Mangalore: PU Students, Parents Storm into Aloysius College Principal’s Chamber


Mangalore: PU Students, Parents Storm into Principal’s Chamber

The Hindu
Pics: Prajwal Ukkuda

Mangalore, Mar 13: A group of students of the St. Aloysius Pre-University College and their parents stormed into the chamber of the principal of the college here on Thursday alleging that he was not issuing hall tickets to students for the second year pre-university examinations, starting on Friday.

The students alleged that the principal was not issuing the hall tickets although they had 75 per cent attendance in all subjects, one of the eligibility criteria fixed by the Department of Pre-University Education to appear for the examinations. Senior police officials stood guard on the college premises from the afternoon till late evening to ensure that the situation would not go out of control.

Allegations denied

However, principal of the college John D’Silva told presspersons that the allegations made by students and parents were false. The hall tickets had been denied to 12 students as they did not meet the prescribed attendance criterion. The hall tickets had been denied to them under sub-section 12 (1) of Karnataka Pre-University Education (Academic, Registration, Administration and Grant-in-aid etc.) Rules, 2006, which referred to “attendance required by the students to appear for the examinations,” he said.

The college had been mailing the monthly performance reports of each student to their parents, regularly. They contained details of subject-wise attendance and marks scored in tests and examinations. In addition, a consolidated report was displayed in the notice board. The college also maintained the reports in the form of a book form, Mr. D’Silva said.

Asked about the allegations that the college had issued hall tickets to some students who did not meet the attendance criterion, the principal said that those who used to participate in sports, NCC, NSS and Scouts and Guides activities, and those who represented the college in inter-collegiate competitions were being granted attendance for the period of their absence for that period, subsequently. Those who had made such allegations might not be aware of this system, he said. He also denied the allegations of beating some students. Jyothi Shetty, a parent, alleged that the principal had made her daughter, a second year Commerce student, to wait in his chamber for hours every day in September last for some mischief she had been accused of. The principal was not showing the attendance register of her daughter, she added. Mr. D’Silva denied these allegations. Srinidhi, national executive committee member of Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishat, told presspersons that the college had denied hall tickets to “30 to 40 students”. The college had not issued notices to students who had shortage of attendance, he added.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • dinesh, saudi arabia

    Sat, Aug 11 2012

    Ok As per rules & regulation this principle is right THE ABILITY OF STUDENT WILL FOUND AFTER THE EXAM SO WHY THIS RULES IT WILL HELPS FOR POOR STUDENT WHO WORKS AND STUDY BOTH BUT THE RICH STUDENT USE FOR RIDE NOT GOOD SOME ARE SAYS GO FOR EVENING COLLEGE PLEASE THINK ABOUT THIS MATTER CHANGE RULE FOR THOSE STUDENT BY PREPARING INTERNAL EXAM IF THEY PASS IN 75% ABOVE PLEASE ISSUE TICKET FOR EXAM IT WILL HELPS FOR GOOD AND BRILLIANT STUDENT

    DisAgree [1] Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • Veronica Rego, Pernal

    Thu, Mar 19 2009

    The title 'Principal' given to Mr. John D'Silva is an ideal one as he is indeed a man of 'Principle'. It's high time for the parents and the students who have not been issued the hall ticket to realise the reason for the same and mend their ways accordingly instead of retaliating and causing chaos and communal harmony which in no way is connected to this incident.

    Let us learn to live with reality and teach our children to be loyal and sincere citizens of our dear country 'India' instead of igniting their innocence and driving them towards atrocity and voilence. Hat's off to Mr. John D'silva upon his adherence to his decision. May God bless and protect you always.

    DisAgree [4] Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • Joe Mascarenhas, Mangalore/Bangalore

    Tue, Mar 17 2009

    As they say, empty vessels make more noise. How appropriate for Mr. Nagesh Nayak. Sticking to the point, I studied in St.Aloysius myself and the same rules applied then too. So its nothing new that students without 75% attendance are denied hall tickets.

    DisAgree [5] Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • Sharon DSilva, Mangalore/ UAE

    Mon, Mar 16 2009

    Abhishek I guess by this time Velyma, you and I have had enough discussions on religious issues. But which message of mine gave you the idea that I am against hindutva or hindus? I undoubtedly hail from a Mangalorean Catholic family but since my childhood I have many hindu friends with whom I have shared meals, visited temples, etc. I am against my community being accused for unwanted reasons and not against Hindutva or Hinduism. Please read my comments carefully and do let me know where have I commented that I am against hindus. I accepted your suggestions whole heartledly about finding out the reasons for my ancestors conversions and I did give you valid reasons why I will do it(please read my earlier comments). Abhsishek bhai why are you deviating from the main topic and again accusing me of doing something which I havent done?

