Is BJP Responsible for Delay in Implementing Afzal Guru's Death Row?


PTI

Mumbai, Apr 15: Is BJP responsible for dealy in executing alleged terrorist Afzal Guru? Going by home minister Chidambaram's words, it is quite possible. Speaking in the metro he said that BJP is looking at Parliament attack convict Afzal Guru's case through the "lens of religion," Union home minister P Chidambaram said here.

Responding to BJP's criticism for not executing Afzal Guru, despite Supreme Court sentencing him to death, Chidambaram pointed out that there are 28 convicts on the "death row", and Afzal Guru is number 22.

"The earliest case (among the 28) is from Tamil Nadu. The death sentence was awarded on June 24, 1987 and confirmed by Supreme Court on April 22, 1998. The BJP came to power in March 1998. Why did BJP-led government not execute any of them?" Chidambaram asked.

There are three other terrorists who are awaiting execution, he said, "If you are picking out one convict (Afzal), you are looking at the case through lens of religion. A convict is a convict, he is not a Hindu or a Muslim," he said.

Convicts in Rajiv Gandhi assassination case too are on the death row, he added.

Explaining the delay in executions, he said that mercy petitions of convicts are examined as per "well established but slow procedure whether one likes it or not" and that was why BJP too did not carry out any executions during the NDA rule.

"There is also a larger debate as to whether death sentence should be replaced by imprisonment for whole life," Chidambaram said. 

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Rolphy Almeida, Udupi/Bangalore

    Thu, Apr 30 2009

    Prshanth Shetty UAE, I think you are confused, if I am not mistaken they have kidnapped Mufthi Mohammed’s daughter and Mr. V. P. Singh’s government was in power which was supported by BJP at that time and not congress. Do not try to mislead people without proper information.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Valerian, Kota

    Mon, Apr 20 2009

    Chidambaram's explanation clearly shows how BJP is misleading the nation for the sake of power. People should not get misled by such publicity. Secularism is the only way for India to develop.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • kumar, mangalore/mumbai

    Mon, Apr 20 2009

    The present ruling govt. is UPA & not BJP. Naturally, how can  BJP be responsible for the delay. If UPA cannot implement the court verdict, it only means the innablilty of UPA or its unwillingness. UPA is purely responsible for delay.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • JOY CASTELINO, MOODUBELLE/DUBAI

    Sun, Apr 19 2009

    Prashanth Shetty, UAE, for your information it is not congress which exchanged five terrorist for former Congress leader (presently PDP) Mufti Mohammed's daughter in Kashmir. It is National Front government, which is supported by BJP. And Mufti Mohammed is not in Congress party that time, he is in Janata Dal.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Prashanth Shetty, UAE

    Fri, Apr 17 2009

    Why Chidabaram messd up DNA report of Mumbai attackers? Congress blames BJP each and every issue. I dont agree with exchange of terrorist but it was started by Congress. Congress exchanged five terrorist for former Congress leader (presently PDP) Mufti Mohammed's daughter in Kashmir when plane was hijacked in kashmir. Kandhahar was outside the Indian teritory and India informed Pakistan about their plan to storm the plane by commondos but the hijackers were suddenly armed by Pakistanis. It is easy to say. Even during the hijacking of ships by pirates in Somalia, how people put pressure on government to send warships to rescue. Storming is only possible, if you have support from foriegn governments not by hostile one.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • rakesh gorigudda, mangalore

    Thu, Apr 16 2009

    We cannot expect any sort of punishment to afzal guru from the upa govt...hope N.D.A will honour the supreme court's decision by hanging afzal guru.....JAI HIND.....

