Bengaluru: 40,000 private hospitals, clinics closed in state due to protest


Pics: Umesh Marpalli

Bengaluru, Nov 3 (IANS) : Around 40,000 private hospitals and clinics remained closed on Friday as private doctors went on strike protesting against Karnataka's proposed amendments to a medical bill to fix costs for private hospitals and penalise doctors.

"Nearly 50,000 private doctors from across Karnataka will abstain from their duties on Friday against the amendments proposed to Karnataka Private Medical Establishments (KPME) Bill 2017," the President of the Karnataka chapter of the Indian Medical Association Dr H N Ravindra told IANS here.

Udupi photos

The bill proposes regulation of costs in private hospitals, prohibiting the hospitals from levying any additional costs from those set by the government, setting up of a grievance redressal committee to look into any complaints against the private hospitals and penalising the doctors for any negligence in their work.

The state was proposing amendments to the KPME Act, 2007, through this new bill.

The bill is likely to be tabled in the winter session of the legislative assembly in November in Belagavi.

"If the government sets up a law this way, doctors are going to be extremely wary of taking up risky cases, as the bill even proposes imprisoning the doctors for up to three years and imposing a fine of Rs 5 lakh," Ravindra said.

With the Medical Council of India already laying down rules for the doctors and prohibiting them from practicing in case of any errors while treating a patient, the doctors' associations in the state have been against setting up another committee.

"Private hospitals are being treated as commercial entities by the state -- the electricity charges, water charges, everything we pay is at commercial rates and not subsidised, unlike in government hospitals. How can the state government, in such case, regulate costs in private hospitals?" Ravindra questioned.

Terming the bill "draconian", medical associations in the state have been demanding the removal of these amendments.

"If the state government wants to bring out a new medical law, then it has to include the government hospitals too, by which the government hospitals could also improve," Ravindra added.

Nearly 80 per cent of the patients opt for private hospitals for treatment in the state.

"We will be meeting all the medical associations in the state on November 5, after which we will decide our next action," he added.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Vincent Rodrigues, Bengaluru/Katapadi

    Sat, Nov 04 2017

    Allowing doctors to go on strike is dangerous and risky too

    DisAgree [2] Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rudolf Rodrigues, Mumbai

    Fri, Nov 03 2017

    Dear Doc,
    If that is what u think, y did u choose the med profession?
    Also u r generalizing on salaries in IT sector; ur view was valid during the dot com boom, not now! Today only the cream gets such creamy offers!! Do u know how shaky an IT job is? Without any notice period one can get the pink slip!!
    With the emergence of AI many in the IT industry will become redundant!! Urs is a recession free profession with a big moat (unavoidable) unlike IT or any other technical profession!!
    In my personal opinion ur profession has now become a money making business!! Hospitals-once called the church of the 20th century-have become a place for fleecing patients!!

    DisAgree [12] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rudolf Rodrigues, Mumbai

    Fri, Nov 03 2017

    Above was a reply to Dr. Kamath, Mumbai!!

    DisAgree [1] Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • Unknown, Mangalore

    Sat, Nov 04 2017

    People who come to pvt hospitals are those who can afford. Doctors are not asking to rise opd charges in govt hospitals. Pvt hospitals give better service than a govt hospitals. Doctors can’t keep doing free service all the time . If He / she does all time free service then how will he or she can look after their family?? In this world u need money to lead a descent life that doesn’t mean ur intentions to be in making money.
    When a barber can charge 400rs for haircut, 200rs of doctors opd charge is more??

    DisAgree [4] Agree [8] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rudolf Rodrigues, Mumbai

    Sat, Nov 04 2017

    How much capitation fee did u pay??

    DisAgree [3] Agree [1] Report Abuse

  • Rudolf Rodrigues, Mumbai

    Sat, Nov 04 2017

    FYI, haircut costs only Rs 50 in A/C saloon!! I don't know where u go for ur haircuts n then recover the Rs 400 charges from gullible patients!!

