Eyes on Governor, Centre after Yeddy Passes Floor Test
Report: Gabriel Vaz
Daijiworld Media Network - Bangalore
Bangalore, Oct 11: After the brazen act of getting as many as 16 MLAs, including 11 from BJP and five independents, disqualified from the membership of the Karnataka Legislative Assembly by using a 'compliant' speaker K G Bopaiah, the beleaguered chief minister B S Yeddyurappa has managed to pass the floor test.
The entire exercise was over in a matter of a few minutes with the ruling party winning the motion of confidence of the House by voice vote amid unprecedented tight security and deployment of police forces in and outside the Vidhana Soudha and even imposing severe restrictions on the media from carrying out their legitimate duties.
The combined opposition Congress and JD(S) members as well as the anti-BJP legislators were not allowed to raise any discussion in the House. In fact, the 16 MLAs were prevented from entering the precincts of the Assembly.
The enraged Opposition members immediately trooped to Raj Bhavan to take their complaints against the 'brazen, illegal, undemocratic and unconstitutional' manner in which the ruling BJP managed to overcome the crucial trial of strength in the House in less than a few minutes, and submitted a memorandum to governor H R Bhardwaj demanding dismissal of the Yeddyurappa regime for what they termed as the 'lack of majority in the Assembly.'
Union Cabinet likely to meet at 3.30 pm
The governor, who has been taking a pro-active role in needling the Yeddyurappa regime right from the time he assumed office and has been actively monitoritng the situation including issuing directions even to the speaker K G Bopaiah, can be expected to submit a detailed report to the Centre.
Meanwhile, the Congress-led UPA regime at the Centre, which has reportedly convened an emergency meeting of the Union Cabinet at 3.30 pm, can be expected to take stock of the changing political situation and take suitable decisions based on the governor’s report.
Media allowed but with severe restrictions
The Yeddyurappa-led BJP regime, which had clamped severe restrictions and even sought to ban the media from covering the proceedings, especially the visual media, later relented. The print and visual media representatives were allowed to enter the Vidhana Soudha precincts with one of the unprecedented security check-ups and allowing only the media representatives having the official accreditation cards issued by the information department and the passes issued by the Legislature secretariat only in the year 2010. The check-up was so tight that even the minutest discrepancy was not allowed.
The ruling party had imposed prohibitory orders in and around Vidhana Soudha upto a radius of 2 kms and had even declared holidays for the staff of Vidhana Soudha and Vikas Soudha for the entire day. Even the staff of the Multi-Storeyed Building near the Vidhana Soudha were given half a day’s holiday.
Several media representatives were pushed around and even allegedly assaulted and arrested. In fact, policemen in mufty were allowed to enter the Assembly precincts. There were altercations between the police, media and representatives of political parties, with breaking of glass panes in the Vidhana Soudha.
Along with the restrictions and curbs imposed on the media, it is learnt that the Yeddyurappa regime had even resorted to unscheduled disruption in power supply in Bangalore, Mysore and other prominent cities to prevent the telecast of the proceedings of the political drama from reaching the general public.
Yeddyurappa, who managed to win the trust vote by disqualifying the 16 legislators who had informed the governor in writing about their decision to vote against him, later attacked the Congress and JD(S) leaders. He was particularly harsh on the father-son duo of former prime minister and JD(S) supremo H D Deve Gowda and his son and former chief minister H D Kumaraswamy, who is also the state JD(S) president and a Lok Sabha member, for conspiring to destabilise his democratically elected government.
CM celebrates with Venkaiah Naidu
Eshwarappa and Anant Kumar Celebrate
Anant Kumar and CM
CM with daughters and daughters-in-law
CM wishes the speaker
Sweets for the chief secretary
Speaker is Yeddyurappa’s 'puppet'
The chief minister accused Kumaraswamy of employing the services of Mumbai underworld elements to kidnap the ruling party legislators and independents, who had become associate members of the ruling BJP, and virtually keeping them under house arrest in different places and shifting them from place to place and state to state. He accused the Congress-led Goa government headed by Digambar Kamath of joining in the conspiracy to destabilise his democratically elected government.
Kumaraswamy attacked the chief minister’s passing the floor test in the Assembly as the darkest chapter in the history of democracy and in the annals of Karnataka. "The speaker Bopaiah had proved that he is a puppet of Yeddyurappa and lowered the dignity of the august office held by him which had seen stalwarts like V Baliga," he said.
"Yedyurappa has lost his majority in the House. He has misused the speaker's chair. It shows their inability to prove their majority," Kumaraswamy said mentioning that the strength of the members opposed to Yeddyurappa was more than 118 in the 224-memebr Assembly.
KPCC working president D K Shivakumar said, "The House was not conducted, the policemen were inside the House. Within a minute the speaker left. We will go with all the MLAs for the headcount in front of the governor."
Meanwhile, the Union home ministry has expressed serious concern over the Karnataka situation and has taken serious note of it. The tenth schedule of the Constitution has been abused, according to a spokesman of the Union home ministry.
Disqualified MLAs trying to get stay order
Incidentally, all the 16 disqualified MLAs are likely to move the High Court or the Supreme Court and get a stay order against the order of the speaker for their disqualification, which automatically leads to Yeddyurappa regime losing its majority in the House.
The Karnataka High Court has posted hearing on the petition filed by the 16 'disqualified' MLAs before a Division Bench at 3 pm.
It remains to be seen whether the Division Bench of the High Court grants the stay order as sought by the 'disqualified' MLAs.
President’s Rule likely?
It remains to be seen what action the Centre is likely to take in the present situation. Speculation is ripe in political circles that the Centre may decide to dismiss the Yeddyurappa regime for losing its majority in the Assembly and go in for keeping the Assembly in suspended animation.
Thus, it is too early and premature for Yeddyurappa and the ruling BJP to hold celebrations for proving its majority on the floor of the Karnataka Assembly.
Kar 'Natak' So Far...
- Bangalore: Yet Another Brazen Act: Yeddy Bans Media Coverage
- Yeddy gets 16 MLAs Disqualified to Overcome Floor Test Hurdle
- BJP Crisis: Speaker may Pronounce Order Before Trust Vote
- Will Yeddyurappa Survive? Odds are Not Favourable
- Governor Puts Breaks on Disqualification Petition
- Bangalore: JDS Indulging in Horse Trading, says Eshwarappa
- Bangalore: BJP Crisis Deepens as More Legislators Join Rebels
- Congress, JD-S have Kidnapped State MLAs, Alleges BJP
- Yeddyurappa Government Will Fall, says Kumaraswamy
- K'taka Crisis: Dissident MLAs Given Deadline
- Bangalore: BJP Crisis - Rebels Face Threat of Disqualification
- Bangalore: Deadlock in BJP as Rebels Stay Put in Goa
- Deve Gowda Says Yeddy is 'Misleading' Speaker
- 11 Karnataka Rebel BJP Legislators Get Show-cause Notice
- Parrikar Begins Fresh Round of Talks with Rebel BJP Legislators
- Kumaraswamy Meets Karnataka Rebels in Goa Resort
- Renukacharya & Co Will Return on Friday, Promise to Support Yeddyurappa
- Yeddy Might Survive Trust Vote; Katta May be Asked to Quit
- Bangalore: Yeddy Sacks Asnotikar, Jarkiholi - Bellubbi, Others Return
- 12 Dissident Karnataka BJP Legislators in Mumbai, May Go to Goa
- 'Horse-trading' of MLAs in Full Swing as Yeddy Braces for Floor Test on Oct 11
- Deve Gowda Family's Misdeeds will be Exposed: Yeddyurappa
- Yeddy Regime Plunges into Crisis, Asked to Prove Majority by Oct 12
Comment on this article
shreya, bahrain
Tue, Oct 12 2010Well Done Nagesh once again you prooved to the world that kannadigas are brainless.When others told me i did not beleive but now i came to know that it is true.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
nas, b.c.road
Tue, Oct 12 2010hello sherigar... its all part of politics.. i agree both are right to save the party.. but suspending the independent is not at all correct.its happend first time in india.if they are part of the govt also speaker cant do any thing for them.he wil surely pay for his dirty politics..
