Sabarimala : Laxity may have Caused Stampede


Saarimala: Laxity may have Caused Stampede

Kottayam, Jan 16 (DHNS): Official apathy rather than a collision between a jeep and an autorickshaw may have caused the Sabarimala Pulmedu stampede that killed 102 pilgrims on Friday.As officials raced to lay the blame on the ''collision theory'', one of them claimed about 80 people were incredibly crushed underneath the jeep and the auto when they overturned.

But at the scene of the stampede, there are three versions doing the rounds on what could have happened to spark the tragedy. The truth may perhaps never be known though the Kerala government has ordered a judicial probe into the incident.
According to the Idukki district collector’s version submitted as a report to the government, there was a “mass descent of pilgrims” after witnessing the celestial “Makara Vilakku” (the light that appears every year on the hill adjoining the shrine as though to mark the “Makara Sankranti” or the summer solstice).

The impact of the “army of pilgrims” advancing through the narrow path caused a jeep on the way to move and hit an adjacent autorickshaw. Later, both vehicles overturned above the pilgrims. Some pilgrims were crushed underneath and, as an effort was made to pull up the vehicle, more pilgrims were hit and a stampede followed.

Another claim, this time from the forest department, said there was an altercation between the drivers of the overcrowded jeep and the autorickshaw that ultimately led to the tragedy. The jeep had hit some pilgrims who in turn smashed the glasses of the two vehicles leading to clashes and the resultant stampede.

A third version, from the locals, is that the forest officials had failed to remove a long chain on the pathway to stop vehicles from crossing over. Pilgrims, descending from the hill, did not see it in the darkness and tripped, triggering a stampede.
The vehicles were parked in a mindless manner because only a handful of policemen were on duty to control the crowd.

But what is more than evident is that the tragedy was caused by overcrowding at Pulmedu on Friday evening. Reports say that three lakh people had converged on the place to view the “Makara Vilakku” because of the place’s vantage position. This number was about 1.5 lakhs last year and the authorities had failed to take note of the increase in the number of pilgrims. Though the Pulmedu route is being used by pilgrims for ages, the area has never been sufficiently covered by security and crowd management plans by the authorities.

On days when there is heavy rush, the entire focus of the authorities, including the police and the National Disaster Response Force, tended to shift to  the Sannidhanam-Pampa route used by over 90 per cent of the pilgrims.

Forest authorities  are believed to have brought these lapses to the notice of higher-ups at review meetings attended by senior police and government officials and even ministers.

It has frequently been brought to the notice of the police that vehicles should not be allowed to enter the area, a reserve forest region.Allowing vehicles into this area is illegal not only during the pilgrim season but also any time of the year as it poses a threat to the fragile ecosystem of the area, sources said, according to an agency report.
On Friday when tragedy struck, only a few members of the Forest Protection Council and about 30 policemen from the local police station were present to cope with the situation.
Of the 102 dead pilgrims, 33 were from Karnataka, 31 from Tamil Nadu, five from Kerala, 20 from Andhra Pradesh, two from Puducherry and one from Sri Lanka. Eight bodies were yet to be identified.

The bodies of the victims were taken in ambulances to their native places accompanied by revenue officials. The state government would meet the flight and road transport expenses for ferrying the bodies of victims to their home towns.

Reports say a dozen pilgrims are missing and policemen and volunteers have been combing the forests for possible survivors. Doctors say the victims succumbed to suffocation, heavy blows and blood-clotting.

Chief Minister V S Achuthanandan, who reached  the spot by helicopter to take stock of the situation with his cabinet colleagues, announced a judicial inquiry by a sitting judge of the Kerala High Court and a relief of Rs 5 lakh each to the next of kin of the victims. The seriously injured would be given Rs 50,000 and those with minor injuries Rs 25,000 each.

The Kerala government had declared a public holiday on Saturday to grieve the loss of human lives. Official mourning has also been declared for three days.

Last Holy Visit for this Muslim Devotee


Karwar: When Mehboobsaab Maddi told his Muslim friends that this would probably be his last pilgrimage to Sabarimala, little did he or his friends know that Maddi’s fate was already sealed.

The 22-year-old devout Muslim from Konewada, who had been going to Sabarimala every year for the past five years, was killed in Friday’s stampede while returning to a parking place after witnessing the Makara Jyoti.

Maddi is survived by his parents and two brothers. He was part of the 20-member pilgrim group from Konewada. Some of the other pilgrims in the group sustained minor injuries and are expected to return to Karwar within two days.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Shiv, NA

    Mon, Jan 17 2011

    Vincy - NDTV article does not conclude that Makarajyothi is hoax. Please do not publish anything without understanding it correctly.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • suresh, Mumbai

    Mon, Jan 17 2011

    Vincy, shamboor/Bangkok.
    "makar jyoti & Makara villaku are 2 different things and there is confusion.
    One :Makara jyothi is a star which disappears once the divine ornaments are brought in to the sanctum sanctorum and are placed on lord. This is not man made.

    Two: Makara- vilaku is a man made ritual performed on Makarsankranti 14 jan every year

    This ritual is often mistakenly referred to makarajyoti (star).

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • M Sunil, Bangalore

    Mon, Jan 17 2011

    Very sad. Govt. is only bothered in rooking in the moolah and least bothered about provding facilities to the devotees.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Valson Mendonsa, Mangalore/USA

    Sun, Jan 16 2011

    It is very sad news, those who lost their life in stampede, which they probably didn't even think about it..
    I was reading the news in Daijiworld.com, here questions arise, how many people concerned about this kind of news? If the news like Communal Clash, Political Clash,VIP Shows,Cricket,Dirty Politics,Religion Issues, then too many people read and putting their comments, but when someone lost the life, just couple of them put their condolence, rest of the world don't even boddered to put their condolence, this indicates that, their no value for Human Life in India.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Shankar P, Kollam

    Sun, Jan 16 2011

    It's true that the light seen in the makarajyothi is the artificial one. All miracles claimed by human beings are created by himself to fill their pockets by fooling others. In this way people spend to die. This will happen again and again until we understand the real truth.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • A.S.Mathew, U.S.A.

    Sun, Jan 16 2011

    Majority of the relgious shrines in
    India with the highest number of
    devotees are time-bombs. It is the duty of the Government of
    Kerala to have emergency management
    teams to handle unexpected
    emergencies like this one.

    The Sabarimala income is a huge
    amount for the Kerala Government:
    and if the money is not properly
    used for making the pilgrimage
    safer for the devotees, it is a
    criminal action. The government
    will donate some money to the dead
    families, then another judicial
    inqiry that chapter is closed
    and the matter is brushed under
    the mat. Again another similar
    episode is repeated, and the same
    formula is applied.

    It seems like the devotees will
    have to fully trust at the
    Sabarimala diety for their
    total protection. Let the
    collection be given to some
    private contractors to build
    hospitlas, new roads, lighting
    system, sanitation department etc,
    in that case, atleast somebody is
    responsible and answerable before
    the court if law for negligence
    and deliberate delinquency.

    How human lives are sacrificed
    due to our negligence? We need not
    have to blindly blame the "fate"
    or "divine time factor" for such
    tagedies of life, but only on
    our recklessness and total
    irresponsibility.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Felix F.,, India/Ksa

    Sun, Jan 16 2011

    Few years back, several people lost their lives in Saudi Arabia, during Haj, on account of Stampede.

    But the Govt of Saudi Arabia, learnt the lessons, and took effective steps, and prevented any such unfortunate things happening in the future.

    In India, in the recent past, many people have lost their lives due to stampede in various places. But the Govt nor the concerned people does not seem to care, apart from appointing judicial inquiries, and offering compensation.

    I think it should be the responsibility of the people who wish participate in huge gatherings, its safety aspect, unless the participation to them, is more important than their lives

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Yashwanth, Mangalore / Oman

    Sun, Jan 16 2011

    The first rascal of this earth was the first priest who preached the first fool.
    Now the world is suffering because of the first rascal and the first fool.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • VINCY, SHAMBOOR/BANGKOK

    Sat, Jan 15 2011

    This is unfortunate for many brothers who died and big loss for thier families. At the same time it is shocking to read a article ..Makarajyoti is the biggest ritualistic fraud in the country which has disastrous social and ecological impact," Dr PM Rajan Gurukkal, director of the School of Social Sciences...
    please visit this site and read.
    http://www.ndtv.com/convergence/ndtv/story.aspx?id=NEWEN20070000611
    and also visit
    http://mailerdeamon.blogspot.com/2006/01/makaravilakku.html

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Sabarimala : Laxity may have Caused Stampede



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.