CBI not Congress Bureau of Investigation, says PM


New Delhi, July 26 (IANS) Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Monday called for the smooth functioning of parliament and said that it was ready for all discussions on the issue of the arrest of former Gujarat minister Amit Shah.

"CBI... is not Congress bureau of investigation. CBI is not mouthpiece of Congress," Manmohan Singh told reporters outside parliament before the beginning of the monsoon session.

He was answering questions on the Bharatiya Janata Party's allegation that the Congress-led central government was behind the arrest of former Gujarat minister of state for home Amit Shah in the 2005 Sohrabuddin Sheikh staged shootout case.

"There is no truth in that. Opposition knows that jolly well. Sohrabuddin Sheikh is Supreme Court-directed case. Central government has no role in it," he asserted.

He added that the government "was ready for every piece of discussion in Amit Shah's case".

Manmohan Singh then called upon the opposition parties to let parliament function smoothly.

"We are here to debate many issues of national importance, Government is ready for every piece of discussion that the opposition may want," he said, adding, "We want the parliament to function smoothly… that is what the people of India expect."

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • ISLAH sharief, DAMMAM,Mangalore

    Tue, Jul 27 2010

    Dear Keshava,Putturu...

    It is reported that Tulsiram prajapati & Soharabuddin sheikh both were extortionist working at the behest of elements in the Gujarat & Rajasthan Police.....

    It is also alleged that Amit Sha had accepted Rs2.5 crore bribe through his intermediary Girish Dani from Scamster Ketan parekh.Parekh was involved in the famous Rs 1,600 crore Madhavapura mercentile cooperative scam...Amit Sha is the director of Maadhavapura Bank.

    Now you decide who is a big cheater & who is small....

    Please donot love or hate on communal feelings...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • nagesh nayak, bangalore

    Tue, Jul 27 2010

    hi,donfrank, Mangalore, India,

    YOUR PM IS HONEST & SINCERE TO ITALIAN MADAMME.

    IF HE IS SINCERE & HONEST LET HIM TAKE ACTION AGAINST RAJA OF SPECTRUM SCAM. IF HE TAKES ACTION YOUR PM WILL LOSE HIS SEAT.

    IF YOUR PM IS SINCERE & HONEST LET HIM TAKE ACTION AGAINST NCP LEADERS WHO ARE MORE INDULGED IN THEIR PRIVATE BUSINESS.

    WHY YOUR SINCERE & HONEST PM WITHDREW CBI CASES AGAINST LALU, MULAYAM, MAYA WATI & OTHERS FOR THE SAKE OF PM GADDI.

    IF HE IS SINCERE & HONEST HE WOULD HAVE REDUCED THE PRICES OF PETROLEUM PEODUCTS.

    HE WOULD HAVE ORDERED FOR CBI ENQUIRY FOR 33% WASTAGE OF FOOD GRAINS IN CWC.

    HE WOULD HAVE TOLD BHARDWAJ NOT TO INTERFERE IN GOVERNMENT'S DAY TO DAY ACTIVITIES PLUS NOT TO USE GOVERNOR HOUSE AS CONGRESS OFFICE.

    IF YOUR PM IS HONEST LET HIM BRING & PUNISH DEVIL WARREN ANDERSON WHO KILLED 20000 PEOPLE .

    LET HIM PUT BEHIND THE BAR TO THOSE WHO MASSACRED 3000 PLUS SIKHS.

    YOUR PM IS INTERESTED ONLY IN DESTABILISING BJP GOVERNMENT.

    DO NOT COMMENT LIKE A PSUEDO.

    JAI HO BJP.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • donfrank, Mangalore, India

    Tue, Jul 27 2010

    Mr Nagesh Naik, your love for BJP has made you blind. However, you should always balance your comments. BJP has done many blunders which you are not accepting but the world knows it. You are only criticising Congress and UPA for all the good or bad things. Our PM is a honest and sincere person. Remeber what happened to your beloved Mr. Advani during the last elections, when he had used very bad words against our PM. People just taught a lesson to Mr. advani and his dream of becoming PM was dashed! Your hero, Mr. Narendra Modi has committed some blunders and he has to pay for it! Let us wait and see!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • shahnawaz kukkikatte, Dubai/Udupi

    Tue, Jul 27 2010

    The list of puupets is below.

    Manmohan singh - Sonia Gandhi,

    Narendra Modi - RSS - Gadkari

    Yeddiyurappa - Mining Reddys

    Yeddiyurappa Shobakka

    The list is never ending. What do say Shriman Nagesh Nayak.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ISMAIL K PERINJE, PERINJE/YANBU-KSA

    Tue, Jul 27 2010

    Some right wing ultra-Nationalist comenting against our beloved ,respected,honest and Mr clean PM of India.Karnataka CM remote controlled by RSS and in another tier by Reddy garus. Can Yeddi go against Reddy and Cheddis?? Every body knows in Karnataka that whenever Reddygarus gives talaq to Yeddy the very next moment there would be no BJP govt in state. We have to thank god for providing us such a personality like H.H. MR MANMOHAN SINGH AS A PRIME MINISTER OF INDIA.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Amit S, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    We already have one SBI. So Sonia Bureueu of Invesitgation is not possible. CBI is a simply a bunch of incompetent jokers dancing to the tune of its masters. MMS does the same thing and it is quite natural for him to react this way.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • nagesh nayak, bangalore

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    hey,aboobaker uppala, uppala/Holy Makkah, WE CAN'T CONSIDER THE HONOURABLE PRIME MINISTER AS A POLITICIAN. HE MAY A BIG ZERO IN THE POLITICS . BUT HE IS AN EXCELLENT PUPPET. NO BODY CAN QUESTION HIS YES MADAMME ATTITUDE .PERHAPS HE IS THE NUMBER ONE PUPPET OF THE WORLD. BLAMING THE TOP INVESTIGATION AGENCY OF THIS COUNTRY IN SUCH A WAY IS NOT HEALTHY AT ALL .IT IS ACTING ACCORDING TO THE CONGRESS & ITALIAN MADAMME.
    THE GUJRAT GOVERNMENT IS A PROUD ON THE FACE OF INDIAN DEMOCRACY.AND THE SUPPORTERS SUPPORTING THEIR DEVELOPING ACT ALSO A PROUD ON THE FACE OF HUMANITY. A HOME MINISTER OF STATE USING THE ADMINISTRATIVE SYSTEM OF THE COUNTRY TO PROTECT A PARTICULAR COMMUNITY AND THERE ARE PEOPLE TO SUPPORT HIM?? WHAT KIND OF A LOVE IS THIS? LOVE IS BLIND BY NATURE. LOVE AND PEACE IS THE TRUTH. WHEN YOU WILL START TO SPREAD THE TRUTH.

    JAI SHRIMAAN NARENDRA MODIJI.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sudhir, Kundapur/USA

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    Lets for an example PM is not lying, and justice in fake encounter victims is the real issue then the first state where the CBI should be conducting enquiry should be UP which tops the list in number of encounters in a calendar year.

    Second in the list is bihar, 3rd Maharashtra and 4th Andhra Pradesh. (source India today July 18 2010 article)

    Why are some encounters more important that others for CBI.

    aboobaker uppala,

    I do support Gujarat government for encounter killing of Sohrabuddin and Tulsiram Prajapati. Both have a known history of smuggling guns and ammunition rounds from Pakistan through Rajastan border. Also Sohrabuddin had links with Dawood Ibrahim. Some one has posted all the charges against the 2 in police stations of MP, Rajasthan and Gujarat on Scribd.

    If you consider me a "blot on humanity" I am happy to be one. (One request please do not use SATYAMEVA JAYATE It does not go well with rest of your post)

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • aboobaker uppala, uppala/Holy Makkah

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    WE CAN'T CONSIDER THE HONOURABLE PRIME MINISTER AS A POLITICIAN.HE MAY A BIG ZERO IN THE POLITICS.BUT HE IS AN EXCELLENT ADMINISTRATOR.NO BODY CAN QUESTION HIS TALENT AND CALIBRE.PERHAPS HE IS THE NUMBER ECONOMIST OF THE WORLD.BLAMING THE TOP INVESTIGATION AGENCY OF THIS COUNTRY IN SUCH A WAY IS NOT HEALTHY AT ALL.IT IS ACTING ACCORDING TO THE COURT ORDER.IF IT IS ACTING ACCORDING TO THE DIRECTIVES OF CONGRESS,THEN WHAT IS THE OPPOSITION IS DOING IN THE PARLIAMENT?

    THE GUJRAT GOVERNMENT IS A BLOT ON THE FACE OF INDIAN DEMOCRACY.AND THE SUPPORTERS SUPPORTING THEIR BARBARIC ACT ALSO A BLOT ON THE FACE OF HUMANITY.A HOME MINISTER OF STATE MISUSING THE ADMINISTRATIVE SYSTEM OF THE COUNTRY TO BUTCHER A PARTICULAR COMMUNITY AND THERE ARE PEOPLE TO SUPPORT HIM??WHAT KIND OF A HATREDNESS IS THIS?HATREDNESS IS FALSE BY NATURE.LOVE AND PEACE IS THE TRUTH.WHEN YOU WILL START TO SPREAD THE TRUTH,THE FALSE WILL PERISH BY IT'S NATURE.SATYAMEV JAYATE.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Franky D Silva, Mangalore, UAE

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    The bottom line is "everyone has to accept the verdict of the judiciary" Our beloved PM is right when he said that CBI is not a Congress Bureau of Investigation. During six years of NDA rule, led by BJP, was it a BJP Bureau of Investigation? We all know that the Supreme Court has ordered the probe and not the UPA Govt. If one is innocent, why to get scared of the courts and the legal cases!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Murthy, Bangalore

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    Politics at best. Manmohan may be a honest person, his party maybe not. What happened to Bofors? Where did the italian culprit escape ? Why did our telecom minister's huge fraud of 2G license not booked ? Why does once in a while Mayawati support Congress ? To survive in politics you have to play the games , if you are honest or not.

    Reddy brothers are @#$@#%. But is Congress is not a sinner. Deshpande the KPCC chief was worth more than 1000 crores (check the application he field for Karanatake Assembly). Does anyone know what industry it was ? Mining. Do u know how much worth he was when he started his career. Congress knows to play the game being in power for decades, BJP does not. In today's world you have to choose the best among the worst parties.

    Is Congress concerned about muslim ? Is congress concerned about convicting Amit shah. Absolutely not. But it does createa enough noise to show their "secular" credential and it helps in forthcoming Bihar Elections too. Its Congress's reply to Nitish's game to influence Muslim vote in Bihar. Amit Shah will be free man in few months.

    There are few good man in politics in all parties..but lets also understand these A%^ %#@# games.

    Regarding mining, why not make it a PSU or nationalize it. Santosh hegde says it generates over 20 crore in revenue PER DAY. Wow.! We can make a world of difference in Karanataka with such money..

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • RICHARD MORAS, BAHRAIN.

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    THE NAME OF CBI CANNOT BE CHANGED AS BBI UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES.IT WILL REMAIN AS CBI ONLY.I DO AGREE THAT MANMOHAN SINGH IS A RESPECTED LEADER.BUT HE HAS NO MUCH CONTROL OVER THE ADMINISTRATION.EVEN THE MINISTERS REPORT TO SONIA GANDHI WHICH IS UNBECOMING OF A DEMOCRATIC COUNTRY.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ISMAIL K PERINJE, PERINJE/YANBU-KSA

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    Mr Manmohansingh the Prime Minister of India is the most respected political head in the world.When NDA is ruling CBI is pure for some of Sangh Parivar supporters and UPA is ruling again sour for them.Shameless dubble speak.

    after AMITH SHA REDYY BROTHERS RAMULU ..........are next few in waiting of CBI list

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Harshith, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    yes M.nayak
    congress will rule for another minimum 10 years . Watch rahul . BJP created hatredness among us which is the main cause people are moving away from it. They could not fulfill a single committment on building ram temple in ayodhya.we donated heavily but god knows where the money went?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Bhaskar Kolnad, Dubai

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    Every party in power at the centre misuses the CBI.Nobody wants the CBI and CVC to be independent body and powerful.
    That's how criminals and corrupts are running and ruining this country.Nothing can be done to clean this mess.
    Sohrabuddin Sheikh is not clean figure .So the government do not need to worry about his encounter if it is fake or genuine.
    CBI had more serious cases to investigate ,but left it rot that is of Lalu's fodder,Madhu Koda's blackmoney,Jayalalitha,Mayavati's illegal assets,Raja'2G to name a few.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ajit, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    Mr. PM,
    This is rubbish. How come you have Lalu, Balu, Allu, Mulu, Jaya, Maya etc are all having clean chit.
    Mr. Nagesh we are not pro cong or anti BJP but nobdy is here to work for you n me. Everybody is ALI BABA. I agree to you views in this regard

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Abbas Ali, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 26 2010


    Well Said :

    IF CBI GIVE CLEAN CHIT TO AMIT SHAH, AN ACCUSED KILLER, THEN WE CAN CALL CBI AS - 'BBI' (BJP BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION) RIGHT ?

    I CANT STOP LAUGHING

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Peter Pereira, Pune

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    IF CBI GIVE CLEAN CHIT TO AMIT SHAH, AN ACCUSED KILLER, THEN WE CAN CALL CBI AS - 'BBI' (BJP BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION) RIGHT ?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • DEV KUMAR, Mumbai - Dubai

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    Congress killed more than 25000 Innocent Sikhs by using his agent KPS GILL in Punjab during the days of terrorism.Why CBI is not investigating these cases.Infact they promoted the officers who killed innocents.I would request mannu to remove his turban and go clean shaven as he is giving Sikhs an image of a LIAR. I think even a kid knows that CBI stands for CONGRESS BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • RAM, Mumbai - Dubai

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    Dear PM, We understand your problems, your senior leaders publically criticising your home minister. Home secretary being publically ditched by foreign minister. Niether yourself nor your ministers have no clue on what's India's policy on critical issues like terrorism, naxalism, handling pakistan and tackling the common man's worry of price rise. So this is the best way to get rid of them, Use investigating agencies and govt machineries against political opponents. Well Done....

