Will Governor's Decision Make Yeddyurappa Stronger?


Will Governor's Decision Make Yeddyurappa Stronger?

by Narayana Swamy, Mysore
(Narayana Swamy is a political analyst, and has written this analysis exclusively for daijiworld.com)

 

Bangalore, May 16 : Unexpected political drama in Karnataka politics has created tremors not only around the state but also around the country among poltical experts.

No one knows the facts contained in the 'special report' mentioned by the governor of Karnataka H R Bhardwaj, and it is only an imagination of the media and political leaders that the governor has recommended suspension of state assembly and imposition of President's rule in the state.

The law experts around the country have already expressed their outrage against the governor's decision, and are of the unaninimous opinion that the "Governor has no right to suspend or dissolve a government that enjoys a clear majority." Country's top advocates like Soli Sorabji, who is also former attorney general of the country, has criticised the governor in very harsh words.

State's top advocate B V Acharya also criticised the governor in a similar way.

At this point of time, if anyone is supporting the governor, it is the JD(S) and Congress.

But political experts in the state are of the opinion that CM Yeddyurappa has now become stronger than ever as even the dissidents within the party have expressed open support to Yeddyurappa by forgetting all corruption charges and allegations of land scams against the CM. The governor's decision has come like a boon to the CM as this could be a great opportunity for him to regroup and take all the MLAs in his confidence.

If the state assembly is suspended according to the governor's recommendation, then the CM might lose power for some time, but in all probability, he would come back to power even more strongly, as the sympathy waves are expected to favour Yeddyurappa in the next assembly elections. One cannot forget the sympathy votes he garnered during the 2008 assembly polls when Kumaraswamy had denied him the reigns of the state after 20 months of JD(S)-BJP rule.

One must admire B S Yeddyurappa for his courage as CM despite facing several setbacks during last three years. More than the Opposition, it was his own partymen who gave him headaches time and again, but he resolutely faced every challenge and emerged triumphant each time. He has definitely proved himself to be a man who cannot be destablilized easily with any political trick.

If at all the BJP is on a strong wicket in Karnataka today, it is not because of its development works or administrative skills, but purely because of the weakness of the Opposition. Poor leadership of Congressmen, low strength and the corruption-tainted image of the JD(S) father-son duo have allowed BJP to move from strength to strength every day.

On the other hand, full credit goes to Yeddyurappa's poltical leadership, and he has played his cards well. He came to power riding on the money power of the Reddy brothers, but since then, the CM has systematically clipped the wings of the Reddys, and almost weakned their power. He was also successful in sidelining central BJP leader and his 'within the party' rival Ananth Kumar, who was silently trying to destabilise Yeddyurappa.

Now all eyes are on Delhi, with speculations rife as to what decision would be taken by the PM, home minister and other top leaders.

Also the question arises, will the governor, who is one of the top lawmakers of the country and a former law minister take a 'silly' decision without going through the pages of the Law book?

Let's wait and see.

 

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • JRAO,

    Wed, May 18 2011

    Mr. BSY has proved himself strong when he knocked down Ex.CM by 44000
    margin. Begining from haveri issue the great oppn. has claimed lives of so many innocents to remove BSY from CM chair but could not. As a last resort they tried to use Mr.Governer but could not. People are observing this and giving the reply in subsequent elections and BSY is growing stronger day by day and same trend keeps continuing.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ramesh Naik, Bangalore

    Tue, May 17 2011

    Ismailji, You are ignorant of Cong mischieves and I can understand your frustration. All scenarios and move from governor are making BSY stronger and if center decides (They are afraid as per latest reports) to dismiss the BSY government then it would be a BIG win to BJP in Karnataka. BSY will get the sympothy and ride back to power on sympothy wave.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • RONY MENDONCA, MOODBIDRI/RAS AL KHAIMA

    Mon, May 16 2011

    Ignorence of law has of no excuse a lamon will not get the top & respectable,honourable position like Governor he should be a matured ,exeperienced in both law & politics . Accg. to my openion Hon. Bharadwaj has both qualification at right now he is Karnatakas governor he is doing his duty better than opposition parties for the betterness of people of karnataka .Few months back Praveen bai thogadia questioned in public Is bharadwaj a governor of karnataka or Pakisthan How many country lovers opposited this statement including chief minister.Now yudirappas monkey prayer.Oh you dont no what is the meaning of monkey prayer .Once upon time a monkey stays in a village disturbing everybody by spoiling food crops eating tender coconuts and chasing small small childrens. The villagers gave complaint to a hunter .At that time suddenly monkey got enlighten it started to pray god . but God is God it gave permission to hunter to kill that monkey because it is disturbing public. Now yudirappa facing many allegations he is opposite to minority commununity anti farmers,and anti for sechduled caste and sheduled tribes.let wait and see the decission

