Fazl, Mangalore

Now a days we cant findout which is school and which is jail.. both are same..

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Leslie & Clara [teachers], Mangalore / Dubai

My sincere condolences to the bereaved family.May the Lord grant them strength and courage to bear this irreperable untimely loss of their kid.
Some of the comments are extreemly disguisting and unecceptable from any point of veiw! No one knows the truth!!! why blame the teacher alone? I am sure the child must have been suffering with some kind of sickness which led to his death.
Teachers are the 2nd parents.Don't you deny this fact!!!! all you commentators!!
No teacher will punish a child for no reason- but present scenario with all kinds of exposures what kind of students you expect!!! These commentators should be given a batch of 70 students to handle oneday! you will endup in mental hospital so called HUCHARA SHALEY!!!
Who knows where you would have been Mr.Lewis if Mr.Madhav Shetty hadn't corrected you? Probably selling coconuts/fish in Kallyanpur market!!!!
'Teach a child to Slap a teacher'??Where are we heading Mr.Vinod? Please go ahead with your own child first.Your child doesnot listen to you,you go crying to the teacher! Now a slap on whose face?
Teachers develop all kinds of diseases!BP,cancer, attacks Alistor this is the 'GURU DAKSHINA'from our loving students for building their charecters and making them future citizens.
'Killing a teacher is the ultimate solution? Do you thik it was done intentionally?
Please stop doing emotional comments! All have to die one day! who knows what kind of death is waiting for us!
Teach your child to respect 'TEACHERS

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

PRAMITH, MANGALORE/BAHRAIN

WE ARE SENDING OUR CHILDREN TO SCHOOL NOT TO JAIL ATLEAST JAIL ALSO HAVE SOME CONCERN ABOUT THE CULPRIT,TEACHERS IF YOU ARE BEHAVING LIKE THIS THEN ALL GOOD TACHERS ALSO GET BAD IMAGE ,SO PLEASE STOP GIVE FUNISHMENT TO CHILDREN,CHILDREN PARENTS ARE ALIVE TO TAKE CARE OF THERE CHILDREN LETS PARENTS TAKE DESITION ABOUT THERE CHILDREN YOU DONT HAVE ANY REIGHT TO FUNISH THE CHILDREN LIKE THIS, IF THE TEACHERS ARE DOING LIKE THIS HOW YOU WILL TEACH THE STUDENTS TO BE A GOOD STUDENT?

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Thomas Pascal Andrade, Toronto / Valencia

Punishing students is one of the worst crimes done by teachers against their young students. I just wonder if they would punish their own children as they do against students. Nobody complains against those teachers who terrorize the students unless there is serious injury or death. I still remember the severe beatings I got on my both palms by my high-school priest-headmaster when I was in 6th grade for being absent, and I have still not forgiven him. Nor can I forget my 4th Grade teacher who skinned out my thighs for not being able to say poetry by heart. I did not complain to my parents about the beatings I got from the teacher as my little mind thought they might think I deserved the beatings for not performing in the class. A colleague of mine tells me how a nun hit her head to the wall when she was not quick enough to answer a question. When my mother went to complain to school head-sister for beating my elder brother by another nun when he was in 1st Grade, the head-sister justified the nun-teacher’s action and sent my mom home with an “advise” to correct my brother. The head-sister did not bother to summon the nun to enquire why she had to beat the boy. This type of atrocities are still going on against students and parents have no guts to complain to the concerned authority against those brutal teachers as complaining could backfire them.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

ALISTER PINTO, kuwait/Agrar

Wat the hell is going on about teachers? He seems to b a KD only as like his name KD Naika, make him run on the same ground untill he dies. Why these teachers are still in schools? After watching the movie Tare Zameen par they should know how to handle children still their minds are filled with cowdung.and they blame on students about cowdung. I do still remember one teacher when I was studying 5th in Agrar beaten me up but my dad was strong enough to handle her as he registerd a complaint against her in police station and then onwards no teachers were able to touch me ever .
Still by the cruelty of these teachers lot of poor children suffocating. But that curse will fall upon their own children because God will do it as I have seen many examples or else these teachers will finally be trapped by cancer,heart attack,low n high bp etc etc.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

joviel D'Cruz, Udupi

Irresponsible comments from Lewis, Kallainpur / Kuwait. Don't drag someone unceccesarily and spoil the name at a site like Daiji. Use the sense!

