Why Rajneeti can be Liked, but not Loved...


Divvy Kant Upadhyay, Manipal
Daijiworld Media Network - Udupi

Jun 10: It is always easy to sit and comment on other’s work, but as a movie buff in cinema crazy ‘democratic’ India we have the right to voice our opinion, don’t we ?

Two reasons why films are made the world over, especially in India – are to Entertain and/or inform. The movies either make you laugh, cry, feel scared or they try and show glimpses of the real world out there. Rajneeti is a political and family drama that mirrored facets of three very famous stories – The Godfather, The Mahabharat and as rumoured, close resemblances to what is better known as India’s first family.

In an effort to combine facets of these three stories, somewhere along the line the trademark Prakash Jha film-making we saw in Gangaajal and Apharan was lost. Perhaps other than the hype that surrounded the release of the film, people had high expectations from the director who brought the hard hitting rustic realities of the in-lands of UP and Bihar to mainstream Bollywood.

It is true that criminalization of politics has made life cheap – but to think of party leaders planning and executing bond-style assassination attempts themselves rather than their henchmen becomes too unrealistic to digest. Ranbir appears fine when shown infront of a laptop and with a cigarette in hand – hurt, anguished and scheming to avenge the loss to his family, but he loses the appeal when you see him using Bluetooth and his own Gun to co-ordinate the murder of his rival –on the day of the election results – that too when he is on the verge of defeating him. This was such a major anti-climax, as one commentator put it.



Too many murders, car bombs and shades of Micheal and Sunny Corleone later, a regular movie buff is bound to compare it with Sarkar, or better still with the original – Godfather. The faltering storyline or adaptations disappointed.

We all have heard jokes about how India’s beds are more fertile than the fields – but to see so many conceptions in the two and half hour film does pull the film further away from the touch of much-needed reality.

The sad part of the movie was seeing Naseeruddin Shah being wasted and Nana Patekar not being used to the full. The fun part was seeing the red-flag-bearing communist role being reduced to a mere few minutes – that too – only to portray a blunder being made. Ajay Devgan was tremendous in Gangajal and Apharan. Rajneeti is a forgettable role for him. Ranbir continues to impress with the attitude that he wears around himself in every movie. Katrina’s charm works. Arjun Rampal’s character on screen had extremities from enjoying the pleasures of the flesh in his backoffice to sleeping away from his wife thanks to her feelings for his brother. Manoj Bajpai could have acted or been portrayed shrewder rather than just plain desperate.

The movie did get its round of publicity and the good ratings as is evident. Infact Director Prakash Jha did confess on TV that movie-making is after all a business for them – they need to add all the spices to cater to all crowds – and after that they need to get returns on their investment as well. In the entire process, we movie-goers lost the chance to see a hard hitting movie on Politics – the one thing that unimaginably drives so much of our country. Sometimes I wonder how easily we take it in our stride, movie after movie, when our institutions like the Police Force and the Media are branded spineless and conniving. It is perhaps to some extent reality itself. The only take-home message in this movie was life is cheap and power blinds the soul. India as a nation breathes politics. We all know how stinking dirty it gets. That’s why we needed a film that connected to the masses – even if it was fictional – especially if it was named Raajneeti !

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • ravi sharma, faridabaad

    Sun, Jun 13 2010

    rajneeti movie is so good for at present time janretion.i like ketreena cherector in this movie

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Reshmi, manipal

    Sat, Jun 12 2010

    I am yet to see the movie, but with so many reviews around, I am looking forward to watch it.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Kartik, Mumbai

    Fri, Jun 11 2010

    i think parkash jah is traitor and dishonest because the movie he made is not good at all. jha if u have ajay devgan and nana in u movie so u have to take the advantage of them, but u didnt give them good ruoes, i think they trust u but u were traitor to them. and what a joke of cross-eyed actor and cartoon ranbir in this movie, just rabish jha. i think ajay devgan should not work again with jah because he is not a good friend of him and good think by nana to not work with him. ranking for acting 1- Ajay devgan 2- Nana patekar 3-Katrina kaif 4-Arjun rampal 5-Manoj bajpai briliant guys

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Arohi, Mangalore

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    Everyone has their own view points, but this is the first movie which has shown the core of politics. its true that murders were more, but this is what happens in politics...
    but in real world politics the murder will be done by some gunda's and name will be given to big dons.
    Prakash Jha has given justices to all the chareters. and Ranbir was looking well educated and cunning but not as a kid as one commented.........

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Piyush Nigam, Lucknow

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    It's a good movie with lots of twist... But it could have been more better if no. of murders were less & storyline would involve some Original characters from Indian Politics....

    Ranbir was the best playing all the mind games in the movie..

