Bantwal: No negligence in pregnant woman's case - Dr Somayaji


Bantwal: No negligence in pregnant woman's case - Dr Somayaji

Mounesh Vishwakarma
Pics: Kishore Peraje
Daijiworld Media Network - Bantwal

Bantwal, Feb 9: Two days after a pregnant woman and her unborn baby died at Somayaji hospital here, the administrator of the hospital Dr B Rameshanand Somayaji clarified that there was no negligence on the part of the doctors or staff of the hospital.

Chanchalakshi, wife of Naveen Kumar M, a resident of government employees' colony at BC Road, was admitted at Somayaji hospital to deliver her second child on Thursday February 6 morning. However, later that evening she developed complications and died, and the baby too died in the womb. Following the incident, the locals rose in protest against the hospital and as a preventive measure to pacify the mob, the police took Dr Rameshanand for questioning.

Addressing a press meet here on Saturday February 8, Dr Rameshanand said that as per the instructions of Chanchalakshi's obstetrician Dr Bharati Shetty, Chanchalakshi got admitted to the hospital on Thursday morning. She was healthy till around 6.45 pm, but all of a sudden she started vomiting and shivering and her blood pressure dropped, he said.

"Dr Bharati Shetty and anaesthesiologist Dr Shashikala Somayaji immediately rushed to the hospital and examined her. Meanwhile, Chanchalakshi developed difficulty in breathing too. The doctors then decided to rush her to a private hospital in Mangalore for advanced treatment, and though she was taken in an ambulance under the supervision of doctors, Chanchalakshi could not be saved," he said.

"The patient was given only Pitocin drips, and neither Dr Bharati Shetty nor any nurse administer any injection," he clarified.

"It is natural for Chanchalakshi's family to feel the pain of her loss. However, even if it was felt that negligence of doctors had led to the patient's death, there is a proper forum to address the issue. Instead of approaching the forum, was it right to protest and gherao the hospital and even pelt stones?" he questioned.

"When there are so many examples of doctors saving lives of patients on humanitarian grounds, projecting this case as a crime, branding doctors as 'criminals' and staging such protest against them is not right. Further steps on the case will be taken after holding discussions of IMA officials," he said.

"There is no question of compensating the bereaved family. As a case has been registered in the police station, it will be dealt with through legal means only," he said in reply to a query.

IMA taluk unit president Dr Sureshchandra Shetty, Dr Bharati Shetty, Dr Satyashankar Shetty and others were present. When reporters asked more questions about the case, the doctors evades them and the press meet came to an abrupt end.


Protest likely

The locals who are miffed with the police for releasing Dr Rameshanand Somayaji a few hours after taking him into questioning on Friday evening, are planning to protest again. The protestors had gathered at Somayaji hospital demanding action against the doctors, and to quell the protest, the police had taken Dr Somayaji for questioning. But soon after the protestors left the spot, the police dropped the doctor back at the hospital.

Meanwhile, the Bantwal circle inspector Rajshekar Mestry said that it was not possible to arrest Dr Somayaji and even the Supreme Court has issued orders in this regard. "Even then, under pressure from the protestors, we took Dr Somayaji for questioning. We too are pained by the death of the pregnant woman, but it is not right for people to take law into their hands," he said.

 

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Dr Edmond Fernandes, Health Concern Foundation, India

    Tue, Feb 11 2014

    Complications are bound to arise and one must always remember, no one really knows the future of a human race so well protected by medical sciences. in this context, i have known the hospital and its work and i am sure that they put good efforts to take care of every patient there. but when complications arise due to varying factors, one must know that doctors are not Gods. Its time that protection is provided to doctors and enlightened citizenship prevails over herd mindset. the police should also come to a realization that most of the doctors enter into the field to do good and nothing but good.
    I hope that the government supports the hospitals and extend their support which is long overdue.
    Growing intolerance should be discouraged manifolds.
    Medically yours

    DisAgree [1] Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • Pratheek, mangalore

    Tue, Feb 11 2014

    Being a doctor myself, I think it's quite appropriate that I make a comment on this article...amniotic fluid embolism is a very rare obstetrical complication...14 percent of 95 maternal deaths in a 1.46 million delivery database were due to amniotic fluid embolism...Another data collected from 3 million deliveries in the United States estimated a frequency of 7.7 cases per 100,000 deliveries with a case fatality rate of 20 percent...and one other study suggests a 60 percentt mortality rate ..and usually many patients are without any obstetrical complication or warning signs...So this can be quite dramatic with death occurring in as little time as 30 mins...all these facts are from the latest edition of what is considered as the bible of obstetrics called ' William's Obstetrics '...the book also mentions in italics and I quote ' there are no data that any type of intervention improves maternal prognosis with amniotic fluid embolism '....so What I mean to say is sometimes there is nothing much a doctor can do.. In spite of the doctor's and hospital's best efforts there are few medical conditions where doctors are helpless..all those data were collected from the best hospital's in the world..so I feel its quite unfair to dafame a hospital which has provided its services for such a long time based on this one incident.. It is very sorry that this tragic incident happened to that lady and I offer condolences to the family for their loss..it is indeed very tragic...