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Kevin Mascarenhas, Mangalore/UAE

    Thu, Apr 16 2009

    I agree with the procedure of giving justice to the death row convicts. However we have to quicken this procedure or simply abolish the death row and give them life terms. What is lacking in Indian politics is that real common man's issues on development plans implemented or planned are not discussed. Only non issues like Nuclear deal, religion, building temple, power politics etc. get highlighted and gullible people fall for it. Time to change our politics.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Robert George, Mumbai/Australia

    Thu, Apr 16 2009

    With the tentacles of the Taliban tightening around Pakistan, the threat of Taliban-backed terrorist attacks on India escalates by the day. Indian politicians of all hues are caught in a cleft stick. They are unable to shake off the mind-numbing political correctness, which is especially evident in their philosophy of appeasement to garner votes. India, which had been critical of Israel’s high-handedness in Gaza and other areas, has realised lately that terrorism is a modern day scourge.

    The real cause of the never-ending terrorism is the unremitting desire of these barbarians to annihilate civilized societies. Politicians need to give up their sophistry and stop tunneling their heads even more deeply into the sand of deceit. If not, soon they will be shaken out of their stupor when the Taliban infiltrate into India.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Saif, Bahrain

    Thu, Apr 16 2009

    Why cant our leaders stop accusing and blaming each other on religion matters. Why cant they just concentrate on fair and good election and look for a good and bright India ahead.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • naveen, mangalore

    Thu, Apr 16 2009

    Dear Lydia Lobo, Kadri, what you are telling about Ram Mandir issue (not built the mandir while on power), for your kind information BJP had Power BUT with NDA so BJP allone c'dnt take decision. Ram mandir Nirman is only BJP's agenda not NDA's.  Please dont give baseless comments...and one more thing after finishing  5 years now during election time only our great minister got this dream or what????

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Chidananda, Vitla/Mumbai

    Thu, Apr 16 2009

    These type of allegations are started by illiterate BJP 'leaders's like Dhananjay Kumar, C.T. Ravi' etc. These people do not really  know the current world affairs. Also these people do not know about the constituion very well.. May god help them.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Manoj, Mangalore

    Thu, Apr 16 2009

    Mr. Shrinvas - are you an Indian or a citizen of another nation? You have termed the Prime Minster as "Your PM", is he not your PM too?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • shrinivas, India

    Thu, Apr 16 2009

    Dear PC BJP asked hang Afzal because he attacked INDIAN Parliament, not any Hindu Temple of Hindu group, then how you will say BJP looks in a religious mind. You want to make every incidents into communal.. why your PM told innocent muslims suffering under terrorist blames, why there is no Hindus also..? why all these ..? you want Muslim vote isnt it..?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • George Cruz, Mangalore/USA

    Thu, Apr 16 2009

    The people like Afzal Guru who have been convicted of serious crimes against mother India should have been hanged long time ago. The UPA government is playing communal politics in this case.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Walter Miranda, Karnataka/India

    Thu, Apr 16 2009

    It is a common Practice in Indian politics criticising other political parties and other politicians and dragging each others legs. As BJP knows that there were 28 convicts on the death row ,so the govt. and court should take the cases in the hand one by as per serial number starting from serial number 1, 2, 3 so on and should not go to pick up the serial number 22 which is serial number of the convict Afzal Guru Afzal Guru. If the earliest death sentence case was from Tamil Nadu which was awarded in June 24, 1987 and it was confirmed by the msupreme court on April 22, 1998 there after on June 1998 BJP Govt. was came to power so that time why the BJP Govt. was not uted this death sentce case of Tamil Nadu?

    And now why the BJP is point out towards the case No. 22 of Afzal Guru? What about BJP POLITICIANS? are they LITERATE OR ILLITERATE who do not aware of the meaning of the serial numbers 1, 2, 3 so on?

    This is the dirty tricks BJP is playing now during the election time for confusing the people and gaining the confidence of the people to vote BJP!!!!! Same as this confusion also created by the Karnataka Minister Krishna Palemar and the corporation newly Elected Maior about self assessment tax both advised the general public to pay the tax according to the old tax payment system but without providing the challen of tax amount how the people can pay the tax in the old system? Suppose we go to ask this matter with the Corporation Revenue department they are telling to approach Palemar and the Maior to get the challen who did not confimred us to collect the tax in the form of old taxation system.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • naveen, Mlr/Blr

    Thu, Apr 16 2009

    Mr Rohit shetty mangalore same terrorists regrouped and attacked indian parliament and so many other attacks.releasing those terrorist was a mistake..

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Joachim Fernandes, US

    Thu, Apr 16 2009

    Respect for the rule of law requires the Indian government to allow convicts to appeal the verdict. BJP's is revealing its contempt for the rule of law by politicising the case of one convict because of his religion.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rajesh_kumar, Udupi

    Thu, Apr 16 2009

    It is however a political answer.. But Sinha what is happening in Mangalore? You mean by the BJP government at the state? Little more clarification will clear the air pretty foul already....? Blame game ?? I heard some one say if voted to power military would be sent accross the border...? it is because if voted to power or is it if the situation so warrants and if the nation so wants and authorises action for a situation and if the nation stands behind the decision what ever the consequences....??

    No Politics in defence and no politics and religion in Law and order please...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Mohammed, Mangalore

    Thu, Apr 16 2009

    Dear Rohith Shetty, Mangalore You should know that The Hijacked flight made two stops in Indian Airport (Territory) before it landed in the lawless state Afghanistan Secondly when you admit that NDA did not ute the No 1 accused for your information that the death sentence was awarded on June 24, 1987 and confirmed by Supreme Court on April 22, 1998. The BJP came to power in March 1998. So you should ask BJP led government what stopped him?

    And moreover it’s BJP who started blame game, when talking about one issue it should be covered all not by part, as Union home minister P Chidambaram rightly said that BJP is looking at Parliament attack convict Afzal Guru's case through the "lens of religion". Why BJP demanding only Afzal Guru’s ution what about those 21 convicts, some of them murderer of our X prime minister of INDIA.

    To be frank BJP don’t have any issue to face the election so it playing religion issue to garner Hindu Vote people would have supported BJP if it fight election on the basis of ROTI KAPDA MAKAN rather than MANDIR / JIHADI / CONVERSSION & COW.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Jude, Mangalore Dubai

    Wed, Apr 15 2009

    The blame game was started by certain sections of the BJP,and not Mr.Advani, because Mr Advani knows fully well why Afzal Guru is not hanged till date. Only now when Mr Chidambaram and the congress have reacted the supporters of the BJP are calling it blame game. Afzal Guru will be hanged sooner or later, but the system that we have been following will continue. Tomorrow even after Ajmal Kasab's conviction, he too will live for another 8 - 10 years before he is finally sent to his maker. Secondly on the issue of the Kandahar hijacking, the government of the day behaved in haste.

    There was no need for Mr Jaswant Singh to accompany the terrorists all the way, and the way he was addressing one of the Talebani goons as His Excellency, was simply sickening. It was as if he was groveling at the goon's feet. Secondly i don't think all avenues of negotiation were exhausted before a decision was taken to release the terrorists. The reason why talk of the Kandahar hijacking is surfacing is because the BJP is needlessly blaming the congress government of being weak, when the governement has acted swiftly and decisively after the 26/11 attacks and isolated Pakistan diplomatically. If the BJP is blaming the congress today, then it should understand that it too did not give a good account of itself while in power in tackling terrorism. They keep harping about POTA, but Pota was used mostly to supress political opponents, rather than terrorists. Terrorism is an international problem and we are one of the most vunerable states due to our proximity with Pakistan and Afghanistan and therefore instead of blaming each other, all parties should sit together and come out with concrete plans to handle this problem once and for all.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Anand, Kinnigoli/Jebel Ali/Dubai

    Wed, Apr 15 2009

    Dear Minister, Once Supreme Court has given verdict for Hanging, no party/govt.should blame each other and prolong the work.Our Country is just quaralling and blamming each other and doing nothing. In every body's tennure they are doing the best for country.All are looking their family safety but not betterment of safty of India.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • jagdish Narayan, Bajpe.UAE

    Wed, Apr 15 2009

    Again one more Blame Game in row. Here i am not favouring any Govt. We need to respect law. Once he has convicted by Supreme court. why should any authority delay to ute it. This should be done irrespective of any thing. Supreme court passed the verdict after all trials. Mr. Chidambaram is just passing the fire ball to others court like Mr. Advani used to do it (still he is doing) during pre Election meetings. I was not surprised by the number to be uted bicause this is our Democratic India. First eliminate all this Culprits and whoever wants themselve indulge in this kind of aciviteis will refrain doing so. Mera Bharat Mahan

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rohith Shetty, Mangalore

    Wed, Apr 15 2009

    Dear Lydia You talk about BJP releasing terrorists. Just answer 1 question what other option the Govt had when the situation was in one of the lawless state Afganisthan which was the safe haven and ruled by Taliban. Do you think the talibans would have let the flight to take of from there ? Do you think they would have kept quite if India planned storming the plane by commondos. Just answer this question before you accuse BJP for handovering terrorists. Would you question the same if one your relative was there in that flight ?. What would Congress would have done when there were more than 100 innocent lives in danger in that plane who were nearly suffocating for around a month. What about the state of those Womens and childrens in that flight irrespective of what religion they belong, party they belong, age they belong. Please imagine wife of Just married Katial Family, i believe)whos husband got killed and dumped in Dubai. Do you guys have any idea what hell the people might have gone through in that plane. Its very easy to say the Govt released terrorist. Anyone party and individuals should first only talk about the options first and then blame the then ruling NDA. Jaswanth singh dint escort the terrorists to kandhahar for his family profits there. Law itself says no matter if one criminal excapes law for the time but innocents shouldnt be punished. Why dint Congress cry that time when the protestors were in the streets of Delhi demanding the Govt to solve the crisis. Why dint they raise their voices then but raise now. Ok we admit NDA dint ute the No 1 accused. Then what stopped the congress which was ruling since 1987 to 2009 minus NDA to ute.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • MANU, ORISSA/INDIA

    Wed, Apr 15 2009

    Whatsoever happened it’s happened and we will not get back. Don’t hang them. Give them a mercy. Sentence them lifetime for their crimes.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Pradeep, Mangalore

    Wed, Apr 15 2009

    Wake up India, wake up !! Whether it is Congress or BJP, both are playing safe in sending these convicts to gallows. Let us make sure that these convicts are put behind bars for life without any bail instead of waiting for mercy petitions. This will never end in Indian democrarcy as one has to go through many offices / authorities for approval. Otherwise to have fast result, let them all be hanged at one time. Job done. Oh....Kasab is in waiting !! Who comes next?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Lydia Lobo, Kadri

    Wed, Apr 15 2009

    PC has been a very tactful minister may it be Finance or Home Ministry. Though being shoe-hit for none of his fault, he handled the controversy very professionally. By making confidential issues a public rag, BJP indeed puts words to the minister's mouth. Had they not bragged on Afzal's hanging, we would not even have known about the number of people awaiting gallows. Now, let BJP convince us why they did not clear out the cases before Guru and instead chose to whipping Congress. BJP has lost in Terror-supporting issue (courtesy release of terrorists), Ram Mandir issue (not built the mandir while on power), now, even Afzal issue is bounced back to their face. What will be the next fault that they will find in Congress ?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • naveen, mangalore

    Wed, Apr 15 2009

    Ok Minister. Let us assume ur argument is correct.Now what prevented UPA from going through list starting from No.1 in the list ? When election comes even intelectuals turn blind. Chidambaram needs one good tap on his brain to refresh it.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Navin Sinha, Patna/Mangalore

    Wed, Apr 15 2009

    Our tolerance is being abused and exploited by the present government.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Is BJP Responsible for Delay in Implementing Afzal Guru's Death Row?



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.