is transporting cattle legally and which one is doing it illegally. Till date Govt is not sure as what is illegal, consumption of beef, slaughter of cattle or transporting of cattle! If consumption of beef has not been banned through a Law, it means abattoirs can function and if the abattoirs have to function, then, there should be supply of cattle. So on what basis do the BD activists decide that a particular consignment is illegal?

Every time a vehicle is chased, it does not mean it is illegal cattle transportation because at time these persons speed away just to escape from the BD activists who have the history of beating them and robbing them off. Do these persons transporting cattle need to display the licence or permit to the BD activists?

The proposed Prevention of Slaughter and Preservation of Cattle Bill 2010 infringes on fundamental rights of the citizens and it is against the rulings of the court. The bill also affects scores of people’s lives and lacks legislative competence. The Bill goes not only against Muslims, Christians, Dalits and tribal people, but also against the livelihood of a huge population of Hindus who form the farmers’ community and possess legitimate rights over their livestock.

If it serves anything, it’s communalism. As long as they are in a farmer’s cowshed, the animals have a good life. Before old age sets in, farmers sell them to butchers to earn some money to buy another calf. So from a farmer’s point of view, even those who do not eat meat themselves, the prospect of selling the cattle that has lived its life and served its purpose is a big economic relief.

So even vegetarian farmers who raise cattle are glad that there is a meat market. The very idea of such a bill also shows that the ruling class of BJP which basically consists of cultural elites from the Brahmin and Brahminised upper castes who don’t like to get their hands dirty doing manual labour, hardly know anything about the rural economy.

DisAgree [10] Agree [74] Reply Report Abuse
Arshad Kadli, Bhatkal / Alkhobar
Sat, Apr 07 2012
I condemn the inhuman method of transportation of cattle. The culprits should be punished as per the law. However there is some missing link in the whole episode.

Yesterday it was reported all people managed to escape after abandoning the vehicle. Today it is being reported that two people managed to escape that too from a overturned vehicle.

Definately they will have at least some minor injuries still they managed to escape desite being chased by BD.

DisAgree [5] Agree [24] Reply Report Abuse

MAS, Mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Better all police take Voluntarily Retirement Scheme in Kar-Nataka and replace all these goon Bajrangis in police station, how these goons are taking laws in their hands is it they are above than police and law. 18 cows were killed because bajrangis.They dont know the value of human being also.

DisAgree [2] Agree [36] Reply Report Abuse
Jude, Mangalore Dubai
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Hars Malhotra, Please tell me what punishment you propose for
1) Corruption
2) Female foeticide
3) Rape of minors
4) rape
5) dowry burning/murder
6) Child marriage
7) instigation of riots in the name of religion

Please sort these burning issues first and then come to go matha.

Finally you might enjoy being ruled by a mass murderer, most of the country does not.

DisAgree [10] Agree [85] Reply Report Abuse
Naveen Shetty, Mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Who gave the power to Bajrang Dal activists to start chasing the tempo driver. Can everyone start taking laws into their own hands to punish the guilty? I know many guys who are doing illegal business from all the religions and is it right on my part to arrange a group of activists to thrash these culprits.

The entire situation created by BD is completely illegal and should be condemned. Suppose the same accident has resulted in loss of humans what could have happened? Any individual who is taking law into their own hands is criminal and not even fit in the civil society.

DisAgree [8] Agree [79] Reply Report Abuse
Vishal P., Mangalore, Kuwait
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Why these things are happing during the time of BJP rule? The day BJP came into power, Bajrangis started their GUNDARAJ in Mangalore. BJP Govt. has to take strict action against this organizations. The previous CM acted as if he was blind on these issues. Now the current CM please dont be blind. Mangalore is your place. Don't allow GUNDDARAJ to grow in Mangalore City...

DisAgree [4] Agree [50] Reply Report Abuse
MGP, KSD/SHJ
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Dear Rakesh, This is a normal phenomena in the universe the common people will be in action if the assigned officers are neglect and close their eyes when the social evils are taken place.

Why everybody call the main actor in the films as HERO and giving applauds when he raise his voice or taken action against the evils of the society? Is this the meaning that he is taking the law on his hand?

Do not point the organisation instead see the cause and comment wisely. Please stop rubbish comments like uneducated person.

DisAgree [26] Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse
Arman, Managalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Dear Harsh Malotra, Yes i Do agree that there should be 'cow slaughter bill' and also there should be a Minority Bill. what do you say ?