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ganesh, Mangaladevi, Mangalore

    Mon, May 16 2011

    Very Good dicision from Governor.
    Keep it up God Bless U.
    no police can work freely.
    Dear Police all the 3rd class Politician, Gunda's, take action now.
    just wait for president rule.
    no one is worried about our Karnataka, all the 3rd class mla and gundas want to make money.
    Thank u for ur Good dicision from Mr. Bhardwaj.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ISMAIL K PERINJE, PERINJE/YANBU-KSA

    Mon, May 16 2011

    CJ Prakash Malpe,FYI this case does not truck with any scandal of corruptions or majority /minority floor test matter but the very question of the one and only constitution's credebilty,existence and compliance in which Constititional Heads like Speaker and CM of Karanataka either did not give respect or not followed while discharging state duties!So be sure while counter comenting? have nice day.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ISMAIL K PERINJE, PERINJE/YANBU-KSA

    Mon, May 16 2011

    S SHETTY Udupi,yes I am in experienced in analizing political misrule of BJP.
    My questions for you are

    What about CEC's stricture?
    What about Lokayukta's report?
    What about (CEC)ELECTION)stricture for sanctioning 100 of crores for temples overnight even though 'ELECTION NEETHI SAMHITHE' is in force in Chennapatana to netural HDK?

    What about GUV's report on law and order problem before not now?

    What about Apex Court's stricture about Speaker and CM?

    What about Land grabing,illeagal de notification,napotism and favoratism....and Lakhs of crores rupees corruptions.

    What about rape,corruptions of cab ministers,open kiss by cab minister(renukacaharya-Lakshimi-Nurse)).....more than dozen ministers either resigned or facing diffrent charges.

    After having above information (if you dont' know or feigning ignorance I don't know)do you still say JDS and Cong are behind all these mess?

    J.Saldhana Mumbai/Mapusa, clearly mentioned that CONG and JDS are incompetent and dumb and I add 'KURUDA'which I share with him.

    BJP Karanataka is new in bussiness of politics and having some vested interest they digging the grave themselves.JAI HOOOOOOOOK

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Jeevan D'Souza, Shirva

    Mon, May 16 2011

    Dear Liddy Bai, Kadri,

    Late YSR Reddy was very good friend and partner of Reddy's in Bellary in looting mines. Please for your kind information he was Chief Minister of Andra Pradesh and Congress and ordinary backward clas doctor became billinaire by looting mines in Andhra/Karnataka Boarder.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Satish Kunder, Mangalore/Kuwait

    Mon, May 16 2011

    BJP and Mr. Yedyurappa are solely responsible for the mess. There is no point in blaming the opposition parties because opposition parties are there to oppose and they are doing exactly the same. Mr. Yedyurappa also would have done the same thing if he would have in opposition.

    This government is in crisis from day one, for one or other reasons and this shows their inexperience and immaturity in running the government. Now they are blaming the Governor but who has asked them to create problems for themselves thus giving leverage to Governor to act.

    It is sad that most of their time is spent on setting right their house in order within BJP and hardly there is any governance in the state.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Louis Fernandes, Belthangady

    Mon, May 16 2011

    The government headed by B S Yeddyurappa has won most of the bye-elections in the last few years. It has succeeded in the municipal elections and panchayat elections. The popularity of the government is not in doubt. Therefore i feel that BJP will grow stronger in coming years in Karnataka especially in coastal districts.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • CJ Prakash, Malpe

    Mon, May 16 2011

    Dear LydiaLobo
    Nobody in sympathising Reddy or Yeddi either. Reddy's mining lisences were issued in Andhra under the blessings of Late YSR. They could do their activity so fearlessly only because of creditting sufficient kickbaks to YSR part of which has also reached to 10 Janpath. Thats is why they could survive till now and if you dint know about another hiden truth. The road to which & how how Veerappa Moily won in Chikkbellapur constituency which he has never gone except may be when he was a CM once or twice also will lead to Mining mafia and the help of Reddy's. Am sure if Yeddi has a chance he will be the first person to prosecute Reddy's because of the trouble they are giving him backed by the support from behind doors of congress & JDS who in front of media talk about secular politics. So today it has become a sword which is difficult to swallow for any party involved beacuse their roots are all interlinked.. My point here is Congress or its supportors have no grace left to point fingers at BJP. I dint mean that BJP is clean , but they have learnt well from their preceders and now they are in the run of overtaking them. But if you wish to compare the volume of looting then calculate from Nehru's times untill now. Just the last 5 years beat all time record including Yeddy's & Reddies.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ravindra Nayak, Mangalore

    Mon, May 16 2011

    Lydia Lobo, Kadri i agree with you. We indians should get united first and fight against corruption irrespective of political parties, caste and religion. In my opinion all the political parties are one and the same. They are least bothered about general public and think only of themselves.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Lydia Lobo, Kadri

    Mon, May 16 2011

    Mr. CJ Prakash,

    Nobody is sympathizing Raja - he is better off behind bars. You are right - over the years - because this started from such a long time that a poor teacher held Telecom Ministry and made so much money that his son snorted cocaine in Rs. 500/- notes. Why can't we let our attention flow towards mining loot in Karnataka ? Ministers establish business in Andhra and hold posts in Karnataka government ! Our natural resources get smuggled by goods trains giving wrong specification of cargo. Lets fight corruption neutrally - not politically !

