Indian journalists say they intimidated, ostracized if they criticize Modi and the BJP


New Delhi, Apr 26 (Reuters): India has constitutional guarantees of freedom of speech and by some measures the biggest and most diverse media industry in the world. But journalists here say they are increasingly facing intimidation aimed at stopping them from running stories critical of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his administration.

At least three senior editors have left their jobs at various influential media outlets in the past six months after publishing reports that angered the government or supporters of Modi’s Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), according to colleagues.

Some reporters, as well as television anchors, have told Reuters they have been threatened with physical harm, abused on social media and ostracized by Modi’s administration.

In its annual World Press Freedom Index released on Wednesday, the Paris-based Reporters Without Borders said that India was now 138th-ranked in the world out of 180 countries measured, down two positions since 2017 and lower than countries like Zimbabwe, Afghanistan and Myanmar. When the index was started in 2002, India was ranked 80th out of 139 countries surveyed.

Reporters Without Borders said that “with Hindu nationalists trying to purge all manifestations of ‘anti-national’ thought from the national debate, self-censorship is growing in the mainstream media and journalists are increasingly the targets of online smear campaigns by the most radical nationalists, who vilify them and even threaten physical reprisals.”

The group said that “hate speech targeting journalists is shared and amplified on social networks, often by troll armies.”

Spokesmen for the government declined comment on the accusations by journalists. They did not immediately respond to the Reporters Without Borders report.

However, not all Indian journalists believe there is a problem. Swapan Dasgupta, a member of parliament and a political columnist who supports Modi, said the press freedom ranking was “quite inexplicable”.

“I don’t believe there has been any shrinkage in the freedom of the media in the past few years,” he said in an e-mail.

G.V.L. Narasimha Rao, a spokesman for the ruling BJP, said allegations of media intimidation were far from the truth.

“On the contrary, the BJP has been a victim of the viciousness of large sections of the media that flourished under the patronage of the Congress, left and other opposition parties,” he told Reuters in e-mailed comments. “The unabashed bias of these media against the BJP has not dented our party’s political growth.”

Some journalists in India say they believe media freedoms are now under even more threat in the run-up to an election due next year. There have been some signs of increasing opposition to Modi’s economic policies and to the BJP’s muscular Hindu nationalism.


Death, Rape Threats

“India is going through an aggressive variant of McCarthyism against the media,” said Prannoy Roy, co-founder of NDTV, India’s first private news channel.

NDTV, which some BJP leaders have called the least friendly of India’s television channels, is being investigated for fraud by federal police. The company has called it a witch-hunt.

The government declined to respond to Roy’s comments.

Sagarika Ghose, a columnist with the Times of India newspaper, said she is viciously trolled for any criticism of the administration.

“The minute I write something, I get droves of hate mail,” Ghose said. “I have had death threats and gang rape threats on social media and also through letters sent to my home. They know where I live.”

Ravish Kumar, a news anchor who has been scathing about the government in his program for NDTV’s Hindi-language channel, said he has been constantly harassed and threatened by pro-government activists.

“This is very organized,” he told Reuters. “They follow me. When I go out to report, a crowd gathers in 10 minutes.”

Reporters Without Borders counted instances of Indian journalists being killed because of what they write.

“At least three of the journalists murdered in 2017 were targeted in connection with their work,” it said.

Among them was editor and publisher Gauri Lankesh, a vocal advocate of secularism and critic of right-wing political ideology. A member of a hardline Hindu group has been arrested for the murder of Lankesh, who was gunned down outside her home..

Journalists say that media proprietors, who often have multiple kinds of businesses, are risk averse and can be leaned on by the government.

“Media proprietors are notorious for reading the tea leaves, they get a clear sense of the tolerance level of politicians in power,” said Siddharth Varadarajan, who runs a not-for-profit online news portal called The Wire. “Government ministers have coined this word, presstitute, to describe journalists who are unfriendly to them or who don’t do their bidding,” he said.


Out of Favor

Bobby Ghosh, the editor of the Hindustan Times, one of India’s premier broadsheets, quit last September shortly after Modi met the owner of the newspaper. At least two senior journalists familiar with the situation said they were told that Modi was unhappy with Ghosh’s editorial policies.

The journalists told Reuters that Ghosh fell out of favor with the government after he launched a webpage called the Hate Tracker, a database of violent crimes based on religion, race ethnicity, gender or sexual orientation.

The database was taken down in October.

Ghosh declined to specify why he quit the Hindustan Times.

The prime minister’s office and the newspaper declined requests for comment on the matter.

A letter published at the time from the government’s chief spokesman Frank Noronha said Modi had met the Hindustan Times chairwoman Shobhana Bhartia when she invited the prime minister to attend a conference organized by the newspaper.

“Other related assumptions and insinuations...are baseless and denied,” Noronha said. “The government is committed to the freedom of the press.”

Restrictions on reporting are likely to intensify heading into the election, said Harish Khare, who resigned as editor-in-chief of the widely read Tribune newspaper last month.

“It (the government) will use every resource in its command to pressurize, manipulate, misguide media or any other voice which seeks to be independent of the government,” said Khare, who was for some time the prime minister’s press secretary in the Congress Party government that lost power to Modi and the BJP in 2014.

