Azmal Alekkady, Vitla/Dubai

Nirmala you diserve it...allready BJP opened the door for you go and encash it...shame on you nirmala.. dont do again....

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

Joseph F. Gonsalves , Bannur Puttur/Mangalore

Mr. Stevi, Sharjah, You are correct. The traders are fully engaged in illegal activities. The cooking oil, the necessary commodities all kala berake (mixing) etc., etc., Can anybody have business without lies? As much Lies, Lies over lies as much business, business over business. Does all those big, big business people without lies and without indulging in illegal activities became rich? If you are caught corrupt administrators, lawyers, law enforcement people and goondas the case is finished.

Nirmala Venkatesh did not become political victim but she deserves this action because she herself engaged in Aa bail mujhe maar, in Konkani vaten vetelaya vaaga maka aavn ka ga. If bjp was in power and she provides negative report they will also sack her from ncw member. Very simple.

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

Clive, Mumbai

Your quitting from the party is a gain for the Congress party and if you are going to join the BJP, best of luck. Because they will be routed in the next elections. If only Gowda and the Congress come together, then BJP will surely be routed.

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

Vera Alvares, Mumbai

To hold any office of importance one needs the qualities of prudence, a clear vision and purpose. This woman not only has lost sight of her purpose for being there in NCW, but also stubbornly clings to the material perks, power and fame that go with it! Congress is better without such social climbers with just one aim- to remain in the limelight and gain power.

Good riddance for bad rubbish! Women of Mangalore should heave a sigh of relief because the one hope for justice that betrayed them in the hour of need has just been discarded out of the scene. Against the back of Hooliganism spreading against women in Bangalore and the Karnataka CM sanctioning Rs. 130 crore in the budget for the use of temples and appearing on the national media to call it a " farmer's budget',what can the people and women expect under these circumstances.

Venkatesh is right- Women, learn political Karate and kick the hypocrites out of power. Let the people assert their rights- remember, rulers can be changed by the power of your ballot, vote wisely, for your own welfare!

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

Stevi, Sharjah

We all talk about illegal things are happening in the pub. Tell me how many things are happening in India LEGALLY? If I just sit in M’ lore town for 5 min on the road side I'll realize the Legal and illegal. Over loaded Buses, cart, auto, sellers, lawyers, police, everywhere in everyone's life revolves around illegal things which are taking place. People are dead for their SENSES. Need revival now Mangalore need REDEEMER for the fake people.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Franklin Menezes, Kalmadi,

Mrs.Nirmala Venkatesh has been sacked from NCW. It is a good decision taken by the concerned authorities. She should have condemned for the attack of girls and ladies and should have recommended severe punishment to the culprits who are behind the such ugly incidence. Now let she examine her conscience and whther she has made a political statement for the subservient of her mentor.

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

Charles Dsouza, Dxb

You will become a neta. Keep it up but one fine day maar kayega....

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

Charles Dsouza, Dxb

Madam!!!! Its not political conspiracy. You are the conspirator.

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

Karen, Mangalore

You are a victim of nothing. We are victims of your stupidity.

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

Charles D'Mello, Pangala

This lady has shaped her eyebrows ...! Is it Indian culture..????

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

Harold D'cunha, Mangalore, India

Nirmala says she is congress woman in all her life. Whether you are a congress person is immaterial for the job you have been assigned to investigate Mangalore pub attack on girls. In your power and capacity you have not made any attempt to meet the girls who are the victims of this incident. Rather you had visited the goondas at prison and gave statement saying they are repentant.

When the entire Country was watching your report, you have made yourself and NCW a fool and laughing object. You are not the victim of conspiracy rather you have conspired against NCW and trying to be biased for your own selfish interest.. Now nobody is bothered to listen your music.

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

Vasanth, Jeddha/saudi Arabia

Thank you Mr.Charles D Mello, Pangla. It is okay for  Mr.Nagesh nayak Bangalore L.K Advani leads the demolistion of Babri Masjid,it is ok for him if L.K Advani condemns pub attack after one month,it is Ok for him if Narendra Modi kills the minorities. What does Mr. Nagesh Nayak mean by western culture. He is like one of our crooked politicians who promote vernacular{ I mean regional language} medium instruction in schools BUT WILL ENROLL THEIR CHILDREN IN THE BEST ENGLISH MEDIUM SCHOOLS. He is a hypocrite.Himself eats the sweet fruits of the western culture and gives to others PULLI[in thulu-sour}and Kaippe{bitter in Thulu} Let him live in his well. I am ready for a debate with Mr. Nagesh Nayak of Bangalore on "Culture'.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Rolphy Almeida, Udupi/Bangalore

People can be influenced by bribing or threatening to comment in favour of the culprits. Most of us have watched her comments on national television now make your own conclusion.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Aarthi Ponnappa, Madikeri (Kodagu)

Dear Mr. Guru, from what I have read in your post, I am of the firm opinion that you should have your head examined by a good pyschatarist before making such comments. For your information, they don't make sense to anybody. Instead of wasting time on the blog, use it for some constructive purpose. Thank you!

