Udupi: Houses Demolished, Families evicted in Alleged Forceful Operation at Nagarjuna Site


Udupi: Houses Demolished, Families evicted in Alleged Forceful Operation at Nagarjuna Site

Pics: Ashirvad - Udupi
Daijiworld Media Network—Udupi (RD/CN)
 

Udupi, Jun 6: The issue of setting up of the Nagarjuna Power Plant in the district that had been pushed to the background for the past few months came to the fore once again on Friday June 5, due to an unexpected development. 

On Friday, three houses located on the project site were demolished despite resistance from the locals.  

The houses of Somayya Moolya, Deju Shetty and Gopi Poojary, demolition of which had posed a grave problem for the project management, were pulled down by the district administration in a clandestine operation jointly launched with the help of Karnataka Industrial Area Development Board and the company,  amidst heavy police security.  

This move of the district administration has raised concerns over the welfare of displaced families despite the efforts being made by the Anti-Nagarjuna Committee formed by the local residents and people’s representatives since the last several years, to fight against the setting-up of the coal-based power plant in this ecologically sensitive belt.  


















The demolition has cleared the obstacles to power plant had been facing at the project site in Taje in Yellur gram panchayat.  

Meanwhile, the locals are worried over the inaction of the Anti-Nagarjuna Committee in saving the homes of the three families in the monsoon season, when it’s difficult to make alternate arrangements for accommodation. 

The locals also are worried that the people’s representatives will also prove ineffective at this crucial moment when they badly need their support to fight against Nagarjuna that is on its way to completing the rest of the work and early commissioning.

It is learnt, the petitions filed by the three families and also Balakrishna Shetty, honorary president of Nandikoor Janajagruti Samiti against the acquisition of the properties, had been recently dismissed by the High Court. KIADB thereafter, had issued five notices to the families, to vacate the lands. Upon the failure of the families to vacate these premises even after these developments and in view of the fact that the land in question has been granted to the project by the government, the emergency operation had to be undertaken, said revenue inspector of KIADB, Balakrishna Rai.  The compound wall of a Garody, a centre of faith, located within the plant premises is also being demolished at present, and the company will at its own cost, rebuild the wall, informed Rai.

Kundapur assistant commissioner K N Ramesh, who was present during the operation said that the company has already fixed rented accommodation for the two families affected, and the company will meet their rentals for one year. The company has also decided to pay Rs 10,000 as contingency fund to enable them to shift their belongings, he elaborated. Out of the three families, the house of Deju Shetty did not have any occupants.

Somaiah Moolya and the other family did not agree to go to the houses fixed for them by the company and instead, chose to go to the homes of their relatives. They said they were treated badly, and in the midst of heavy rains, they were driven out of their homes.  Diwakar Shetty, son of Deju Shetty said the eviction was conducted in a hurried manner, before the appeal preferred by them came up for hearing before the Supreme Court.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • ashok pai, bangalore/ mangalore

    Tue, Jun 09 2009

    So just where are the politicians and the activists when they are really needed ? this thermal plant will suck the region dry. why do they want fertile lands to set up these monstrous factories ? the fly ash will be disaster, its like throwing mud into our eyes.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • p Shety,

    Sun, Jun 07 2009

    Power is crucial for development and better living without daily power shutdowns Its important to come out of power shortage but while ing the loaction one should avoid farm land / agriculture land why dont they set up such plants in remaote locations on baron dry unusefull land these are available in plenty beyond western ghats while we travel toward hubli belgaum bellary gulbarga etc why dont they set up the plant in such places for coal based project what we need is good train connection

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ravi Shankar, Mangalore/UAE

    Sun, Jun 07 2009

    I do agree it hurts and pains a lot when somebody is asked to vacate a property which he has acquired or inheirted from his ancesstors. but devolpment and change in society needs sacrifice from common man, otherwise we will remain where we were in 19th century. I am a sufferer from the land reforms act enacted by the Goverenment during early 1970s, ( we hardly got any worthwhile compensation )but the sufferings forced me and my other sibllings to study and diversify into a different field other than agriculture and today we are all highly qualified professional in various fields. People should try to exploit the adversary into an opportunity than only the progress and opportunities come our way

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Godwin mendonca, mudarangadi/dubai