He told Reuters his relations with the Tribune’s controlling trust nosedived after the newspaper published a story exposing flaws in Aadhar, the government’s national identity card project.

The newspaper’s trust rejected his accusations. “To the contrary, the Tribune Trust gave an unprecedented award of

50,000 rupees ($765) to the correspondent (who wrote the story) in recognition of the work,” said Officiating Editor K.V. Prasad in an e-mail.

“The editor-in-chief’s departure came close to the end of the tenure.”

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Heri Fernandes, Mangalore/UK

    Fri, Apr 27 2018

    We are not far away from Hitler's rule if the current leader and his team are continued to rule us for another 5 to 10 years....Hope Indians wake up before its too late!

    DisAgree [1] Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse

  • Vincent Rodrigues, Bengaluru/Katapadi

    Fri, Apr 27 2018

    This is quite serious matter because no one can impose anyone on media whose main work is keep the public with true picture of national and international news

    DisAgree [2] Agree [12] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rathan, Mangalore

    Fri, Apr 27 2018

    How much they r paid to give such statements against MODI /BJP
    All three named (Roy,ravish,Mrs gosh)above r anti BJP /HINDU/MODI right from their journalism career.so it is no surprise that they give such statements.

    DisAgree [16] Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • Ruchir, Dharwad

    Fri, Apr 27 2018

    All these pappu lovers will question something positive said by even World Bank as though WB is RSS branch. Anything +ve written by Swapan Das or others is questionable because they are close to BJP. But the same logic will not apply to people who crib like above. Should we not reject criticism of the govt by Cong favorable journalists and reporters if we want to dismiss praise by reporters close to BJP?

    DisAgree [16] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • Declan, Mumbai

    Fri, Apr 27 2018

    Everybody in the media knew about this intimidation and ostracizing four years ago when the Modi government came to power in May 2014 but people were silent then because of Modi's 'perceived' huge popularity and an atmosphere of intimidation and fear created. I say perceived popularity because BJP got only 31% of the vote share all India. Largely responsible for this atmosphere of intimidation was Modi's troll army who were always alert and in attendance to blast and steam roll any voice of dissent. The main stream media at least most of them were one by one made to 'toe the line' by orders which came from the corridors of power it seems ? If not complied with then expect witch hunt in the form of IT raids, mountain of online abuses and threats, other harassment and even death threats or death from right wing groups emboldened by the government's attitude towards such media persons/houses ?
    Thankfully four years in government has revealed the incapability of this Modi government and exposed the series of lies. Slowly media persons are finding their voice again but there is still a long way to go. We want more of news reporting and less of opinion giving. Headlines and TV debates should not be dictated by the government to media houses especially that which is against the Opposition when they question the government's non performance. Let the media do their job unhindered and without bias. We do not want sensational or Tabloid style news. We want the truth reported and not the government's version of it. We want the truth reported when it happens and not when the timing of it's reporting suits the government of the day. Government should not hide behind the garb of 'nationalism' or 'dignity of PM's office' to prevent the truth from being reported. Government should not resort to the lame excuse of 'secrecy' to prevent corruption and/or over expenditure from being exposed. Also, stop blaming the past government/governments when they fail.

    DisAgree [4] Agree [19] Reply Report Abuse

  • Ruchir, Dharwad

    Fri, Apr 27 2018

    SO how much % vote the mafia party got when it won elections? Was it 100%?
    THis shows people dont understand democracy but want to hate Modi and this govt just for the heck of it.

    DisAgree [9] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • Jossey Saldanha, Mumbai

    Fri, Apr 27 2018

    Intolerance ...

    DisAgree [2] Agree [13] Reply Report Abuse

  • Swamy, Mangalore

    Fri, Apr 27 2018

    One by one the stones are tumbling from BJP fortress. It's matter of time before BJP is exposed completely. End of fakugiri soon.

    DisAgree [3] Agree [25] Reply Report Abuse

  • Ruchir, Dharwad

    Fri, Apr 27 2018

    Yeah right! You can believe in fake dyansty with a surname to fool people and a fake party claiming the legacy of independence when they actually im[posed emergency but want to call a hardworking PM and govt feku.
    Pappu was shouting Doklam-Doklam all the time but wait till Modi finishes meet with CHinese premier tomorrow. We will see who won. Pappu will go hiding somewhere.
    1) Low inflation
    2) 20 cr bank accounts
    3) Subsidised cooking gas for poor who were not ahving it
    4) OROP for retired defence personnel
    5) High FDI
    6) Low CAD
    7) Best Ease of doing Business rating
    8) Fastest growing economy
    9) 18000 villages electrification
    10) Fastest rate of road construction
    11) Highest Naxals killed
    12) Highest exposure of bank frauds
    13) Attacking Bank NPAs
    14) Lowest corruption scandals (forget Pappu's parroting of Rafaele, tere is no scam there)

    ...many more. Yes they are all fake:) but paapu mafia dynasty's "garibi hatao" is real because there are no poor country in the people today. Get Real!!

    DisAgree [15] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Indian journalists say they intimidated, ostracized if they criticize Modi and the BJP



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.