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
RAJ ULLAL, MANGALORE
Mon, Oct 11 2010Mr BASHEER, Kuwait/Mangalore, BJP doesnot have any links with Bajrangdal or Ramasena. Do you know one thing Ramasena supported congress in one of the elections. So will you blame our present BJP incase if Ramasena does something wrong?
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
A.S.Mathew, U.S.A.
Mon, Oct 11 2010Captain CM, your celebration of a
wonderul political coup, and the
subsequent tasting of sweets with
your stooges are not going to
last even for days. You have simply
jumped from the frying pan to the
coal of fire, and watch for
scorching political experience.
As the heat is going to be unbearable, you will find special
help from the gods in the Himalayan
mountain range. If you thought that the politicians standing
across the court are not smart like
you, you made the biggest mistake.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
RAJESH, MANGALORE/DUBAI
Mon, Oct 11 2010JAI BJP..This is a fitting reply by BJP.Now BJP is safe from all sides.if the prez rule is imposed on us then BJP will come more strongly in the next election."isse kehte hai apne pair pe kulaadi maarna".if it is right in maharashtra how it can be wrong in our state.After this BJP will become more strong as all the kachra is out of the party.jai BJP JAI HIND
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Kumar, Vittal/USA
Mon, Oct 11 2010And give us the clean Congress/Deve Gowda culture - what a joke!! I would take BJP any day.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Jewel, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Good job from speaker,by the way how many crores did CM give you, to take this decission. Shame on Karnataka politics. All over the world people are watching through television.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
anis ahmed, mangalore/dubai/agc
Mon, Oct 11 2010God help us, save us from these CORRUPT BJP culture
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Satish Kunder, Mangalore/Kuwait
Mon, Oct 11 2010I am surprised with the comments of BJP supporters here. Who has to be blamed for all this mess? After infamous ‘Operation Kamala’ BJP got the clear mandate to rule but their leader is not able to keep the flocks together because of his arrogance.
After BJP has come to power we have seen such confusion at least 3 times and administration had almost collapsed during the period. If Yedyurappa had leadership qualities then nobody would have dared to rebel against him and no opposition party would have been able to pick his MLAs. It is funny that BJP is celebrating as if they have won the war but sadly this is the shameful day in the history of Karnataka for which BJP is totally responsible.
Actions of speaker is not worth mentioning as he acted as if he is agent of Yedyurappa. Disqualification of Independent MLAs is laughable and this decision may not stand even in the court. I am not the lawyer but the court may direct the speaker to repeat the floor test to be done in a constitutional way.
But I do not either support the rebel MLAs or the president’s rule as both are dangerous to the very fabric of the constitution.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
ISMAIL K PERINJE, PERINJE/YANBU-KSA
Mon, Oct 11 2010An ardent lover of democracy I am very much pained by the incident of Assembly today.We karanataka citizens were made to bow our head down becuase of some MLA'lust for money and power.
MR ABHIJITH and MR GIREESH SHETTY,WHEN SWEET HAS PUT OPEN PLACE TO TASTE,HDK TASTED IT.REBEL BJP MLA'S PROBLEMS ARE NOT NEW ONE AND IT SHOULD PUT IN TO REST FOR THE BEST INTEREST KANNADIGAS SO THAT HE SWUNG IN TO ACTIONS.IF OPPORTUNITIES ARE GIEVEN EVERYBODY WILL MAKE USE OF IT.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Kamath V, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010I was amazed but not shocked when my friend told the money brought fwd to buy rebel BJP MLAs could have come from abroad..Saudi and gulf countries..who want to release Madani, the jailed PDP leader for bangalore terrorist bombing..Governor, Cong n JD-S are hand in glove..But all these trends are dangerous, if it is true..Does anyone have any idea of how Madani emerged without punishment in the coimbatore bombing which killed so many lives..I precisely see some link too.
BACKDOOR entry fooling people of Ktka is not acceptable..If at all the central govt has the guts to dismiss the ktka govt or announce prez rule, let them ALSO have the guts to go to the people again by announcing elections..people are watching and are not idiots !
Also high time fulltime Congi AGENT/politician like bhardwaj vacate rajbhavan at the earliest for someone OF REPUTE acceptable to all.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
naveen, udupi
Mon, Oct 11 2010KUMARASWAMY LOST NEARLY 600 crore indian rupees. each MLA got 30 to 45 crore rupees
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
nagesh nayak, bangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010hi,Ramesh Nirvani, Bantwal,
DO NOT FORGET THAT YOU ARE THE ONLY ONE LAWYER IN THIS COUNTRY.
SHRIMAAN BOPAYYA TOOK RIGHT DECISION & HE IS ALSO A LAWYER.
BJP LEADERS HAVE DISCUSSED WITH SRI SOLI SORABJEE( I THINK YOU KNOW HIM VERY WELL) THEN TOOK ALL THE DECISION.
IN MAHARSTRA CONGRESS DID THE SAME THING? THEN IT WAS AS PER CONSTITUTION? NOW BJP FOLLOWED THE SAME RULE IS ANTI CONSTITUTINAL?
WHAT ABOUT CONGRESS AGENT? WHY HE WROTE A LETTER TO THE SPEAKER? SPEAKER IS THE ULTIMATE AUTHORITY TO DECIDE WHATEVER HAPPENS IN FLOOR.
MR. BOPAYYA GAVE FITTING REPLY TO CONGRESS AGENT THAT " DO NOT POKE YOUR NOSE INTO MY CONSTITUTIONAL WORK"
DID YOU WATCH WHOLE DRAMA ON ELECTRONIC MEDIA.
SINCE ONE WEEK YOUR KUMARANNA & ZAMEERANNA HOLDING BJP MLAS FOR RANSOM . FROM WHERE THE MONEY COMES FROM FOR CHARTERED FLIGHTS, RES0RTS, STAR HOTELS , TAXIS, FOOD & DRINK BILLS.
WILL ANYBODY VOUCH THIS NONSENSE?
I APPRECIATE YOU AS A LWAYER IF YOU CONDEMN THE JDS GOONDAISM & CONGRESS IS TRYING FOR BACK DOOR ENTRY.
I STRONGLY CONEDMN JDS GOONDIASM & CONGRESS BACK DOOR ENTRY FOR OBTAINING POWER.
LET THEM FIGHT IN ELECTION & LET VOTERS DECIDE.
BJP IS DEMOCRATICALLY ELECTED GOVERNMENT & TRYING TO DESTABILSE THE GOVERNMENT IS A COWARDNESS.
NIRVANIJI, AS A LAWYER DO YOU SUPPORT THIS TYPE OF GOONDIASM?
JAI HO BJP.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
nagesh nayak, bangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010hi,Ramesh Nirvani, Bantwal,
DO NOT FORGET THAT YOU ARE THE ONLY ONE LAWYER IN THIS COUNTRY.
SHRIMAAN BOPAYYA TOOK RIGHT DECISION & HE IS ALSO A LAWYER.
BJP LEADERS HAVE DISCUSSED WITH SRI SOLI SORABJEE( I THINK YOU KNOW HIM VERY WELL) THEN TOOK ALL THE DECISION.
IN MAHARSTRA CONGRESS DID THE SAME THING? THEN IT WAS AS PER CONSTITUTION? NOW BJP FOLLOWED THE SAME RULE IS ANTI CONSTITUTINAL? WHAT A LAWYER YOU ARE?
WHAT ABOUT CONGRESS AGENT? WHY HE WROTE A LETTER TO THE SPEAKER? SPEAKER IS THE ULTIMATE AUTHORITY TO DECIDE WHATEVER HAPPENS IN FLOOR.
MR. BOPAYYA GAVE FITTING REPLY TO CONGRESS AGENT THAT " DO NOT POKE YOUR NOSE INTO MY CONSTITUTIONAL WORK"
DID YOU WATCH WHOLE DRAMA ON ELECTRONIC MEDIA.
SINCE ONE WEEK YOUR KUMARANNA & ZAMEERANNA HOLDING BJP MLAS FOR RANSOM . FROM WHERE THE MONEY COMES FROM FOR CHARTERED FLIGHTS, RES0RTS, STAR HOTELS , TAXIS, FOOD & DRINK BILLS.
WILL ANYBODY VOUCH THIS NONSENSE?
I APPRECIATE YOU AS A LWAYER IF YOU CONDEMN THE JDS GOONDAISM & CONGRESS IS TRYING FOR BACK DOOR ENTRY.
I STRONGLY CONEDMN JDS GOONDIASM & CONGRESS BACK DOOR ENTRY FOR OBTAINING POWER.
LET THEM FIGHT IN ELECTION & LET VOTERS DECIDE.
BJP IS DEMOCRATICALLY ELECTED GOVERNMENT & TRYING TO DESTABILSE THE GOVERNMENT IS A COWARDNESS.
NIRVANIJI, AS A LAWYER DO YOU SUPPORT THIS TYPE OF GOONDIASM?
JAI HO BJP.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
BASHEER, Kuwait/Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Nagesh Ji .
when congress/jds does it you call it goonda giri and back door entry politics . but when your BJP powered bajrang dal and ram sena and parivar does it its called love making right ? come on man grow up !! .start speaking like a educated man .
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Chandra, Kasaragod/Saudi Arabia
Mon, Oct 11 2010Well done Mr. Speaker suspending all the 16 MLA's and ordered not allowed to enter the Rajya Sabha. These peoples wondered here and there like mad dogs wasting crores of rupees which is the money of tax payers. Govt. must funish them. JAI HO YEDDY.JAI HO BJP.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Donald, udupi/Bangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010aswin!
NAGESH IS FIT FOR POLITICS.. BJP IS MISSING HIM AS ONE OF THE TRUST VOTERS. SUPPORTER OF CORRUPTION IN OTHER WORDS..
TILL DATE HE NEVER COMMENTED OTHER THAN POLITICS. U CANT SEE ANY COMMENTS OF HIS WHEN SOME ONE ACTUALLY NEED TO COMMENT.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Ashwin, bejai, mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010nice to see the great NAGESH NAYAK . "freelancer" of BJP back .
wonder why you sit silent all over the breaking news and come out after its all done . just like police in the movies
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Vincy, Shamboor/Bangkok
Mon, Oct 11 2010we must learn from Eddy on how to smile during crisis.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
kiran, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Hey Nagesh..
i believe you are happy with the underdeveloped state to solve these conflicts your BJP needs another years time . and your beloved "srimaan yeddyurappa ji " will be busy crying and visiting another 1000 temples. and dont worry about the speaker , for what illegal orders the puppet has taken , he will surely face the consequences.and at the end of the day remember this the rebel MLA's where from BJP itself .. jai ho to this
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
sameer, kundapura
Mon, Oct 11 2010Mr.perira, The looters inlcuding speaker has raped the democracy. BJP is totally unfit to rule Karnataka. Then what do you say for central govt.italian lady who guarded nation looter quotrochi and thousands of crores rupees scandal in commonwealth game?
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Gananath B Shetty, Nandikur/Mumbai
Mon, Oct 11 2010Speaker K.G Bopaiah has followed the anti-defection law, it is perfect to expel rebel MLA's. This is a brave step
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Nawaz, Bangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010NAGESH, If Congress /JDS asks you to jump in the well, will you jump??? You are blaming Congress and JDS for offering money and trying to topple etc, How cheap are your 11 MLA's who have no integrity, Morale or Faith in BJP to accept the offer. "Jis thali main Khate ho usii main ched kharte ho" shame on u MLA's (Namaak H.....)BJP- Bhrastachara Janata Party. Your party has Rapist (Halappa), Goondas (Reddy's) criminal's and frauds (Katta Naidu).
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Ashok Kunder, Udupi/Dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010Mr. Ramesh Nirvani, Bantwal As a Lawyer can you PLEASE tell me our Governer's action & working like agent of Congress is Democratic?
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
KINI, udupi
Mon, Oct 11 2010CONGRATS TO ALL BJP SUPORTERS
WE WANT BJP IN KARNATAKA
WE WANT YEDIROORAPPA
JAI HO BJP
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Francis, Moodbidri/Dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010Dear Ramesh Nirvani, Bantwal
your knowledge on this issue is good for us to accept but if you try to convince Nagesh Nayak, it like Hundiya munde Muttu ratna esedante!!
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Donald, udupi/Bangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Ramesh Nirvani, Bantwal
ULTIMATE INFORMATION... THANKS ....
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Khattab, Katipalla / Dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010Y TRUST VOTING IN ASSEMBLEY? NATIONAL WIDE RESORT ARE WAITING FOR YOU PEOPLE, ALSO BJP IS BRASTA JANARA PAKSHA
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Gopal Sherigar, Udupi/Mumbai
Mon, Oct 11 2010Dear Ismailbhai
It seems that you are a staunch supporter of Congress since its inception the same party which uses minority as a vote bank. Every wrong done by Congress is right for you and every good thing done by other parties is wrong. You were talking about the Speaker has committed a blunder in disqualifying 16 rebel MLAs. I would like to recall the incident happened in 2002 when to save the Vilasrao Government the then Speaker of Congress has disqualified several elected MLAs. In your case that was correct and this is wrong. You seem to be double edged man. Stop critising BJP throughout. Atleast appreciate what they have done for the last 28 months. Ismailbhai grow up and speak some sense.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
BH Balakrishna Pai, Mangalore / NaviMumbai
Mon, Oct 11 2010Congratulations to BS Yediyurappa for having won the trust vote. Any party is better than this congress plus JDS combine who are after power and looting the state. They cannot see the other party (BJP) giving a good governance. Added to that , the present governor of Karnataka is also an agent of the congress party who is , instead of upholding the constitution , doing all sorts of partisan activities. His report will surely go against the BJP and , the centre will not like to lose this opportunity of dismissig the BJP Govt. and imposing the president's rule on this pretext.
The governor should be dismissed or recalled for doing partisan activities and uphold the constitution.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Deshpremi , Mumbai
Mon, Oct 11 2010Speaker has acted within his constituional Powers Then why blame him In any case the people of Karnatka have repeatedly in various by elections etc have said WE WANT BJP ,WE WANT BJP A truth is always a truth
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Nawaz, Bangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010I Agree with Ramesh Nirvani, Bantwal.
NAGESH, this is for you.... "KALLANIGE KULLA SAKHSHI" by the way JAI HO was the slogan of Congress and the song was patented by INC for its election campaign. Your BJP used "India Shining" so continue with that. You keep saying Italian madam, Italian .... How come BJP uses english words such as "India Shining"in its campaign. Before commenting on others set your house in Order.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Rama raju, Sullia
Mon, Oct 11 2010ತಾನು ಕೇಂದ್ರ ಸಚಿವನಾಗುವುದು, ಸಿದ್ದರಾಮಯ್ಯ ಮುಖ್ಯಮಂತ್ರಿಯಾಗುವುದು ಮತ್ತು ಸಹೋದರ ರೇವಣ್ಣ ಉಪಮುಖ್ಯಮಂತ್ರಿಯಾಗುವುದು ಅದಕ್ಕಿಂತಲೂ ಹೆಚ್ಚಾಗಿ ಬಿಜೆಪಿ ಸರಕಾರವನ್ನು ಉರುಳಿಸುವ ಯತ್ನದಲ್ಲಿ ಕುಮಾರಣ್ಣನಿಗೆ ಮೊದಲ ಬಾರಿ ಸೋಲುಂಟಾಗಿದೆ
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
vinod, bangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Dear Lawer
dont u think the Governer is acting as agent of congress????infact he himself claimed so
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Louis D'Souza, Udupi/Kuwait
Mon, Oct 11 2010@Ramesh Nirvani, Bantwal. Well said Mr. Ramesh. No one is above law, BSY & Speaker both will pay dearly for their mistakes. The sweets they are eating will be sour soon.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
pandit, Mangalore/dub
Mon, Oct 11 2010Shameless Govt. Good News for corrupt goondas.Next time a party loses the credibilty of its own mlas just disqualify them before the confidence vote & stick onto the dirty seat .A shameful act.In real sense this govt is out & has now survived through backdoor with 106 votes far less than majority. Relax Yeddy now U can continue to Govern with your corrupt ministers without any problem or fear .
