Karnataka to Enforce Cow Slaughter Ban


Karnataka to Enforce Cow Slaughter Ban

Bangalore, Feb 10 (IANS) : The Karnataka government will enforce a ban on cow slaughter strictly by amending a 1964 act to prohibit the sale and consumption of beef, Home Minister V.S. Acharya said Wednesday.

“An amending bill will be introduced in the coming budget session to make cow slaughter, sale of cows and consumption of beef a cognizable offence under a new law,” Acharya told reporters after a cabinet meeting here.

The amending bill will replace the Karnataka Prevention of Cow Slaughter and Cattle Prevention Act, 1964. According to section four of the proposed bill, no person shall slaughter or intentionally kill any cattle. The definition of cattle in the bill includes cow, calf, bull, bullock, and buffalo. Section five of the proposed bill prohibits sale, use and possession of beef.

The cabinet also decided to enhance punishment with seven years imprisonment and a penalty of Rs.100,000 for serious offences against cows.

“The minimum punishment will be one year imprisonment and a fine up to Rs.50,000 for smaller crimes against the domestic animal,” Acharya said.

The month-long budget session will commence Feb 25 with an address by state governor Hans Raj Bhardwaj to the joint legislature and the state budget will be presented March 5.

In a related development, the Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) protested against the cow slaughter ban and criticised the first Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government in the state for hurting the sentiments of Dalits, Muslims and backward classes with an anti-retrograde measure.

“Each individual is entitled to his/her own food habits. The government has no right to force people to not consume a particular food,” BSP vice-president N. Mahesh said.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Shalini, kerala

    Mon, Aug 30 2010

    India can never do any thing to stop cow slaughter. Its all about advertising for them... shame on us.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Paula, Bangalore

    Wed, Mar 10 2010

    What is this country coming to. What is Mr Acharge trying to get from this Ban. Political mileage. Its a pity to have narrow mind goons in our Ministry who have cowdung in their brains

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • I.santosh kumar, Manipura, Udupi

    Sun, Feb 14 2010

    With the shadow of uneducated uncultured politician some groups of religion, some groups of cast and some groups of language are ruling India instead of court or police to judge and punish, these groups are the lawmaker and administrators of the state, these types of politics give fuel to hatred, no peace and development. All educated people, students are no speak and hiding inside room, my request with all responsible educated citizens and students come out and protest against the wrong

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • fr adolf washington, Bangalore

    Sat, Feb 13 2010

    What a clever way of diverting the attention of people from more serious issues that the Government has ignored. Cattle of our poor farmers are dying due to drought. What has the government done about that. Farmer's livelihood is at stake! What has the Government done about female infanticide and infants dying because of malnutrition and famine??? What has the government done about deaths because of poverty? Is the Government really serious about suffering humanity??? Fr. Adolf Washington, Bangalore

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Mahesh H. Lobo, Bangalore

    Sat, Feb 13 2010

    this government is for the weakest of the society. Cattle is really belongs to this category.So must be protected against all odds. What better can you expect from this cabinet, as they cannot protect weaker / minority sections of the society and their property, at least they are protecting the weaker section of the animal world. The next bill will be safeguarding all the dogs. then it will be cats and goes on. Those who rear cattle, when they find it is economically not viable to rear them, they can leave them in the house of the minister in charge of the district. After all each minister is in charge of the cattle of the district!! If the in-charge minister's house is not in the distict, handover the cattle to Deputy Commission, who in turn will transport the cattle to the concerned minister. Be careful, as per law, you cannot transport cattle lest you should be caught and jailed. What a wonderful government we have!! Surely, the people of Karnataka are truly blessed!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ronald D, Udupi

    Fri, Feb 12 2010

    Do not overload Acharyas mind, fit only for appeasement of few individuals, who also love beef on the quiet! It is politics! Quick money is on the subconscious mind!! and the support!!! Yeddy is much better. though both has fox mind!! Who are the grass root supporters seen, mostly lazy & uneducated!!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • nagesh nayak, bangalore

    Fri, Feb 12 2010

    MR.V.S ACHARYA, GO AHEAD WITH YOUR WORK. WE ARE WITH YOU. ALL THESE PSUEDOS TALK RUBBISH . WHY THEY ARE KEEPING THEIR MOUTH SHUT ON

    1) ARTICLE 370.