    Sun, Jun 07 2009

    Dear all commentators wait and watch who will be the next, there are 10 more MNC are going to come in coastal area. it will be your house next. be ready to vacate.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Krishna, India

    Sun, Jun 07 2009

    People of undivided DK don''t care for environment. Otherwise Mangalore would not have become notorious for its vehicular density which is polluting the city like anything. Obviously people want luxury and that is the reason they purchase those delux vehicles and stay in big airconditioned independent bunglows. In search of luxury they even migrate to more polluted places like Mumbai or Dubai. I think these incidences of relocation will be forgotten once the government successfully provides uninterrupted electrical power to the people. In Nagarjuna case as relocation is almost over and the plant is almost ready the environmentalists should now focus on environmental related issues like how Nagarjuna is going to handle flyash and whether the effluents are treated properly before releasing into sea, etc as these are very important for safegaurding their luxury of good environment which they are enjoying so far. I was more moved by earlier MSEZ Kudubi incidence than this incidence as these people seemed to be rich enough by looking at the size of the houses being demolished and Nagarjuna arranging for the rented houses and the relocation expenditures. However I feel that Nagarjuna should had relocated Garody instead of demolishing it. The better way of using the money collected by NGOs & Samithis of environmentalists is planting trees, developing orchards and mangrove forests. Even these Samithis can take interest in removing garbages from footpath and roads and getting rid off garbages thrown into rivers & lakes.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Charles D''Mello, Pangala

    Sun, Jun 07 2009

    I fully agree with Ajay, U.K and George Belman.... These so called environmentalists do oppose in the beginning.Once their pockets are filled their opposition is only on news papers to fool the general public... See the status of the job...it is halfway and people are fools to still stay in the houses and protest.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Godwin Mendonca, Mudarangadi/dubai

    Sun, Jun 07 2009

    Nagarjuna is like a ''ANACONDA''in coastal area it solowing the land slowvely. Next deffinitely its our turn to vacate the land. So many leaders came front to fight against nagarjuna, but now they are quiet. why? they are sold themselves to nagarjuna, wakeup people next your turn.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • shameer, Paniyoor/ Dubai

    Sun, Jun 07 2009

    I agree with shetty''s view. I also call everybody to join hands together to save our land. Really Heart touching photos. may be this phoTos will get awards in the future but wht about the peoples future who were living arround this internationally banned coal power generation project. please forget your parties and fight for the rights. other wis eour next generation will suffer from dangerous deseases.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • FELIX, QATAR

    Sun, Jun 07 2009

    Ajay you may have your point and Mr, Shetty his. Both of you are sitting pretty in Dubai and London. It is the plight of the people who have lost their means of livelyhood.With no chance of employment in these projects, they left with no option but to try the things like suicid jus as D''souza family. We have seen this in the past,whether it was for MRPL or Konkan railway. It is the same for all future plants in the coastal districts. Mr. Shetty might be interested in a gas based plant. All the same we do not need any Industires in the coiastal belt.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • JDs, Neermarga

    Sun, Jun 07 2009

    Someone call Sadanand Gowda and Nalin kumar shetty. I am sure these people have been given pitiable compensation which usually is 1/5 of market value. When the govt. valuates a house for demolition they look at its age and materials and compensate. Why cant they compensate with the actual cost to construct the house of same area today

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • AJAY, UK

    Sun, Jun 07 2009

    Indian cities are sadly one of the most polluted in the world ,oh not from industries because India is not an industrialized nation but from garbage generated from humans . In my 33 years of life in India I have not come across any environmentalist who has protested against it. We have all the diseases in India mainly due to unhygeinic conditions that prevails in our cities...Typhoid,hepatitis ,TB and the list is endless.Still we have people who are so concerned about the environmental damage caused by a power plant! That is very strange.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • joyjony, padubidri

    Sun, Jun 07 2009

    Before Janajagrithi samithi support to BJP to Stop Nagarjuna project, when BJP get Govenment in Karnataka they forget environment and reopen the Nagajuna project again.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ajay, UK

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    Mr Shetty While I respect your sentiments on this issue by and large in India everything is opposed for the sake of opposition and various vedike''s and samithis suddenly spring up from nowwhere with different interests capitalise on it. No wonder our country has not improved with respect to infrastructure development over the past 40 years or so or more.In the UK it is true that govt is planning nuclear plants which produces more toxic wastes than a coal power plant. Will you or the people ever allow any more nuclear plants in our country.Never.I am personally aganist nuclear power plants but sometimes we have to make sacrifices . Well it is a balance .If you wait for solar power plants and windpower then the power shortage in our country will never be sorted in the next 100 years.Thankfully or rather unfortunately many people in India have not had the experience of benefit of uninterruped power supply or 24/7 safe drinking water because there have always been vested interests opposing everything. Even the New Mangalore airport expansion was opposed. Thankfully they managed to complete it and it is reaping benefits.Lack of transparently and middlemen are a big problem in India rather than the project itself.One thing is that it has become increasingly difficult for companies to take people for a ride due to increasing awareness from green groups .Thankfully we have a somewhat efficient supreme court! Thanks for the website. I am an avid Hindu reader.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Harold D''cunha, Mangalore, India

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    Elections are over. Preachers, teachers, lecturers and all utsav’s received their due share and waiting for next election to come. That time again different issue like same wine in different bottle. Always it is poor suffer not rich and influential people. Is a single MLA, MLC, MP''s house anywhere in Karnataka has been taken over by govt. or demolished? This is the fate of our poor people. Power plant is good but at what cost? We are talking about people participation in govt. i.e. Panchayat Raj but here we evict people forcibly without people’s approval. This is Karnataka Govt. Paper Raj on poor people. Isn’t it. Shame on this govt.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • George Belman, Mangalore

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    Mr.Balakrishna Shetty (DUBAI), It is time you admit your failure and hidden agendas behind opposing Nagarjuna Plant. You forced these people to go to court and fight your battles by not accepting a super package KIADB and Nagarjuna was giving and see what happened now. People who trusted you are on the roads in Monsoon rains and you are sitting happily in Dubai posting comments on Internet!! Mr.Shetty - you talk about environment sitting in a region exploited to its end by man for oil. Now you say, oh it is just desert here - but desert also has eco systems and oil extraction kills millions of birds, snakes and what not. As Daiji''s article notes, locals are now against you for propping up these poor people and then abandoning them after court rejected your petitions. Where is anti-Nagarjuna samithi now? What happened to lakhs of rupees from foreign NGOs received by samithi to oppose this project? Why are you not helping these poor people now? I hope you and others with narrow agenda against development in Coastal Karnataka at least realize your follies and keep hands off our region. You don''t live here so don''t have right to tell us what is good or bad for us. Respectfully, George

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • george borromeo, angelore, mangalore

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    Regional and National Elections are over, Now we have to look after ourselves. Building the Power plant is in their agenda and they will do it. Who bothers about the environment and ecology? Who bothers about the ultimate benificiary from this controversial Power Plant? All ready they have painted our Coastal City Red , from their reckless export of Mines from Bellary. Now they are ready to paint our Coastal area Black by the Imported Coal, and Grey by the Ash blown out from the Plant.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Balakrishna Shetty, Yellur, Udupi/Dubai

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    Mr. Ajay, While you admit that coal fired plants are being decommissioned in the UK on one hand cannot justify the dirty project coming to our place in the 21st Century on the other. Most countries including China are decommissioning such plants. I did visit coal based power plants of National Power Co and British Coal in the UK and seen the misery despite state of the art technology. Such plants are required to be at least 25KM away from sensitive areas like habitats, townships, religious places, cultivable lands and water resources etc as per the guidelines in India. But these are violated in nexus with the baboos and the politicians.

    Moreover, the region has unique features and is encircled by Western Ghats almost from all 3 directions and we have low wind speed and high wind calms thereby increasing the ground level concentration (GLC) of the pollutants. Several National Experts, UNEP & World Bank have reported so. What we are arguing is get the power generated to the extent coast needs but with cleaner sources. And the total need of the coast is not beyond 300 MW for the next 20 years. If you get to the statistics 40% of energy generation is lost in theft and T&D in our State.

    Power is supplied to industries etc without billing in the name of theft and poor conditions of transformers and lines. The national survey revealed that even half of it if saved the State will have enough power. It is untrue that there is protest against Suzlon. They were in fact welcomed. But they became greedy and tried to take more and more lands and even subsequently tried to destroy a forest "Devara Kadu" & the public protested. They stopped their project because of their own economic problems. T

    hen these companies are multi-nationals and can go out and procure lands for their industry by paying market price of their own. Why the government force evacuates these small land holders of their livelihoods? Have you ever heard of lands belonging to a Minister being acquired in India. As for my luxury in Dubai, yes if you call living in the air-conditioned room when it is 47 D.C. outside I must agree it is luxury. But my heart and soul is with the affected people as they are my neighbors, with whom I grew up and went to the village school. Visit Hindu in www.hinduonline.com and click “I want my land back not compensation” and that will tell you some story.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Vins, Pangla

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    Everytime We Object in one or another way. If govt want make road extn and asks some part of land we object. Now i think they have paid for this land for vacating and when they came to break it, we are saying its not right. Everytime we object and we say govt is not working.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ajay, UK

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    Mr Shetty, Surprised to see your comments as I just realised that you are sitting in Dubai enjoying all the LUXURIES as people in India suffer from severe power shortage.ELECTRICITY 24 HRS IS A BASIC NECESSITY AND NOT A LUXURY. Here in the UK many coal powered plants are being decommissioned and going Nuclear which produces more toxic wastes sadly.Windpower and Solar are the best but sadly India is so starved of power and politicians have to really put their mind to this. The power project in Nandikur has taken n number of years to commission .

    It is also true that farmers are treated badly in India but that I hope is improvingwith increasing awareness.Today''s news on the Reliance SEZ was welcome. I have lived in DK most of my life, and realised after coming to the UK how much we Indians suffer as a result of lack of electricity ,drinking water and bad roads that kill millions in our country. We Indians deserve better .I am enjoying all the good facilities here but would be delighted if fellow Indians got the same facilities as well. Being an anaesthetist and working in labour ward I can understand the mother''labour pain'' more than anyone else as I used to specialise in labour epidurals!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Gananath B Shetty, Nandikur/Mumbai

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    This is forcefull act & contempt of court. when the three families have their special leave petition challenging the acquisition of their agricultural land is pending in the Supreme court

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ajay, UK

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    This is reply toMr Blakrishna Shetty''s mail. I do agree with many of your points and I agree that in the past there have been total lack of transparency in the past. I am not a great supporter of capitalism(In fact I am a socialist) but at some point there has to a limit to opposition. I remember doing my entire CBSE ,PUC studies under candle lights that too in the sevenentees and early eighties and I am told things are becoming worse each passing day. I am fully for windpower /and other renewable sources but I gather people are opposing even the Suzlon project!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • irfan/MANGALORE, mangalore

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    farmer is the backbone in india police is to take action & secure agricuture & land...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • nirmal, mangalore

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    Elections are over.Political party's gained the power in the state.People voted them on their sweet promises.Cheif minister to the last chapracies are currupted. All around the world nations shouting with the slogan green revalution & and fight against ecological polution.Where our leader''s ears become deaf against the curruption,how can one expect to stop this project.Govt , civic authorities should have waited until the appeal could hear.In Mangalore most of the coastel belt has been vanished, by the industies, chemical plants, and refinerey polution.How could this coal power plant will help our south Kanara dist.How our next generation will over come the situation?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Charles D''Mello, Pangala

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    If only these three houses were disturbing the project, then the demolition by the Nagarjuna is right. There is no choice for the families ...take compensation and move...if not be ready for such tragedy. Project looks like it is half the way..!!??? What were these environmentalists doing so far..????? Just make big noise and take bribe and keep quiet. That is what has happened in this project..??????

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Balakrishna Shetty, Yellur, Udupi/Dubai

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    This is particularly for Ajay from UK. You need to learn that only mother knows the labor pain but she tend to forget it when she sees the face of the baby. But, here the State is forcibly acquiring agricultural lands at its own nominated price from poor farmers for a private company to earn profit and what you would get from the project is ash on your face and poisoned water to drink. We need the power all right but we do not have coal reserves in the coast. So we should only go for projects that are sustainable and attempt mini-hydel and other renewable energy sources.

    Did we ever call for a single tender for any such project despite so much going on world over about the climate change? If coal can come from Australia to Udupi district it can also go to where the power is actually needed. Do you know there is a massive financial goof up in the project amounting to thousands of croes which ultimately would be the consumers’ burden? What do you think is it because of admin inefficiency or because of kick-backs. Either way we bear the burden along with health problems. We are born here and we have dreams!

    Our constitution does not permit forced sacrifice from any individual even though that might provide luxury to millions. Just as we all made a lot of noise when the rich are hit in Taj attack we must learn to be behind not so lucky ones of the country at least occasionally when in distress especially if it is State sponsored.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Bulsam, Mangalore

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    Where ever home displacement is a great tragedy but circumstances forces one to live behind all the memories which are priceless. In such a situation only emotion & not the money or power should play the key role. The religious head of that region should consol such victims with emotional support or that will create a deep scar in their psyche.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Jawar D''Souza, M''Lore/Doha

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    It should be made sure that 50% of the jobs are given to the local''s 30% to the rest of Karntaka and only 20% to the rest of India now the question is who should impose this. Frist it''s the duty of the M.P to take a firm stand than the MLA then the muncipalty, the state Govt local people all should be involved. WE people do not vote we sit at home and and neighbour''s sucess this is our D.K. You go to every household in D.K. people will be talking about other people''s acheivement''s. Envy is in our blood because of the coastal climate, we are a population of brillant mind''s but what to do jealuosy is n our system. If we come out of this we will be the topper''s in whole of India. So Buddies wake up move & forward.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr S K Shetty, Hyderabad / Udupi

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    Since Daijiworld has huge popularity specially outside india, I am affraid that International Human Right officers will get this news, and name of Mangalore will be in bad shape again, also Nagarjuna project will be in trouble. Request, Nagarjuna should not indulge in forceful evictions.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • kumar Fernandes, Mudarangadi/Dubai

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    Andha Kanoon Hai.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sharath P, mangalore

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    Good,project work is going soon,appreciate meanwhile they should provide alternative home those who lost because of this project.Also i would appriciate localities if they support for this project,also so many people will get job in this.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • sathish, kudla

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    Dear ''HENRY DSOUZA, Borivali, Mumbai''It will be purely northies,tamilies,maliyalis and the big andraass getting benifted by this project as it happeded in case of MRPL OR TBPC in mangalore for the big and white collar jobs and of couse the locals will be given the labour / technician work that too as a third party contract ...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ajay, UK

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    I personally do not like any one''s house being ripped apart but this unacceptable resistance by some people towards a project of national importance has gone a bit too far. We are one of the few countries in the world suffering power shortage and one must remember that Karnataka has been borrowing from other states where too people have sacrified their lands several years ago. I am certain these people who lost lands in Ramagundam or any where else would have been exploited as awareness was low then against environmental concerns and compensation issues But mind you this is 2009 at he companies generally do not get away so easily now. But a few people holding up a project is unacceptable .By and large things are more transparent nowadays . Regarding jobs for locals every effort has to be made to give jobs for the displaced people but appointments like in any field hads to be based on merit and competance. THis is just pure logic. I am not sure if other states are getting benefiytted . If they are so be it as Karnataka has been dependent on other states for so long but the dependence on other staes would decrease. One cannot be selfish on such matters. I guess as this is in private sector Kerala wants to buy power but I am not sure. One should remember that people of other states have given jobs for people from South Kanara to go and work in industries all over India. I do not think people of those states protested.Otherwise we would have been in an unimaginable position now!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Shaila, Managalore, Muscat

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    Very sad to hear this news. Now where are the ruling BJP & opposition Congress Men. Why do not they come and safe guard those people who are in trouble. Before the elections every one will come and give lots of of hopes to the poor people. Its better the citizen should wake up and safe their own property or houses.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • HENRY DSOUZA, Borivali, Mumbai

    Sat, Jun 06 2009

    Very bad to hear this news. The Nagarjuna Authorities should have waited till monsoon season. Is this is the treatment given to poor families by our Govt? The Nagarjuna authorities should have found them the alternate houses before demolishing their present houses. Is this project really beneficial to our people? or will the other states get benefited by this project ?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Udupi: Houses Demolished, Families evicted in Alleged Forceful Operation at Nagarjuna Site



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.