Next time a problem comes just disqualify the disident MLAS again & you will continue. Even with 50 MLAS you can rule karnataka in future.Immediate president rule to be imposed in our state without waiting.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Karnataka, Bangalore,
Mon, Oct 11 2010Congrats to all BJP supporters..God knows better..Dirty politics by congress and JDS..Try to win by votes not by buying the MLAs by offering them money..This has proved that JDS and congress are the worst political parties existing in INDIA..Congress is looting India since independence..BJP is the best party n elibible one to rule karnatake as well as India..Jai BJP..
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
RAJ ULLAL, MANGALORE
Mon, Oct 11 2010Congrats Sir Yeddiyurappaji. Whatever the protests the congress and JDS done in the past against the govt is waste. Dear Congress and JDS people it's better you stop those things now and co-operate with our present BJP govt in their development works. JAI HO BJP
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Suresh Shetty, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010600 crores investment lost by Congress and JDS. Each MLA cost 30 crores. All the money has gone waste. Now even bigger problem for the rebel MLAs is that the Cong and JDS moneybags are going to swarm to their residence and demand the money back. I feel pity on the Rebels bcos they lost power and also all the money they got for this. They are now with empty pockets with mouth wide open.
Also all ktka brothers watch out for a surprise release of information by the Lokayukta and the CID regarding two Mammoth scams in LAND AND IRONORE which is going to swallow 27 bigshots in Krntaka. The COngress and JDS was lucky that somehow they smelled the investigation report getting ready and panicked. This entire drama is just to preempt the filling of the report which is "termed as "Mother of all Political Tsunamis" which will swallow a lot of political leaders.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
allan, Bnaglore/Mnaglore
Mon, Oct 11 2010ಕಾಂಗ್ರೆಸ್ ಹಾಗು ಜೆಡಿಎಸ್ ಗೆ ಹೇಗೆ ಬೇಕೋ ಹಾಗಿದ್ದರೆ ಅದು ಸಂವಿದಾನವ....
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Felix F., India/Ksa
Mon, Oct 11 2010Any party is better than congress, better still no party at all, as said by Girish
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
raghu, udupi
Mon, Oct 11 2010JAI HO BJP
JAI HO SRIMAN YEDIYOORAPPAJI
JAI HO KARNATKA
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
kumar, dubai/udupi
Mon, Oct 11 2010Speaker Bhopaiah did well by eliminating 16 rebels. From last 3 years kumaraswamy is giving some or other trouble to congress or bjp governments, first we have to ban him participating in any election or any party activates. so that karnataka people will get some stable govt. JD (s) means ಜನತೆಗೆ ದ್ರೋಹ (sangha). ಸ್ಪೀಕರ್ ಯಾವ ರೀತಿ ಕಲಾಪ ನಡೆಸ ಬೇಕು ಅನ್ನೋದನ್ನ ಕಾಂಗ್ರೆಸ್ ಹಾಗು ಜೆಡಿಎಸ್ ನಿರ್ದರಿಸಬೇಕಾ? ಹಿಟ್ಲರ್ ರಾಜ್ಯಬಾರ ಯಾರದ್ದು ಅಂತ ಇದರಿಂದ ಗೊತ್ತಾಗೊಲ್ಲವಾ?. ವಾಮ ಮಾರ್ಗ್ ದಲ್ಲಿ ಅದಿಕಾರ ಗಳೀಸಸೋ ಪ್ರಯತ್ನ ಬಿಟ್ಟು ಮಾದರಿ ವಿರೋದ ಪಕ್ಶವಾಗಿ ಕೆಲಸಮಾಡಿ. wht democracy u r speaking abt HDK looking for other party MLA's to spoil the govt and Governor acting as Cong agent TiT FOr TAT wht BJP has done is best
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Sadananda, Pejavara
Mon, Oct 11 2010Bopiah is a puppet of BJP and Yeddy. He got crores for stooping so low. BJP proved majority by goondagiri. The govt in the whole world. Shame shame. Yet, they smile as if they have done a great job. Each inch of their face is written corruption and the smile.....very wicked.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Eijaz, ixe/dxb
Mon, Oct 11 2010Mr gireesh...our forefathers have never looted anything from our land bharath...We are indians and it is our land..Might be ur father(bjp govt)yeddi & reddy looting the natural resources like mines etc....from our land..dont comment on you working on arab land..
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
kishore, chickmangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010ಕುಮಾರ ಸಾಮಿ ಅದಿಕಾರಕಾಗಿ ಯಾರ್ ತಿ ಕ ಬೆ ಕಾ ದ್ರು ನೆ ಕ್ತ್ತಾ ನೆ
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Suja, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Disqualification can only be on two grounds - one if the MLA resign from the party voluntarily and two if he votes against the whip.
but here none of this happend so Disqualification in unconstitutional
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Donald, udupi/Bangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010THE MOST BENEFITED PERSON IS NAGESH MAMU... .. HA HA HA HA
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
S Shetty, Udupi
Mon, Oct 11 2010Dear All readers please read Mr. Gireesh Shetty's comments. I 100% agree with Mr. Gireesh Shetty.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Avani, mangalore/UAE
Mon, Oct 11 2010Actually it feels very bad when a government elected with majority seats is allowed to rule. If the corruption is the reason, it is known fact that all are same. It cannot be a valid reason why a govt should be toppled. If bad administartion is the reason there are people to decide on this. Opposition has to keep raising their voices against bad administartion. Instead of doing that if oppositions keep on trying to topple the elected govt through hook or crook, not allowing them to administer properly naturally people's sympathy goes with the victimized party. When oppostion resorted to hook or crook, ruling party is justified in resorting to the same. If by tomorrow the govt falls because of Govrnr's report to centre through president rule, everybody should know that which way the people's sympathy falls. It will be a blessing in disguise to the ruling party in next election. So my advise to the opposition is please stop the tactics of toopling the govt concentrate on criticising & publishing the govt wrong doing in every fields, if any, and allow people to decide the rest.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Shashi, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010All MLA s are sailing in the same boat and their main intention is to sit on the ruling chair to make money. They never look into the real problems of the state instead enjoying all the facilities benifits from the public money. Once they elected and become ministers pretending as supreme heros but never think they are public servants. We the public should teach a lession to them.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
ASHOK, Udupi/Dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010MR.Louis D'Souza, Udupi/Kuwait, Tomorrow may be different day & tomorrow may be president rule. We are happy TODAY BJP won the trust vote. People now clearly know the game of Congress & JDS. They never fool the educated people of Karnatak. They can fool only minorities of India.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
S Shetty, Udupi
Mon, Oct 11 2010Dear Mr. Gabriel Vaz
When Congress, JDS and Governer showed thier Brazen act you never highlited. I dont know why you people are behind this karnataka govt. This attitude of yours ( See the comments againstBJP) make majority people to vote for BJP.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Arun Menezes, Udupi/Kuwait
Mon, Oct 11 2010Mr. Nagesh Nayak, what about Balachandra Jarkiholi, Belur Gopala Krishna,Anand Asnotikar, Dr Sarvabowma Bagali,V Nagaraju, Raje Kage, Y Sampangi, Nanjundaswamy,S K Bellubbi,H S Shankara Lingegowda,Shivanagouda Naik,Venkataramanappa,Shivaraj Tangadagi,Goolihatti Sekhar and M P Narendraswamy.