    2)LAND GRABBING BY FAMILY OF HEAD OF STATE.

    3)CLEAN CHIT TO QUOTROCHIHI.

    4)ATTACK ON INDIANS IN AUSTRALIA

    5)BAN ON MINARETS IN EURPOE COUNTRIES

    6)BAN ON BURKHA IN FRANCE.

    ALL PSUEDOS ARE HAVING PROBLEM IN INDIA. JAI HO GOU MATHA.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sunil D'Souza, Mangalore

    Fri, Feb 12 2010

    Hey like you guys have proposed cow slaughter in Karnataka. Why not also propose a ban on Stray cows. At least it will do good to all in fact. I was surprised to read a report sometime back which indicated that stray cows are one of the major reasons contributing to 2 wheeler accidents in India. Further its really really difficult to walk in Mangalore due to cow dung on roads from these stray cows. Further why not tagging of the cows could also be a good option to identify owner of the cow. You see such a measure will do more good to everybody. Incidents Vendors selling meat by slaughtering stray cows (or even stolen domestic ones) could be reduced. Afer all its our city and we ought to keep it clean and tidy.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Edward Maben, Mangalore/Bangalore

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Mr.Acharya, just who do you think you are. Do you forget that you represent every individual who has got you to power? You are the upholder of every common mans interests. Not of a single group, let alone yours.Have a little shame and stop thinking 40 years behind. Do you know that by trying to withhold the consitutional rights of each citizen of the Republic of India, you are voilating the constitution yourself. Show some reasoning, lock yourself in a room and rethink where you stand.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • shahnawaz kukkikatte, dubai/udupi

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Sunil/Sydney, I reallly pity for your knowledge of India. India has never been a hindu theocratic state. Before the advent of Aryans, India was inhabitated by nomadics/adivasis and dravidians who had no religion and used to worship nature. Aryans invaded India and brought vedic culture which you call as hinduism, which itself is alien to India. Then came muslims, christians. We didnt had our own identity. What you see today in India is all imported ones. The present muslims and christians are original dravidians but converted to their respective religions. Modern day manu vadis are descendants of aryans who are foreigners. Vaishyas, kshatriyas and shudras are descendats of dravidians. The land of Indus belongs to its original people like all non brahmin hindus, muslims, christians, jains, buddhists, jews of India and certainly not to the brahmins who are direct relations with aryans who are foreginers to India. Afeter 1947, we have adpated a constituion which d India as a secular democratic state and no where its mentioned as hindu state. First you change the constitution and then claim stake in Indian land. Vinaasha kala vipareetha buddhi man.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Charles D'Mello, Pangala

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    We don't need science to learn that milk is from cow, which is a animal . Hence all those practice strict vegetarian diet are not vegetarians in true sense(even mothers milk is also non vegetarian).

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sunil, Sydney

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Many countries are democracies but they have rules and restrictions. We all adhere to them to if we live in that country. India is a Hindus nation no matter what people say and we do not want cow slaughter. Arab nations will not allow pork in their country so why is it ok for them?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • shaukath, dubai/mangalore

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Mr. Prasad karkada good comment man. no one have any right to stop eating cow.India is democratic country.we muslims do have the right on india.Jai Hind...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Joseph F. Gonsalves, Bannur, Puttur/ Mangalore

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Mr. Thomas Valder Bahrain, Where are these cows in Mangalore or in Bahrain? Are you involved in transporting those cows? Who will pay the transportation charges? Will the old cows capable to walk up to Udupi, Mr. Acharya’s house or Vidhana Soudha, Bangalore or will they die in-between? Who will burry if they die in-between even though you have to dig graves/big grave. If you are capable to dig the grave, it's ok. Is it not too hard for you to dig 7 graves/big grave? \

    You will have to appoint laborers even though you have to pay to the laborers for digging graves and pulling the dead cows/lifting the cows inside the grave and covering with the soil. I suggest you to call Mr. Acharya and sell those cows from your house so that at least you will have some benefit/income. Let them put in Go-Shalas and the fundamentals will teach lessons to the cows.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Siddik, Omen

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Nice work indeed.we could hav saved thousands of cows if this rule has been made long back.we need milk first rather than a meet.anyways thanks for HM..we are expecting more from you

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rodney, Udupi / Bahrain

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    GET WELL SOON ACHARYA !!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • AMAR NATHAL, MANGALORE

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Even cows and pigs are smarter than human beings when it comes to politics and religion. If animals had a say, they would have preached non-violence in some forms. This is how dirty and dangerous politics and religion can be, when animals take over human beings!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • John, Shamboor/Bangkok

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Mr .Minsiter can you amend any act .so I can slaughter human being instead of cow , bull , buffalo..??

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • lukasmalpe, malpe

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Dr. acharya think about sealing mobile tower which effect human being in residential area like Delhi and Noida. dont do vote bank politics by influencing one religion.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Jaimini P.B., Manaipal,Sharjah

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    I don't want Government to ban Cow Salughter. Because beef is a main food for non hindus. No one has got right to prevent them from eating their main food just because we worship Cow. Instead of that ,Government should punish cow transporter if they trasnport cows in a barbaric way.(I saw some photos recently where many cows were put in small tempo/van and died due to suffocation.

    Even in one photo which made me very upset where calfs mouth were stiched so that no one from outside listens its crying sound. So there should be restriction on transportaton method. Torture is crime whether it is on human being or animal or tree.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Naveen Shetty, Mangalore/Malesiya

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    It is ridiculous, because of vote bank these politicians are playing with people, how can you stop practiced culture/habits which come from generations, in a democratic country, is there no freedom to eat or drink what is permissible by God. this is against the law of nature,how many people are dependent on this trade. day is not far such dictatorial government will fall soon.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Jude, Mangalore Dubai

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    This is just a political stunt. Acharya will not be able to change the law. Secondly I do not care on condition that beef imports will be allowed. I would prefer eating Australian or European beef to Indian beef. Finaly for an ignorant comment by Mr Madyastha, I just would like him to know that Pork is available all over GCC except in Saudi Arabia. It is also available in all other arab countries like Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt, Turkey etc.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Thomas Valder, Bahrain

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Very good decision Mr. Achari. I have 7 old cows. I am not getting milk from them & unable to feed them. Pls. give me your address, I will send them to you for taking care of them. Afterall, you have proved that you are the care taker of cows, buffallos..etc. etc. except human beings. You have made yourself a laughing stock Mr. Achari. A true enemy of BJP. Power to a fool is very dangerous - 'mangana kaige maanikya kotta haage'.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Manoj, Mangalore

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Is honourable(?) minister Acharya a Home Minister or Cattle Minister?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • lingappa rao, udupi

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    It is nice to stop cow slaughter.I will appreciate the govt. if it stops human slaughter in the name of cows.Human being is more precious than cows.During vedic period the brahmins ate and sold beef and killed cows.Kindly stop cow politics and concentrate on governance.People have voted you to represent all communities and religions.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Kate, Mangalore

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Don't worry, all these years, people going to Kuwait & other Gulf Countries used to secretly carry Pork, now we can ask them to secretely bring Beef (Australian, Newzealand) from there.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Tony, Mangalore

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    This is a good decision by the minister. Cow slaughter should be banned. Keep it up.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Don Amnon, Lower Bendoor, Mangalore

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    What a pity. If this law is enacted, there bumper HAPTHA biz to Karnataka Police & Ruling party Politicians. Guys we have to knock the High Court/Supreme court door.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • MAGANJAM, muscat-oman

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Mr. Acharya - instead of banning cow slaughter, i think u have to say trading of cow is illegal or to be prohibit. here u r using double standard... nearly 95% of cows owned by .. hindus.. pls rethink..

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ismail zaorez, bhatkal

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    In the indian constitution its clear that every religion has independent.and should not be disturbed by anyone.for muslim its a top priority of sacrifying cow in the way of our holy religion.is this a independent for muslims?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Roshan, Mangalore

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    According to Govt Statistics, Milk production is lowest in last two years. May be cows themselves having realized slow, starving death, started producing less. I think the ban is certainly to suite the illegimate motives of Reddy brothers who are holding KMF? People will be certainly discouraged to rear cows, as a result there will be shortage of milk. Are Reddy's going to milk us all with price rise? Need to wait and watch.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • David Pinto, Mangalore / Bangalore

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    This is the only work Mr. Acharya has done ever since becoming the Home Minister.Mr. Acharya seems to be ignoring the bigger problems haunting the State. What about the Church attacks and infamous Pub attack. Why does not Mr. Acharya ban the groups and organisations that are behind such attacks. Mr. Acharya has proved that he is mere puppet in the hands of the fundamentalists. I wonder whether he is the Home Minister of the State or the 'Minister for grazing cattle'.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Anil Dsouza, Moodubelle

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Congratulations Jerald Fernandes, BJP(moodubelle) on you victory on making karnataka beef free. I'm sure you would have become vegetarian. You can bring about a healthy vegetarian change in moodubelle parish as well

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • abusaad, mangalore/dammam

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Major manufacturer & exporter of Leather product is Hindus (Specially Brahmin's in Tamilnadu). How they will continue the business as the cow slaughtering is banned. Again in our DK district, price of the Beef increased not due to Muslim and Christan peoples. Because of most of the Hindu families are consuming beef meat and served in each Bar & Restaurant same meat... Just think who will loose and who will get benifitted.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • oliver machado, UDUPI MUSCAT

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Soon, It would not be a surprise if someone hurls a shoe filled with cowdung on Mr. acharyas face. Afterall he has not done anything good for any community.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • David Rodrigues, Kayyar/Bangalore

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Why ban only on beef. Ban slaughter on all living things. All living things needs to be treated equally.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Nagappa lingaraj, blore

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    What about all the cow products these brahmins / battas are wearing??? Leather sandals, having leather sofa, or wearing a leather jacket during cold weather in blore or mysore??? Will there be ban on the above products too, because these products cannot be manufactured without slaughtering cows...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Julian D'Mello, Mangalore

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Dont worry guys no one will ban cow slaughtering, just for politcal milage. Mr. V S Acharya is preparing for next election. just 2 years left of "MEVA".

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Soofi Anwar, Mangalore/UAE

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    This is disgusting! Mr. Acharya, you are playing politics on poor people's stomach. Look at the entire economical aspects of such ban, dont look just from consumer's point, you may rear cow for milk, what will you do bullocks?. What are you going to do with them? Your own farmers will curse you. This will be the beginning of end of your ruling in Karnataka.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ms. Fernandes, Udipi

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    Dear Mr Acharya, You are in a position to implement laws for the upbringing of the society and by God’s grace you are intelligent and by people grace today you are Home Minister of Karnataka. Why don’t you use your position/power and intelligence in the field where you can help Karnataka to improve and eradicate unemployment. Rather than pushing yourself in certain affairs where you no need to put your nose. You want to implement this rule just you are Hindu.

    Yes, Hindu’s adore Cow as sacred animal. Have you gone through the implication and hardship that the Govt and Kannadiga’s needs to face upon the enforcement of this law. • What the farmers will do with the Calf’s – neither they can sell or keeping them is an extra expenditure to them. • What to do with the Old Cows/bull when the farmer can not get any income from them – do not tell the farmer to keep them with him and serve as his old father/mother! This is practically not possible. • Have you arranged to build enough cow sheds and take care of Calves and old cows/bulls?- you need to include this in the budget and also for the fodder – this is an extra expenditure, ultimately common public need to pay from their pockets. • New Government department to care of the cow sheds is required ! • People will still slaughter cows and illegally sell them. And when they are caught do you think they will pay fine and go for one year imprisonment… Oh! NO for sure. So called Guardians of Law will pocket some money and slaughtering will still continue …illegally. • Many people will lose their daily bread once you stop the slaughtering, are you planning to relocate them and provide them employment? • Everyone has a right to express their opinion. I am not hurting anyone’s feelings. • If any one thinks slaughtering should be banned, then they need to come forward to care of all these deserted animals. I think and it is a known fact that Govt will spend more money on old cows rather than for the citizens and it will lead to more illegal activities. Mr Acharya - Think 100 times and take action.. At least you need to consult people of all communities and take note of Advantages and disadvantages.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • anton santis, mangalore

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    i think our home minister has gone sensile.rather then worry about law and order he is worried about peoples food habits.is he going to come to each house and investigate what one is eating?most probrabily will send his goons ram sena,bajrang dal,vhp and nagesh nayak to check on every one.they will trash every one under new law of cow policing.to day what we eat,tomorrow what we wear,speak,do,talk to will be decided by this buffoon!!!!!!!!can't do a jack about law and order .can't provide adequate electricity,roads,food for the poor and is worried about cow slaughter.fine ban it but what will you do about your leather shoes that you go strutting about!!!!!!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Jerry Moras, Mangalore, Calgary

    Thu, Feb 11 2010

    BJP and its allies have not only rewritten constitution but even history. Question is it BJP’s accomplishments ? Answer is yes. BJP manages to delight some section of Hindu groups and create wider gaps between religions to broaden their grass root base. It’s win-win situation for BJP and some section of Hindu society. I respect those who preach and practice Hindu as per Vedas , Bhagavad-Gita, Ramayana and Maha Bharata epics. Who decides what to eat or what not to eat ?

    It is all political game. As Advani originated Babri Majid issue for gain. Here comes another hero (for wrong reasons) to ban cow slaughter. Good job done boys ! This can happen only in India. I leant from books Hindu religion is tolerant and India never invaded any country but from recent months some section of society link religion into politics and invades freedom of others creating barriers – don’t eat meat , terrorize religious places including profession of faith. India has more internal problem than external interference. Costs to fix those bottlenecks is huge in the long term For example, Mangalore has International airport but if above is the case how come foreign tourist visit our place ? Also we would discourage foreign students to study in Karnataka. Good luck with that…

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • D. F. Lobo, Mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Mr Acharya, first you pass an order to Hindus not to consume Beef and drink Cow`s milk in Karnataka. Others will follow later. You are only a Home Minister not the King of Karnataka. Work within your limit and tenure. Still I love Mr A. B. Vajapayee. But BJP may not like him and his ideology now. Jai Bharath.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Anil Moras, Mangalore, India

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Dr Acharya if you are proud of this new law, the neighbouring states will be generating revenues. You think you can stop people cross the borders and bring cooked or raw meet?? What would you do those cows after certain years... Will this move encourging people to continue cow farming? Who will be the ultimate looser cow eaters? those who own cows? State loosing revenue? or at the end there will be hardly anyone would have a single cow!!! Why Karnataka is special in everything?? Nonetheless, Karnataka will remain below poverty line forever and Kerala will certainly dominate.. I guess before implementing any new laws, needs to verify the pros and cons and especially the economical aspects!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ashu, Kundapura/UAE

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Mr. Acharya its your Vinaasha Kaala Vipareeth Buddhi, you have lot of things to instead of ban cow slaughter.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Prasad Karkada, Udupi / Dubai

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Dr. Madhyastha for your kind information I work & live in Dubai, UAE that United Arab Emirates, which incidentally is a Muslim country but sells pork(pig meat) to its expatriat community like us. By your statement "does muslim country sell pigs" do you intend to say that India is a hindu country & there is no place for Christians or any other religion.

    How stupid can you be?? In this era you guys are still bickering with religion, this is a secular country sir we have the right to practise our own religion & our own eating habits. Its a pity that UAE a purely Muslim country shows tolerence to all religions & even lets us build Temples, Church's & other religious places of worship & in my India we have intolerant imbeciles like you spreading hatred. Are you a doctor or are you doctered Madhayastha??? Time to wake up & call yourself an Indian. Jai Hind

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Roshan, Mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Acharya represents Shakuni of Mahabharat. When things are cooling down, he will come with something to get it raging. With a Shakuni mama like acharya, the state BJP is well doomed to be the Kauravas, who will vanish without a trace, if sanskrit language subhashita's to believe.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • poojary, kinnigoli

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Well come decision, the Acharya you showed your guts. Well said fathima

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Naveen Pinto, Madanthyaar/ Bangkok

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    J.C Furtado, Mumbai why not ban on chicken? Eggs also best for health. Hindu’s worship fish also. Time for Muslims to ban on pork, then Jain’s on all non vegetarian items etc etc. What this Archarya will do with handicraft, useless cattle’s? Worship in go shaala and after die burry?

    Any proof goshaala’s people don’t sell to butchers or other state? I have an experience when our cow went to others Hindu fence and he sold to one Muslim butcher for half rate of its actual and next day same butcher sold meat to us. No doubt Congress minting votes slowly by foolishness of these zero valued rulers. Jai ho congress.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • nagesh nayak, bangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    HATS OFF TO SHRI.YEDIYURAPPA & TEAM. KARNATAKA WILL BE PROSPEROUS SINCE DUE RESPECT TO SACRED COW HAS BEEN GIVEN BY BJP GOVT. JAI HO. GOU MATHA KO PRANAM.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Joel, Mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Dukor kavetghi Acharya Maam's

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • nurya, Kundapur

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Mr. Achary collect waste of cattle ping all over the city on roads and street, then start growing vegetables.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • shahnawaz kukkikatte, dubai/udipi

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Mr Acharya, you are just implementing RSS/VHP agenda in Karnataka. Beef is consumed all over India and not only in karnataka. Yes you can sentence some one who kills cows (muslim) for 7 years and fine him Rs.1 lakh. What punishment is in line for those who sell cows to these slaughter houses? Are they not party to this deal.You stupid minisiter is showing double standards. What punishment is there for those who attack places of worship, kill othrs in the name of religion??? First make your home department bribe free department.

    As long as corrupt police officials and inefficient home minister like you are there, beef would continue to sell in karnatka. NO SWAMIJI OR NO MINISTER OR NO LAW CAN STOP IT. Hindus too are eating beef. In our neighbouring state kerala beef is openly consumed by all religious people. Kerala hindus are not hinus? Only karnataka hindus are true hindus? Try to bring nationwide ban on cow slaughter, that more appropriate.

    You hate minority community so much that you dont consider them to be your fellow citizens. We have least respect for you or your mentor organisations. Do whatever you want to do. How long this government would survive? Are you the permanent or life time home minister of karnataka? I have seen and read in the history, big emperors have lost their title and you too are not an exception to this rule. Dont hijack the fundamental rights of citizens of this country. If your dont want to eat , dont eat, but dont stop others from eating it.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Harish Balalya, Mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Good Decision by State Govt, Thank you Mr. Acharya.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rohan, mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Forget all this, can someone focus on getting some electricity to karnataka and improving the rural infrastructure?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Anil, bangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    If, BJP Government put on ban cow slaughters it will be more than 2 years. When this government exists the ban also go behind them..(Mr.V.S. Achari your not eating beef?)

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Melwin Pais, Mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Should I go to Uppala for Beef? Well, if 100% Hindu folks support this move, we'll face less cattle robbery in the villages(sorry, I lost my cow which was stolen by beef mafia at midnight near Benjanapadav) and will find more "GoShaale" than primary schools...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Roger Desouza, Mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Why ban possesion and consumption of beef?. Why ban buffalo meat?. Is it not done with a ulterior motive for political gains.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • mansoor, dammam ksa

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    waa Sony what a article man really appreciate thanks,

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • pasha, Mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    The reason cow slaughter was banned was that in an agrarian society, cows signified wealth, therefore the more cows you had the more rich ad powerful you were. May be Mr. Archarya wants to collect bovines to display his power & wealth. What an idiot?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr.Madhyastha H, Balkudru-Hungarkatte/Japan

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Congrats Dr.Acharya. good move. According to Scinece, milk is product of Cow. So debate on milk consumption is meaningless. Does Arab country sell Pig meat. So it is natural that cow slaughter is banned. Here is there is no relegion and politcis.Even Our governer voiced and supported the move other day. In final move he no wonder he may reject this move too.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dennis.L.Vaz, Hirgan / U.S.A

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Great idea Mr.Achary. no more agriculture now days.your free to talk & comment. coz your not paying tax on your comments is'nt. after all your a achary and you will remains as a olden days achary. how long you will remains in your H.M. post? as a H.M.you should control & concern more about Naxel group ect.wish you a very happy Valentines day. God Bless you.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • charan, udupi

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Few days back this idea was advised by the Governer Bharadwaj, a congress Ideologue. I do not understand why people are crying foul on BJP government?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • jossey saldanha, thane

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Mr. Acharya, Ban cutting and eating of vegetables as it leads to global warming.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Bruno DSouza, Udupi/ Dubai

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    This going to make me travel 300 KM north to Goa to eat my Fav. Beef Chilli Fry dish

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • fathima, mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    The move to be respected. There is nothing special in cow meat or nobody obliged to eat cow meat or nobody die without it. So please stop writing stupid comments.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Felix F., India/Ksa

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    I have been a well wisher of the BJP lead by A.B. Vajpayee, even for that matter Advani but the BJP of Karnataka who resemble MNS Manoos of Mumbai, will be instrumental self destroying the BJP.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Abu Acharya, Belman/USA

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Dont Worry Mr Abdul Khader, If VS Acharya stands for election from Udupi again, we will show him how to remove skin! Every time he stood for election except 1983 assembly election, we removed his skin and sent him home!!( 1972, 1978, 1985 assembly and 1977, 1980 parliment elections). In 1983 we could not skin him, because our dear Congress leaders like Vasanth Salian and UR Sabhapathy have thicker skin than Ancharya himself!!!.

    Wait for some time, if Congress can genenerate some leaders with backbone(Remember Oscar???), then we can skin him again, if he dares to contest a election from Udupi again, I am sure he is smart enough not to contest!!!! Till then Mr Khader, why dont you start an agitation against eating Matti Gulla, since plants also have life!, please dont call Congressmen for your agitation, they are more charitraheens than Sangh Parivar themself. Mr Khader, i pity your intelligence for expecting anything better than this from Mr Vedavyasa Srinivasa Acharya, being a nominee of Sangh Parivar.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Albert D. Alvares, Bondel-Mangalore/Toronto

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    This is bjp's first nail to the coffin of the poor class. Bjp want people to die of starvation.I think they want public to eat or to follow religon of their choice. Are we free in a democratic country. When the cow stops to yield milk, the farmer, cannot afford to maintain it. The farmer chases that cow out of the shed and those cows die of starvation. I suggest that bjp collects these cows and feed them. Finally who likes beef ? Please guess.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • A.M Ali, Mangalore/KSA

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Without investigation of the Surthkal case. Mr. Acharya can decide alone overnight.Looks like he has brain almost as big as the sardine fish. Will he well suit in fish society to take care of their politics?or the ant. Many churches, statues and properties destroyed by so many individuals any actions were the police and the politician taken so far.

    Don't live ignorant living bodies,they worth nothing.next time someone will find a dead fish near the temple,so you will ban fish eating like wise chicken head and big watermelon.It is surprising why not rock cutting is stopped, rock is one of the Goddess too.All Kannadigas be prepared to watch the Dogs and cats eating cows scenes which may be award winning photographs.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Art, Urva

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    There are folks starving everywhere and these jokers want to ban a food item based on religion, we should ban fish, vegetables, chicken, pork, etc. as well since they are religious items.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Cynthia, Mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Wow....great to know that there is so much love, respect and religious value attached to animals. Just wondering why these animals are allowed to roam on streets hindering traffic and also letting them spot in bus shelters. Respect towards anything is caring for it first and then everything follows.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • M.A.Crasta, Mangalore/USA

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Imprisonment term and fine seems is slightly negative for the value of the cow'cause it is golden.What happens for man slaughtering, walk free in the public like a bull.It is indigenous our politician, human death rate will increase tremendously, because non milking and old cows will sleep on the road as night watchmen traffic controllers and increase accidents.This step is very smart to control the population growth.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sony, D'souza

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Mr. Acharya, are you gone crazy??? Being politicians please know the constitution of India & if you don’t know the constitution of India you are not fit for your seat and shows your illiteracy in the administration. India is secular country were all the religion have equal importance… if you are focussing on only Hindu religion, this shows you are an unfit home minister.

    If you really want to ban, ban the Hindu’s who kill the cattle’s don’t force other religion people to do so. By implementing this policy you cannot hurt the sentiments of other cast / religion. And as said by Mr. Furtado if he has given up eating beef after realising natural importance, then even he has to stop eating chicken because even egg laid by the hen has natural importance too…

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • T.K. Hamza, Kushalnagar

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Acharya should ban Fishing and killings of Boar coz Fish and Boar were 1st and 3rd incarnation of Lord Vishnu, Rats also to be protected by law coz Lord Ganesha rides on it. Fruits, Vegetables also be banned coz trees and plants also live creatures and feels pain. now beef consumer should eat what BJP decides.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • munna, bangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Mr.J C FURTADO, MUMBAI/UK... for ur information even the milk that u enjoy is not your share ... its the share of a growing calf so ban the milk as well...?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • S.H. Ali Udupi, Udupi

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Dear brothers and sisters no surprise, because this Acharya is from RSS ideology. We minorities can't expect anything from this BJP Govt. This is the start of implementing their hidden agenda.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Naveen Sequeira, Mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Is Acharya is going to ban "KAMBALA" as well? I don't see beating the crap out of these buffalos for Kambala is a "Kind/Humane" act in any angle. Please dont take me wrong, i do like Kambala ("Arasu" Kambala is my favourite one) and like beef too. Also, what about the cows and buffalos that are malnurished by many of our villegers? Is that a kind act? All i can say is "Jai Ho BJP" and "Jai Ho Vote Bank Politics".

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Shetty, mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    A very good move...Cows are precious to our country's agriculture & economy...Great going Mr Acharya.At last some respect to hindu beliefs..

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • m.haaris, kuwait

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Mr.chittaranjan now you should leave from doha as soon as possible. because in qatar beef is still permissible. Really if u want to say jai hind then you should follow your sacred teachings. hurry up please!!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Abdul Khader Kukkaje, Mangalore/RassAlKhaimah,U.A.E

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Mr.Acharya stop this cheap political milage games.If your Bharatheeya Janatha Party (BJP) have sincere love with these animals then why not your BJP government has not stopped the export of beef during the Vajapeyee govt.you know india's meat is available in most of all forign countries including the arab countries.thease meat items included mainly beef only.,you know during your leader vajapeyee's govt., these export business of india is better then other govt., accoring to the export record.

    Mr Acharya you know there are many leather facotries are using cattle's skin for their raw material.these leather factories are mostly belongs to your superior caste of hindus only,if you have sincere love with cows can you shutdown or cancel the licence of thease factories atleast in our karnataka.because you know removing the skin from cattle is after killing them only.so can assure there is no leather factories in karnataka which using cattles skins for their raw materials. in democretic country citizen of india they have the freedom to eat their likeness or choice of food as well as they have freedom to worship as their choice of beleif.so respect the democretic value.,instead of creating some cammunal inspiration among the people, to gain your votebank from the innocent people.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Antony T. D Souza, Karkala / Qatar

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    In a civilized Hindu society which is more sacred ? To avoid food by cow slaughter ban or to ban yet prevailing castism, untouchability, stratification in the society? Which is more heinous ?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Francis , Moodsbidri/Duabi

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Karnatka VIDHANASAUDHA is become cowshed. So Acharya and his follower afraid!!! Anyways Jai Ho man Salughter Govt!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Joseph F. Gonsalves, Bannur, Puttur/ Mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    This is the beginning of the death knell of bjp in other words beginning of bjp's slaughter. Irresponsibility of the fundamentals mindless law.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Siva Avadani, Manipal/Dubai

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Un democratic act. Sorry beaf eaters, this will effect thousands and thousands of middle class people no matter which caste, who mainly depend on cow milk, and when the cow is old they sell it and buy a new cow and life goes on. Milk sellers and Meat sellers and meat eaters are loosers. In short its a lose lose situation.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • jacintha, mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Wonderful. Follow this up, with a doddi in each city center. How else will we handle the stray / useless cattle? Indirectly, this will create long life for all those who became fat and had attacks due to red meat. Acharya now has to handle this old men/women who otherwise would have died of red meat cholestrol.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • J C FURTADO, MUMBAI/UK

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Very good .well done . Iam happy with the ban . killing cattle which provides us milk is a shame. cows milk is the best.I did eat cow meat but when i realised the natural importance of a cow I gave up.I eat other meat. In india cow has a sacred religious values as well. great work.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Harold D'cunha, Mangalore, India

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    The most disappointed people with this ban are those who eat beef in disguise.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Althaf, Kaup/Bahrain

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Hello Mr.Acharya Please include Chicken in the definition of cattle in the bill includes cow, calf, bull, bullock, and buffalo because not only cow, calf, bull etc are animails, all the living things are animals. So apply rules on all the animals.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ivan Vaz, Mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    If this Government exists for next Budget may be we can expect more rules on Non Vegetarians and Targeting to Minorities

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Bruno DSouza, Udupi/ Dubai

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Banning consuption of beef is harsh. Hopefully canned beef from outside Karnataka is allowed.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • suman, mangalore

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    I want to see how many Go shaalas Acharya builds, he can do nothing for suffering people. But he is doing it for cattle. What can a poor human being or Sc /ST in South Canara expect from this person

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • chittaranjan, Mangalore/DOHA

    Wed, Feb 10 2010

    Congrats Mr.Acharya. good work. Jai hind, jai sree Ram, Vande Matharam.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Karnataka to Enforce Cow Slaughter Ban



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.