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Jude, Mangalore Dubai

Nice suggestion Mr Guru. From now onwards please ask your women folk to stay indoors. If anything happens to them outside the house please then do not blame the government or the Police. Please stay at home and be safe.

Let us turn our country into another Somalia or another Swat valley. Let us forget the government, police, law and order and our fundamental rights. Let us hand these over the the moral police. Your logic is stay at home and be safe. Let us just find out if the rest of the country agrees to your logic. Jai Hind

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Guru, Hindustan

Hello Charles D'Mello, Pangala... I totally agree with whatever you said.. It is the right of every individual to choose how they want to live. where they want to go etc etc But my Question to you is after choosing if something happens then who is responsible... Why the heck do you blame the goverment? Goverment cant provide police security to each and everyone of us.. if you want this to happen then join the police ... Coming to the pub incident... I dont know why the pub was opened at 3:30 in the afternoon.. when the licence of the pub is not legal then most of the things which was happening inside the pub was also illegal... Let us sit and drink in our house rather then going to PUB... JAI Hind .

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Joseph F. Gonsalves , Bannur Puttur/Mangalore

Do the people/police/administrations know how many pubs are operating in Mangalore and all over Karnataka without proper license, permission and Haptha? Who keeps the security in Mangalore and other places except the star hotels? Why they did not cancel the licenses of all those Pubs? If the Police are not taking Haptha how they will feed politicians for transfers? In Karnataka from top to bottom without corruption a single file will never move and the recent incidence Mr. Sampangi bjp MLA caught red handed. I

n fact Nirmala Venkatesh deserves this action and should have been sacked earlier. If the excise department can cancel pub license with the influence of bjp why congress with the evidence for her partisan report cannot be sacked from the post? She was speaking positively before disembarking Mangalore after that she is speaking negatively. Reason - Firstly, she was naïve in what was going on in Mangalore. She asked arrested people why these girls have not come forward to file FIR against attackers.

Secondly, fear and terror was inflicted in the minds of citizens by the communal minded people and in such status how the girls will file FIR with the Police? Thirdly perhaps she sold herself in Karnataka with the Operation Kamala and may get party ticket to contest elections from bjp. Fourthly, she speaks that as if she is the only supreme NCW member.

Finally, if bjp was in power and appointing her to conduct inquiry and she submits negative report, bjp will also sack her as NCW member. Very simple.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Charles D'Mello, Pangala

MR. NAGESH NAYAK, BANGALORE... IT IS BETTER YOU COME OUT OF THE WELL AND SEE THE WORLD !!!! iF YOU WANT TO DRESS LIKE MAHATMA GHANDI OR WEAR ONLY DOOJA PUJARIS IS YOUR CHOICE. IF YOU WANT TO FOLLOW ANY CULTURE IT IS YOUR CHOICE !!!! GO AHEAD AND DO THAT !!!! YOU AND MUTHALIKS ARE NOBODY TO PREACH OTHERS WHAT CULTURE THEY HAVE TO ADOPT OR WHAT THEY HAVE TO EAT OR HOW THEY HAVE TO DRESS AND WHERE THEY HAVE TO GO TO ENJOY OR GET SPOILED WHATEVER MAY BE !!! IT IS NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS. STOP PREACHING NONSENSE TO THE WORLD BEING IN THE WELL !!!!!

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Sara, Mangalore / UAE

This lady needs to get her head checked first. Instead of focusing on the issue she does everything else including meeting the goons who attached the girls. She is a perfect candidate for the BJP and Rama Sene.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

JAYANT SALIAN, Suratkal/riyadh

Nirmala was Chairperson of NCW who is also a Member of Legislative Council from the Congress party, If her report was in favour of Congress it is OK and if her report is against PUB it is wrong for you guys. Warre Wa, Mangaloreans wake up. Be not Hindus, Muslims and Chrisitians or whatever religion you belong when it comes to our city. Say Rama Sena goondas are wrong, Pub culture is sin, Pink chaddi campaign is sin. Sending your own sisters and daughter to pub is sin. Through your reaction do not show to which religion you belong to. We all Mangaloreans belong to one happy fmaily.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Lester Pinto, Mangalore-Chennai

Ms. Nirmala Venkatesh, with due respect to your ignorance of facts, let me remind you that India is a vast country with great potential. If you lose your job today, it may be very difficult to find another job. But if you choose to quit your party today, you are rest assured of being welcomed by your rival party with open arms. Remember, in India there is absolutely no difference between politics and prostitution! So it is high time you come to terms with reality!!

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

Damodar M.P., Bangalore

Bye Bye Nirmala Venkatesh....BJP ticket is waiting for you.Sri Rama Sene will be at your back!!