    DisAgree [3] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • Velyma, Mangalore

    Sun, Mar 15 2009

    Abhishek, I have already accepted that my ancestors would have been converted, whatever the reason be,I salute them and respect them for what they have done.If not, I would still have been a part of the narrow minded culture even now, where a woman is supposed to be a slave and a servant of the orthodox society. I salute them for the freedom I enjoy today as a woman, a daughter and as a respectable professional. Its almost 62 years since independence, and what we are today as a nation is because of the struggles our ancestors would have gone through.To answer your question about missionaries, can i give you live examples of my very own Hindu friends who were sent to Manipur, Nepal, North India and the neighbouring countries to propogate Hinduism? You might not agree, but I have a list of them and even now there are people around for the same reasons.If you do not accept conversion, how can you accept mass conversions from Hinduism to Buddhism and Jainism, isn't that conversion? Why do you target Christianity and the missionaries, I would strongly suggest you to get down to the reason for conversion and advise you to first strengthen faith in your religion and stop people getting converted ( which I bet you cant) rather than fight against conversion and in turn provide publicity to the " So CALLED EVANGELISTS" I respect your views and appreciate a constructive dialogue with an open mind.If not this is sheer waste of time. The catholic community is also a victim to the same as I have already mentioned, but who are we to question while the converts do not have a problem?Do you know the famous proverb? Anybody can drag a horse to the pond however its the horse who needs to drink the water. Hope my message has created some sense and raised questions for you to check answers for...I would appreciate further questions and answers to all my previous questions as well.Till then we would continue to pray for you and your well being

    DisAgree [5] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • abhishek, mulky

    Sun, Mar 15 2009

    Hi sharon..being rational,i have only two questions. Who is hindu?? Define hindutva?? Don't go by what few comrades in the so called secular media has to say.You define these two questions correctly.Any good human being who understands hindutva can never oppose it as it says "vasudaiva kutumbakam" & "Ekam satya,viprah bahuda vadanti". Any person of any faith & even if he is a non-believer will agree to this.Then how can you oppose hindutva!!

    DisAgree [2] Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • Velyma, Mangalore

    Sun, Mar 15 2009

    Sharon....Thanks for the support...I have been observing your comments on Daijiworld..Guess its high time now, all of us need to Arise Awake and start reacting in the right way as we are doing...rather than be on mute mode and allow people to criticize, torture and comment on our community.Its exceeded the level of patience and toleration now.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • abhishek, mulky

    Sun, Mar 15 2009

    Hi velyma..thanks for your prayers.I also do pray that good sense prevails over the missionaries & stop these anti-national conversions once for all.FYI..conversion is not by torture & voilence. Its by giving money,distributing freebies,enacting dramas like holy christ cures all ills which cannot be cured by praying hindu deities.( missionaries have many such innovative ideas).Even christ wouldnot have wished that his teachings would be propagated using such dubious means.Exploiting the illiterate tribal people is nothing but a anti-national activity.But missionaries have to rememnber one thing hindu dharma is "avinashi" & india can't be evangelised like africa. For us every person born in india is a hindu,although he may follow any faiths. We do understand that muslims & christians are our own brothers who changed their faith owing to oppression of invaders over 1000-1200 years.Now the question is do you accept this? If yes,then there is never a problem called conversion & if not then thats the begining of all the problem..

    DisAgree [2] Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • Sharon DSilva, Mangalore/UAE

    Sun, Mar 15 2009

    Dear Velyma, I dont think you should apologise as you have tried to open the blind views of a few people who are trying to deviate from the topic. How long are we Catholics expected to listen to unwanted, illogical accusations? We are undoubtedly peace loving people but everything has a saturation point and when people unnecessarily accuse us we have to let them know the reality. It is a sad thing that in spite of so many discussions people like Mr. Abhishek will still continue to bring topics of Hindutva, conversions etc for every article whether it is related to such topics or not. As you said let us all pray for him that at least now he will stop such nasty comments. Hope he reads our comemnts and analyses it so that we catholics next time instead of being accused for 'religious conversion' will be congratulated for having converted or transformed a 'blind viewed' man like our dear friend Mr. Abhishek to somebody who will comment rationally on articles on Daijiworld.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Velyma, Mangalore

    Sun, Mar 15 2009

    To all the readers of this column I apologise to have diverted from the topic, however at this point in time, I felt it was best to advise Mr Abhishek on his comments...Lets all pray that GOOD prevails and JUSTICE is done to St Aloysius College, (My college)Lets also pray for all the unfortunate children and the irresponsible parents. Lets not forget to pray for our good friend,Mr Abhishek too. He's the person who deserves it the most...now

    DisAgree [1] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • Velyma, Mangalore

    Sun, Mar 15 2009

    Mr Abhishek, thanks for your reply. Based on the reply, I have one question for you...How deep rooted is the current faith of the people who are being converted? My ancestors would have been converted since they were unable to bear the torture given by the then ruling people. But as I here from you, that the evangelists are using this opportunity to convert,I am damn sure there is no torture anywhere except from the recent ones that arose from other communities( ashamed to mention the incidents).Whatever the situation be, can you question the people who are being converted and ask them: "How deep rooted they where in their faith, to be converted for earthly things( as per your understanding). And how many such convertees have complained to you about forceful conversions? I am no evangelist or a missionary. I am a lay person and can understand the basic concept of brotherhood.I have many questions to ask to people like you, Last year while the churches where attacked, What would have happened if temples were attacked too. I am sure it would have turned to a hell.I am proud to be a catholic just because we are taught values of life and brotherhood and that's why we are peace lovers. If we were to question your faith and community, we also would have a list of things to point out.Please come out of your shell and think practically.No one is perfect, not you , not me if we were we would have been GOD.We the catholic community also condemn conversions, if you have noticed many of our catholic brothers also have been converted, we should have been more restless compared to you,since we are already a minority . We are not, coz we understand that each person has a right to religion as per the constitution and also think each one is responsible enough to take a decision.I will give a practical solution, if you like it please practise as we do in our church- Pray for the nation and the community, to be more loving and especially pray for the ones who hurt you.Thats the biggest gift you can give to your neighbours and I repeat " LOVE YOUR NEIGHBOURS AS YOURSELF"

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • abhishek, mulky

    Sun, Mar 15 2009

    Hi joe..everything is in context when you consider the bigger picture as per your valuable advice.Stop stop stop conversion..thats the only plea of hindu dharma.Hindus have the same belief in all gods for that matter.Then how can you justify conversion?? Social upliftment can be done without converting & letting people follow their beliefs.Hindus respected all faiths & gave them shelter.Even jews were given shelter here,when they were persecuted all over the world & till today they share a strong bond with india.But in return we have got terrorism,jihad,conversion,crusades,missionaries..do you think its justified??

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sharon DSilva, Mangalore/UAE

    Sun, Mar 15 2009

    Mr. Abhishek, Thank you for your 'valuable comments' regarding christanity and missionaries. My whole point of commenting on your view was simple - "to concentrate on the issue of halltickets, etc and not let hinduism or christanity or amything in the name of religion to creep in." I personally feel that only people who have had the experience of studying in Aloysius should speak (as they will be in a better position to portray the reality, otherwise it will be an issue of pointing fingers for all the wrong cases. Like many other crucial issues the issue of halltickets is sidelined because of people linking it to unnecessary topics. No wonder India is still a 'developing country' since ages and has not even perhaps crawled one step ahead. When will it tread the path of development? Any comments Mr. Abhishek or do i expect another nasty, blindfolded or one sided comment about christianity. My forefathers may have converted for whatever reasons, but the present generation have no regrets that we are Christians as we dont suffer because of caste system, untouchability, etc. Neither do we beat women in public. At least for these good reason as suggested by you I will definetly look into my family history. Thank you.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • abhishek, mulky

    Sun, Mar 15 2009

    Dr Ahmed..good that you have commented about my education.Just let me refresh you that the history of bharat is very rich than what we read in our Macualay inspired education. Macualy had himself told in the british parliament "India can truly be conquered only thru cultural invasion & the easiest way to do it corrupt their education,so they feel everything about bharat is inferior"..now tell me education is not only in schools curriculum but also in our surroundings!! Pls visit hampi,kashi,mathura,ayodhya,temples in kerala,goa,northeast,somnath,capital of chalukyas,hoysalas,temples of pakistan,b'desh etc.Just give a thought what happend there few centuries back?? You wont find that in any Macualyian text book. Finally history is studied so that the bad things should not repeat itself & there should be an awareness..were you aware??

    DisAgree [1] Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • abhishek, mulky

    Sun, Mar 15 2009

    Dear Vyl..Hindu dharma still has its own negatives like untouchability still being practiced.Hindus are fighting against it & shall overcome it.However that doesn't give the missionaries the licence to convert by degarding the dharma.We never said hindus are supreme..we believe in" truth is one,ways of finding it are different".The many negative points written about hindu dharma in your message reflects the basis of your conversion theory.We never say bad things about christianity,its only about the evangelists .Finally india is truly secular because of its hindu dharma as we welcomed even those who persecuted us & in return we are being decieved..

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Stephen, Mangalore

    Sat, Mar 14 2009

    I strongly feel that the Principal has taken a wise decision.He actually needs to be congratulated.I feel that the parents should not have supported their children when they actually knew that the fault was from their side.It looks like the parents do not want their children to grow and develop with good values.The parents should keep a track of their childrens performance right from the begining so as to avoid these kind of problems.I feel that because of the carelessness of the parents the children have suffered today.So dear parents please wake up and see to it that your children are not let down by your carelessness and take this as a lesson.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Shilpa , Mangalore

    Sat, Mar 14 2009

    Having studied at St Aloysius College for 7 years i strongly feel that the Principal Mr D'Silva has taken a right decision.I strongly feel that the decisions taken by the college authorities are as per the rules prescribed by the PU Board.These kind of actions must be taken so that other students should not repeat it. This I believe is a complete failure from the parents and students side and not the college...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Joe, Mangalore

    Sat, Mar 14 2009

    Mr. Abhishek, Mulky, your comments on the subject matter are totally out of context and has no meaning. It is fortunate that Daijiworld is kind enough to post your comments on the site, which ofcourse exposes your state of mind and thinking and also the knowledge. It looks like your thoughts are like that of a frog in the well, which considers that it is the only world existing in the universe. Please think over and look at the bigger picture and try to respect other's beliefs and you will definitely know the difference. God Bless You and May He open your heart and mind to think good about others. Jai Hind...!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Veylyma, Mangalore

    Sat, Mar 14 2009

    Question to Mr Abhishek:Do you know where the funds come from and the root of it.FYI: They are from our very own brethren who have slogging abroad for their daily bread and wish to feed a meal to the poor in India.They are not from any Black Markets or Hundis.While some of our brothers are eating a meal from some ones hard work, why do u have a problem? can you afford feeding a family ?please do so.

