Carlsen forfeits game to protect rating, sparks chess controversy


Daijiworld Media Network - Budapest

Budapest, Nov 18: World No 1 Magnus Carlsen has triggered controversy at the pilot event of Total Chess in Budapest after forfeiting his fast classical game against Kazakhstan's female Grandmaster Bibisara Assaubayeva on Tuesday, reportedly to protect his rating.

The Norwegian's decision has divided the chess community, with several prominent players criticising his conduct, while American Grandmaster Wesley So defended the move, saying Carlsen had little to gain from playing the game.

Carlsen and Assaubayeva had already played six games across rapid and blitz formats before the fast classical encounter. Carlsen won both rapid games and three blitz games, while the remaining blitz game ended in a draw. He was leading 11.5-0.5 before the fast classical game, which carried eight points.

The game was scheduled to begin at 6.45 pm local time. Assaubayeva arrived at the playing hall and took her seat, waiting for Carlsen for more than 15 minutes. Carlsen eventually arrived but went directly to chief arbiter Anastasia Sorokina for a discussion before leaving the hall.

According to Sorokina, Carlsen had asked about the penalty for not playing the game. Since the game was not played, he would not lose any rating points. However, he forfeited the eight points available, leaving the overall score at 11.5-8.5.

Both players are scheduled to face each other again on Wednesday.

Carlsen later defended his decision, saying the match was effectively over and that he saw little reason to play a game that would have no meaningful consequence for the overall result.

The decision drew criticism from India's Olympiad chess captain Srinath Narayanan, who wrote on X, “Dignity and courtesy took a fall long before the rating.”

FIDE Chief Executive Adviser Emil Sutovsky also criticised the move, describing it as unsportsmanlike conduct.

American Grandmaster Hans Niemann, who has had a strained relationship with Carlsen since the 2022 cheating controversy, said forfeiting a game was disrespectful to the organisers and the opponent. He argued that such conduct could result in a player being removed from a tournament in other competitions.

Niemann said the event remained serious despite being a pilot tournament and added that he would never take such a decision himself.

Carlsen's former World Championship rival Ian Nepomniachtchi, meanwhile, said he was envious of the Norwegian's position, as his commanding lead in the rapid and blitz segments allowed him to forfeit the game without significantly affecting the overall result.

Wesley So was among the few players who defended Carlsen's decision. He said the Norwegian had little to gain from the game, while a defeat could cost him valuable rating points and potentially allow World No 2 Hikaru Nakamura to overtake him.

So pointed out that Carlsen could gain just one rating point from a win but potentially lose nine points in the event of a defeat, adding that the decision made sense from a rating perspective.

Carlsen has struggled in the fast classical format at the Budapest event. During the group stages, he failed to win any of his 10 games and suffered a defeat against Armenia's Haik Martirosyan. The poor run has reportedly cost him 22 rating points, bringing him dangerously close to dropping below the 2,800-rating mark.

At several points during the tournament, American Grandmaster Fabiano Caruana came close to overtaking Carlsen in the classical rating standings.

Fast classical chess is an accelerated format in which players receive 45 minutes on the clock at the start, with a 30-second increment added after every move.

Total Chess CEO Kjell Madland said the Budapest pilot event was an important opportunity to assess the format and regulations in a live competitive setting. He said organisers would gather feedback from players and arbiters before making any possible refinements ahead of the inaugural edition scheduled for March 2027.

Madland said the organisers were not approaching the exercise with a predetermined intention to change the rules but wanted to ensure the format was thoroughly tested before its official launch.

 

 

  

Top Stories


Leave a Comment

Title: Carlsen forfeits game to protect rating, sparks chess controversy



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.