DisAgree [3] Agree [30] Reply Report Abuse
vinod shetty, udupi/dubai
Sat, Apr 07 2012
I think when someone raping our sisters or mother that time we have to call police first and till that time we have to wait and watch till the police comes (to thepeople who want bd to inform this to the police first)

DisAgree [33] Agree [16] Reply Report Abuse
Edison D'souza, mangalore/kuwait
Sat, Apr 07 2012
This malhothra is nuts.. kick him out of daijiworld blog... Please

DisAgree [8] Agree [41] Reply Report Abuse
Candle, Mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Why do we need Police department in Karnataka,if B D is trying to maintain law & order ? It is unbelievable B D is getting information earlier than the police.What is the motto behind not informing the police? If police had been informed,then these many cattle's would have been not died in this way.Karnataka need to wake up and stop this maniacs

DisAgree [1] Agree [30] Reply Report Abuse
ISMAIL.K.PERINJE, PERINJE-YANBU/KSA
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Nature is like that..there are checks and balances...If old cattles are left sine die farmer will be in loss. Another thing is if beef banned, there could be a migration to other food like veg or meat which will cost again more..India is third largest Beef exporter behind Aust and Brazil..How could balance the Balance of Payment which may hit beef export.

It is high time to ban Militant Org like Bajarangis who are taking law in to their own hand. If paid HAFTA, then they will escort the cattle vehicle safely until destination. Police in Mangalore in this particular issue watching mouse and cat play..

DisAgree [6] Agree [35] Reply Report Abuse

Alan, M'lore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
how come everytime bd gets all such kind of information and police dont receeive any such information.
Police should have been notified and allowed them to take action. If right now itself the BD isnt kept under controll they surely make m'lore and slowly whole of india into Taliban.

where's democracy is and Police if BD has to do all such kind of things. I blame solely BD for this Instance.. hadn't they chased the vehicle accident wouldn't have occured... Gunda raj is prevailing in m'lore

DisAgree Agree [21] Reply Report Abuse
Ravi Gopal Acharaya, Udipi/Dubai
Sat, Apr 07 2012
In the name of relegion our BD members kill the both animals as we well as human beings. BD members think animal life is more precious than that of human beings. BD members as well as the transporters of these animals need to be punished as it is grave injustice to both.

Our Karnataka Govt lost completely failed to maintain law and order as private members are controlling our state and ruling party is sleeping as they are scared of coming elections which depends on RSS, BD, VHP and Rame sene. It is shame and pity on all of us as this is the rule of Goons.

DisAgree [2] Agree [35] Reply Report Abuse
aysha, mangalore, muscat
Sat, Apr 07 2012
how dare you talk about turning Mangalore into Gujarath, the state where humanity has died long long back. You get the hell out of our home cos only people like you, who dont know the history of Mangalore, the parasites who come and suck our happiness can talk about making our peaceful Mangalore into the bloodshed land of Gujarath. Here all the communities have lived peacefully with love for one another until recently when people like you have come and contaminated it. We treat everyone who come from different parts of World as equals, so dont exploit it.

DisAgree [2] Agree [42] Reply Report Abuse
sushma, mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
We can ban killing animals or birds bcz its natures rule to survive. but we dnt have right to kill those like this.. people should think before they do this.. even if government takes action it has to bare comments from different religions religions..

DisAgree [1] Agree [11] Reply Report Abuse
Rohit Mangaladevi, Mangaladevi/Mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
I think all the BJP Leaders has to be replaced by our Bajrang Dal friends, b'cos these are the one's who are really working hard & are taking pain for the cause of Hindhutva.

PSEUDO HINDU PARTY BJP has only made use of Hindhutva but never worked towards it. They just betrayed Pramod Muthalik & Mahendra Kumar.

The PSEUDO HINDU PARTY BJP, will never ever try to make the dream of all Hindus come true, regarding banning of Cow slaughter.

Now they have lost their strong fort in coastal belt Udupi-Chikmagalur, the BJP High Command is worried about the forthcoming election for Lok-Sabha.

There had been strong uphold regarding cow slaughter to be stopped during 1999-2001, during the period of Atal Bihari Vajpayee's Prime Minister Office.

And they were about to implement it. But because Chandra Babu Naidu the then Chief Minister of Andhra gave a threat that he will withdraw the support from NDA, Atal Bihari Vajpayee did not implement it. This clearly shows that the PSEUDO HINDU PARTY BJP wants vote and not the GOHU MATHA.

Chandra Babu Naidu was scared that he may loose Minority Votes & also Scheduled Caste & Scheduled Tribes votes (Who eat Beef b'cos of low cost) in the state election for Legislative Assembly MLA as well as Central election for Lok-sabha, which was in May 2004.

PSEUDO HINDU PARTY BJP is just fooling the people of India by bringing these kinds of confusion and polarizing the Hindu Vote to BJP.

They never did what they said. They told they will build SRI RAAM MANDIR. But they did not even have the basic courtesy to remember SRI RAAM, while enjoying power in the center.

So till now in the history of RSS, Jan Sangh, BJP they have only brought confusion in the minds of the people of India and nothing else.

They are just using the youth power by dedicating OBC, SC, ST youths in Bajrang Dal & VHP so that these youth give their sweat & blood for the members of RSS & BJP to enjoy power in Comfort & Sophisticated way

DisAgree [7] Agree [31] Reply Report Abuse
Don, Udupi/blore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
You are not the one who live in India. You will worship all kind of stuff that doesn't mean that rest of the religion can't eat beef. If you are so religious towards Beef then don't eat it man!!

DisAgree [4] Agree [28] Reply Report Abuse
Harsha Malhotra, Mangalore/New Delhi
Sat, Apr 07 2012
eventhough every body is having there own mother's milk..no body think of killing there own mother..!! it's natural..gift from god..!!

DisAgree [52] Agree [16] Reply Report Abuse
Rohit Poojary, Mangaladevi/Mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Harsha Malhotra, you are a KuupaManduka.
I think all the BJP Leaders has to be replaced by our Bajrang Dal friends, b'cos these are the one's who are really working hard & are taking pain for the cause of Hindhutva.

PSEUDO HINDU PARTY BJP has only made use of Hindhutva but never worked towards it. They just betrayed Pramod Muthalik & Mahendra Kumar.

The PSEUDO HINDU PARTY BJP, will never ever try to make the dream of all Hindus come true, regarding banning of Cow slaughter.

Now they have lost their strong fort in coastal belt Udupi-Chikmagalur, the BJP High Command is worried about the forthcoming election for Lok-Sabha.

There had been strong uphold regarding cow slaughter to be stopped during 1999-2001, during the period of Atal Bihari Vajpayee's Prime Minister Office.

And they were about to implement it. But because Chandra Babu Naidu the then Chief Minister of Andhra gave a threat that he will withdraw the support from NDA, Atal Bihari Vajpayee did not implement it. This clearly shows that the PSEUDO HINDU PARTY BJP wants vote and not the GOHU MATHA.
Chandra Babu Naidu was scared that he may loose Minority Votes & also Scheduled Caste & Scheduled Tribes votes (Who eat Beef b'cos of low cost) in the state election for Legislative Assembly MLA as well as Central election for Lok-sabha, which was in May 2004.

PSEUDO HINDU PARTY BJP is just fooling the people of India by bringing these kinds of confusion and polarizing the Hindu Vote to BJP.

They never did what they said. They told they will build SRI RAAM MANDIR. But they did not even have the basic courtesy to remember SRI RAAM, while enjoying power in the center.

So till now in the history of RSS, Jan Sangh, BJP they have only brought confusion in the minds of the people of India and nothing else.

They are just using the youth power by dedicating OBC, SC, ST youths in Bajrang Dal & VHP so that these youth give their sweat & blood for the members of RSS & BJP to enjoy power in Comfort & Sophisticated way

DisAgree [8] Agree [19] Reply Report Abuse
Zuze Pernal, Pernal
Sat, Apr 07 2012
May be, all Indians might respect the cow as “Gomaatha” if, those who respect and worship the cow as god, stop cheating the calves by forcibly restricting them from drinking its own mother’s milk for selfish gains.

DisAgree [21] Agree [67] Reply Report Abuse
Rakesh Kumar, Urva, Mangalore / Dubai, UAE
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Who has given this rights to Bajrangadal's? Why Police or the Karnataka Govt. is not taking action against this Bajrangadal's when they take law in their hands? If the govt. is keeping quite when such things are happening continues, this clearly indicates state govt. is supporting these stupid Bajrangdals and are also equally responsibly for this like of crime. If Bajrangadals had got the info about transferring the cattle's their first duty is to inform the police and its the duty of the police to chase the vehicle if it was illegal. Were did these Bajrangdals get the degree to act like police person. The State Govt. should take against these kind of organisation... I am sure they will not take action against these organizations because if they take action, next time in the election they will not get the majority.

DisAgree [20] Agree [97] Reply Report Abuse

Harsha Malhotra, Mangalore/New Delhi
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Mr.Aslam Sanjeeva Shetty, kottara..

what you said is absolutely right..
we should follow what happens in gujarat..as immediately as possible..!!

DisAgree [86] Agree [17] Reply Report Abuse
N. V., YEKKAR PERMUDE
Sat, Apr 07 2012
There is no modernized slaughter house in india....
private firms like AlKabeer have mordern medical approved technology.....
Banning cow slaughter is not a solution these kind of acts....
N. V.
YEKKAR
PERMUDE

DisAgree [3] Agree [29] Reply Report Abuse
Harsha Malhotra, Mangalore/New Delhi
Sat, Apr 07 2012
implement immediately 'cow slaughter bill' and impose heavy fine and rigorous imprisonment for not law-abiding persons..!! should require agitation all over india..!!

who these minorities who preach to 85% majority people..??????????? 'go-hatya' itself is a big sin...!!! every country have imposed there own rules..why still not in india..???????????

DisAgree [132] Agree [29] Reply Report Abuse
Sanjeeva Shetty, kottara
Sat, Apr 07 2012
The Representatives of Budhivanthara Jille are NAPUNSAKHAS. Law & order has completely failed. This incident as witnessed that, we the people of Coastal are moving towards vinaashsa.

"Vinaasha Kaale Vipireetha Buddhi"

DisAgree [8] Agree [47] Reply Report Abuse
Louis, Kuwait
Sat, Apr 07 2012
I feel pitty, for those who sold Godess Gomatha to these Butchers. They are the biggest sinners. Bajrag Dal is killing cattle instead of saving them. Suspend the police officers, who are not able to control these Bajrangis. Gohathya will haunt Bajrangis n DVS. Bcz DVS gave statement few days ago, Bajrangis started policing in Manglore.

DisAgree [8] Agree [55] Reply Report Abuse
ASh, Mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Wel done BD, you guys chose best way for protect Cows..isn't it?

DisAgree [14] Agree [63] Reply Report Abuse
Mohammad Salauddeen Bantwal, Panmengalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Punish both Illegal cattle transporters as well as BD members. I don't understand why the hell BD have to chase them. has our Government gave the authority to do them so?? BD memebers, if you guys have so much affection towards cows, why don't you feed cows at your home? I have never seen a single bajarangi taking care of a cow in his home. One thing is sure that even if you ban cow slaughtering, you can't stop people eating beef. because beef is cheaper, healthy and middle class families can't afford mutton regularly.

I, being a muslim as well as a human strongly condemn this kind of inhuman cattle transportation. Even if i don't get beef to eat, i don't mind. All muslim brothers, please check the sources from where we are getting beef. if it's stolen, then it would be haraam for us.

DisAgree [5] Agree [54] Reply Report Abuse
murali, murali
Sat, Apr 07 2012
very sad news..but here i am so surprised that no one our regular comm enters has commented on this? i don't know why? here i request both of the bhajarangis and thieves hence forth dont d like this.

DisAgree [1] Agree [13] Reply Report Abuse
Louis, Kuwait
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Bajrangdal responsible for this Gohathya. All these cattle were not suitable for milking so the owners sold these Gomatha for slaughtering. Selling God to make money, on the other hand want to bring anti slaugter bill?

DisAgree [4] Agree [17] Reply Report Abuse
Mohammad Salauddeen Bantwal, Panemangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Punish both Illegal cattle transporters as well as BD members. I don't understand why the hell BD have to chase them. has our Government gave the authority to do them so?? BD memebers, if you guys have so much affection towards cows, why don't you feed cows at your home? I have never seen a single bajarangi taking care of a cow in his home. One thing is sure that even if you ban cow slaughtering, you can't stop people eating beef. because beef is cheaper, healthy and middle class families can't afford mutton regularly.

I, being a muslim as well as a human strongly condemn this kind of inhuman cattle transportation. Even if i don't get beef to eat, i don't mind. All muslim brothers, please check the sources from where we are getting beef. if it's stolen, then it would be haraam for us.

DisAgree [6] Agree [43] Reply Report Abuse

avani, mlore/uae
Sat, Apr 07 2012
I appreciate Mr. Rahim, udupi and praveen mlore for their sensible comments. Cruelty against animals need to be stopped. Meanwhile, my request to BD is, please do not chase the vehicles carrying cattles. Find some other way of stopping the vehicles. Because, already these illegal activity, the cattle are jam packed. Some cattles might have died in the process of chasing itself. Through the network of your units it is possible to stop these vehicles without actually chasing them down. By chasing with hgh speed your putting their lives to risk, Your whole purpose of saving cattle will not serve then.

DisAgree [3] Agree [35] Reply Report Abuse
Rohit Poojary, Mangaladevi/Mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Law & Order as completely failed. This as witnessed that, we the coastal people are moving towards Vinaash.

"Vinaash Kaale vipireetha Buddhi"

DisAgree Agree [12] Reply Report Abuse
Edgar, M'lore/Sharjah
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Waste....m sure they r gonna bury it..which was to be consumed as food..afterall wat r these goons gonna do if at all cow slaughter wud b banned in future??

DisAgree [6] Agree [16] Reply Report Abuse
Satish Kumar, mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
All these cattles theft from poor peoples home who depends cattle for their livelyhood to sell milk. Illegal transportation of cattle person should get a severe punishment.

DisAgree [18] Agree [12] Reply Report Abuse
Deepak, Mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
A very sad incident! The most cruelest death to one of the most kindest living being's! As she is kind (Maa),the sinners would never realize the sin they have committed as they would never be punished by her!

DisAgree [4] Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse
AJ, bangalore.
Sat, Apr 07 2012
I'm in favor of banning cow slaughter. One should respect Hindu belief. Hindu brothers will get same feeling and agony while the issue of cow sluaghter pops up, just like chirstians or muslims if someone insulted christian or muslim Gods or hurted religious feeling.

I bet no one will die due to hunger if they don't get cow meat to eat.

wake up congress.

DisAgree [5] Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse
latha, mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Mr.aloknath why dont we pay haftas to bajarangis to tie all the people together with u to fill in small box and do same what they did to innocent cows. i m not appreciating bds the way u respond is wrong. In comu issues people forgetting humanity .very sad.

DisAgree [2] Agree [20] Reply Report Abuse
Arvas, Mangalore/Dubai
Sat, Apr 07 2012
What is the purpose of the chase done by BD activists that they had to flee the site once the mishap took place?

Why they take-up the task themselves, is it because their level of moral is very high or they are paid for moral policing?

It’s quite evident that their moral level of these BD activists is actually below the basic responsibility level, if they were really moral policing in concern to the cattle’s which were illegally transported they would have stayed there and done the required moral activities for the cattle’s at least. Instead they fled and SRS activists have done the mortality part here, they took the person who was injured to hospital and arranged for the veterinary doctor for the cattle’s.

If they have got a tip on illegal cattle transport, then why take law in hand why not forward the same to police, for instant any illegal or assumed wrong act why not forward the tip to the police. Are the BD activists underestimating the police?

It only seems like they are interested in destructive activities rather than their so called upholding of the principles, in this case I guess the purpose was only to catch hold of the people involved and trash them, which didn’t materialize here, Seems like they are paid for the job, networking to trash, harass people.

Who gave them the right to chase without even confirming the authenticity? The government also does nothing about it these BD activists are becoming goons in the shield of moral policing in Mangalore, still the purpose of the chase done by BD activists remains undisclosed.

DisAgree [1] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse
Rj Errol,92.7 BIG fm, mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Oh my God.Can't see these pics. RIP..

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse
Shalmali Prabhu, Mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Cow slaughtering is the greatest sin a man can commit..

DisAgree [6] Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

Lancelot N Tauro, Manglore - Doha Qatar
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Any illegal transport of cattles should be informed to the nearest police station. Now Bajrang Dal is responsible for accident and killings of 18 GO-Matha's. SO SAD

DisAgree [1] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse
stan, dubai
Sat, Apr 07 2012
BD please start old age/orphanage home for Go Matha's. Now days even children can't take care of Old Parents how they can take care of old cow's and baffellos, Please start old age cattle home so that they can leave thier cattle here insteat of selling to such traders.