I know they are all good ones because they are your people right, it is fair to blame the opposition for toppling the government, but what about the 16 MLA's who rebelled???
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Alex, Mangalore/Abu Dhabi
Mon, Oct 11 2010Dear all,
It is great shame on Karnataka as a whole for our politicians to play such dirty games. What is a government after all?? Are they working for/by the people?? What has Indian politics come to??
The anguish in our hearts is not reflected on our (common man's) pitiable state but has got a partisan color. All the 80 comments I read, spoke of this party and that party but, Where do Me and You stand in this situation??
Kick out all these old horses and mules. Bring in educated, trustworthy and God and country loving youngsters to not only rule but to guide and inform us about where our country is heading.
All in all, be it Gov rule or Yeddi rule for a few days (as infighting will not allow him to do any good)it is a chance for us to rethink on our own stake and decide for the better while we come to the next game...
Strategise my dear friends, for our good... Not for the good of a few who loot you. I and You toil in and out of India forsaking our right to enjoy the fruits of the free democratic country.
PLEASE THINK OF YOUR OWN FUTURE NOT OF ANY SCOUN...... PLEASE.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Ramesh Nirvani, Bantwal
Mon, Oct 11 2010nagesh nayak, bangalore
AS A LAWYER I CAN TELL YOU THAT THE ACTION TAKEN BY SPEAKER IS TOTALLY UNDEMOCRATIC AND AGAINST LAW. HIS DECISION WAS CLEARY ONE SIDED AND A DESPERATE ATTEMPT TO SAVE BJP GOVT.
THE BJP GOVT HAS CLEARLY ABUSED THE ANTI-DEFECTION LAW USED TO DISQUALIFY THE MLA'S.
THIS SO CALLED SPEAKER ACTED LIKE A BJP PUPPET AND MADE A MOCKERY OF TENTH SCHEDULE OF CONSTITUTION. HE HAS VOILATED ALL THE NORMS OF TENTH SCH. UNDER FOLLOWING GROUNDS -
1) A MINIMUM OF 7 DAYS NOTICE HAS TO SERVED IN EFFECT OF DEQUALIFICATION OF ANY MLA
2) IT IS APPLIES TO ONLY RULING PARTY MLA'S IF THEY FOUND GONE AGAINST THE WHIP.
3) YOU CAN'T DISQUALIFY A INDEPENDENT MLA SINCE HE IS NOT BELONG TO ANY PARTY.
4) THE LETTER FROM REBEL MLA'S TO GUV CLEARLY STATES THAT THEY ARE AGAINST THE CM AND NOT THE PARTY. SO IT CAN'T BE TERMED AS ANTI PARTY ACTIVITIES.
CONSIDERING ALL THE ABOVE ASPECTS ITS PRETTY CLEAR THAT SPEAKER WAS BIASED AND ACTED AS PER YEDDY'S DIRECTIONS.
NOW UNDER THE LAW THERE IS A PROVISION FOR DISQUALIFIED MLA'S TO APPEAL IN HIGH COURT TO BRING A STAY ON DISQUALIFICATION. ODDS ARE CLEARLY AGAINST SPEAKER AND IN SUCH CASE HC CAN NULLYFLY THE FLOOR TEST RESULTS.
AND FINALLY THE REPORT SENT BY GOVERNER TO CENTRAL GOVT AND PRESIDENT WILL DECIDE THE FATE OF BJP & CO.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
IRAFN, MANGALORE
Mon, Oct 11 2010this is blunder if yeddy have respect in constitution he should resign his post & go to people even if yeddy dont have support to own his party MLAs then why he is in seat? kumaraswammy his hero of youth best of luck kumaranna
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
naveen mascarenhas, mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010bjp is trying it's best to catch the sympathy of the people though they are lost in keeping the party united. sad part is the general public will also see this incident as injustice done to the ruling part, if government is dismissed. with these kind of politicians, no one knows for sure what is the best alternative for karnataka.
Sensible public must think twice before they elect a person or party.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
anis ahmed, mangalore/dubai/agc
Mon, Oct 11 2010every one knows who could be the best leader for karnataka,Congress??
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Alex, Melbourne
Mon, Oct 11 2010Kukkikkate,You pray atKukkikkate or arab god /godess is ur own business , same logic apply for me as well and for the reason it is CM s business let us mind own business first and dont bring personal intrests in here dude.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
naveen mascarenhas, 180273
Mon, Oct 11 2010bjp is trying it's best to catch the sympathy of the people though they are lost in keeping the party united. sad part is the general public will also see this incident as injustice done to the ruling part, if government is dismissed. with these kind of politicians, no one knows for sure what is the best alternative for karnataka.
Sensible public must think twice before they elect a person or party.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
ravindra, mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Kumaranna, neenu maduttiruva kelasve ninage visha. JDS will not get a single seat in next election for the DADAGIRI and MONEY POWER OF GOWDA FAMILY.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Rehman Konaje, Dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010Mr. NAGESH, DON'T LAUGH . FROM TOMARROW ONWARDS, YOU HAVE TO CRY. BECAUSE PRESIDENT RULE IS DEFINETE IN KARNATAKA. BHOPOYYA SHOULD REALISE THAT HE IS THE SPEAKER OF A SMALL STATE OF INDIA. NOT THE PRIME MINISTER OF INDIA.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
fathima, mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010All this mayhem engineered by none other than cow-expert Bhardwaj. Let the opposition demand what they wish and let them go to HELL. Who cares. The important achievement and relief is, Gowda and Sons cannot take control of Karnataka atleast for now.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
KUMAR, KUDLA / DUBAI
Mon, Oct 11 2010JAI SHRIMAAN YEDYURAPPAJI, CONGRATULATIONS YOU AND ALL BJP MEMBERS. BJP ALWAYS WINS...WE SUPPORT YOU..ALWAYS.. JAI HO... JAI BJP...
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Saleem, Belvai / Dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010The game which has been played by both opposition & ruling in Karnataka could be part of CWG
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Roshan, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010UNBELIVABLE THAT A PARTY LIKE BJP, CAN GO TO THIS LOW. THEY UTTERLY FAILED PEOPLE WHO TRUSTED THEM AS AN ALTERNATE TO CONGRESS TO GIVE GOOD GOVERNANCE. UNFAIR, UNJUSTIFIED MEANS CAN GIVE SHORT TERM GLORY, BUT NEVER DIGNIFED WIN.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
S. S. Salian, Kalladka
Mon, Oct 11 2010Congratulations to BJP Govt!!
Well said Nagesh Nayak and Gireesh Shetty!!!
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Shoukath, Bangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Hi, this is just nothing, all the party's are fooling the people of karnataka.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Vijay, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Satya mathu Nyayake sikaa jaya.
jai ho bjp. we all people r with you.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Gireesh Shetty, Sharjah-Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010In the current state no party deserves to rule Karnataka. BJP for its currption by proving that we are no better than the congress & JDS and for the opposition playing politics by using the governer and trying all means to topple down the Government elected by the people. President rule is invitable.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Suresh Heggade, Nairobi
Mon, Oct 11 2010It is too early for BJP supporters to celebrate their victory. They have to wait for today's evening.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Joba Alva, udupi/Dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010I heard like this politics happen only in Bihar & U.P but now in karnataka good improvement if same situation coming 3years may be middle & low class people suffer for their daily bread
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
IMRAN, MANGALORE
Mon, Oct 11 2010Very sad that this episode got end very soon, Governor would have given BJP some more time to prove majority, so we would have enjoyed news some more days.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Ahmed, MAngalore / Doha
Mon, Oct 11 2010Eddi is smart. The JDS - Congress paid crores to each rebels, while yeddi paid corores to only one man - the speaker. Yeddi and his chaddi (RSS) goons will rule Karnataka once again.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Nitesh R.M, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Yeddi won finally by 'HOOK' or 'CROOK'?