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Kaa.Vee.Krishnadas Pakshikere, Mangalore

    Mon, May 16 2011

    Definetely Governor's Decision Will Make CM Yeddyurappa Stronger

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ramesh, udupi

    Mon, May 16 2011

    well said Rathnakar, Shirva ..
    Congress agent, Bhardwaj being governor of state defaming himself by the grace of Sidhu, gowda & sons

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • CJ Prakash, Malpe

    Mon, May 16 2011

    Dear Jossy Saldanha/Ismail Perinje
    The same supreme court has found out how Congress and its ally's raped the nation in 2G spectrum case over last many years. So if theay have any grace lefet UPA should have resigned by now. So untill they accept the responsiblity and resign they or yous who support them do not have any moral grace to ask to sack BJP govt. All these just proves your frustation by getting defeated againa and again.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Peter Pereira, Pune

    Mon, May 16 2011

    Yes, Mr. Bhardwaj is the worst Governor in the history of India & a staunch Congressman. He should be recalled and Mr. Somashekar should be Governor of Karnataka. Then only the fraustration and desperation of all BJP pseudos will be over. A curious question to Mr. Richard Moras - I remember Mr. Richard Moras had confirmed to one of the commentators (if I am not mistaken - Mr. V. Thomas, Bahrain) in 'Daijiworld' that Yeddy had sanctioned Rs. one crore for construction of a building for Kannada Sangha in Bahrain and funds will be released once the plot is ed. Any progress Mr. Moras...It is almost over a year now. Or waiting for BJP's 5 years term to get over ? I do not have access to your contact, that is why forced to know through 'Daiji'.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • RICHARD MORAS, BAHRAIN.

    Mon, May 16 2011

    THE APPOINTMENT OF CVC K.THOMAS WAS HELD AS UNCONSTITUTIONAL & HE WAS REMOVED FROM THE POST BY THE SUPREME COURT.DOES IT MEAN THAT THE CENTRAL GOVERNMENT SHOULD HAVE RESIGNED?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • S. Poojary, Karkala / Bahrain

    Mon, May 16 2011

    This Governor is not allowing the current BJP Government to work. At the slightest available opportunity he is trying to destabilize the Government. People of Karnataka have given the mandate to BJP to rule for 5 years. Opposition parties, rather than waiting for 5 years for their opportunity, have tried umpteenth number of times to bring down the current Government with the connivance of the Governor.

    This time Governor himself has taken the lead to bring down the democratically elected Government with the active collusion of opposition parties. This Governor does not allow the Government to function at all. He is using Raj Bhavan to carry out the political activities. He is a curse on Karnataka. He needs to be sacked by the Government / President of India. Or else the people of Karnataka should throw him out from his office if the people of the state expect any governance and development.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Vinay Shetty, Muscat

    Mon, May 16 2011

    Send Flowers to Bhardwaj, he needs all our best wishes.
    He is going to help BJP be become more stronger in Karnataka.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • SANJEEV POOJARY TONSE, TONSE/MUMBAI

    Mon, May 16 2011

    First of all Governor Bharadwaj should be replaced for peace to prevail in Karnataka

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • GMGC, Mangalore

    Mon, May 16 2011

    Gentlemen,
    The Governor's recommendation should be viewed from the perspective of the recent developments in Karnataka.
    I agree on the face of it, it may look like a unfavorable bias to BJP.
    But the fact is when the Speaker had disqualified the 11 or so MLAs while taking the floor test was grossly unconstitutional and the case went up to the highest court of the land.
    Now that the Supreme Court verdict has come, the floor test conducted at that point in time is unconstitutional and consequently the suspended animation of the assembly is the right constitutional penalty for the alleged BJP government.
    When the speaker disqualified the 11 or so MLAs he and the CM, indirectly violated the basic fundamental right of freedom of expression of the MLAs. Today it is with MLAs tomorrow it will be we the citizens.
    The MLAs with this money might took so much time, money and effort to earn justice. Can a common man think about this?
    I feel ashamed to be an Indian looking at the political drama going around.
    The MLAs who rebelled created all the mess and now they are back supporting the BJP Govt. The court at various levels had to spend thier time on a priority basis to solve their drama rather than spending time on other important cases lying for years together. They have taken advantage of the judiciary and taken the citizens at ransom.Such crooks must not be spared.
    I feel no party deserves to be at the helm in Karnataka and a President's rule is appropriate.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • S Shetty, Udupi