    Regarding conversions:If you were to say Christians convert in the name of service,can you touch your heart and tell me that you have not preferred a catholic institute for any need of yours?and why have you not been converted? In addition to this guys why dont u understand, in your protests you are publicising other religions. Half the job is already done by you...we also understand that the root for all religion is Hinduism in India.But u also need to understand and question why those conversions have happened. Guess the answer would be the stringent rules,narrow minded approach, tortures,bias and discriminate behaviour shown to people in your own religion.Why are people feeling insecure? PLEASE GUYS PRACTICE BEFORE YOU PREACH....LIVE AND LET LIVE

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Wilson, Kuwait

    Sat, Mar 14 2009

    Dear Mr. Nagesh. Read the content. Its not Orissa Vs Mangalore. This is a purely Educational Institution and i am a student of this college.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ASHWIN , MANGALORE

    Sat, Mar 14 2009

    Dear Mr Abhishek, why are u simply bringing religion in between something which is completely the responsibility of a parent or the student itself ??? I am a passout of St. Aloysius PU college n believe me, after every monthly test the college sends a marks sheet to every students house by post n this sheet also contains the attendance percentage of the student for each n every subject . It was the duty of the parents to check if their children were attending classes regularly or not. And the principal always used to warn us about the consequence of having attendance shortage. It was the students duty to abide by the rules. How can they be so careless about their future.Mr D'silva sir was just doing his duty. There's no need to get religion in between. We are all Indians so please don't get all these unnecessary differences between the people. Grow up !!!! please !!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ASHWIN , MANGALORE

    Sat, Mar 14 2009

    Dear Mr Abhishek, why are u simply bringing religion in between something which is completely the responsibility of a parent or the student itself ??? I am a passout of St. Aloysius PU college n believe me, after every monthly test the college sends a marks sheet to every students house by post n this sheet also contains the attendance percentage of the student for each n every subject . It was the duty of the parents to check if their children were attending classes regularly or not. And the principal always used to warn us about the consequence of having attendance shortage. It was the students duty to abide by the rules. How can they be so careless about their future.Mr D'silva sir was just doing his duty. There's no need to get religion in between. We are all Indians so please don't get all these unnecessary differences between the people. Grow up !!!! please !!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr. Ahmed,, Toronto

    Sat, Mar 14 2009

    This Abhishek seems to be a product of poor upbringing. This is how someone will speak if deprived of quality education. Abhishek, speak your thoughts to people of your mentality. You have no caliber of background to comment on the quality education provided by the Christian missionaries worldwide (I doubt if you have ever attended any school). As to your views on conversation, people change their religion at their will you cannot change the beliefs of people forcefully /deceitfully as portrayed by you and your bunch of follower. St. Aloysius should provide education to only the minorities of this country. Ungrateful, so called followers of saffron cult should attend Rama Sene / Bajrang Dal University.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • lloyd, udupi

    Sat, Mar 14 2009

    a very good action by the college.the bindaas Aloysian boys/girls should learn a lesson from this.keep it up dear principal

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Joseph F. Gonsalves , Bannur Puttur/Mangalore

    Sat, Mar 14 2009

    Dear Mr. Rajesh, UAE, Examination forms will be filled in advance obviously a couple of months earlier. A minimum attendance is required for writing examinations. Suppose fifteen days are less also they are not eligible to obtain Hall-Ticket. Kindly refresh. Concerning the fee of students paid that if there is provision to provide back from the pre-university definitely they will return. If not losing the elections and without obtaining minimum votes losing the deposit also

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • abhishek, mulky

    Sat, Mar 14 2009

    First of all dont be under the wrong impression that only missionary run institutions are prestigious.All have seen the fraud services of missionaries who fool poor people for converting as they did in Africa.Now their target is India, with vast funds flowing from Vatican.One more question?? why didn't these institutes declare a holiday when thousands hindus were butchered in Kashmir, Marad,Godhra or when Swami Lakshmananda was killed?? Christianity is a great religion,but unfortunatley churchanity & missionaries have degraded the same in the name of service. Service should be selfless not aimed at promoting one' beliefs.Look back at your family tree & you will find out why your ancestors converted owing to the voilent crusades!!Jai Hind..Respect your mathr dharma.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rajesh, UAE

    Sat, Mar 14 2009

    Why college allowed them to fill the exam form and fee, if required percentage of attendance was not met. I know many students could not give the exams because of shortage of attendance. But, they were told before filling the exam form. Why they didnt folow this procedure. Holding the hall ticket is looks to be arm-twisting tactics of the principal.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • george dsouza, mumbai, mangalore

    Sat, Mar 14 2009

    Perfect fall into a trap, that's what Nagesh Nayak always wanted, intimidating people and looking for provocation.I have always seen his comments and the best thing is ignore them, he neither has any point of view nor his comments have any prose.He at best is like any of today's politicians and trouble mongers trying to poison innocent minds.Probably he wanted get into some political party bur missed the bus and must be working somewhere.I do not think he is doing any constructive work, most of the times he is logged to Daigiworld and waiting for an opportunity to comment.Guys! please do not waste your time on reacting to his comments! take it with pinch of salt.People have right to express their views , there are many in this website do it in a civilized way.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Crast T., Dubai

    Sat, Mar 14 2009

    Dear Parents, don't worry. 2009 is not good for them. They will ge given hall tickets next year. But see that they regularly attend the classes. - This year - your fault. next year be careful. Remember- principal is following the rules only. He must keep-up the name of SAC. Don't blame him. That is the difference between SAC and other colleges. Dont' ask a mercedes car at Toyota carola price. From: ex-student of SAC

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Pradeep, Mangalore

    Sat, Mar 14 2009

    John D is a man of principles. I was his student while I was in PU and he was teaching us Maths. I remember once he put me out of his class just for being late by 5 minutes to his class. Being a catholic, I am 100% sure, he has not acted against any community. What he has done is 100% right and the parents should have checked their children's report regarding marks and attendance. Well done John D and may God bless at this difficult hour. Long live Aloysius, long live Mangalore. Jai Hind.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Steven , Dubai

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    I think Mr Nagesh is out of his mind. The incident is totally different to that of his comments. This incident is so sad. Parents of those students not given Hall tickets wake up , check with your children regarding this issue.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ani Vernon Dsouza, VALENCIA / DUBAI

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    unless thre is a dialogue of students,parents and teachers at the OBA hall which has transformed good results We have have the best advocates, CA's ,diplomats .journalist'so so called student leaders why not give it a try

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Hari, Vamanjoor, Dubai

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Mr. Nagesh Nayak, Sorry for being rude. But I have been observing over the months that your comments on any topic are always out of place or are not normal. Please proof read your comments through an educated intellectual person and then submit or else you are making a fool of yourself. I know that not all people are blessed with intelligence!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • vasanth, Jeddha/ Saudi Arabia

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    There are two things that unite us together.One the feeling of belonging to one's country in otherwords Nationalism and the other is the educational institution where we study.All of us who have benifited from this great institution owe our success to the College St. Aloysius. St. Aloysius is the one among the many christian institutions in India which have done great service to humanity. Rules are important and to be an Aloysian means to be a DECIPLINED PERSON. What the prinicipal has done is absolutely right. May god Bless abundantly all the management members,lecturers and the non teaching staff for their dedicated service to the society.Those who criticize this College are like the one ungrateful children who murder their own parents for a little bit of property and wealth.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ani Vernonl Dsouza, VALENCIA / DUBAI

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    I had to come into the picture, since I was silent till now.Please young students vote for the the one of your choice. Dont get influenced by your relegion or caste. Vote for who is able and who can work for the betterment of mangalore which is now become manga gala uru.

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • K S Zahoor Ahmed, karkal/KSA

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Alosiyus Collge,Reputed educational institution of Managalore,There is no compromise in teaching and decipline.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • R Prabhu, IXE/KSA

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Minimum attendance during the academic year is mandatory for every student. This has been a strict guideline issued by the PU Board. Unfortunately many take it very lightly. Basically the students and parents should understand that rules are for all and should be followed. Many people have a arrogant attitude to break rules especially if they are well connected and "Bokka Thuka" is the phrase. In student life if this kind of attitude develops, it will really reflect in later life.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sharon DSilva, Mangalore/UAE

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Mr. Abhishek please dont go away from the topic and bring issues like religious diparancy in between. I had the privilege of studying in Aloysius for 5 years and Mr. DSilva was the dean then. the discipline and education imparted in the college is commendable. Mr Abhishek in case you have not had the privilege of studying in such prestigious institutions you must visit the college once when activities are conducted and I am sure your blind views will undergo a tranformation when you will see how many hindu students are secretaries of various associations, etc. Every student irrespective of religion and social and financial background is treated in the same way. The Jesuits are renowned world wide for the service they render especially in education. Mr. DSilva is the first lay person in the history of Aloysius to become the principle and i congratulate him.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Roydon D' Souza, Mangalore

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    I am an ex student of St Aloysius P U College.. I strongly feel that the decisions taken by the college authorities are as per the rules prescribed by the PU Board, and these kind of actions must be taken so that other students who see this will not repeat it again. This I believe is a complete failure from the parents and students side and not the college...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ani Vernonl Dsouza, VALENCIA / DUBAI

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    I had to speak for my almamatar. Even though i was considered the bad student,but voted the best leadership award in 1989 besides being college president 1989. There is no bad student as such. I remember travelling with Fr.Prashanth matdtha to Bangalore and he said students have to be naughty othervise they are not students. Being one of the naughtiest student during my school, high school, and college time's I never went beyond the limits. hence my request to all students studying at college besides my nephew ,son to be resttraint on the situation like your uncle and Dad.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Theo D'Silva, Kadri,Mangalore/Toronto,Canada

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Dear Readers, I would strongly recomend the Pricipal to issue the tickets to all the students by counciling the student and parents about the issue. Jesus Christ forgiven all the sins by dieing on cross. This is a very small thing in modern days where human intellegence is weighed by their mind rather than stereotype books. I too am a Aloysian and they were strict those 40 years back. But, pardoning is devine. Thanks, Theo.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ANIL VERNON, VALENCIA / DUBAI

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Being a college president of 1989 aloysius college I would be in a good position to reply to this even though I have never been in your so called ti ta tae answers. We had strikes for carry over system , if students failed in 3 subjects in ist year and they were not allowed to go to 2nd year degree there was a strike and Aloysius college was the college was the one which went against the strike by Govt college and its associates. Friends it is difficult to go against the strike and call yourself Gandhi but go along with it.Not to mention the people who went against the movement who are the trouble makers in the society that day and even today.( names not mentioned)

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • SATHISH VAS, MANGALORE/ DUBAI

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    I have met PU College Principal John Disilva.I Strongly feel we need people like him to run the college. He has done the right thing according to rules.First we should see whether our son/daughter is right or wrong.Never blame the teachers. All this is political to take advantage.

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Kevin Mascarenhas, Mangalore/UAE

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    I am an Ex-Aloysian and my class was majority hindus. We all got along well. We did have disciplinary action taken against even christians like those who did not attend classes being denied hall tickets, dismissed for indiscipline and so on so forth. St.Aloysius College is the first preference for students of all faith. Some misuse the excellent facilities and deserve to learn the hard way. I am sure the principal Mr D'silva has taken a measured decision. Its time for parents to be parents and not act like deliquents. Those who comment on communal nature just shows they lacked the Jesuit education and hence so narrow minded.

    DisAgree [1] Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • MELROY D'SOUZA, Madanthyar/mangalore

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    I am proud to say that i studied in St.Aloysius P U college.I personally experienced the dicipline,rules and regulations of the college.The college sends progress reports along with the attendance records to the parents.Even they call the parents to the college to enquire about attendance shortage or failure. Why the parents have been sleeping throughout the year and now they are awake? If at all they were bothered about their children,they should have come to the college as soon as they received the report cards. "HATS OFF TO ALOYSIUS COLLEGE FOR THEIR BRAVE STEP TAKEN IN THIS REGARD"

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • jessy castelino, surathkal

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Yes its right what college has done.This is what all the colleges have to follow.This rule is framed by the govt.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • A. N. D., Mangalore

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Principal you are right, most of the parents do not know what their children are doing whether their children were attending or not attending, parents should keep eye on their children from the begining. Parents of these children (not issued hall tickets) woke up at the last moment and blaming principal.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • L Saldanha, Mangalore/Bahrain

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    No attendance- No hall ticket. These rules are in place at S A C from when I was a student there 25 years ago. What the principal has done is right. Nagesh Nayak needs to visit a psychiatrist. What has orissa got to do with an internal discipline matter?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sudhir, Mangalore/Qatar

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    I am proud to be a Aloysian, what Pricipal has done is very right, please follow the system, the parents should wake up and see what thier children are doing.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Wilson Saldanha, Karkala

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    i have some friends from this college according their them principal is right in not giving hall tickets. but Nageshanna please......... i feel sorry for u...........good luck

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Shoukath Hussain, Karkala

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Mr Nagesh Nayak, be a civilized human being first and then start your allegations. Also do not talk something irrelavent to the matter.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • inas, mangalore-575003

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Appears to be nothing but more malicious actions against minority Christian Institutions by Sangh Parivar outfits. ABVP appears to be very enthusiastic in creating trouble in Christian Institutions and encouraging indiscipline amongst students. Another foolish attempt to malign the reputation of St. Aloysius College, and to further strengthen the Taleban image of Mangalore. Parents are to be blamed for not enforcing proper disciple on their children at home and for turning a blind eye on the monthly appraisal reports sent by the College.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Maurice Quadras, Mangalore / Vijayawada

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Our dear Mr. Nagesh Nayak always passes comments, whenever there is some news on Christians or related to the Christian inatitutions, just for his mental satisfaction or just for the sake of commenting. Every Mangalorean knows about the principles followed at St Aloysius. The students just did not attend the classes and the parents thought their children were always right despite receiving periodicals on their attendance and performance. What the management of St. Aloysius did is right, they have followed the rules and regulations and there is nothing wrong in doing that. Nagesh Nayak, think of doing something good for the society at large rather than poisoning the minds of the people (the one who have got nothing else to do but create trouble).

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • abhishek, mulky

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    I am sure all students denied tickets would be hindus who were with the ABVP.John disilva is playing dirty politics in this..

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • zak, mangalore

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Dear Nagesh Nayak looking at your comment & spelling mistake anyone can make out that your are not studied in Christian Institution… if so then you one among those who fell short of their attendance ...Moreover in any Christian institutes other religion students out number Catholic students …u don’t have to colour everything in communal way..

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Nelson Vas. Neermarga, Mangalore

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Hello Mr Nagesh Nayak... do you need to be treated like a LKG student... if Issue of Amarnath can come to every nook and corner of the country why can't the issue of rape and murder , violation of human rights and spoiling the integrity of nation can't be brought here...? ok sorry it's my fault to argue with the idiots like you.. by the by whatever the THE GREAT ST. ALOYSIUS COLLEGE has done is truely a great job. Dear parents you support youre children without knowing where they went and what they did during their absnteeism... Surely it'll be going to affect the future of your child as well your old age....

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • INDIAN, INDIA

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    MR. NAGESHANNA, "ORISSA IS IN INDIA, NOT IN OTHER COUNTRY" COME OUT FROM THE WELL & SEE THE INIDAN MAP.

    DisAgree [1] Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ganesh Nayak, Mangalore

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Please do not communalise this issue. St. Aloysius is a prestigeous educational instittuion known for it's good education and discipline. Please give them free hand to deal with the students as per their college rules book. Students and parents are in fault. Don't bring Hindu /Christian issue once again we are fed of this.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Joe, Mangalore

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    I think the principal is right in not giving hall tickets  to all those students who are not regular to classes without any valid reason. These kids dont understand where they would land up if they dont have proper preliminary education. For heavens sake let their parents be responsible enough and ensure that they take up studies seriously otherwise they will have enough jobs as goons in the associations which are troubling mangalore already. They will realise the truth of life when they grow up.

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • observing the media, jackson

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Dear nagesh naik my kind advice for you before commenting on any issues please refer two sides of every coin.Just see the film sholay where dharmendar did the mistake by not observing the coin properly.I think the same situation you are facing. it is better for all viewers before they speak.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Santhu, Mangalore

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Mr. Nayak - your statement smacks of prejuidce - it is totally out of context and it is very obvious you are an uneducated ruffian - please dont use this site to air your views, use your local language tabloid - you may find other like-minded fanatics.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Anil D'souza, Qatar

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Those who object to the rules should be shown the door. what were the parents doing when the reports were sent by the college certainly not sleeping i suppose. Who is the ABVP to enter the college premesis this college is not meant for goons of the khaki chaddie parivar to flex their muscles. If they do not like our colleges and our sense of discipline the parents can jolly well remove their wards from our colleges and send them to the mutts run by the saffron brigade. As for Mr. Nayak he can send his children to the RSS Shakhas

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Arvind Nayak, Mangalore

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Mr.Nagesh Nayak, bangalore......Do not try to divert the issue....Talk about this issue or else dont comment....We are in Karanataka not Orissa....

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Natasha, India

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Nagesh Nayak talks as if the Hindus were not behind what happened in Mangalore and Orissa. Mr. Nagesh should learn to keep his opinions to himself.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Raj, Mangalore

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Strict action to be taken against this principal and managment by educational ministry, they want to spoile career of a few students for personal reasons, i have been noticing previously as well when i was student Mr.Disilva is behave very rudde with the students of some perticuler community.he should be sacked from his position without any delay.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • sameeksha, mangalore

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Even am an ex-student of pu college. they give complete records of attendence..it is not fair on parents part to accuse our principal this way. Parents who are concerned about their children should check their marks and attendence position..and not behave this way... college just can't go away from its rules and regulations.. what u have done is right sir...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Diwakar, Bangalore

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    hey nagesh nayak, do you mean christians do not have right to protest for terrorists of orissa ?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Simon, Mangalore / UAE

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Dear Nagesh Nayak, Bangalore So silly and ridiculous on your part to expose yourself to the world, you are one track minded. Isn’t that the mouth speaks what the heart is full of. Come on for God’s sake grow up. Do you have any so called principles, should you be a laughing for the most of the people??????????????

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • H. R. LOBO & ALICE MARY LOBO, DEREBAIL MANGALORE - PUNE

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Mr. Nagesh Nayak, please do not go off the tangent! Christian schools joined the protest against astrocities on Orissa Christians, taking justification of the Optional Holidays Rule. If you born in 1940's or early 1950's you would have known/read of the terrible time the Christian and other Private schools protested against the State's (Ist Communist Government) attempt to control education in Kerala. They closed all private schools for almost a week in the year 1958.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Nita, Mangalore / Mumbai

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    St.Aloysius is a very good and desciplined college. The Principal has taken a very right decision.for all these consequenses the Students and their Parents are only responsible.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • jane, dubai

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    mr nagesh nayak dont compare the bundh to this incident try to read the content first

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • c ferrer, mangalore

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    maybe instead of getting regular attendance these students were frequenting places they should not have been frequenting.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Nilesh Kamath, Mangalore

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Mr,Tony What has this incident got to do with Taliban, Taliban bombs schoools and doesn't allow girls to study.Is it happening in Mangalore.Understand things first before you commment

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • nagesh nayak, bangalore

    Thu, Mar 12 2009

    WITHOUT GOVT.PERMISSION CHRISTAIN COLLEGES GAVE BUNDH CALLS FOR ORISSA MATTER.

    DisAgree [1] Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Naveen, Mangalore/Dubai

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    I am an ex student of SAC. During my PU days I too cut classes often. But the college authorities promptly sent a report home informing of my regular absence. I look back today and thank the Vice Principal who sent the warning note to my parents. I thank my father and my elder brother who took me to task and ensured that I never cut classes without good reason. If not for them, I would have also suffered the same consequences.

    In this incident, I squarely blame the parents who have failed to check the progress of their children. The affected students must take responsibility and face the consequences, hopefully not to repeat the offence again. It would be unfair to the studious students if the defaulting students are allowed to appear for the exams.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Eric Coelho, Mangalore/Ajman

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    There is no institution in Mangalore as old as ST.Aloysius.The Action taken by the Principal is absolutely right and within the Rules Framed by the Govt. St. Aloysius is the best run institutions in Mangalore and in India besides other Catholic Schools and College in Mangalore. What surprises me is about ABVP. In such a situation where is NSUI are they Snoring or sleeping to confront the ABVP.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Charles D'Mello, Pangala

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    If a student does not have prescibed attendence, he will not be eligible to sit for the exams... true as per rules. Sports persons will be given attendence for their absense, it is normal. If the hall tickets were denied to these students, then only a request can be made by parents!!! This kind of storming into the principals chamber in a group is not a good sign !!!!! For the parents mistake, students shall suffer...Because they failed to keep an eye on their children !!!!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Avil Rao, Kinnigoli

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    I am an ex student of St Aloysius College . The allegations made by some students is not true. Every month college conducts tests and every month they send marks cum attendence report to the parents. Its parents duty to check the regularity of the student.I think once again here politics has played a dirty game. St. Aloysius College not only imparts knowledge but also teaches disipline. Jai ho St.Aloysius.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Tony , Mangalore/USA

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    I am pained to see that ABVP has promptly jumped on this issue of attendance and hall tickets at St. Aloysius College, as though the problem of not getting hall tickets for insufficient attendance was created by the college and is not the fault of the students who have failed to do their duty. ABVP will do well and can earn a good name for itself by fostering discipline and a sense of duty among the students rather than make a big issue of the hall tickets where all college authorities (and not just St. Aloysius College) are bound by the rules of Karnataka Govt. I hope the elders of BJP will take this example of how ABVP gets involved in these matters of discipline unnecessarily and guide the organization to be a positive force for the long-term development of our youth and help promote a sense of purpose and pride in being responsible students. I venture to say this because the ABVP leaders I knew during my college days were very responsible people and were positive role models to others. We need to know what positive work is being done by ABVP now other than politicizing matters of discipline in reputable institutions such as St. Aloysius College.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ambrose, Mangalore/Bangalore

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Dear Parents of the class 12 student who have not recieved Hall Ticket atleast wake up from the sleep now. Even I was a notorious student of the same college and I was not denied Hall ticket because I had attendence. Now its your turn my dear friends dont go to the college for the rest of your life. You guys are good for nothing and am sure you guys are trouble makers and you are all making false alligations.. Good job done dear John D . Keep up the good work .

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Manohar Dsouza, Mangalore/Bahrain

    Fri, Mar 13 2009

    Appears to be nothing but more malicious actions against minority Christian Institutions by Sangh Parivar outfits. ABVP appears to be very enthusiastic in creating trouble in Christian Institutions and encouraging indiscipline amongst students. Another foolish attempt to malign the reputation of St. Aloysius College, and to further strengthen the Taleban image of Mangalore. Parents are to be blamed for not enforcing proper disciple on their children at home and for turning a blind eye on the monthly appraisal reports sent by the College.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • joegonsalves, U.S.A. Mangalore

    Thu, Mar 12 2009

    I am a past student of St. Aloysius College and I feel that it is my duty to make my comments on the issues involved. Rev. Father Francis Serrao, Rector SAC and Mr. John D'Silva are doing their best to run the PUC division of SAC effectively within the norms prescribed by The Government and it expedient that parents like me try and study the rules governing attendance etc. for eligibility for Hall Tickets. Obviously exceptions are made when the students concerned attend sports and other such activities. We have to learn our lessons from the prevailing situation. Instead of questioning the authorities for denial of hall tickets our children should ensure that they attend classes regularly. After all it is in their own interest that rule governing attendance has been imposed by The Government. St. Aloysius is not framing rules but of course they are required to follow the rules as per Government regulations. Joe Gonsalves

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ajay, India

    Thu, Mar 12 2009

    If you do not have 75% attendance you do not get the hall ticket to attend the exam, period that is the PU Board rule. I can understand the parents being shocked at what their children have been doing instead of attending classes, but parents ought to keep an eye on their children rather than waking up when the sun has already set. Regarding the lumpen elements of Mangalore involving themselves in this, well what other work do they have ?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Mangalore: PU Students, Parents Storm into Aloysius College Principal’s Chamber



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.