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • salim, udupi

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    its a nice movie but i am disappointed with ajay devgan role, prakash jha didn't do justice to ajay devgan, ranbeer had powerful role but he looks kid in front of all these big guns.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • pamaru, machlipatnam

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    i think movie making was good ,as there was no time to dance,it was gripping from first.the movie is always had this feeling what happens now? that could be the reason for liking, but the story as a part was daily paper nonsense we read and see on tv,so it may not be loved,the casting had some clitches ,naseerudin shah was wasted ,nana patekar was not given his kind of role, Ajay devagan was given a good heroic saga kind of ,at the begining, but the climax was as of in Mahabharath so played safe there. the reason why we dont love it is that it morals that those who commit crime can go free,so law and order are influenced by politics(Rajneeti),that cannot be gulped by audience so he doesnt love it.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Aldrin Vaz, Mangalore

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    Excellent film. My ratin 4 stars. 1st half is ultimate wth twists & turns. U wil hve no time evn to blink ur eyes. 1 of th best evr screenplay. Aftr interval it bcms a bit slow but it retains th intensity & curiosity til th end. Climax could hve been more exictin but its fair.

    ALL actors hve gvn their lifetime best performance. Superstar Ranbir is terrific again.

    Direction,story,background music,cinematography is ultimate. Surely it wil sweep all th national awards this yr. I dnt think any film on politics cn match raajneeti in future also.

    Even if u dont like politics this is a must watch film. Thou 95% of th film is political ther is humanity, love, friendship,family values,loyalty,betrayal etc. Masterpiece frm Prakash Jha.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • bishnu, USA

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    i agree with the above article. while the movie was definitely entertaining, it lacked that gel. how can politicians go around killing their rivals so frequently right near the election. that is so improbable, and to do the killing themselves, doesn't make an iota of sense. if this movies was supposed to make us realize the dirty politics, it was far from it.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Khalid, France

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    Carrying a good pace of events parallel to Apaharan didn't look good as things in politics happen contrary, means, very slow. If I am to say, the director put a party's lifetime story in one election compaign. To say, waste of time.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • akyar mulla, shiruru / dubai

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    nice movie.....Ranbir was awesome in the movie.....

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • STALIN MISQUITH, BAHRAIN

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    AJAY DEVGAN AND NANA'S ROLE WAS SUPERB. PRAKASH JHA ONCE AGAIN PROVED A GREAT DIRECTOR AFTER GANGAJAL.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Kenjari, Mangalore

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    Was it necessary for Ranbhir to smoke at all. It looked like some Tobacco company paid Prakash Jha for this. The Movie release was also very near the Anti-Tobacco day and the campaign is meaningless if Big Stars with big fan following (Youngsters mostly) encourage them to Smoke.

    At least Ranbhir should Apologise for this.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Geeta, Abu Dhabi

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    I didnt like this movie at all. Please dont watch it.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • arif.bava, kaup/abu dhabi

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    Its nice family story, but not sentimental family drama like Rajashri Prodution, hard core voilance for getting hold/control on power (govenrment)rocks rajneethi

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Max,

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    Good movie kept you on the go. Ranbir was cool,Arjun Rampal ooooh was hot and Katrina as usual sizling

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Nikhil Puthran, Mangalore

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    awasome movie..i just loved it..worth watching...dirty politics...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rachna, New Delhi

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    i agree that movie has been inspired from mahabartha and india's first family.
    Ranbeer's character has been based on rajiv gandhi, arjun and I loved to see him in this character far away from romantic image.
    the movie truly depicted how values are changed, how relationships are made or sacrificed for the power.
    hats off to prakash jha for making this wonderful movie.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ali, Mangalore

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    Good movie, and Superb acting from Arjun Rampal & Manoj bajpai.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Chaitanya Karnik, Mumbai

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    I understand that every viewer has a right to express his opinion and interpret any movie as he or she feels, but I would strongly disagree with the above article.

    Personally, I felt that Rajneeti was a very hard hitting and gritty take on politics, as it works in our country.

    The characterization was apt and since the story was based on the epic Mahabharat which has a universal appeal and in all probability can take place anywhere.

    When the writer says that that Ranbir loses the appeal when you see him using Bluetooth and his own Gun to co-ordinate the murder of his rival –on the day of the election results – that too when he is on the verge of defeating him, I feel that this is where in the movie maker has gone deeper and delved into the basic human instinct of revenge and redemption.

    I feel that Manoj Bajpai was brilliant and there is no reason that he should be shrewder, since every person would react or behave as per his own personality, attitude and thinking and whatever he believes is rational. For a fact, Ajay Devgn was brillant in Apaharan and Gangajal but I think that this movie is not centered around one single person and Prakash Jha has given each character enough screen time to establish the reason why he or she should be there on the screen. Its like saying that Amitabh Bachhan who was portrayed as an angry young man then in every other movie he should be shown in a similar persona even if the movie genre is comedy and there is no action.

    I think Rajneeti rocks

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Arohi, Mangalore

    Thu, Jun 10 2010

    nice movie.....Ranbir was awesome in the movie.....Ranbir's girl friend was hot than Kat.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Why Rajneeti can be Liked, but not Loved...



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.