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

nagesh nayak, bangalore

NIRMALA VENKATESH DONE A FANTASTIC JOB.REAL PICTURE OF UPA COME OUT AT LAST.THEY WANT WESTERN CULTURE AT ANY COST (EVEN ILLEGALY).DAY BEFORE YESTERDAY TV9 WAS TELECASTING KAMAKANDA IN CONGRESS GUEST HOUSE IN ANDHRA PRADESH. TIMES NOW TELECASTING TORTURE BY USA POLICE PERSONNEL ON TEEN AGE GIRL. EVERYDAY LACS OF INCIDENT HAPPENNING & YOU GUYS ARE STILL WORRIED ABOUT PUB INCIDENT.COME OUT OF THE WELL & SEE THE WORLD.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

DEEPAK, MANGALORE

she looks like bollywood film actress...

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Jude, Mangalore Dubai

Mrs Venkatesh, You have done the most common thing by blaming your present situation as a political conspiracy. As someone else suggested would you have written the same report if your daughter or a woman from your family was attacked?. You were not sent there to check on the licence of the pub and security arrangements. Is any pub allowed to maintain an armed security force in our country?. What can a few security guys do when a gang of goondas attack just like the horde of Ram Sena goondas did at Amnesia?.

Instead of meeting the victims and consoling them you visit the goondas in jail and offer your sympathies to them. Do you think that the entire nation is just stupid to digest your actions and your silly report. I think reading your report would make every woman's blood boil. Accepting your report would mean sending back our women way back into the medievel times, just as how the taleban would want them to be. Anyways you may soon get a ticket from the BJP to contest.......Your political career might be on the upswing.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Eric Coelho, Mangalore/Ajman

A Fanatic Group attacked Good Time Partiers, then the Political Parties started politicising the Issues, then the Woman Commissioner puts Verbal Attacks on Pub LIcence, its security and provides consolation to the Criminal Attackers, then there is a Clash going on between the Ministry and Womens Commission. Ultimately to conclude it is nothing but Ego Clash and Clash of Arrogance. This Pub Attack and many several attacks on Women will all have a slow death.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Ashraf Sullia Kuwait, Kuwait

Ms Nirmala Venkatesh, Your next door will be open so soon in BJP. Also, forget the wrong report which you have produced recently even though that doesn't say the fact happened in PUB. However you were successful to appease BJP groups. Good Luck in your Political Career!

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

C. Ferrer, mangalore

OH so now we find that the fight is between two women- the MLC and the Union Minister- wait, both from the Congress. NCW has become a tool among politicians- how long will it be bfore the MLC moves over to another party as she is not wanted after her biased report. She was sent to investigate the incident she comes back with a report blaming the pub management, its great she did not check whether the bldg was legal,the road was proper etc. Just like so many things,reports are a whitewash the girls expected action and got nothing at all.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Vincent, Mangalore

Mrs Venkatesh - First of all you were sent to investigate the violence against women and not for checking violations of pub licence.If you dont know your job and try to do something outside your purview then its but natural that you will be dismissed so you cant call it a political conspiracy!!! ITS YOUR STUPIDNESS IN DOING SOMETHING YOU WERE NOT SUPPOSED TO DO.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Kevin Mascarenhas, Mangalore/UAE

Nirmala Venkatesh ...should we now have a one woman committee to go into your sacking? If you had not played with your powerful position people would have supported you. Now you have learnt your lesson play with fire and one day you could be burned.see the positive side you now have an opportunity lots of time for reflection.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

kiran, Udupi

Now we can see the true color of congress party

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Ravi, Karkala

All these years what congress has done to the public is what exactly nirmal venkatesh has said,congress is totally biased that is the reason it is losing its identity being I was a stuanch congressman.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Vasanth, Jeddha/ Saudi Arabia

Dear Ms. Nirmala Venkaesh, which party you belong is immatirial.Let me ask you a simple question.If one of the young girl students happened to be your own daughter -would you still support the action of the Goondas.What culture were you supporting-molesting girls.

All of you, including you Ms.Nirmala-have been used to western attitude and way of life why mix a WAY OF LIFE in to culture.Do not talk of conspiracy.You should be tried in court for supporting Goonadas for molesting and disgracing girls in public.Those insulted were our SISTERS and we will NEVER ,NEVER allow this hypocritic GENDER BIAS to continue.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

R Prabhu, IXE/KSA

Ms Ventatesh you will surely find another good job soon. Well I hope you will realise that you should have done your JOB and not meddled into affairs which is not of concern. The primary objective of your visit was to report correctly and accurately on the incident in question.

Realising your position and responsibility, you should have handled the report and findings with utmost care and perfection. It was a report the whole nation was waiting for and the outcome was a huge huge dissappointment specially for the women and men who were attacked in the pub including the ones watching the story and incident closely.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Charles D'Mello, Pangala

Ms Nirmala Venkatesh, since you have been sacked from NCW, you can make public what you have reported !!! Anyway we are not ready to by your report regarding the pub licence!!!! As no customer will be aware of the legality of the Restaurant or Bar.....!!! We are not even going to buy your comment that women must be ready to face their security !!! As a woman evan you have failed to keep your posting !! Come up with some logical comments please. This comment of yours that you are a victim of political conspiracy can not be digested by a common person!!! Cheers to you !

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse