Italy Shipwreck - Captain's Mistake Cost Lives, say Survivors


Italy Shipwreck - Captain's Mistake Cost Lives, say Survivors

Pic: Yahya Hallare
Daijiworld Media Network – Karwar (RD)

Karwar, Jan 22: It is not everyday that one gets a second chance at life. Or rather, a second life. Three of the lucky 200 Indian survivors of the Italian cruise liner Costa Concordia which capsized off the Tuscan shore a few days back, have returned home, and live to tell their story on what happened aboard the ill-fated ship.

Tony Fernandes, Wilson Fernandes and Makeria Xavier, residents of Chendia village in Karwar were aboard the Italian cruise when the tragedy took place. They even helped in the rescue operations and saved several lives.



Tony, Xavier and Wilson

They agree on one point - that it was the captain of the cruise ship, Francesco Schettino, who was to blame for the tragedy, as has been reported by media worldwide. It was the delay in giving orders to evacuate the ship that led to 12 lives being lost and many more missing, and moreover, instead of directing the rescue operations, the captain himself allegedly jumped into a life boat, for which he is under enquiry.

Tony Fernandes narrates:

"It was on 9 pm on January 13, the Italian luxury cruise liner Costa Concordia had set sail in the Mediterranean sea for a few nautical miles, when the crew realized it was sailing off-course, but dared not question captain Francisco Schettino.

"We heard a thud at around 9.30 pm and the cruise liner leaned a little and changed its course, and by then the emergency sirens also blared. We rushed to see what the matter was, and at 10.15 pm, the captain announced, ‘No problem, everything is in control. It is a technical problem and there's no need to fear.’ Obviously, we heaved sigh of relief.

"However, we could sense the ship moving in a haphazard manner, and at 11.45 pm the captain issued orders to evacuate the ship. By then the giant vessel had  leaned further and we could see a few storeys already flooded. The electricity supply snapped and darkness enveloped the ship.  We rushed to the passengers cabin.

"There were thirteen life boats on either side of the ship when it began its voyage.  But as the ship was beginning to lean and submerge, 13 life boats on one side could not be accessed. We then rushed the passengers into life boats on the other side," says Tony.

"If the captain of the ship had sent SOS at 9.30 pm, all passengers and crew could have been saved on time. The captain delayed his orders by about two hours, which proved hazardous and complicated the rescue operation. The captain’s error in going off-course and navigating the cruise liner too close to the Giglio Island resulted in the tragedy," says Tony.

When the cruise liner hit the rocks, about 2,000 passengers were dining, and as many were watching movies. A few of them were sleeping and others were on the deck.  "The passengers had the shock of their lives when they heard the emergency orders. The ship plunged into darkness, and we could hear cries for help," says Makeria Xavier.


Happy reunion

Nevertheless, for Tony, Wilson and Xavier, the tragedy ended in a happy reunion with their families. The parents of the three seamen were overjoyed when they reached home safely after being rescued from the shipwreck.

"We were anxious and worried when we heard of the tragedy, but relieved and happy when Wilson called us to say he was safe two days later," says Wilson's mother Vixina Fernandes. The same was the case with Tony, whose grandmother could not bear her anxiety till she saw him herself.

 

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Louis, Kuwait

    Mon, Jan 23 2012

    100 yrs ago the day TITANIC was to start it's 1st trip, the Captain said "Not even God can sink Titanic" result we all know. God has given us brain build n create anything you want but don't Challange God who created us. Student cannot be above his teacher. Thank God many lives are saved bcz of security systems n Boats for immediate evacuations.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • Alex, Mangalore

    Mon, Jan 23 2012

    I have also worked on the navigation bridge of few ships. The charting of the course is always preplanned, and not been done by a single officiating officer, of the usually three Officers on duty taking 4 hours duty on rotation. Any deviation from the charting of the course has to be approved and orders of Captain only, no deviations are permissible, similar to military code. Chief Engineer is only in charge of the Engine room, not for deck and bridge side.

    DisAgree [3] Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • cpt. mohan prabhu, mangalore

    Mon, Jan 23 2012

    when in doubt,down or out - blame the captain! that is why he/she gets the best salary on board!!

    DisAgree [10] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • Evans Christopher Sumitra, Udupi/New York, USA

    Mon, Jan 23 2012

    Chendia village in Karwar must be bustling with joy with the safe return of Mr.Tony Fernandes, Mr.Wilson Fernandes and Mr.Makeria Xavior. Thank the Almighty God for giving another life. Your family must have prayed very hard when you all were going through this ordeal.I feel sorry for the people who lost their lives and hope through some miracle some of them will be found alive.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [9] Reply Report Abuse

  • Walter Pereira, Mangalore

    Mon, Jan 23 2012

    I am a Chief Engineer on VLCC's (Very Large Crude Carrier), which are more than 40 times the size of Costa Concordia. Hence, I know what I am talking about.
    The comments that the Captain is to be blamed is coming from crew members who are stewards and are virtually unaware of Navigation.
    The Port to Port course is laid down by the 2nd Officer- he should be the first one to be blamed. Also, the watch-keeping Officer who was on duty at that time is at fault.The Captain (Master) checks all aspects of navigation but he cannot be on the bridge 24 x 7.
    I feel that the duty navigating officer should be blamed for grounding (hitting the rocks) the vessel.
    The Captain will send an SOS or give order to abandon the ship at as a last resort.

    DisAgree [9] Agree [27] Reply Report Abuse

  • A. S. Mathew, U.S.A.

    Mon, Jan 23 2012

    It is a great miracle that only a
    few people have lost their lives
    in this huge accident. Whether we
    fly or sail, we need to pray double for a safe landing because
    only God knows, how the captains
    and pilots are doing their jobs.
    A lot of pilots put the aircraft into automatic pilot right after
    take off and sleep very comfortably while flying over the
    oceans, then God only is the
    pilot.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [18] Reply Report Abuse

  • Victor Fernandes, Jedigadda, London U.K

    Mon, Jan 23 2012

    Welcome back Wilson Fernandes,Tony Fernandes and Xavier
    . Thanks to God for your safe return. God Bless you.... Praise the Lord.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [14] Reply Report Abuse

  • Navin, Manipal/Bahrain

    Mon, Jan 23 2012

    Thank God!, another Titanic disaster just missed, thanks Tony Fernandez, Wilson Fernandez and Makeria Xavier for your help in rescue operation.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [11] Reply Report Abuse

  • Leslie fernandes, Dutco, Dubai

    Sun, Jan 22 2012

    HEADSTRONG AND OVERCONFIDENT LEADERS ARE ALWAYS A TRIGGER TO UNSAFE JOURNEYS.
    LOOK AT THE AIR INDIA EXPRESS PLANE WHICH HAD NOT ENOUGH RUNWAY TO STOP OR THIS TRAGEDY WHERE THE CAPTAIN HAD ORDERED THE VESSEL TO SAIL TOO CLOSE TO THE ISLAND OF HIS 'FRIEND'.
    LOT MANY TIMES IN JOURNEY OUR LIVES ARE IN THE HANDS OF THESE IDIOTS WHO CLAIM TO BE THE GREATEST DRIVERS, SAILORS OR PILOTS.
    EXCEPTION MAY BE ONLY THE HAPLESS TRAIN DRIVERS WHO HAVE NO OPTION BUT TO FOLLOW THE OFTEN DRUNK SUPPORT STAFF.
    EVEN SCHOOL VEHICLE DRIVERS HAVE NO SENSE OF RESPONSIBILITY IN MANY OCCASIONS.
    THIS IS REALLY A UNENDING UNCERTAINTY AFFECTING MOST OF US ON EVERYDAY BASIS.

    DisAgree [7] Agree [28] Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Italy Shipwreck - Captain's Mistake Cost Lives, say Survivors



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.