DisAgree Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse
Alwyn, Mangalore - USA
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Hope Karnataka State will three days Government mourning. Reason for mourning is 18 cows are died.

DisAgree Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse
Prashanth Pinto, Mumbai India
Sat, Apr 07 2012
The entire fault lies with Bajranag Dal cowards. They should have alerted the Police instead of taking law into their hands. They ran away because they do not have the guts to face the reality. This can happen only in our State. Very sad indeed. BJP should learn lesson from states like UP.

DisAgree [5] Agree [28] Reply Report Abuse
sandy, Bangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
I feel bad for the cattle. I don't understand why police fail to restrict illegal transportation?

DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse
samee, doha
Sat, Apr 07 2012
arrest BD people bcoz of dem it happen if dey had correct information y they dint calld police.

DisAgree Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse
suhail, Udupi
Sat, Apr 07 2012
BJD gundagiri should stop. this is all becoz of them. now they are happy?

DisAgree Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse
Mitwa, Sharjah
Sat, Apr 07 2012

BD should be more proactive in addressing social problems like,

1. Dowry Deaths
2. Female Infanticides
3. Child Marriages

rather than going behind these animals.

DisAgree Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse
deepa, kottara/mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Very sad to see these animals dying for no fault of theirs. Are we human beings are ready for such death???

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse
jigmig, mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Do these people have more power than the government. Why the government is not taking any action against all these people. Does this means once you are elected, release your power to your party so that they can do as they wish.

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse
Ummer, Kundapura
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Kill these illegal cow transporters and gang,this is business don't blame only muslims for that everybody involving ( It seems ). Today's market this business is good, Take risk and make money. We have to think ourselves where went wrong and how to sort out this problem.

DisAgree [2] Agree Reply Report Abuse
Sneha H, Udupi
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Hi praveen, Mangalore

Well !! Your way of view is superior !! But one obsession for your indication there is no expectation whole population to become vegetarian but our anxiety is that avoid cow as food because we all think it as a gomatha well known as as GOD !!

DisAgree [81] Agree [21] Reply Report Abuse
Jeevan, Mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
praveen, mangalore

meaningful thought.....

DisAgree [6] Agree [36] Reply Report Abuse
nagesh nayak, bangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
HATS OFF TO BHAJARANG DAL ACTIVISTS.

BD IS THE ONLY ORGANISATION WHICH CAN ERADICATE ILLEGAL TRANSPORT & SLAUGHTERING OF GOU MATHA .

DisAgree [15] Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse
praveen, mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
it is high time india has high tech slaughter houses and provisions for animals which includes all cattle, pigs and chicken also. slaughtering in religious functions also is cruelty. it is not possible to expect whole population to become vegetarian, we can only make things more humane for the animals.

DisAgree [14] Agree [172] Reply Report Abuse
sunil, Mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Very sad to see pictures. Please ban cow slaughtering in India. Once again don't drag every time BJD's name.If police are not doing their duty somebody need to watch. These Police are involved and are dump.

DisAgree [153] Agree [49] Reply Report Abuse
RAGHUVEER ACHARYA, MADANTHYAR/DUBAI
Sat, Apr 07 2012
please..for god sake... any control over illegal transport of cattle...?..for the mistake of some of the miscreants 18 cattle lost the life...can district authority stop this......?

DisAgree [40] Agree [71] Reply Report Abuse
shahnawaz kukkikatte, dubai/udupi
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Book a case on BD for causing death of these cattles and taking law into their hands. Impotent BJP government in karnataka...no say.. on law and order situation...

DisAgree [86] Agree [220] Reply Report Abuse
rahim, udupi
Sat, Apr 07 2012
What a tragedy..Innocent animals loosing their lives on easter. The person transporting these cows should be punished severely. We need to respect the sentiments of the majority community and cooperate. BD need to stop policing and allows the real police to do their job.

RIP

DisAgree [25] Agree [130] Reply Report Abuse
Aloka Nath, Bengaluru
Sat, Apr 07 2012
Why don't you pay Bajarangis Haftha and allow safe transport of cattles under their own protection?

DisAgree [45] Agree [199] Reply Report Abuse
sunil, mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
very sad to see. Please shoot them in fake encounter.