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Vinod John, Mangalore

Mr. Gladson Brahmawar,

"If the teachers are really guilty, punish them so that no one dares to such thing again and if there are lies in the story, bring the true fact and spare the innocent." How will you do the above mentioned thing? And who will do it? The kid is gone right. To Control emotions we need to be like machines. Why should any child be asked to run the ground without his wish and will? It's not the first time its happening in India. A lesson should be taught to the teachers as well so that no teacher dares to repeat it.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Jessy, Auh

Whatever the cause of death, the teachers have no right to touch the child. If there is any problem with the child the parents should be contacted. It is the parents who should deal with the child not these teachers. Children please report to your parents if a teacher is illtreating you. It's the parents who give birth, take care of their kids. Teachers are just to do their job, if they cannot better take early pensions. Every teacher after the age of 35 should undergo medical fitness test.Punish that teacher without showing any mercy, and all those mentally sick teachers.May the soul of Afzal rest in peace.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Vinod John, Mangalore

Was shocked reading this news, but not surprised. I think its time we teach the kids to slap the teachers back if they punish them. Teachers duty is just to teach. It ends there. They don't dare to harm the child. I remeber there was this PT sir I think Alwyn in Cascia high school Jeppu who used to hit kids like donkeys. It's best parents talk to the kids and know exactly what goes on in school.. Kids will be so scared..

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

RAJESH KALNAD, MUMBAI

Yes, if The Teacher can survive 5 rounds the beatings no water till 5 rounds are completed., then he is free.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Frederick Pinto, Shirva

What is happening in Indian school? When will this nonsense stop in our country? What are the teachers there for to kill or teach? The government should end this once and for all and come up with some solution. The school should ensure that the teacher is this case pays a huge compensation.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Dominic, Mangalore

@VishalIf the boy was a Hindu, then all your barking would be from the opposite direction and your comments would have been totally different..Grow up..Your name is Vishal ,but your heart is not..

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

S. Ashrafullah, Bengaluru

May Allah grant the young boy a place in Heaven and give his parents the courage and strength to bear the untimely loss of their young son. Ameen. Every community respects teachers and have high esteem for them, as they are regarded next our parents. However, we must recognize that there is always a possibility of bad apple(s) in the basket. As responsible parents, we must identify such bad apple and take necessary measures to report on a timely basis to the appropriate authorities to check and remove it from the basket. School Administration must analyze and scrutinize the complaints against teachers in an extremely serious note and fairly condudct internal investigation to ascertain the merits of the complaint and take appropriate corrective action. School Administration must implement policy prohibiting any punishment which is even appear to hurt the children and lay out a detailed procedure as to what a teacher/parent should follow if they have a grievance against a student or a teacher. I hope the teacher who gave the boy such an irresponsible and inhuman punishment realizes that what if his son is given similar punishment by his teacher? Those teachers who are harsh, should realize what if they are at the receiving end?. Mob is a mob, always, irrational and insensible. What did they get by destroying the school property? Their anger did not help the diseased boy, his parents nor the school.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Lewis, Kallainpur / Kuwait

By reading this instance ...i remember Madava Master in Milagres School, Kallainpur...he was horrible!!! Thank God you saved us....

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

neelu, mangalore

strict action should be taken for that teacher...

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

jossy dsouza, mangalore

Beating a child in school is damn wrong,I Hope school teachers learn to control their anger and frustration.there are schools which follow same method of punishments.I have witnessed in 2 schools in Mangalore since 2 years.Some teachers have disgusting attitude!when i was in 9 the standard i was beaten by a cane for 15 minutes and piece of cane had got stuck in my flesh, I cried with agony, yet i was beaten more. What was the explanation? I could not do maths ! and teacher had blood pressure problems! I guess there should be law protecting the children who are so precious and delicate.

My prayers are with the boys family, May God give them peace and strength to bear the precious loss of life which will never return ! I hope these teachers get severe punishment and hence let others learn from their mistakes.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Jaimini P.B., Manipal,

Doctor's report may tell boy died due to heart problem or something else.Whether he died due to heart,kidney or whatever problem..School teachers are indirectly responsible for boy's death.My school days was a horror.We were not allowed to play even in PT period because HEAD MISTRESS(Brahmavar)wanted us to get 100% .Only read read ..read..Actually management didn't understand that we were reading without sense and I got 75%(90% student) in 7th std but my/our General knowledge was 0%

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Nurya, Kundapur/Israel

It is better to wait and find the true facts. Barking to the shadow is not good!!

