Udupi: 'UPCL expansion a threat to Western Ghats': Environment activist writes to UNESCO


Daijiworld Media Network - Udupi

Udupi, Jul 4: Balakrishna Shetty from Yellur, who runs a trading business in traffic safety systems in Dubai, has written to the UNESCO, France expressing grave concerns over the damage to Western Ghats, a World Heritage Site, that is likely to be caused by the expansion of Udupi Power Corporation Limited (UPCL) power plant.

In a letter addressed to the secretariat of World Heritage Committee of UNESCO, Balakrishna Shetty, who has been actively participating in environment protection activities in his hometown, has pointed out that the 'coal-based thermal power plant by Udupi Power Corporation Ltd in our village of Yellur of Udupi district in the west coast of India, is posing serious threat not only to the local environment but to the Western Ghats as well.

"It has already commissioned 2 units each of 600 MW (1200 MW) and now planning expansion with 2 more units of 800 MW each, that is, with 1,600 MW to make the ultimate capacity to 2800 MW in a sensitive location close to the Western Ghats and that too by using sea water without desalination."

Shetty also recalled UNESCO's description of the Western Ghats when granting it the World Heritage status, wherein UNESCO had noted that the Western Ghats, older than the Himalayas, was of 'immense importance with unique biophysical and ecological processes', whose 'high montane forest ecosystems influence the Indian monsoon weather pattern'. The UNESCO had also pointed out that the site presented 'one of the best examples of the monsoon system on the planet' with 'an exceptionally high level of biological diversity and endemism'. "The forests of the site include some of the best representatives of non­equatorial tropical evergreen forests anywhere and are home to at least 325 globally threatened flora, fauna, bird, amphibian, reptile and fish species," the UNESCO had said, adding that of the total 325 globally threatened species in the Western Ghats, 129 are classified as vulnerable, 145 as endangered and 51 as critically endangered.

Shetty further stated, "There are some 37 court cases pending, some of them since 2005, against the project at various including those based on the grounds of environmental sustainability. Ownership of the plant has changed hands quite often. However, the present owners of the project being highly influential are planning the expansion that would destroy not only the coast but impair the unique biodiversity of Western Ghats. It would appear that with its money and man power the ignorant farmers are either tempted with cash or forced to surrender their lands.

"As per various expert studies including by NEERI, environmental degradation locally would impair theWestern Ghats as well due to various features of the region. Surprisingly the power is not required for the coastal belt but is transmitted to Bengaluru and other cities on the leeward side of the Ghats. The transmission lines were taken through the RF of the Western Ghats after felling over 30,000 trees in the villages and RF (reserve forest). The expansion will require more forest land for transmission also apart from the environmental impact from plant emissions.

"Despite best efforts by groups of people, a number of expert studies including by the top institutions of the country ­ NEERI, IISC and others, a number of representations to the ministry of environment and forest and various other authorities and filing court cases, the expansion also is likely to go through, and that would be an environmental catastrophe," the letter stated.

Shetty also raised concerns over the controversial Yettinahole project that has been vociferously opposed by environmentalists in the region.

"Unfortunately, that is not all, about 35 km towards the south from the power plant, a river called Netravati that flows down the Western Ghats to the Arabian Sea is being diverted by building a dam and in addition to huge earth movement vast forest is destroyed for the purpose. If immediate action is not taken the corrupt intentions would win and the unique biodiversity of the Western Ghats and the people in general lose," he stated.

Urging UNESCO to intervene in the above matters, Shetty stated, "I would therefore request you to use your good office and direct the government of India not only to refrain from expanding the power plant but to shift the existing to the leeward side of the Western Ghats where the power is required and rehabilitate the damages caused to the World Heritage site. The local energy requirement being small can be met by putting up district­wise, taluk­wise or even village­wise solar plants."

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Mrs Geeta Pinto, Mangalore

    Tue, Jul 05 2016

    The best / safest and cleanest is nuclear energy. The initial project cost may be very high but its worth it in the long run. I think it may need less land than a coal based thermal plant.

    I have a solar power panel on top of my roof. But i do not get hot water during cloudy weather and monsoon season. How is that ? In the summer months i don't need hot water. I am back to my electric geyser during the monsoon season.

    Is Mr.Balakrishna Shetty going to lose any land in that area due to the expansion ?

    DisAgree [1] Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • T.Hegde, Manipal

    Tue, Jul 05 2016

    Natural gas pipeline will be laid from Ratnagiri to Mangalore via Udupi.Contract has been already awarded to M/S Hiranandani Group. It will be reality within three years. Including Adani's there will be many more gas industries in coastal Karnataka which will be less harmful to the environment

    DisAgree [2] Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Aloy, Udupi

    Tue, Jul 05 2016

    Dear readers, this project belongs to non other than M/S.Adani Group. Expansion will take place because of money power. The high tension Wires are crossing in front of my house and the required land was taken al most by force to erect the pillars. We can feel the sound coming from the wires during the transmission of electricity ,also there is a tremendous effect we can feel during the lighting & thundering at our homes.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [9] Reply Report Abuse

  • abdulla, india

    Tue, Jul 05 2016

    Nuclear power is the best remedy..

    DisAgree [2] Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Sunil D'Souza , Mangalore / Mumbai

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    To all the intellectuals commenting on this article remember the following :

    1) 80 % of the power you consume comes from coal fired power stations run somewhere else at the cost of environment sacrificed at some other place of some other people.

    2) Cost of coal fired power is very low (approximately Rs. 2 to 3.5 per unit)

    3) Cost of solar electricity is in the range of Rs. 7 to 11 per unit and is available only in the day time. Can we afford to pay that price.

    4) All of us enjoy cheap coal power but do not want pollution at our door step instead want the pollution to be on somebody's door step (so selfish is'nt it)

    5) Both wind and solar power are not steady power sources and vary depending on the time of the day and year. For a large population as India solar, wind and hydro alone put together will not solve our problem with the current technology at least.

    6) Hydro electric power stations are the best options we have but will not suffice to serve the huge population that we have managed to produce.

    I am not supporting UPCL or coal fired power plants but I want you to bear in mind the above points before you comment. Most of the people who have commented here I am sure have no knowledge on where the power comes from or how it is generated. They blindly enjoy the benefits.

    DisAgree [20] Agree [12] Reply Report Abuse

  • Balakrishna Shetty, Yellur/Dubai

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Sunil, you are right to some extent but not completely. Solar can be stored now for night supply with new tech and cost is down to Rs.4/unit. A fews jobs are already awarded in India after bidding. Some EU nations already said good-bye to dirty coal energy. Netherlands does not issue completion certificates to buildings without enough solar panels.Gulf countries are into solar in a big way-the parks and other public places are lit with solar power and are now into export and undertaking contracts in other countries. If cloudy countries with hardly any sunshine and oil rich gulf countries can excel in solar power why not India? Karnataka is assessed one of the best for solar generation in Asia yet we are behind all the rest. Coming to coal true the cost should be 2 to 2.50. UPCL signed agreement with govt at Rs.2.11/unit but started blackmailing the State by claiming about Rs.6.50/unit. Being helpless govt is paying Rs.4.20/unit and is awaiting SC decision. Project is awarded without inviting tariff based tender in which case price payable has to be cost plus profit margin. So higher the cost larger the profit. Again the Expansion is granted without bidding.

    Important: cost of ecological and health impairment is not added and has to be borne by those who suffer.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [21] Reply Report Abuse

  • Ramakrishna UR, Bangalore/Ulloor

    Tue, Jul 05 2016

    Agree with you. Thermal power plants are outdated technology and only third world countries like India are encouraging it. Look at Raichur Thermal power plant and its damage it has caused to environment over the years. If anybody just walks and comes home, he can see black dirt on his shirt. If companies follow strict environmental procedures and minimal pollution, nobody will question. Look at UPCL, how many have really visited the affected villages nearby to comment. Sitting in cities and commenting is easier. Please go to the village, see the damage it has caused already but not now. Wait for summer so that the signs are easily visible. Let there be an audit on the safety systems employed by the company and let them produce the environmental clearance certificate of non-polluting. Only people who have lived closer and nearby know its true effects. People nearing by MRPL near Surathkal, ask them how they feel early morning when gas is released and how nauseous it is, how bad it smells. Ask the people of Hosabettu nearby how patches of oil shades are found in water wells and how unfit it is to drink. In India, nobody cares about safety and health hazards, that is why India is like this today.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [17] Reply Report Abuse

  • C D Souza , Mannagudda,

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    It is easy to mail letters to concerned highlighting the negatives of expanding UPCL. But before talking about shutting down how many have mailed letters to CM asking why IT companies are not coming to Malore though it is tier II city. Will someone ask this question to politicians. Where should our students who graduate go in search of employment. Why the state govt is not allowing IT companies beyond Bangalore. It is easy to sit far away and give advice and speeches. ground reality is different. Why our children should go out of Molore leaving parents behind and suffer in bigger cities. They work there but salary not enough. Parents have to send from here to help them meet their expenses. So think of representing govt to set up industries and then suggest packing up UPCL

    DisAgree Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • iota, mangalore

    Tue, Jul 05 2016

    simple.. builder lobby has huge investment in unsold apartments of Bangalore.. but i guess at least 5-10 companies should come to Mangalore.. more than that will spoil "namma kudla" culture way it is destroyed in Bangalore

    DisAgree [1] Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • tom Cat, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    The best medicine to stop all these or shut it down is ....
    Do not vote for congress or BJP both are a curse to the nation.

    Vote for a party that listens to common man.

    Unfortunately

    DisAgree [4] Agree [11] Reply Report Abuse

  • Samson Fernandes, udupi

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Very Good Initiative Dear Mr. Balakrishna Shetty. But in front of Money /power and corrupted Politicians all these requests will be ignored.Since Many Years there was a protest and Many People have been enjoyed by the Company's Monetary Support and Local Contractors too .

    DisAgree [1] Agree [13] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr.S.Kamath, Mumbai

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Kudremukh Iron ores company was closed down of its operations because of the damage it could cause to the western Ghats.KIOCL was giving the best quality of Iron ore and lot of our people got jobs .But I agree that it could have caused environmental damage and hence closed down good
    Now UPCL Causing environmental damage good issue raised by Mr Balakrishna Shetty -Dubai.But all these issues can be mitigated through effective counter measures .like power transmission shall be used locally instead of giving out or through underground cables? But closing down UPCL is surely not a solution we need to progress .We need development .All the issues raised shall be discussed and sorted out .

    DisAgree [5] Agree [16] Reply Report Abuse

  • hans, udupi

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Set up the additional units in Mysore or hassan and transmit the power to Bangalore. No coal based power plant will be set up in Mysore or hassan due to stroany political opposition. Only I'm udupi its free for all.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [14] Reply Report Abuse

  • Citizen, India, Kudla

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Development at the cost of Ecology is a disaster.

    DisAgree Agree [12] Reply Report Abuse

  • Ramesh Prabhu., Kateel/Basngalore

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    I admire heartily Sri Balakrishna Shetty's concern for environment and especially for taking up the issue to UNESCO on the grave danger posed for our Tulunadu heritage by UPCL.
    He has been waging war single handedly against this disastrous project of Udupi dist since more than 16 years.Due to the apathy of our corrupt political leader and various vested interests the project is set to expand in mega scale.Though I do not come from this village I has a long association with this tiny Yellur village of Tulunadu and also abode of Lord Yellureshwara an ancient temple of more tha 1200 years and visited and hailed by great yati of Madhwa parampara Sree Sode Vadiraj swamy in 16th century.Temple is important from the point of archaeology too.The present project has already done untold problem to this tiny village of Yellur as well as surrounding other places.People residing nearby are experiencing carbon dust particles in their daily life and many are suffering from ill health due to this.Today many might have been benefited by the project which is only a short term one but disastrous in long term.There is no hope by I complement and appreciate Mr. Shetty's concern.

    DisAgree [3] Agree [21] Reply Report Abuse

  • John Tauro, M'luru / Kwt

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Well done Mr. Balakrishna Shetty! With the commissioning of MRPL people in the surrounding areas already feel the pinch of pollution. Now with expansion of UPCL on one side and diversion of Nethravati River on the other will prove catastrophic to the environment. In the long run this manmade ecological imbalance will lead to pollution of air and water, disappearance of birds in the sky, wildlife in the forests and finally scarcity of water in the region. Both the Western Ghats and Nethravati River are to be conserved at all costs. There’s ample scope to promote tourism on the Ghats by building resorts and by creating sightseeing spots which can generate good revenue to the state. It’s time eco-friendly people to stand against both these hazardous projects.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [12] Reply Report Abuse

  • Richard, Shirva/Sharjah

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    well said Suleman Beary, Udupi...these some people support UPCL not for nations progress but for their personal progress..!!..real blood suckers

    DisAgree [1] Agree [22] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rk, Kinnigoli/Dubai

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Yellur is closer to coastline than western Ghats. Although enhancing the capacity of power plants may cause some environmental impact, crying as if biodiversity of western Ghats will disappear is childish. One need to keep the progress of nation against his/her own priorities.

    DisAgree [31] Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • Raj Rao, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Mr, what progress are you talking about here man? Destroying western ghats means there won't be any future left for our beloved nation.

    Don't you want our children to have a better future? our grandchildren might not even see so many animals or hell even a blue sky.

    We have a huge coastline, why not spend money on wind mills? Solar panels? OR hydro electricity?

    DisAgree [1] Agree [24] Reply Report Abuse

  • Sunil Dsouza, Mangalore / Mumbai

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Raj dear, these coal fired plants fall into base load category and have huge capacity of order 500MW and upwards. The amount of land per MW will be 1 acre per MW.

    Putting those many solar panels in the same area will not produce the same amount of power. Solar plants are usually of much lower capacity and only cater to 20% plant load factor

    DisAgree [1] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • Raj Rao, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Agreed. Instead of over populating bangalore, they should start planning actual smart cities like all houses should have solar panels on the roof, Germany already does this.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [4] Report Abuse

  • Balakrishna Shetty, Yellur/Dubai

    Tue, Jul 05 2016

    Again Sunil, it is important where you put the plant - it should be closer to the load center. 90% is going for Bangalore from UPCL via Hassan grid so the plant should have been at Hassan. They could have put it in Cubbon Park also if they want considering Polluter Pays principle. Whereas solar plants can be village-wise & at every home. About the land for coal based plant actual need is 300m2/mw as in the rest of the world including China & Russia. I have ground plan from British Coal & this is not disputed in the courts. That means here they are taking more than 3 times land in excess. UPCL has lot of lands vacant from previous acquisition. In the new requirement of 800 acres 93% is agricultural as admitted by it also to MoEF. What happens to food security in the country and what happens to clean water in the region that gets highest rain fall next only to Cherapunji? Visit Raichur and see Krishna River which had crocodiles once does not breed fish and the entire fishermen folk is in distress. You want the whole of nation to follow what other countries have been doing centuries ago?

    DisAgree Agree [8] Report Abuse

  • Ramakrishna UR, Ulloor

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    I strongly agree with Balakrishna Shetty. In fact, my native is Ulloor, close to the project. Has anybody visited the area to assess ecological damage caused already? Already coconut, areca nut, and banana plantation are affected with premature falling of coconuts and drying of leaves. Already so many houses in Ulloor have their wells completely destroyed with water unsafe for use. Now, the question is why this project was sanctioned in its first place? Who took huge bribes to get his project cleared? Now, since the project has already been running for quite a few years, if project is being expanded, at least the government compensate the people fair. Why should some middle men get involved as it is happening right now? Supreme court has ordered to pay 4 times government price for land acquisition. Let these people pay 4 times directly to the people affected and let them give employment to each member of the family.

    DisAgree Agree [26] Reply Report Abuse

  • Balakrishna Shetty, Yellur/Dubai

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Thank you Daijiworld for supporting the cause by the coverage. I also thank those who support the cause and for those who do not I can only say that if we look for some short-term benefits, the precious gift from mother earth will be lost for ever. It is said that environment we enjoy is borrowed by us from our grand children. So we are liable to hand it over to them safely when we go Home. So try and protect it

    DisAgree Agree [65] Reply Report Abuse

  • Raja Kolya, Kemundel, Yelluru. Udipi.

    Tue, Jul 05 2016

    I admire heartily Sri Balakrishna Shetty's regarding for the environment and especially for taking up the very very important issue to UNESCO on the grave danger posed for our Tulunadu aswell as our Native place heritage by UPCL.We always with you. Regards Raja Kolya Mutt.

    DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • prem, tallur

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    upcl is gift from modi to adani. adanis ruling now thermal power..they dnt bother about .,,,, clean or green. they just destroy western ghat...y not shift upcl to gujarath home town of adani nd modi..keep clean green 24 hrs electricity...nd water.

    DisAgree [6] Agree [24] Reply Report Abuse

  • Anonymous, Yellur

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    He is unwilling to give up his land in spite of the compensation offered. This letter to the UN is just an eyewash. This man creates hindrance to other people who want to sell their land to UPCL.

    DisAgree [48] Agree [9] Reply Report Abuse

  • hans, udupi

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Ok Mr. Adani why don't you move your power plant to Gujarat and thereby contribute to vibrant Gujarat? Why are you hell bent on turning our fertile motherland into a barren wasteland???

    DisAgree [2] Agree [34] Reply Report Abuse

  • Suleman Beary, Udupi

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    @you...anonymous....
    why you hell bend to expand UPCL and supply power to industries at Bangalore. Go to the barren land nearby Bangalore and open your shop with blood sucking politicians.

    DisAgree Agree [30] Reply Report Abuse

  • Suzie Pinto, Udupi/Mumbai

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Kudos to Mr.Balakrishna Shetty for his contribution towards environment protection ! Where will people dwell when such power plants not only emerge but also want to expand leaving no room for fresh air. Let's not make the Earth a `Gas Chamber'

    DisAgree [2] Agree [34] Reply Report Abuse

  • Vishal, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    I whole heartedly support and appreciate the initiative taken by Mr. Balakrishna Shetty to write to the Unesco about the adverse effects the plant is likely to have on the Western ghats. His efforts are commendable and worthy of emulation. At the same time, I am totally disillusioned by the claim made by Mr. Rajesh Shetty that more trees are now growing in the Western ghats. Nothing can be further from the truth than this misleading and false claim. It is an undisputed fact that the Western ghats are losing trees at an alarming pace and all efforts should be made to restore the ecological balance.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [29] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rebello, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Thermal plants & Nuclear Plants are always a danger to Environment and Human Beings.

    Why cant we produce Green Energy from solar and wind power. Germany is the right example for us to follow. Germany generates excess electricity using only Wind and Solar Power.

    DisAgree Agree [38] Reply Report Abuse

  • Zeitgeist, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Rebello,

    Setting up solar panels to generate electricity needs vast amounts of land. Here the govt has problem even to acquire 100 acres of land. Now how will it acquire 1000s of acres?

    Charanka Solar Park in gujrat occupies 4900 acres of land.

    DisAgree [6] Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rajesh Shetty, Padubidri

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    There is nothing wrong in the expansion. What is Balakrishna Shettys qualifications to call himself an environmentalist ? Our country is going backwards because of people like him. Infact more trees are growing now in the western ghats because of good monsoon. Let B.Shetty drive to Kudremukh hills to see for himself the lush greenery and forests.

    DisAgree [83] Agree [11] Reply Report Abuse

  • Ashok Shetty, shirva

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    I think you also got the Insurance package from Adani group .

    DisAgree [4] Agree [45] Reply Report Abuse

  • iota, mangalore

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    it doesn't need qualification or degree to be environmentalist.. love for mother nature is more than enough. with world moving forward with renewable energy, thermal based power generation takes us back in time to pollute environment.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [61] Reply Report Abuse

  • Richard, Shirva/Sharjah

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    thanks to Balakrishna shetty for the concern, hats off to you

    @ Rajesh Shetty, Padubidri..no need qualification to check/feel the effect of UPCL...being a local i can definitely feel the lot of disadvantages to the environment by UPCL..but greedy locals supported the evil cause!..well equipped, planned project without hindering environment and public in general always acceptable and that UPCL does't help locals to get adequate power! at-least to spend sleepless nights..some people are thinking too much business oriented even at the cost of nature!!...
    compare to earlier days coastal receive not much rainfall..greedy people destroyed environment by cutting trees, supporting anti-nature activities!!
    see the fate of our imcomplete high project coz of peoples business mind..feels bad in Padubidri city..no locals raise voice only support UPCL for what??

    DisAgree [2] Agree [39] Reply Report Abuse

  • hans, udupi

    Mon, Jul 04 2016

    Did you even read a word of the article?

    DisAgree [2] Agree [22] Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Udupi: 'UPCL expansion a threat to Western Ghats': Environment activist writes to UNESCO



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.