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • RICHARD MORAS, BAHRAIN

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    THE CASE OF AMIT SHAH IN GUJARAT IS UNDER THE DIRECTIONS OF SUPREME COURT.BUT IN GENERAL IT IS CONGRESS BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • anil kumar, bangalore

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    Now don’t take others in between Amit Shah, he is a Criminal now & his boss is still not come in the picture. SC court will decide who is wrong & Who Right. If he is innocent why he is disappear from last 3 days ……

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Roshan, Manglore

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    If at all anyone uses CBI for political gain, that is not only unjustified but also condemnable. Such party need to pay dearly politically. Having heard the PM talk, it is quite clear there is no pressure from congress side.

    On the other hand BJP is in NO POSITION to take moral ground, as they themself have withdrawn cases against Reddy Bro's.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • manu, bangalore

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    investigation, its only a tool in the hands of congress party to stick to power, otherwise Sibu soren, lalu yadav,Raja,Balu,mayawati all would have been in CBI custody or may be in jail. Officers killing terrorists in this country has to go to jail. The country will not be surprised if u put CBI cases against those who killed Kasab's aides in the 26/11 massacare, thank god it was not BJP govt in Maharashtra at that time.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Hemanth, India

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    This time somehow I tend to agree with Nagesh Nayak

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Hamid, Mangalore - KSA

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

     what intention BJP criticizing this issue? Crime and cruelty was more worst in Gujarat riot than Mumbai, they are not left pregnant women and children. if BJP justifying their crime, what wrong some body else demanding to not hang Afzal guru..

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • adams, hyderabad

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    dont take the case of Amit Shah in isolation Mr PM , whats your take on the cases of Mr Q, Mr Mulayam Singh , Ms Mayawati , Mr Anderson , 1984 riots , Mr Tytler , Mr Sajjan Kumar.........who got benefitted from these cases.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • shiv, Karkala

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    *** "We are here to debate many issues of national importance, Government is ready for every piece of discussion that the opposition may want," he said, adding, "We want the parliament to function smoothly… that is what the people of India expect." ****

    This should be applicable to Karnataka too. Your own congress people have wasted the time in Karnataka assembly and Manmohan Singh never opened his mouth.

    But now he understood the value of Parliament Time.

    This CBI is a bunch of jokers (Assert from previous Central Minister) are used against the opposition parties.

    As per Law, when the base is Illegal, nothing upon that can become Legal. Apply the same formula to Sohrabuddin Case. When Sohrabuddin is a Terrorist, killing him is not against Law. If it is against Law, Then our Military people should be very carefull in handling issues!!!!!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • MOHSIN AHAMAD, DUBAI/MOODBIDRI

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    The BJP true face is communalism,illegal mining lobby,riot for money,bomb blast, moral policing for women... list is endless

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Stany D'sa, Balehonnur/Dubai

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    Honourable PM is justified in his statement.No one has right to intervene in Supreme court directed case. Mr. Amit Shah must be aware of this and let the law take its own course.Absolutely Government has no role in this case.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Madava Nayak, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    Hey Nagesh  I do understand your frustration & anger towords the truth. But you are helpless.Accept the truth or try to digest the truth. By your cummunal writtings, comment against any Govt doesnt works. Every religion says truth will win the war.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Keshava, Puttur

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    Very well said Nagesh. This PM should first teach his party men of our state first (last para). His words are like "Kumbala kayi kalla hegalu mutti nodida"

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • nagesh nayak, bangalore

    Mon, Jul 26 2010

    IF CBI IS NOT A CONGRESS BUREU OF INVESTIGATION WHY YOU HAVE WITHDRAWN CASES AGAINST LALU, MULAYAM, MAYAWATI & OTHER CRIMINALS TO SAFEGUARD YOUR SEAT & UPA GOVT.

    THE LAST PARA OF ABOVE NEWS WILL ALSO APPLICALBLE TO KARNATAKA CONGRESS LEADERS . YOUR CONGIS MADE HUNGAMA ON ONLY ON ISSUE WHICH IS NOT RELAVANT.


    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: CBI not Congress Bureau of Investigation, says PM



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.