Mangalore: IFKCA symposium highlights harmful effects of Niddodi power project


Mangalore: IFKCA symposium highlights harmful effects of Niddodi power project

Pics: Spoorthi Ullal
Daijiworld Media Network - Mangalore

Mangalore, Aug 31: Creating awareness among people on the hazards caused by thermal power plants, conducting surveys and filing petitions in High Courts and Supreme Court, is the need of the hour to stop the government from going ahead with the thermal power pllant at Niddodi. But creating public opinion is proving to be a difficult task in our country and I don’t know how to do it,” opined an exasperated Dr Ravindranath Shanbhogue, president of Human Rights Protection Foundation, Udupi.

He was speaking at a symposium organized jointly by International Federation of Karnataka Christian Associations (IFKCA) and Balmatta Karnataka Theological College, held at Sahodaya here on Saturday August 31.

Dr Shanbhogue presented his views on Niddodi Thermal Power project with slides delineating the harmful effects caused by thermal power plants particularly UPCL which has come up in Padubidri. He pointed out that coal-based power plants are the single largest stationary source of pollution the world over and they are a recipe for ecological devastation, health hazards, detrimental to agriculture activities and would cause havoc to the fragile and rich biodiversity of Western Ghats. We are destroying the bio-diversity of Western Ghats due to our follies and will have to pay a heavy price for it.

Citing examples of the havoc caused by UPCL and other power projects Dr Shanbhogue said “the pollutants caused from the coal used for the power plant would lead to heavy metal poisoning in the form of lead, mercury, chromium, carbon dioxide and fly ash which would cause serious health and environmental hazards. If 1000 MW UPCL is causing serious health hazards as is evident now, one can only shudder to think the pollutants caused by the proposed 4000 MW Niddodi power plant”.

Highlighting the havoc the proposed Niddodi thermal plant might have on the ecologically sensitive Western Ghats Dr Shanbhogue also stated that the Western Ghats is like a tank filled with water that releases water all the 365 days of the year. “Though it rains only for 105 to 120 days in Dakshina Kannada water gets recharged naturally because of Western Ghats. Thermal power plant will cause acid rain which would be detrimental to the Western Ghats and also to coconut, areconut and beetle leaf crops grown particularly in Niddodi. The pollutant ash and the saline water around this project will not be suitable for growing any crops. Dakshina Kannada district has so far not witnessed any cyclones only because Western Ghats has been giving a cushioning effect to the district from cyclones”, he stated.”

Convenor of Mathrubhoomi Samrakshana Samti Niddodi and journalist Kiran Manjanbailu who was the other speaker in the symposium stated that the proposed Niddodi Power Plant would have deleterious impact not only in Udupi but also in Dakshina Kannada District. “We know UPCL has caused harm to the sensitive jasmine cultivation. Niddodi is known for its beetle leaf cultivation and the proposed power project would be detrimental to its cultivation. It would also destroy the rich and veritable local culture like ‘Siri”, Gumtam and the Kudubi community of the area will be extinguished”, he said. He also said that according to the information available to them from the central committee that visited Niddodi the project is in need of 1000 acres of land in and around Niddodi. The main plant of the project is planned in the 200 acre government land but plans are afoot to acquire 800 acres more adjoining land which is cultivable.

Kiran Manjanabailu also highlighted the harmful impact caused by the proposed plant on Nandini river water which will be used by the project for cooling purposes. ‘If people are not ready to fight the might of the government and oppose the project, undivided Dakshina Kannada district would become a dumping yard of wasted ash accumulated from the plant ”, he opined. He highlighted the need the scrap the project to save agriculture, the environment and the distinct culture of the coastal region.

The assembled gathering which was full to the brim listened to the views of the speakers in rapt attention and later interacted with the speakers to get their doubts cleared on various issues pertaining to Niddodi power project. Alphonse D Souza, who hails from Niddodi and is President of Mathrubhoomi Samrakshana Vedike shared his experiences about their efforts to opposed the Niddodi power plant.

Earlier chief guest Rev Dr H M Watson, Professor of Karnataka Theologicial College Balmatta inaugurated the symposium by lighting the traditional lamp. He said that it is time the people of undivided Dakshina Kannada join hands and fight unitedly against Niddodi power project to demonstrate that we are really an intelligent and enterprising lot.

In his introductory speech IFKCA state convenor Dennis D Silva emphasized the need for the people to wake up from their slumber and wage a spirited fight against Niddodi project.

President of Mangalore unit of IFKCA Roy Castelino welcomed the gathering. Jayakar Samartha proposed the vote of thanks. Florine Roche compered the programme.

 

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • simple, Bangalore

    Sun, Sep 01 2013

    Like Mr. Charles,DXB pointed out, just opposing a project sighting environmental pollution and displacement of farmers is not enough.
    Those who oppose should come up with alternative which generates electricity power affordable by Industry and public.

    One has to sacrifice for the reason of development and as the development takes place, jobs for locals will be aplenty locally.

    Let the Government before starting the project find ways and means to contain\lessen the pollution from such coal based plants. If such precautions are taken and made known to public, there will minimal resistance from locals where the plant is going to come up. Especially in the present scenario where they will be compensated very well.
    I came across someone saying here such kind of pollution control is taken in Bellary Power plant where no fly ash\dust (pollution) is visible.

    DisAgree [4] Agree [6] Reply Report Abuse

  • simple, Bangalore

    Sun, Sep 01 2013

    Like Mr. Charles,DXB pointed out, just opposing a project sighting environmental pollution and displacement of farmers is not enough.
    Those who oppose should come up with alternative which generates electricity power affordable by Industry and public.

    One has to sacrifice for the reason of development and as the development takes place, jobs for locals will be aplenty locally.

    Let the Government before starting the project find ways and means to contain\lessen the pollution from such coal based plants. If such precautions are taken and made known to public, there will minimal resistance from locals where the plant is going to come up. Especially in the present scenario where they will be compensated very well.
    I came across someone saying here such kind of pollution control is taken in Bellary Power plant where no fly ash\dust (pollution) is visible.

    DisAgree [4] Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • L N Rego, Bendur

    Sun, Sep 01 2013

    We need Power, but not with the Cost of Greenery, We need development without Destructing the Ecological balance.
    Somebody has started praising NRI's in the comment. Remember before getting the NRI status you are an Indian and just because you have the NRI status you cant take the credit for all the development taking place around Mangalore. I don't find any reason why and with what intention you have commented (No where i find the reference of NRI). You must also remember In and around Managalore there are families which are doing pretty good without NRI status.(pls note: Here i have no intention to put down the sacrifice of NRIs).

    In most of the cases the achievements of NRI people primarily to improve their families Economical level(Not to Invest for the development of the City).
    Its very important that while opposing the project we should also find a alternate proposal for the power.Let the movement take a prospective direction which may benefit all.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • Valson Mendonsa, Mangalore/USA

    Sun, Sep 01 2013

    POWER! POWER!! POWER!!!What are you talking about?People cannot EAT POWER and Survive. This project has be implemented in North Kanara not on fertile land.

    Some people are lecturing about Gulfs, once upon a time gulfs are contributed lot to the society. Every single house in entire Mangalore was benefited with gulf money.

    >Mangalore Intl. Airport: Due to NRI's
    >First NRE Bank Deposit: Because of NRI's
    >Construction Projects: Because of NRI's
    >Business Shopping Mall: Because of NRI's
    >Visit visa for M'lore Residents: Due to NRI's
    >First Stereo System in India with Sony Cassette: Because of NRI's
    Even Daijiworld readers: Majority NRI's

    Is anyone have DOUBTS?

    DisAgree [4] Agree [9] Reply Report Abuse

  • Adv. H.A. D'Souza, Kolachikambla, Mulki, Dahisar

    Sun, Sep 01 2013

    Every industry has it's drawback. If the industrialization is not done where the present generation will get the jobs?. For industry power, water and transport is necessary.The generated power to be made affordable to the people. when the power and oil prices are increased people descend to the street to protest. Those who eared good amount of wealth, they are misleading the people. How many people have gone to gulf countries from niddodi even they have sufficient farming land?. Come back and start farming.

    DisAgree [11] Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • Charles, DXB/IXE

    Sun, Sep 01 2013

    If there is no power, the government is blamed. If initiative is taken then there is opposition. The alternatives such as nuclear, petro, solar wind etc. are expensive. Common guys those who are lecturing are doing from the comforts of their a/c homes. At least let them come up with an alternative.

    Without power there will be no industrialization, no employment etc. Come to the Gulf, work as servants.

    Yes there is impact to the environment but technology is available to mitigate the damage.


    The new land acquisition bill gives 4 time return to the farmer. The real estate guys in the picture can acquire some more and swell their coffers

    And as if IXE citizens care. In my recent visit to IXE I saw people spitting, littering, crapping etc. with scant regard to the people and environment. Wake up Mangalore Jagoo. Do Not oppose for the sake of it.

    DisAgree [16] Agree [9] Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Mangalore: IFKCA symposium highlights harmful effects of Niddodi power project



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.