    Mon, May 16 2011

    ISMAIL K PERINJE, PERINJE/YANBU-KSA, i think you can express your opinion but i think you are not a experienced political analyzer and I can understand your frustration. If you real nonpolitical man just analyze all the developments happened from the day 1 of this BJP govt. JDS and Congress try all the way to dis stabilize the Govt, because BJP had a very wafer thin majority even after 6 Independent MLA's support. That's why all these developments happens. But now BJP got a clear majority(even they win all three assembly seats) and Let them rule for the balance term. then let people decide the next government.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • RICHARD MORAS, BAHRAIN

    Mon, May 16 2011

    THE WORST GOVERNOR IN THE HISTORY OF INDIA.THE STAUNCH CONGRESSMAN IS A DISGRACE TO THE POST.THE BEST THING FOR CONGRESS PARTY IS TO RECALL HIM & TO INSTALL HIM AS A MINISTER IN THE CENTRAL GOVERNMENT.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sunil, Mangalore

    Mon, May 16 2011

    Humble request to all the people and commentators here, please stop blindly supporting these selfish politicians before they ruine the country. Wake up, think what is wrong and support for the basic correction.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Irshad Shaikh, Udupi/Dubai

    Mon, May 16 2011

    There is nothing wrong in Guv decision. If yeddy and speaker can support unconstitutional things why not GUV?? A Kannada proverb ''MULLANNU MULLINDALE TEGEYABEKU''

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rathnakar, Shirva

    Mon, May 16 2011

    To those who are supporting Governer,
    If we use same argument why the central government is not thrown out? Supreme court many times critisized Central Goverment and even PM in CVC case, Raja Case, Hasan Ali case. It is funnny to note that people with no law background questioning law experts.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ashok, Udupi/Dubai

    Mon, May 16 2011

    No doubt at all. CM is already strong because of stupid Congress, JDS & Cow Expert.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • MENON V.X., LONDON

    Mon, May 16 2011

    Chief Minister along with his ministerial colleagues , INCLUDING THE REDDY BROTHERS WHO PLUNDER KARNATAKA AND FINANCE BHARATIYA JOKERS’ PARTY , and MLAs SHOULD stage a dharna in front of NOT Raj Bhavan , BUT SUPREME COURT BECAUSE The Supreme Court on Friday HAS quashed the disqualification of 16 MLAs ahead of the “controversial October 2010 no trust motion” .AS THOSE 16 MLAs were qualified ,AT THE TIME OF THAT NO-CONFIDENCE MOTION, to vote against the CORRUPTAPPA GOVT, WHATEVER DECISISIONS THIS GOVT. HAVE TAKEN DURING THE PERIOD OF LAST 7 MONTHS , ipso facto ARE null and void , not “ voidable “ IN THE ABSENCE OF MAJORITY IN THE ASSEMBLY !!! !

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Jossey Saldanha, Mumbai / Mapusa

    Mon, May 16 2011

    @hemanth67, france/mangalore.
    Congress and JDS are dumb and incompetent in Karnataka
    It is only the Supreme Court who has found BJP guilty of raping the constitution on 11th October 2010.
    I only hope our Italian will allow BJP to continue in Karnataka so they can dig their own grave.
    I wonder where is Basanthi Tangewali – Yeddy did her a big favor and now she has abandoned him.
    Is that the true colors of BJP?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Roland,

    Mon, May 16 2011

    For the governor to request presidents rule is another politics played by none other than 3 parties: 1) dissidents in the BJP 2) congress adn 3) JDS. DOnt be surprised if these 3 come togehter and form government. but end of the day there is no doubt that yeddyurappa will come out much much stronger.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ISMAIL K PERINJE, PERINJE/YANBU-KSA

    Mon, May 16 2011

    In short run,may be yes.But in long run BJP is the who going to loose the credibility,and
    the ground.I heard BV Acharya's comment on TV,however it is one sided and as if he has spoken as spokesperson of BJP.If someone carries reputation in advocacy then he should come out with pros and cons of BJP and Gov!Where was so called adovacate when GUV Illegally gave Yeddy second time to prove the majority in floor of the house when first test was manuplated and unconstitutional?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • hemanth67, france/mangalore

    Mon, May 16 2011

    This act from governor shows all the allegations made by JDS and congress on CM is false.thr goal is clearly topple the government...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Will Governor's Decision Make Yeddyurappa Stronger?



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.