DisAgree [108] Agree [45] Reply Report Abuse
Ahmed, Mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
On 5th April those culprits involved in transporting the cattle illegally have fled the place. Today, seems like the saviors of cattle fled the place after causing the vehicle to loose control which instantly killed 18 cattle. Either ban cow slaughter or don't restrict at all.

DisAgree [14] Agree [120] Reply Report Abuse
sunil, mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
very sad. BAN SLAUGHTERING OF COWS

DisAgree [128] Agree [49] Reply Report Abuse
Rakesh shetty, mangalore
Sat, Apr 07 2012
SO SAD TO SEE ALL CATTLES. I WOULD LIKE TO REQUEST BAJRANGADAL MORE ALERT NOW AND PUNISH THEM WELL THOSE INVOLVE IN THIS SUCH A CRUEL CRIME. THEY ARE NOT HUMAN BEINGS. JAI GO MATHAA. JAI HO BJP.

DisAgree [190] Agree [51] Reply Report Abuse
shahnawaz kukkikatte, dubai/udupi
Sat, Apr 07 2012
This is all because of the clandistine cattle and beef trade. If you ban, you are not doing any good but you are harming these cattles...As free transportation is not allowed, people will resort to other means to transport these cattles. As a result, in one vehicle one could load as many as heads. Its a trade which shall thrive and prosper on illegal means by paying hefty haftas to the authorities. Proper licensing and permit and proper classification shall avoid these mishaps and conflicts...But no one could stop or eradicate it completely....

DisAgree [41] Agree [208] Reply Report Abuse

Latest

Top Stories

Mangalore: 18 Cattle Killed, One Person Injured as Transport Vehicle Overturns

Top Stories

Comment on this article

mukesh poojary, mangalore

stan, dubai

Melvin, Australia

sunil pereira, neermarga

Steevan, Mangalore/Dubai

Ram Shetty, Mangalore/Mumbai

Girish Kumar, Mangalore

Girish Kumar, Mangalore

Sayed Kaleem, Udupi/Dubai

Alwyn, Canada

lawrence, abudabi mangalore

NASRULLA, MANGALORE /DUBAI

Suresh P, mangalore

Arshad kadli, Bhatkal /Al Khobar

MA, Kateel

shahnawaz kukkikatte, udupi/udupi

KRPrabhu, Kudla/Bengaluru

shahab / Dubai, Kasaragod

Joseph F. Gonsalves, Bannur, Puttur / Mangalore

ziyan, Udupi/Dubai

zameer, m'lore

ISMAIL.K.PERINJE, PERINJE-YANBU/KSA

Gladson, Brahmavar

Arshad Kadli, Bhatkal / Alkhobar

MAS, Mangalore

Jude, Mangalore Dubai

Naveen Shetty, Mangalore

Vishal P., Mangalore, Kuwait

MGP, KSD/SHJ

Arman, Managalore

vinod shetty, udupi/dubai

Edison D'souza, mangalore/kuwait

Candle, Mangalore

ISMAIL.K.PERINJE, PERINJE-YANBU/KSA

Alan, M'lore

Ravi Gopal Acharaya, Udipi/Dubai

aysha, mangalore, muscat

sushma, mangalore

Rohit Mangaladevi, Mangaladevi/Mangalore

Don, Udupi/blore

Harsha Malhotra, Mangalore/New Delhi

Rohit Poojary, Mangaladevi/Mangalore

Zuze Pernal, Pernal

Rakesh Kumar, Urva, Mangalore / Dubai, UAE

Harsha Malhotra, Mangalore/New Delhi

N. V., YEKKAR PERMUDE

Harsha Malhotra, Mangalore/New Delhi

Sanjeeva Shetty, kottara

Louis, Kuwait

ASh, Mangalore

Mohammad Salauddeen Bantwal, Panmengalore

murali, murali

Louis, Kuwait

Mohammad Salauddeen Bantwal, Panemangalore

avani, mlore/uae

Rohit Poojary, Mangaladevi/Mangalore

Edgar, M'lore/Sharjah

Satish Kumar, mangalore

Deepak, Mangalore

AJ, bangalore.

latha, mangalore

Arvas, Mangalore/Dubai

Rj Errol,92.7 BIG fm, mangalore

Shalmali Prabhu, Mangalore

Lancelot N Tauro, Manglore - Doha Qatar

stan, dubai

Alwyn, Mangalore - USA

Prashanth Pinto, Mumbai India

sandy, Bangalore