This man will go to any extent to save his chair today he got 16 MLA's diqualified and did the most undemocratic act of barring the media. CONGRATS!!
Yeddi you can fool some people sometimes but you can't fool all the people all the time!!!
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
nagesh nayak, bangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010hey,kiran, Mangalore,
SHRIMAAN BOPPAYYAJI IS A INTELCTUAL & LEARNED PERSON.
DUE TO HIS DECISION KARNATAKA IS SAVED FROM GOONDAGIRI & BACK DOOR ENTRY POLITIOCS.
STUPIDS ARE THOSE WHO HATCHED CONSPIRACY TO TOPPLE THE GOVERNMENT LIKE ITALIAN, KUMARANNA, SIDDANNA,RAVANA, DYAVEGOWDA,CHELUVANNA, SIDDANNA, DKS, RVD, MOTAMMA,DATTANNA, CHELUVANNA, ZAMEERANNA & PSUEDOS LIKE YOU.
HA HA HA HA
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
ilyas, Dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010My Question is that how can be a independent MLA is disqualied on anti pary activities? they are not elected on BJP ticket then how?
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Naveen , Mngalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010CONSTITUTION is same for entire India....
There is no seperate constitution for maharastra,karnataka etc..
If speaker has right to disqualify MLA in maharastra, why speaker in karnatka has no right to disqualify MLA for the same reason..?
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
wilfred, pamboor/doha
Mon, Oct 11 2010The proceedings of the assembly are illegal. For what reasons the speaker has disqualified 6 indepents? what breach they have committed? They are independent and they can individually support any party they like. Speaker cannot take action nor any party. If they violate any rule of the house in the house the speaker can suspend them for the day or for certain days.Therefore BJP has by illegal way said they have majority. The oppoding 11 MLAs of BJP are managed to be disqualified just before the commencement of the proceedings is illegal. Speaker has acted beyond his powers. He has disgraced the house. The position of strngth should be as on the day of issuing notice.if he has any principle, sense , ethics or belief in God. If not, he is not a man of any reason,a leader. In the circumstances what ex PM H.D. Devegouda once called him is idiot? He knows not what he does for the sake of power and damaging the image of BJP. It is disgrace for people of Karnataka to have such a CM . it it wrost poltics by BJP and yeddy to save the chair,
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
nagesh nayak, bangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010hey,kiran, Mangalore,
SHRIMAAN BOPPAYYAJI IS A INTELCTUAL & LEARNED PERSON.
DUE TO HIS DECISION KARNATAKA IS SAVED FROM GOONDAGIRI & BACK DOOR ENTRY POLITIOCS.
STUPIDS ARE THOSE WHO HATCHED CONSPIRACY TO TOPPLE THE GOVERNMENT LIKE ITALIAN, KUMARANNA, SIDDANNA,RAVANA, DYAVEGOWDA,CHELUVANNA, SIDDANNA, DKS, RVD, MOTAMMA,DATTANNA, CHELUVANNA, ZAMEERANNA & PSUEDOS LIKE YOU.
HA HA HA HA
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Ilyas, Dubai/Chikmagalur
Mon, Oct 11 2010It is proved beyond doubt that coconut is stronger than tantra and mantra thanks to the speaker. good to see Mr Nagesh Nayak is back with bang.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Ramesh, Pangal
Mon, Oct 11 2010Last election BJP won nearly 109 seats far ahead than congress and JDS. This indicates that majority people want BJP to rule Karnataka for next 5 years. If congress or JDS wants to topple the government first they must think of alternate government. Let them make alliance first ask rebel BJP MLA's to resign and win in their symbol. But JDS and Congress acted in unconstitutional manner and now they blame BJP/Speaker. Speaker did right thing by disqualifying rebels. This is the reason why anti defection law implemented in the country. What is the point in disqualifying rebels after the trust vote. The moment these rebels gave press statement holding HDK's hand it is proved that they are deflected. So they deserved to be disqualified. Governers action is cristal clear. We all know why congress/ JDS supporters supporting him. Let anyone argue anything, what BJP did is right. If congress/ JDS want to come power fight election win and take it. who will prevent you? When you follow unconstitutional way dont expect others to follow the rules. Todays condition even if many think that BJP did wrong, majority of people think that BJP did right. All greedy MLA's and corrupt polticians got good lesson. Better for future.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Kumar, Udupi/Dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010Eradicate corrupt politicians who's main object is money making and not the interest of country or society
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
kiran, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010stupid speaker. because of people like these and the BJP government the whole state is suffering .
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Ashwin, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Honestly we minorities have no problem with Bjp , problem here is that they spend lot of time resolving their inner conflicts which ultimately we have to pay a price , underdevelopment, riots , protests,religious hatred , income tax etc etc .
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Deepak D'Cunha, Mangalore/Kuwait
Mon, Oct 11 2010Kar 'Nataka' politics-Whining, mining and dining...Alas!God bless Karnataka!
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Gireesh Shetty, Sharjah Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Mr Peter Pereira... We have a saying. "Bhoothadha baayalli Bhagavadgeethe". Serves true for people like you and Ismail Perinje. Whetever the Congress agent in Rajbhavan does is Democracy but if speaker dances to Yeddi's tunes then its undemocratic. Regarding me earnign my bread in ARABLAND is due to the act of your forefather's who came to our country and looted it and as their agents lef Congress to rule Inda for 60 years , deprive citizens from its own resources, transfer the treasury to Italy. Otherwise no Indain would have had to leave their homeland in search of a decent job, thanks to your congress. By the when you are saying this what are you doing in Pune, I thought you should have been working in 10 Janpath under some reservation quota ?
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
lawrence, mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010bara barutta rayara kudre katte ayithu
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
KT, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Most believe that even Muslims vote for Modi & BJP in Gujarat - that’s because of the non partial development work from BJP. Is it true?
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
prakash, mlore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Nagesh, i will continue your stanza.. Shame on the Govt that has curtailed the free and fair press from reporting.U call this a democratic govt?? you are a frog in a well dont know anything.come out and see world has changed ur still in stonage.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
shahnawaz kukkikatte, dubai/udupi
Mon, Oct 11 2010I feel the Goddess from Kerala has blessed Yeddi. Yeddi didnt trust the Gods/Goddesses from Karnataka. So he went to the neighbouring state to offer prayers.Any way best of luck. Karnataka govt has become a playground. The people of karnataka are fools. Dont blame the politicians, but blame the people who elected them.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
JOY CASTELINO, MOODUBELLE/DUBAI
Mon, Oct 11 2010What is happened today is not correct. But those who are Blaming the Speaker that he did the thing all unconstitutional, should rememmber that, Congress also did the same thing in the year 2002 in Maharashtra for surviving Vilas Rao Deshmukh government!!!!.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
RAJESH KUMAR, MANGALORE
Mon, Oct 11 2010Truth is always Truth.......it never..... dies... it wont cheat the good people......good qualities always stand up.......respected CM really u...r.... deserved it sir.......
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
nelson, Karambar
Mon, Oct 11 2010I feel this G'ment will not run longer. They purchased Law & order with them.count on......