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Naziya,UAE, Mangalore

Mr.Gladson ,Bhrahmavar
U might be right to some extent.But u see this boy was yet to recover.It is out of fear he came to school coz they punish them evn for the absent case without knowing the cause.
He was asked to take 5 rounds,he succeeded upto 3 rounds n later he came to his PT teacher where he said Im feeling very thirsty plz gimme some water.But the teacher hit him n warned him to take rounds.n this was the time where he collapsed-As per his classmates report.
Ask any physician HOW WEAK WILL BE HUMAN BODY DURING FEVER.
THIS IS JSUT A PLAIN MURDER DONE BY A SCHOOL STAFF.N COMPENSATION SHOULD BE THAT HE TOO SHOULD b FORCED TO TAKE ROUNDS UNTIL N UNLESS HE DIES.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Ayman Farhan, Mangalore / Al Ain

"Verily we belong to God, and to him shall we return." The matter is not whether the boy died because of the punishment or not but is it the correct way to punish any student in this manner, this act is totally unjustified. May the creator's blessing be upon him and may he rest his soul in eternal peace and may he bestow patience upon his parents.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

A.S.Mathew, U.S.A.

So hard and terrible to read such
news. Hearty condolence to the
bereaved family.

Who gave the right to the teachers
to lay their hands on the student?
Also the punishment of forcing the
student to run around the school
two times. People with
certain heart problems can die
in such running experiments.

Some percentage of the teachers
teaching in all grades are not
qualified to be teachers. They may
have the academic requirements
established by the State or the
Department of Education. Teachers
job is more of a divine side, and
the teachers must have an inborn
nature and calling to be fruitful
teachers.

In the 7th grade, I was afraid
of going to school because of
the two monster teachers (John sir and Vasupillai sir). Both
of them were evil looking, and simply spanked the students and
the students were crying as if
marching in the funeral procession
every day. How the student can
learn anything in fear and while
wiping tears?
After reading several books in
psychology and mental disorders,
now I strongly feel that both of them had some
mental disorders, also anger
problem. How mentally
sick teachers with high temper can be model teachers?

Those teachers caused the death of
the student are criminals: they
need deserve any sympathy, and be treated like street criminals.
They must feel the pain of beating in the jail life, or the experience
of an early death.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

MakMon, Manglalore

First Of All May Almighty Rest The Departed Soul Of the Innocent student Master Afzal Hamza Saab, Rest In Peace & Give Strength/Courage to his Parents, to face this injustice done to their loving child. The so called Teachers fit to be called as Cheaters? Is it a school or Central jail? Shame on you to this inhuman cruel creatures(teachers or cheaters & the management committee also) of the so called New English School/Huchchara Koota.
This is nothing but a murder of a innocent student/child in a different way by the so called mad authorities of the school. There seem to be some hidden agenda? behind this heinous crime committed by the so called Huchara Kootada Shaley?(school). Are they
fanatics or lunatics? Still these sort of uncultural words are not sufficient to be expressed on these mad monsters(manava roopada
rakshasaru). Let The concerned Legal Authorities give justice to the deceased child and their parents by punishing them without any prejudice or bias., so that these sort of inhuman act should not be repeated in future. Let the shameless draculas think, if the same fate had happened to their children? May Almighty save all the children from these sort of butchers?...Once Again With A Minutes Silent Prayer To Departed Innocent Soul.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Vishal, Mangalore/Bangalore

The fact is still not clear. Emotional comments without verifying the facts is unfair. The face of the deceased child has blood. Are the teachers butchers to punish like that? Certainly, there is something more to this which might unfold shortly. Let us wait and watch.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Ashraf, Udyavar/Udupi/Dubai

Dear Gladson, he died because of punishment, teachers have no rights to punish like this, this is totally un-acceptable.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Durgadas Suvarna, MLORE/BLORE

VERY SAD INCIDENT. A STRICT ACTION SHOULD BE TAKEN ON THAT TEACHER.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

basheer, mlore

she is trained from police department not from teachers training

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

najeeb moosa, doha - qatar

Very sad ! teachers must get some sort of training how to treat with the student beforre their assingnment, giving a punishment does not work at all.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Vijay D'Souza, Pernal/ Doha-Qatar

Well said I D'Souza,M'lore/Kuwait. It's true.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

shameem, someshwar

very sad news,i can remember one of my kannada teacher(praksh pandith, anandashrama highschool)beating students without reason,some of his questions are nonsence.he was asking who is woman,if answer mother he is beating and say no, if answered different answers he cant agree,he wants reason for beating, finaly he gives his own meaningless answer to it.i always pray with god to save our student brothers from this type of (pshyc) teachers

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Clara Lewis, Kemmannu/Dubai

Very sad news, very difficult to forget this incident, the memory of student Afzal Hamza will remain longest time in our mind, young boy lost his life for pity reason, may his soul rest in peace

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Gladson , Brahmavar

I still believe that one needs to exercise constraint both on tongue and hands when these kinds of incidents take place. With due respect to the deceased student and his beloved parents' feelings, I believe the concerned persons who ransacked the school should wait for the post-mortem report. Could this news be completely true? Unless this boy was sick previously or had certain ailments, I would not buy the argument that he died only due to the punishment meted out to him by teachers. Teachers might have been brutal and out of the way. But could they be the killers and could the punishment be the only cause for death? We are going through an era, wherein forget about corporal punishment, even a scolding by the teacher is reported home and the parents are ready with accusations next day at the school. If the student had explained properly the reason behind his leave or if one of the parents had accompanied the student to the school after his two-day leave, a lot things could have been clearer. It's quite easy to jump to conclusions in these kind of incidents since they are quite emotional and the concerned persons can encash bigtime since two communities are involved. But what about the ransacking which has troubled perhaps scores of other students? If the teachers are really guilty, punish them so that no one dares to such thing again and if there are lies in the story, bring the true fact and spare the innocent. If justice has to prevail, emotions need to be controlled.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Kishor, Dubai

Very sad Indeed. Feel very sorry for the parents. Some of the teachers are very cruel. I can remmember my school days how they treated me in High School one of my Science Teacher. That scene is still live in my mind!!

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Jaimini P.B., Manipal,Sharjah

Teachers Terrorism !Head Master,teachers should be punished and jailed.Not only parents of victim,but also public should protest till killers get jail punishment.In India ,it is a common practice that children loosing their eyes or body injuries bcause of teachers terrorism !

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Karan, Mumbai

Much is said about the nobility of the teaching profession. Incidents like this give the profession a bad name.As part of their service contracts, teachers must give an undertaking to abstain from corporal punishment, under pain of disciplinary proceedings for any display of child abuse.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

I Douza, M'lore /Kuwait

Teachers were fight at home with wives & husbands & that angry they are showing on school childrens. Even now a days after 35 yrs most of them are Blood Pressure & Daibetic patients. So those who are Bp please terminate from their post. Otherwise these type of cruel action will not stop.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Santhosh Bhandary, Mangalore/Dubai

This is very very serious and also the height of madness and irresponsibility. There cannot be any justification for this heinous crime. All the involved should be severely punished without any mercy. An innocent boy has lost his life and the unlucky parents have lost their son for no fault of theirs. Also the punishment should deter any future offenders all over India. Please note this is not an accidental killing but a deliberate action on part of all concerned.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Ozy, Mumbai

This is the third time I repeat, parents please kill the teacher. Only then these fanatic teachers will learn the lesson.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Anita , Mangalore

In so many schools these incidents take place despite the teachers being told strictly not to harm or harass children physically. Beating children is forbidden. I have recently heard of a similar incident, one of our staff's daughter aged 10 years studying in a school at Kuppepadau in Mangalore was beaten up by her class teacher till the blood came oozing out from her skin for remaining absent from school.

There were contusions on her body i heard. Very very shameful to treat the innocent children and beat them up ruthlessly for just being absent from school. I had advised our staff to lodge a police complaint against the teacher and she should never dare to repeat such things in her life. I am told when our staff went to school the teacher started crying, begging and pleading him not to file a police complaint against her and being a soft hearted person he let go and sorted out the matter amicably.

Extremely shocking how can the children be beaten up this way? We send our children to school to educate them and not to be treated as animals. The matter should be taken up seriously and all the teachers who are involved in the heinous act should be punished severly.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

GK, Mangalore

Ransacking the school !! Dont they realize by doing this they are playing around with the education life of other students who still go to that school !!

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Clifford, Mangalore

Disgracefull. Feel sorry for the parents

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Jovit, Janthra/Dubai

How could the teachers be so cruel?? The boy could have been ill because of which he was unable to attend class!!!! And, do the authorities think paying money will bring the boy back??? I think what's befitting is to make the teachers run around the grounds as punishment!!

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Fredrick Correa, Nairobi, Kenya

When will the teachers learn from their mistakes. During our schooldays, there were many children who were ping out of school due to the fear of getting beaten up by the teachers for not doing the home work, not bringing books, rulers etc. It was a routine procedure and most of the classrooms had sticks and beating was a regular feature. At least now it is banned and the teachers should learn how to teach the children within the framework of the law.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Pramod Suvarna, mangalore

Very sad news .May his soul rest in peace.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse