Bantwal: Head constable a victim of land grab, no respite even after 19 years


Shreyas H S 
Daijiworld Media Network - Bantwal
 
Bantwal, Jul 21: Head constable Rukmayya Gowda has spent half his life walking in and out of government offices to protect his inherited 1.65 acre of land which has been usurped. Yet justice has eluded him and he ends up losing more than half his monthly salary.
 
Gowda, currently working in Uppinangady, has been running from pillar to post to protect his land. The land was sanctioned to his father Thyamappa Gowda, under Rule 7 (1) A of the Mysore Land Grant Rules 1969 in 1972 in Peraje village. The land for which Thyamappa was an unauthorized occupant was sanctioned after regularizing the land.


Rukmayya Gowda

 
Gowda claims that an individual named Venkatramana Bhat, using bureaucratic clout of revenue department, created fraud documents in the name of Parameshwara Naik in 1995 to allegedly grab part of the land (1.65 acre) under survey number 12/2 (3.60 acre), granted to his father by the government.
 
Gowda says Bhat, hand in glove with the then tahsildar, created fake documents to lay claim to his land. A new survey number - 13/2 was created in the year 1995 for the part of 3.60 acre of the land. The then tahsildar allegedly created fake records to claim that the land measuring up to 1.65 acre had been granted to Parameshwar Naik on 9 April, 1980.
 
Since 1995, the case was discussed many times at taluk and district levels and in the High Court, but to no avail. The head constable was also reportedly cornered by the police department for his legal fight against the officials of the Bantwal revenue department. According to Gowda, he also wrote a letter to the United Nations High Commission for Human Rights, in relation to the gross violation of human rights which has caused him to run from pillar to post to get justice, but in vain.
 
However, the then assistant commissioner of Mangalore had ordered cancellation of the document pertaining to survey number 13/2. The assistant commissioner, in the order dated 12-3-2000, ordered de-listing of the land sanctioned to Parameshwar Naik. But the tahsildar at that time failed to comply with the order. The information gathered through RTI on the action taken following the order also suggests that the tahsildar has not acted on the orders of the assistant commissioner.
 
Gowda filed a writ petition in the High Court. During the hearing, the authority concerned deposed before the court and said he would take swift action to cancel the land documents granted to Parameshwar Naik. But nothing of the sort happened.  

Failing to get back the land after tedious efforts, Gowda wrote a letter to the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights(UNHCHR). The UNHCHR instructed the commission functioning from Karnakata to take measures to protect Gowda’s interests. However, on learning of theland dispute, the commission told the concerned authorities to deal with the issue and provide justice to Gowda.
 
"Till today, Bantwal revenue department has not complied with the orders passed on several occasions,” lamented Gowda. He said that he has lost faith in the law of the land. He also claimed that there could be at least 15 more victims who have fallen prey to Bhat and lost their land.
 
Bhat, when contacted, said Gowda is making false claims that he had got a favourable verdict in court. The latter, when asked about the assistant commissioner’s order, contended that the case was tried in the court. He was unable to answer to the statements by the court which said the tashildar will reverse the RTC.
  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • 1smail shaffi, peruvai

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    it is the failure of indian leagal system

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Lawreence, Mumbai

    Wed, Jul 23 2014

    There are many cases like the above case in Karnataka. My mother, a widow aged 92 is a victim of such a case.My mother applied for regularization of land she was cultivating and got the Order from the Land Tribunal in 1981.One lawyer claimed her entire property by filling a Writ petition in High Court in 1993 after a lapse of 13 years. The division bench of the high court passed an order directing the land tribunal to check whether opportunity was given to the party or not and reverted the matter to the tribunal.The tribunal did not follow the direction of the high court and divided the property between the two. My mother moved the high court again and the matter was reverted again back to tribunal directing the tribunal to follow the direction of the high court. The matter is going on 21 years with no end in sight. What is worse, the tribunal decided the matter without conducting the cross examination of the complainant for extraneous reasons. My mother 92 years old, is worrying me by asking when she will get her land back.Filing false case is another way of acquiring someones land using influence.

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Chandrashekhara D, Bangalore

    Tue, Jul 22 2014

    Mr. Rukmayya Gowda’s father got this land in 1972 in Peraje village.Then why Mr. Venkatramana Bhat and Mr. Parameshwar Naik creating problem with fraud document . Here government comes to his rescue with proper law .Other wise it will creating problem in the society . So here revenue department will take quick decision and save the innocent people . Here society should fight against the fraud people . So Mr. Gowda don’t worry we will fight against fraud .

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Eric Coelho, Mangalore

    Tue, Jul 22 2014

    In Vidhana Soudha in English it is written on top of front entrance "Govt's work is god's Work". I dispute this sentence which should read as "Govt's work is devil's Work". Since the end of Lal Bahadur Shastri's era I have seen, heard and read only about scams and nothing but scams coming from State and Central Governments. There is no meaning to the highest law of the land verdict. There is a total collapse of the system in this country. Time the corrupted people are crushed and destroyed forever.

    DisAgree Agree [6] Reply Report Abuse

  • Ash, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 21 2014

    Most of the fraud are committed by Govt officials, religious heads and influential’s people. Common man is just made to run around and suffer under law.

    We are facing problem done by Registrar, Tahsildar & Taluk officials who had registered a false sales deed of our land (ancestral Property) in favour of another unknown party and the case is dragging in courts from many years.


    we need to have all Govt departments, Courts computerised and online. All form submission, tracking of progress of work and case matters must also be made available over internet with online access. So we will have an option of going personally to Govt office and get the work done or do it over internet or get assistance of an agent. This way direct contact with Govt officers is broken and all application submitted must be logged with track\ticket no which needs to have a time frame of closing application\case with s sent through emails or SMS.

    All cases in lower to supreme court needs to be upto date online. By this we keep a track of all proceeding and not waste our precious time waiting to get s from lawyer or court admin or standing in line at Govt departments waiting to meet officers just to get bribes payed.


    I am sure if people are smart enough to use SMART PHONES, they will be happy to get the work done online and paperless.

    One more important thing is to have Unique Identity card\no for each individual. Having this card does not mean that the person is a citizen of this country or can avail any govt facilities.

    Contd in 2...

    DisAgree Agree [9] Reply Report Abuse

  • Ash, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 21 2014

    Cont 2...

    I am sure if people are smart enough to use SMART PHONES, they will be happy to get the work done online and paperless.

    One more important thing is to have Unique Identity card\no for each individual. Having this card does not mean that the person is a citizen of this country or can avail any govt facilities. This card is only to identify a person and also it is easy to keep a track of any fraud committed. Even if the person is not a citizen of this country and staying here for long period, we can have information of the person with help of this card and his whereabouts. This card can be then linked with Banks, Govt related work, licensing, banning, blacklisting, transactions etc.

    we live in a country with many languages, different cultures. Today I am living in Mangalore tomorrow I may have to move to some other state out of Karnataka due to work or for personal reasons. I may not be fluent in all languages. So my request is to have a document divide into 2 columns with regional language written on one side and English on other side like documents done in Arab Gulf nations. So we don't have to dependent on others and reduce fraud to a large extent.

    Always try to get a people and environment friendly better solution.

    DisAgree Agree [11] Reply Report Abuse

  • joe Gonsalves, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 21 2014

    Here is a case of a helpless constable losing what is due to him.

    Hope The government comes to his rescue and he gets the land rightly due to him.

    Joe Gonsalves

    DisAgree [1] Agree [13] Reply Report Abuse

  • SAMANYA JANA, mangalore

    Mon, Jul 21 2014

    As reported here, if a serving police constable "has lost faith in law of the land", then his post of the constable is also under the law of the land.
    why not try some other method with this Bhat and Naik so that sri Gowda can serve this police department with all due respect to the law of the land.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [12] Reply Report Abuse

  • ISMAIL.K.PERINJE, PERINJE

    Mon, Jul 21 2014

    VAs/Manekars/Surveyors and finally ambitious Taluk Tahsildars joins with others,then can sell Karnataka Land to Andhra Pradesh(like Reddys converted Karnataka land to AP(the case still with court)If any body want t get on hand experience just visit Taluk and Manekar(revenue office)Poor HC tried his half of the age with half of the every monthly wage spent on for his genuine demand of reinstatement of his land but all are in vain till now!WHY HE DID NOT APPROACH KARNATAKA LOKAYUKTA?

    DisAgree Agree [34] Reply Report Abuse

  • GK VENUGOPAL, BANGALORE

    Wed, Jul 23 2014

    It is very pathetic to see Mr.Rukmmaiya gowda is fighting a much needed battle against corrupt officials. Now a days it has become easy for the fraudsters, with the assistance of corrupt officials to grab the land illegally. If a POLICE is loitering pillar to post for justice, I wonder what about the condition of COMMON MAN. Lokayuktha officials please help the policeman

    DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Bantwal: Head constable a victim of land grab, no respite even after 19 years



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.