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
venkat, chennai
Mon, Oct 11 2010steve, kuwait, even if the crores are paid to the speaker, it might be much much lesser than what Cong-I and JD-S have paid to the Governor, and dissident MLAs.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
HARISH KUMAR, MUDARANGADI/DUBAI
Mon, Oct 11 2010Speaker's act of disqualifing independent MLAs is highly regretable,indeed.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
mahendra shetty, mumbai,dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010Well said Mr. Kishore.Now some people are crying on honorable speker i don't know why? same people supporting agent of Congress Mr.Bharadwaj,hahahha..whatever now happened its good for BJP.President rule etc,now People of Karnataka know the game of Congress and JD s.KUMARA is in Sagma because of Heavy loss of money which he paid to Rebels.Kumara don't go home otherwise Devegowda will beat you,he need Money only in any Cost.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Sudhir, Mangaluru
Mon, Oct 11 2010WE DONT BOTHER HENCEFORTH OUR ITALIAN FOOTLICKER BHARADWAJ DOES. NOW WE ARE THE WINNER, PEOPLE WILL TEACH LESSON TO HDK & HE ALREADY SCUKED THE DUST. HE DOENT HAVE ANY SHAME , IF HE HAS, HE SHOULD HANG HIMSELF IN GOA OR CHENNAI RESORT.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
shaila borges furtado, Sasthan/Perth
Mon, Oct 11 2010Good the govt survived all you people demanding for presidents rule got to be joking right?Looks like lot of anti BJP folks here.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Louis D'Souza, Udupi/Kuwait
Mon, Oct 11 2010Nagesh Nayak, Congratulations, have your last laugh, tomorrow is going to be different day for you n Yeddy.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
vishwa, mangalore\usa
Mon, Oct 11 2010Clear winner are Resort owners who got good business for many days and media who got good coverage.
Loser are we all
Still Jai hooooo
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
nagesh nayak, bangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010MANY MANY CONGRATULATIONS TO SHRI SHRI YEDIYURAPPAJI.
ITALIAN , KUMARANNA, SIDDNNA, RAVANA,ZAMEERANNA,CHELUVANNA, DYAVEGOWDA,RVD,DKS,MOTAMMA,DATTANNA,UGRAPPA SHOULD TAKE ONE MORE PADAYATRA TO KASHI-MATHURA FOR PRAYASCHITTA.
ZAMMERANNA & KUMARANNA LOST THEIR MONEY INVESTED ON CONSPIRACY TO TOPPLE BJP GOVT.
LOKAYUKTA SHOLD INVESTIGATE SOURCE OF MONEY FOR RS 20 TO 25 CRORES TO EACH MLAS, COST OF CHARTERED FLIGHTS TO CHENNAI-BANGALORE-GOA- BANAGALORE, STAR HOTELS BILLS & RESORT BILLS, AIR FARE , TAXI BILLS, FOOD BILLS ETCCC.
SHAME ON ALL PSUEDOS, ITALIAN,JDS & CONGRESS LEADERS WHO HATCHED CONSPIRACY TO TOPPLE BJP GOVERNMENT.
SHAME ON CONGRESS AGENT WHO IS TRYING 24X7 TO TOPPLE BJP GOVT.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
KT, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010in fact too many politicians and their kin live openly on indian public money, and consider themselves above the law. what will happen to the common man? then we wake up when the people eliberation movement such as naxals and maoists are formed!!!
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Ramesh, udupi
Mon, Oct 11 2010Good move by BJP for those who speak about constitutional & requesting to dissolve government. People will decide not the rebel MLAs & not the gowda family. what congress & JDS did to remove BJP government also unconstitutional.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Faru, Banglore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Dear All
Wait & see till tomarrow evening u will get surprising news.....
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Abhijith, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010kumarswamy and congress is day dreaming of get into power through back doors..(horsetrading)...they are best in doing this..they have proved it in past...
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
R.ACHARYA, UDUPI
Mon, Oct 11 2010Well Done BJP. The corrupt and unscrupulous disqualified MLA’s got the befitting response. It is high time to disqualify Kumar Swamy in politics , who is a pain in the neck and hurdle for progressive Karnataka. This acts as strong deterrent all those who want to dissent for their personal gains. BJP got rid of unwanted elements. We now look forward for bold and progressive performance from Chief Minister. Congratualtions!!!
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Peter Pereira, Pune
Mon, Oct 11 2010President rule is inevitable in Karnataka. The looters inlcuding speaker has raped the democracy. BJP is totally unfit to rule Karnataka. It is high time, the Governor MUST dissolve this unfit govt. and impose President rule now.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
KT, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010The current happenings in Karnataka remind us of Shanker Singh Vaghela episode in 90's. Congress could never recover in Gujarat after that. It may end up with the same fate if it tries to spoil its name with these political games of defection.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Alfred Vincent Monis, Bantakal,Kingdom of Bahrain
Mon, Oct 11 2010Good that Karnataka Govt.survived the confidence vote.Sonia's agent Governor will try his best to dismiss the Govt.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
hemanth, France/mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Puppet Governer,
Dismiss government or hang yourself...
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Satish Menon, India
Mon, Oct 11 2010Send the governer to post office to work there. Pity congress joining corrupt gowda family politics. there you go CM bring all those corrupt to the outerworld. I started liking your idea but not BJP as a party though.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Abhijith, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010@Mr.Ismail Perinje..whatever congress and JD(s) do in this state is constitutional...????
what right does Mr.Kumaraswamy has to topple the government which is elected by people and which was enjoying a full majority..???
u people r blaming the speaker???y our honourable Governor is acting like a congress agent..??answer this please...
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Asif, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Goonda rule and tit for tat, One uses police force in Goa and to top it all our CM pulls up a ace by not allowing dissident MLA`s into the Vidhana Soudha as a Soudha has been done by the CM and Katti with their children to sell Vidhana Soudha also. It is ridiculous not to let a elected MLA into the assembly and it should have been a voting by ballot and not by voice vote as we would have known how many more of the BJP MLA`s would have voted against the goverment.God save our state.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Dinakar M. Bangera, Dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010This will be a good lesson for all those MLAs who are ready to switch sides for a price. Both JDs and Congress I with the help of the agent governor, wanted to pull down this elected govt.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
hemanth, France/mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010If governer dismiss the government...winner will be BJP....
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Vincy, Shamboor/Bangkok
Mon, Oct 11 2010Fasting and prayers of the beloved one have really worked for Eddy.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Ronald Mathias, Mangalore / Bahrain
Mon, Oct 11 2010End of BJP GOVT. in Karnataka State...!!!??
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Louis D'Souza, Udupi/Kuwait
Mon, Oct 11 2010Tomorrow morning we will have President rule in Karnataka, all BJP drama will end today night. Speaker has allowed police to enter the house. Shanker Bidari too was inside the house. But those who where suppose to be inside were standing outside. Voting was not done as per democratic procedures. So rediculous.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Santosh, Udupi / Bahrain
Mon, Oct 11 2010Very well said Gireesh & Fathima.....all those BJP & Yeddy haters in this page can go and catch a fish......Yeddy is too smart for HDK or HDR or HDD....Yeddy & BJP will complete their full term and will again win and form government in the next election including in the center.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
sripathi s, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010The politicians we elect and we send them to form the Government to rule the state honestly and efficiently. But they just sit there to earn money by corruption and many other ways. Now we the voters have to demand money to vote for them. Because they any how making money. why we send them to assembly without any benefit??? Aware - the voters.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Peter Pereira, Pune
Mon, Oct 11 2010Girish Shetty, Sharjah, your BJP has crossed every norms of democracy and retained power. This is not democracy, but, terrorism. Bopaiah has completely lost his mental balance. Anyhow, congratulation Shetty, now BJP will employ you in their office. So, no need to serve Arabs anymore. Go to their office and see anyone recognises you and what treatment you will get there. Good luck Shettre.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
venu, pune
Mon, Oct 11 2010Congress getting their own medicine back nw ! They did the same in Maharashtra few yrs ago wht BJP doin nw against them !! Same disqualification drama n all. Court has already given verdict so going to court is a waste fr congress nw.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
nagesh nayak, bangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010HATS OFF TO SHRIMAAN YEDIYURAPPAJI & THANKS TO SHRIMAAN BOPPAYYAJI FOR BRAVE DECISION.
SHRIMAAN BOPAYYAJI GAVE FITTING REPLY TO CONGRESS AGENT " DO NOT POKE YOUR NOSE INTO MY CONSTITUTIONAL WORK"
JDS , CONGRESS & CONGRESS AGENT NOW BETTER TAKE REST & GO TO HIMALAYA FOR PEACE.
VOTERS NEVER SUPPORT GOOND JDS & CONGRESS PARTY WHO WANTS POWER THRU BACK DOOR ENTRY.
SHAME ON ITALIAN, KUMARANNA, SIDDNNA,RAVANA, DEVEGOWDA, ZAMEERANNA, CHELUVANNA,DATTANNA, RVD, DKS, MOTAMMA WHO HATCHED CONSPIRACY AGAINST BJP GOVT.
SHAME ON ITALAIN .
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
prashanth, mangalore/bahrain
Mon, Oct 11 2010Congrats CM.....U proved it....
See the behavior of Zameer Ahmed and Siddu in the vidhana soudha they are the No1 goondas in karnataka.... Jai Ho BJP...Jai Sri Ram
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Sudhir, Mangaluru
Mon, Oct 11 2010Well done BJP. We are with you always, dont worry. But plese dont give tickets again to those idiots & people from thier constituency will teach them lesson.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Satish Kunder, Mangalore/Kuwait
Mon, Oct 11 2010This is another example how the laws can be misused. Speaker in this case has behaved in a partisan manner as an agent of Yedyurappa and brought the shame to the constitutional post. There is lot of debate going on if the anti defection law can be applied on BJP MLAs just on the basis of letter given to the Governor or action should have been taken after they voted against the government. But this speaker took the action not only on them but also on Independent MLAs on whom such law does not apply at all.
This is the authoritarian show by BJP that it can go to any level to hold on to power. I think now the Governor may act and dismiss the Government on the basis of this foul play.
But for the people of Karnataka no party seems to be in position to give the good government at the moment. Shame on these politicians!
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Kishore, Udupi/Dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010Whats wrong with our karantaka's Minority? He proved the mejority. Atleast from now onwards shut your mouth or praise BJP.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
ISMAIL K PERINJE, PERINJE/YANBU-KSA
Mon, Oct 11 2010Mr Gireesh/SHJ/MLORE,Certainly Gali Reddygaru will be joining by Yeddy to play 'GOLI',as said as of today by evening or by tommorrow.Just wait series of for breaking news hearafter?
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
steve, kuwait
Mon, Oct 11 2010Job well done speaker. By the way how many crores did CM gave you to do this ?
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Gireesh Shetty, Sharjah-Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Dear Mr Ismail Perinje, When your rebels for whatsoever reason is barred from entering the Vidhan Soudha, they slap & punch the marshals as per media report to enter in, then if not the police will you enter the house to save democracy ?. Did you see the sct of Golihatti Shekar tearing down his shirt shouting. Anyways TIT for TAT. I dont know where this will end. If Congress in using Governer trump card, BJP is using speaker. after all politics. All the parties have raped the constitution with Operation Kamala, or supporting rebels and horse trading in crores trying to bring down the peoples elected Govt. At the end of the day who wins by hook or crook matters today not the values of Democracy.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Suresh Heggade, Nairobi
Mon, Oct 11 2010The speaker has committed a blunder by disqualifying the MLAs before trust vote. Here Anti-Defection law was abused by the speaker to save Yeddi govt and he acted with partiality. First, he can not disqualify independent MLAs and the second he can not use this law on rebel BJP MLAs before their submission of resignation or before allowing them for trust vote. As such, the action of the speaker is questionable and illegal in the eyes of law. Therefore, the Governor should dismiss this govt and impose president rule.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Ashok Kunder, Perampalli
Mon, Oct 11 2010I feel sorry about Sonia's agent Governor Bharadhwaj. God bless Karanataka 's Govt.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Dr. Haneef Shabab, Bhatkal
Mon, Oct 11 2010This is may be the Victory for the Yeddy & Reddy Company and a license to loot the public treasure. But as a common man we are deceived at every stage by these corrupt politicians. How they are misusing the office and the resources for their own benefit is an act of national shame.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Ravi Kadri, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Well Done C. M. , for giving proper reply to money mongering, currupt and irresponsible MLA's. your response should convey strong message to such charactors in future. I am glad to see Ranukacharya's name in the list.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
naveen, kottara
Mon, Oct 11 2010bjp bjp jai jai bjp
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
ISMAIL K PERINJE, PERINJE/YANBU-KSA
Mon, Oct 11 2010Yeddy and BJP of Karnataka simply raped Indian democracy and constitution.Gov's intervention is inevitable.By evening or tomorrow morning Karanataka Assembly would be put on suspended animation and paving the way for Presidential/Gov rule in Karanataka.Police intervening in assembly by by passing Marshals authority is unprecedented in Indian political system.Even opoosition party MLA's were blocked by Commissioner of Police is a wonder and seems to be Hitlers rule prevailing in Karanataka.Manuplated majority votes in house not stands at all and it is writing on wall for outer world also.Yeddy and Speaker both are responsible for this shameful and disgraceful happening in Karnataka's political areana.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Ummer KunhiMK, Perinje/Dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010Congrats Mr. CM! FULLY THANKS GOES TO SPEAKER,at the moment Bopaiah is the KINGMAKER,wait and see what is TIGER's*(GOVNR) action??????????
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Ummer KunhiMK, Perinje/Dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010Congrats Mr. CM! FULLY THANKS GOES TO SPEAKER,at the moment Bopaiah is the KINGMAKER,wait and see what is TIGER's*(GOVNR) action??????????
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
fathima, mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010Atlest from now on both JD(S) and Congress should learn if they can do something bendind the doors, others might do something under carpet.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Shail, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010THIS IS TIGHT SLAP BY BJP TO CONGRESS AND JDS...
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Roshan, Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010He should have done in the resort itself, with all BJP members sitting in one place. Why in assembly? Shameless face of BJP is out in open. They are pretty sure it is going to be president's rule. All they are trying to do is - opening up a front to critize the governor acting unconstitutionally. Where as all facts and law prove BJP is acted absolutely in disregard to law, constitution and even ethics.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Gireesh Shetty, Sharjah- Mangalore
Mon, Oct 11 2010For all the day dreamers out there wiaitng to see BJP Govt falling down..Dream on Though luck this time. Try to kncok the back door again with the help of Siddhu, Puppet Governer & his highnedd Devegowda & fly. Am no big fan this Govt but do Support BJP for Vaajpayee. But Yeddi Along with Reddy's playing good politics. Although these people are not good leaders they are good politicians. Yesterday I saw Janardhan Reddy's statement. From the time I started playing GOLI (marbles) I have not been defeated. I will not do any work which i may think that I will be defeated. Good attitude reddy. TIT for TAT for these despo Congress & JDS. However I am impressed by JDS role in this entire episode & I belive they have better future in Karnataka than the Vote bank Congress. I guess there will be by election soon for the diaqualified seats. Yeddi, if you want BJP to continue strong in the state its time you have to step down and allow Ashok or other popular leaders like Shettar to lead the state. Concequitive winners for BJP should be given place in Cabinet like Haalaadi Shrinivas Shetty, Yogish Bhat etc who have a clean background. Time for some clean up Yeddi, the stains are removed now.
Anyways at the end of the day, we middle class or poor class have to go to office everyday to earn our bread no matter which corrupt govt comes and sits in our state or country.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
ASHOK, Udupi/Dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010Hon CM God is with you. This is Devi Chamundeshwari's blessing.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
Louis D'Souza, Udupi/Kuwait
Mon, Oct 11 2010Governer must dissolve the assembly with immediate effect. All this is unconstitutional and not acceptable. There must President rule from today itself.
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse
kumar, udupi/dubai
Mon, Oct 11 2010ಹೆಚ್.ಡಿ.ಕೆ ಏನು ಕಿತ್ಕೊಳಕ್ಕೆ ಆಗಿಲ್ಲ. ಪಾಪ.!!!
ನಿಗುರಿಕ翤ಡು ಓಡಾಡುತ್ತಿದ್ದ ಕುಮಾರಣ್ಣನಿಗೆ ಸರಿಯಾದ 绌ಗಳಾರತಿಯಾಗಿದೆ..Were is siddu and deshpande???
DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse