India Steps into History with Women's Quota Bill


Minu Jain/IANS

New Delhi, Mar 9: India's politics took a decisive step towards change Tuesday with its upper house passing a historic bill giving one-third representation to women in parliament and state legislatures, crossing the biggest hurdle in the road towards political empowerment for women in the world's largest democracy.

The 13-year perilous political struggle to give women adequate representation ended with the Rajya Sabha finally debating the contentious issue and then voting 186-1 on the Constitution (One Hundred and Eighth Amendment) Bill, 2008 amid acrimony, political divides and ugly scenes of dissent.

Only the last step remains - of the Lok Sabha endorsing it. With the numbers stacked in favour of the Congress-led United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government in the lower house, this should hopefully be a formality, said activists and leaders, who had fought long and hard to see the day.

The reserved seats would be allotted by rotation to different constituencies and would be valid for 15 years after the commencement of the Amendment Act.

The flagship legislation did not get passed on International Women's Day as the government had hoped but a day later. Nonetheless, it was a time for hyperbole and the timing of the bill, introduced by the Deve Gowda government in 1996, could not have been better.

Even for the usually taciturn Prime Minister Manmohan Singh who described it as "a historic step forward" towards "strengthening the process of emancipation" of Indian women. Both he and UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi had staked the government's future on the passage of the bill.

"This is a momentous development in the long journey of empowering our women," he said at the end of a lively debate on the bill that saw 27 speakers participate.

"Our women faced discrimination at home, there is domestic violence, they face discrimination in equal access to education, healthcare, there are all these things. All these things have to end if India were to realise its full potential," he added on an emotive note.

That the issue of giving women in a still deeply traditional country assured representation in the highest echelons of political power provoked the most intense reactions was evident from the prime minister's opening remarks itself.

"I owe you a profound apology for the disrespect shown to you...," he told Vice President and chairman of the house Hamid Ansari.

On Monday, Ansari found himself virtually accosted by a handful of MPs who tore the bill into shreds and hurled the pieces at him. On Tuesday, a disgusted Ansari suspended seven MPs from the Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD), the Samajwadi party (SP), the Lok Janshakti Party (LJP) and the Janata Dal-United (JD-U), regional parties whose main support base is in the Hindi heartland.

At this point, women constitute nine percent of the Lok Sabha, 10 percent of the Rajya Sabha and only seven percent of state legislative assemblies.

Correcting the anomaly, however, saw the blurring of many political lines and the Congress-led United Progressive Alliance government losing some of its political edge.

The RJD and the SP announced the withdrawal of their support to the government and the ally Trinamool Congress abstained from the vote. Within the Janata Dal-United (JD-U) divisions appeared with Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar for the move but its other big leader Sharad Yadav bitterly opposed to it.

But the Congress battled the hurdles. It was a triumph for Congress president Sonia Gandhi who was determined that it would go through. In the Lok Sabha, the task would be easier with the Congress having a strength of 208, the largest constituent of the UPA's 259 members.

The SP's 22 seats and the RJD's four would not make a difference, said a party leader.

But this was an issue that went beyond politics, a reflection of the emerging women power in a rapidly modernising India.

Principal opposition Bharatiya Janata Party's Arun Jaitley who opened the debate said he had a feeling of being a party to history in the making when he came to the house and his party "unequivocally" supported it.

Communist Party of India-Marxist's (CPI-M) Brinda Karat said the move would change the "culture of the country because women today are still caught in a culture prison. In the name of tradition, stereotypes are imposed and we have to fight these every day".

These stereotypes will also be broken by the bill, said a delighted Karat, who believes the entry of a larger number of women in legislatures would make for "more sensitive politics".

Inequalities would be rectified, age-old biases corrected. With this bill, could things finally change. A tempting thought for India's women.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Praveen Bangera, Kaup/Dubai

    Wed, Mar 10 2010

    A very brave decision by the UPA government. One of the finest decision of respected Mr. Manmohan Singh and Mrs. Sonia Gandhi. Congratulations to the ruling party and the main opposition party. However, I really doubt whether this bill will be passed in Lokhsabha becouse if this bill is passed then no member can contest int the same constituency also there will be opposition from minority communities against this bill.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Nithyananda Beskoor, Udupi,Dubai

    Wed, Mar 10 2010

    Good decision by the Govt.N.R.I's after returning to india have got a chance to field their wives in local elections.ANY HOW MANY OF US HAVE LEARNT COOKING IN THE GULF.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Patrick Braggs, Bejai,Mangalore

    Wed, Mar 10 2010

    Atlast we had a Constitutional Amendment to something of significant relevance.Another example of the truimph of hope over experience.Hope we have more women in politics and less of corruption.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Gilson, Mangalore

    Wed, Mar 10 2010

    I congratulate all woman folks.

    Observation 1:
    Most of the Critical road accidents that happened had woman in the driver seat. With more woman drivers eventually, the male drivers started to be very careful and resulted in lesser accidents. Women have different way of thinking and they never collided vehicles of the same category.

    Obervation 2:
    Females are intelligent, they scored more ranks in the school. Some of them are highly influencial such as Indira, Margaret, Benazir, Hilary etal.
    Even inside the house, they are powerful and authoritative.

    But they are also the victims:
    Observation 1:
    Still a minority in administrative organizations and being dictated by males.

    Obervation 2:
    After marry, they are forced to vacate fathers house and move to husbands house.

    I have a soft corner, and I wish there would come a day when you see guys moving to wives house and parliament that has male minority

    Then you see the change in Indian politics. Corruption should wipe out in their hand,they would make India beautiful (see themselves. They are aesthetically and physically impressive, and art and discipline oriented. If they dont cook at home, we starve).

    Guys, please take a deeper breathe, and pray the next Governement would ammend this law, but no guarantee. Work hard. If some of you have a ambition of becoming politicians, chance is slim, so think to marry the able ones :-)

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • shyam, mangalore

    Wed, Mar 10 2010

    Abdul Rahman, Dubai..
    ur 100% right..
    that is called as uniform civil code.
    there will be no cast or relegiun column in any applicatoin.
    but ll our minority brothers will support this .?they need equal but crying equal right.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Abdul Rahman, Dubai

    Wed, Mar 10 2010

    Dear Ismail K Pernije,
    I cannot take your example of Mrs Shobha Karandlaje. She became minister and lost it because of her own merits/demerits and various other factors.I do not agree that she lost the minstership just because she is a woman. Totally unacceptable reasoning.
    There is a saying - "we can take the horse to the river, but can't make it drink the water". By reserving seats in parliament, we can take them to parliament but we cannot make them empowered just by doing that. Empowerment needs a systemic change, a change in cultures, attitudes and social values.By reserving 33% of the seats, we are taking a high amount of risk, risking the development of the nation.We don't know what type of women will be filled in these seats. What we require for our country is able leaders, not just women.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ISMAIL K PERINJE, PERINJE/YANBU-KSA

    Wed, Mar 10 2010

    Congrats to all women foks.India made a history by reserving 33% seats in Parliment and state assemblies.Democracy says irrespective of gender,cast creed religion,ect all are equal.But what is the representation of 50% women in the country to our elected bodies?A male dominated society of India definetly need this arrangement to give justice to 50% of the total population.

    Mr ABDUL RAHIMAN DUBAI,a simple example for you as I am differing with you- Take for example of Miss Shoba Karndalaje, she was alone women rep in council of minister of Karntaka Govt,but for the reason of male pressure she was shown gate pass from the Council of Ministers.Infact she was most powerful active minister capable of dealing as her counter part male members.My question is,if some place was reserved for women can any body try to dethrone her?Certainly female members of this country under represented in all legislative bodies.Reservation in other fields(jobs,education Ect)may be a curse for development as you said and for some extant I agree with you.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Jawar D'Souza, M'Lore/Doha

    Wed, Mar 10 2010

    The bill is a very good move for Indian women, but if women like Mad Mayavathi who spent cores of rupees on statues are dangerous to the society. Better have some women with brain's in politics. Don't think that women are not corrput, avarice for money makes every human being corrupt. I have seen that in my life in the bombay custom's dept where there were women officer's who openly asked money, it's no secret. I think women should be given a good quota in the Police, Millitary,Home gaurd's, Air Force, Navy etc etc. Then the other women in the Society will be confident to apporoach them, specially the police force. Any way all the best to the women folk.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • jeevan, capitanio/mangalore

    Wed, Mar 10 2010

    A very sad day for India ...I totally agree with Mr.Abdul Rahman, Dubai. Reservation of any kind is not an answer to the problems we face..

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Abdul Rahman, Dubai

    Wed, Mar 10 2010

    Mr.Shanawaz,
    Read your comment again and see whether it has any relevance here. Passing of this bill doesn't mean that our women are automatically empowered.Empowerment of women is possible only through social and cultural change.Empowerment of women is required but not by providing reservations in parliamnet and assemblies.We are electing our representatives to rule our nation, we want the best people to be elected, irrespective of whether they are men, women, minority, majority, whatever. Reservation of any kind is a curse for development. India has taken a step forward in the wrong direction. You too have been carried away by the hollow slogan of woman empowerment. Majority opinion need not be always correct.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Peter, Brahmavar/Sharjah

    Wed, Mar 10 2010

    I am not against the bill. But not agree with the women politicians are not corrupt. Jayalalita is the most corrupt woman plotician. Mayawati & Jayalalita spending money on building temples, statues for their own.If there is riservation it shoud be 50% and monority,Dalit but qualified womans also given necessory quota.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Abdul Rahman, Dubai

    Tue, Mar 09 2010

    I feel India has taken two steps backwards by passing this bill. Women empowering is required but not at the cost of the nation. What we need today for India is not woman empowering but a strong, able and sincere leadership whether man or woman. Reservations in the Parliament and assemblies whether it is for women or dalits or SC/ST should altogether be abolished, only the able and honest people should get elected to rule this country. In the name of reservation we are trying to turn the wheel of progress backwards. Our politicians got carried away by hollow canvassing by woman protagonists. I consider yesterday as a black day for India, every party joined together to defeat my India.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • shahnawaz kukkikatte, dubai/udipi

    Tue, Mar 09 2010

    Congratulations to women folks of my country. Womens welfare cant be achieved without doing justice to them. They just cant be treated like birth giving machines. They are more than that. A good woman will make a good house, good wife, good mother and many other roles, a good woman can be a good lawmaker too. Stop treating woman as subordinate and second class citizens. They truly and rightfully deserve a place of respect amongst us.

    We should salute to women. My mother is a good woman who made me what I am today. Woman is nothing but mother nature and mother India. Those who oppose this bill are blind to the realities and need tobe banned from the soceity. Women in the history have proven their worths. Lets make India a better and safer place for our women counterparts. Dont forget that your mother who gave you birth is a woman, your wife, daughters, daughters in laws are woman. Can we multiply and sustain without woman?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • R.T.SHETTY, mangalore

    Tue, Mar 09 2010

    Congrats to all the womens of india.there is no chance for the welfare of the world unless the condition of women is improved.it is not possible for a bird to fly on only one wing.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Antony Crasta, Mangalore/Sydney, Australia

    Tue, Mar 09 2010

    Good news! I am delighted to hear that the subject bill has been passed in the Parliament with a thumping majority and I congratulate all the eminent Members of Parliament who voted in favour of this historic bill, which was long overdue. It`s now an opportunity for you all those educated, smart and affluent women out there, to come out of your shells, specially from your mundane routine life at home and elsewhere, and take an active part in the political field, and show your clout, merit and strength, which I am sure, you have in plenty, and work towards the betterment of the country, for we, the people of India, are fed up for a long time now, with the men being dominant in Politics for so long, specially with their corrupt and crude ways of governing and functioning, for, we believe that women generally are known to be more down to earth, honest and truthful, and unlike men, they are less susceptible to corruption and bride taking culture (please ladies, don`t let us down on this assumption and way of thinking!). By the way, I fully endorse the comments of Mr. Shenoy, specially when he says that men in politics are corrupt in nature and politics itself is corrupt because in politics anything goes. To conclude, I wish to say that Politics is a very difficult field to survive, specially for a honest and clean person.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • nailappa, Goa

    Tue, Mar 09 2010

    There are some groups who were beating at women's,who were attending for a pub in mangalore a few months back.Now they voted for a political reason .womens Vote.A salute to Congress Government.Well done

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • jacintha, mangalore

    Tue, Mar 09 2010

    Through legitimate process, women were not allowed to come in large numbers in politics. Those few who are there, are often referred with deregatory remarks.

    In corporate world there is glass ceiling, and they justify it saying 'it is business'. Politics is not busines, it is for good administration.

    If we can trust our homes, our children in women's able hand, I suppose trusting women to be in bigger numbers in politics is not a risk.

    As someone said, they would bring in some discipline, some decorum and time management in our parliment, which is so lacking.

    Now the game is open, who ever really meant women upliftment, will have to support this.

    And men, don't worry. All nations which are led by women are florishing, and are in peace.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • manish, canada

    Tue, Mar 09 2010

    We already have mayawati ,jayalalitha to shake the nation.with this passing of the bill...expect some more my dear mens

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • manish, canada

    Tue, Mar 09 2010

    We already have so many reservations like ST ,OBC,ETC ETC.educated guys dont get jobs because of these quotas. How many more quotas are there to come.....

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • adshenoy, mangaluru

    Tue, Mar 09 2010

    "A historic step forward". Mr. Prime Minister, well its hisoric legally by reservation and mind you, reservation only. A quota in politics for women only or its all POLITICS. Empowerment, perhaps. Getting rid of discrimination, Not so, because all women are legitimate voters in India.Indian democracy, the largest democracy on earth works under quota system. A question ponders, is democracy supposed to work this way?

    There is no question that women representation in politics is much lower, not only in India but around the world including the so called- developed nations.Question, is politics unattractive game for women. Perhaps, yes, given the nature of women. Politics is dirty game. Dirty not because it is hard work but because it is toungtwisting, arm twistering, hand shaking, back patting and so on, sometimes even forgoing the ethics, ,morals and principles of life. Its a power game, not for the sake of real power but because at times they are powerless given the nature of business of politics.

    Men in politics are corrupt by nature and politics itself corrupt because in politics anything goes.
    This is an opporunity for women to get rid of corruption because most women by nature tend to be less corrupt than men. Women can do wonders and women can do blunders. Just like managing a family. I wish all women success in politics but mind you that sucess will be at cost if one wants incur
    Can women retain this principle character being in politics. I wish them good luck

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Joseph F. Gonsalves, Bannur, Puttur/ Mangalore

    Tue, Mar 09 2010

    Congratulations to all our Indian females. Congratulations to all those who have supported to pass the bill. Congratulations to Italian born madam Indian citizen Soniaji, Dr. Manmohan Singhji and also Congratulations to those who have opposed the bill. No doubt there was opposition and that is a healthy democratic process. The most disheartening was the M.P's senseless misbehavior on the floor of the house. One more feather on the Congress party's cap. Jai Hind and God bless India.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: India Steps into History with Women's Quota Bill



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.