    DisAgree [3] Agree [2] Report Abuse

  • Unknown, Mangalore

    Sat, Nov 04 2017

    About the caption fee I ll give an example.
    If an iPhone gets spoiled Apple ppl take 48hrs time to diagnose the problem. And the charge is 1800rs .
    A doctor doesn’t take 48hrs to diagnose the disease(expect the rare diseases) they diagnose the case in max to max by 10-20min. The charge is 200rs
    Kapil Sibal demands 1lakh rs for just an appearance in the court for one time. The case won’t solved in 1 vist. So how much is he earning???
    If a tatasky guy comes to home for a repair he charges 250rs as min charge. So doctors who study for 12- 13years charge is 200rs.
    For me pvt Doctors charge of opd 200rs is way too less by seeing a the above example wt do u say??

    DisAgree Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • sharan, Mangalore

    Sat, Nov 04 2017

    Oh..barber charges Rs.50 for haircut.Then how can you tell that 200rs OPD consultation is more? If you don't know the difference between barber & doctor, you should go to barber for treatment.He.ll be the best person for people like you.Else , go to Government hospital for free treatment.We are in a system where the Gov't.has totally failed in health care in their set up & both doctors and patients are at the mercy of private health care..that accounts for 80% of health care provided in our country.Now..if that's throttled..these facilities will close & everyone will be at the mercy of Govt.hospitals.Good luck to all 👍.Those giving big speeches about sacrifice, recession & all utter nonsense should understand that Medicine is a profession like any other with the highest tuition fees..fixed by these Gov't..With your stupid, impractical outlook..only lesser people will take up this profession & your kin can go to barber for treatment.The only way forward is to just upgrade Govt.healthcare..so that more people avail it & eventually all docs too find comfortable employment in these hospital with a decent salary.When patients don't visit Private facilities they.ll be forced to close.No issues of fleecing patients then.

    DisAgree Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • Basappa, Mangaluru

    Fri, Nov 03 2017

    We should see how the Delhi AAP government led by Arvind Kejriwal performs within limited resources. The government in between ridicules upgraded healthcare. Government hospitals have become far better than private hospitals there. Unless we get a sincere government in Karnataka like that, our healthcare system is bound to suffer. Unfortunately nobody supports such government elsewhere. Read about AAP performance to know better.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [10] Reply Report Abuse

  • Alwyn, Mnaglore

    Fri, Nov 03 2017

    Why in India they do not take Citizens opinion when they make any law. That is really non-sense in Indian Government. [Both Central & States].

    DisAgree Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr.S.Kamath, Mumbai

    Fri, Nov 03 2017

    In USA Govt spends money to make the mind set of Doctors to be in profession without quitting.But here in Karnataka Doctors are discouraged to be in profession through KPME act .Just imagine one Engineering student completes BE at the age of 23 gets job as software engineer gets lakhs of salary
    A Doctor gets MBBS at 25 then MD at 28 then gets less than a lakh or just 1 lakh salary .But work for more than 12 hours some times called in night also
    Pvt consultant charges Rs 500 .Then on Sunday night that Patient calls again to ask a query for which no fees is paid .
    If Govt is do serious why not include Govt hospitals drs also in KPME act?
    They also do Pvt practice
    Here Govt is not spending any money by making a law so just as an election gimmick to show Ramesh Kumar is pro-poor
    Actually not .
    Because moment the law is made Doctors will go to court and Court will put stay as per parity Govt Doctors should also be included

    DisAgree [8] Agree [15] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rita, Germany

    Sat, Nov 04 2017

    Dr.S.Kamath Mumbai,Just explain us dear Dr,K:did you choose this profession to collect lacs or out of your love to humanity?Here suffer humans ,not IT branch. becuse of closure of clinics dont you hthink patients who are in need of a emergency ,go might die with out your attention?There are doctors who mint money from poor patients ,when they cant ,docs deny?Even Govt.docs too do the same.In such moments ,govt should handle.In private sector ,docs collect money bar ,not even a reciept is given for the payment why?

    DisAgree [10] Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • Sam, Udupi

    Sat, Nov 04 2017

    To tell you frankly, I joined medicine because my parents wanted me to become a doctor.
    During my studies, I did retain the concepts of love of humanity and service. However, when I started my career, I realised what lies out there is a cruel ungrateful world that takes advantage of any signs of love of humanity and service.
    I also realised that love of humanity doesnt pay my bills, love of humanity doesnt allow me to own a decent house. Love of humanity doesnt allow me to buy a simple comfortable vehicle let alone afford a comfortable holiday. Love of humanity doesnt allow me to educate my children in a good school. Love of humanity doesnt allow me to take care of my aged parents. Love of humanity wouldnt allow me to build a hospital. If at all I did, Love of humanity doesnt allow me to pay my nurses and other staff. Love of humanity doesnt pay for the mandatory bribes in the Indian regulatory system. Love of humanity doesnt pay for costly medical equipment, materials and drugs.
    Private doctors and doctor owned hospitals have always maintained fine balance between costs, profits and affordabilty of the middle class and above. It is the corporate hospitals run by MBAs which charge exorbitant rates with an eye on obscene profits as their bonus are linked to profts.
    In an effort to curb this, bringing draconian legislations such as imprisonment for simple civil offences and impractical price caps on all doctors will only result in flight of both private capital and talent from health care sector in Karnataka.
    Compounded to this is the abject failure of the government in developing quality government health care system as govt money is wasted in Bhagya scheme . If the government hospitals are good, private systems will not flourish. Are there private hospitals in Germany? If so are they cheap?
    Ultimately private health care will have to close or be marginal and with such terrible government hospitals, people will have nowhere to go for their health care needs.

    DisAgree Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rudolf Rodrigues, Mumbai

    Sat, Nov 04 2017

    Do u know how many people go bankrupt in USA while on extensive medical treatment??

    Just last week one pharmaceutical co owner there was trapped who was offering heavy commission to docs to liberally prescribe opioid meds to gullible patients???

    DisAgree [1] Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rao, Udupi

    Fri, Nov 03 2017

    Please do not stop emergency services.
    People will die.
    Peoples' lives are above all issues.
    Stop OPD but not emergency services. Your protest against draconian law should not be draconian to people. If you stop emergency services Govt has to take action against you.

    DisAgree [6] Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rajesh KR, Mangalore

    Fri, Nov 03 2017

    Are the evening private clinics also closed?
    Wish the same zeal was shown in getting better salary & facilities for the nursing staff too.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [11] Reply Report Abuse

  • Jd, Mangalore

    Fri, Nov 03 2017

    The strike is on the price issues, or the grievance issue? Don't combine both. On the price regulations, I am with government, on the grievance, you do have a point.

    DisAgree [17] Agree [9] Reply Report Abuse

  • Unknown, Mangalore

    Fri, Nov 03 2017

    On the price issue I want to ask a simple questions.
    If govt is passing pvt bill then it should also pass a bill stating all the restaurants in Karnataka should cost same price irrespective of the 5 star or 7 star I.e they should cost dosa at 20rs in all restaurants. Will hotel ppl accept it??
    All the mobile should cost 10k irrespective of the company, will smartphone companies accept??
    All barber shop should charge 50rs irrespective of posh saloon will those ppl accept??
    All the court cases should the chrarged at 30rs/case. Irrespective of Supreme Court lawyers or the session court lawyers , will they accept it???
    All politicians should be treated in the state govt hospitals only will they accept it??
    J.D. may I know ur profession??
    The problem here is govt can’t upgrade hospitals and can’t compete with the pvt Hospitals facilities. All the funds goes to minister and MLA pocket.
    Shameless uneducated politicians ruling educated people.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [25] Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Bengaluru: 40,000 private hospitals, clinics closed in state due to protest



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.