    DisAgree [1] Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rudolf, Mumbai

    Tue, Feb 11 2014

    Doc the suddenness and prognosis of AFE is understood, but what is the "gold standard" national/international protocol for introducing labor inducing agents would be highly appreciated?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Pratheek , Mangalore

    Tue, Feb 11 2014

    Mr Rudolph..the previous article on this subject suggests that the pregnancy had already gone past 41 weeks..that is an indication for induction of labour...since post dated pregnancy carry a risk to the fetus...there is a scoring system called 'The bishop's score'...if the bishop's score is satisfied there is no reason why labour shouldn't have been induced in that patient..And synthetic oxytocin is one of the most commonly used agent for this purpose and is almost all Pregnancies to augment labor and help contraction of uterus to prevent Post partum hemorrhage...the use of the oxytocin when used according to the standard regimens is quite justified

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • akhil, mangalore

    Tue, Feb 11 2014

    Emergency situations like amniotic fluid embolism are very difficult to diagnose and if at all diagnosed very hard to treat when it has occurred. most of the time tertiary care hospitals are the best equipped to deal with life threatening complications and usually the apex and final centre in life and death situations such as these. Hence blaming anybody would be baseless in these situations as most of the time the condition of the patient is very poor or even almost critical when they reach such centres. Tarnishing a hospital's reputation in view of such crises is uncalled for and many a times unnecessary where more than adequate measures have already been taken for the same like in this case.This being said ,many condolences to the family who have suffered, but in general, the public should be made aware and educated about the emergency situations present in medical practice and identify simple warning signs so that quick and adequate care can be provided at the right time.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse

  • Aravind, Mangalore/bangalore

    Tue, Feb 11 2014

    Heartfelt condolences to the family of the lady who passed away in this unfortunate event.
    May the souls of the departed rest in peace
    Somayaji hospital is a well renowned hospital, which has been giving excellent services to the people of the area over two decades. One unfortunate event, the outcome is almost always devastating. It could have happened to anyone, anywhere, and in any hospital.
    Logically, every doctor would try hard to save his patient because it is the question of his professional credibility and career. If we start to throw stones at doctors for each of these incidences, the doctor is put under extreme stress in his next treatment and the risk of misjudgement increases. The doctor may refrain himself from accepting any emergency cases at all.

    My sincere request to the people is to maintain peace & harmony not to indulge in unwanted protests

    DisAgree Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • meghana, bantwal

    Tue, Feb 11 2014

    it is very sad to see that people are reacting without any idea about the real facts of the case. Most often, it is the ignorant people That make a big deal out of such incidents. somayaji hospital is an old hospital headed and run by a set of very EFFICIENT doctors. Medical complications happen all the time and in most of the cases the Cause is simply not known. It is very sad that this is being attributed to the doctors involved in the Treatment!! This is not fair to them! It is obvious that they did everything in their power to save the patient. It is sad that the family lost a loved one... and the little boy, his mother. But by Making false accusations, especially from people Who are totally ignorant about medicine, it is neither going to bring back the woman nor do Good to ANYONE. People should seriously stop talking unnecessarily and stop spreading false information and Making rumours.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • sonika, mangalore

    Tue, Feb 11 2014

    The emotions expressed by t patient party s rite n let her soul rip !
    But no doctor will do 5 1/2 yrs mbbs course 3yrs PG 23 yrs of service to society to kill a pregnant woman. None of t doctors wud intend to kill any of their patients.
    ths s t main hospi in t locality or t patients shud travel almost 25 kms to reach a hospital in case of any emergencies so ths hospi has definitely saved 1000s of life n made life lot easier in t surroundin.
    In case of any mishappenings, Thr r legal norms to b followed. Simply blaming n pointin out 1 great doctor n person , who has worked day n nite s really disappointin n demeanin n psychologically weakenin t entire doctor profession. I respect the doctor and his service. . Thank you sir

    DisAgree Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse

  • Delma, Mangalore

    Tue, Feb 11 2014

    When death knocks at the door, The DOCTOR is looked upon as GOD.

    When he accepts the challenge, he is looked upon as an ANGEL.

    When he CURES his patient, he is looked upon as a COMMON MAN.

    But for an Unfortunate outcome, He is treated as the DEVIL.

    This is very much true in this case.

    Somayaji hospital is a well renowned hospital, which has been giving excellent services to the people of the area over the past many years. ONE unfortunate event, such as Amniotic Fluid embolism (which is rare, and also unpredictable and unpreventable) should not be taken so Strongly and negatively against the Hospital. In cases of AFE, the outcome is almost always devastating. It could have happened to anyone, anywhere, and in any hospital.

    From the details available, it is clear that the staff of the hospital gave in their best to try and save the patient.

    Heartfelt condolences to the family of the lady who passed away in this unfortunate event. May her soul rest in peace.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse

  • anil, mangalore

    Tue, Feb 11 2014

    Hey, what are you speaking about when the patient is not his... He doesn't have any rights over the patient. .. He didn't do so, such mistake. .. Please know the details and talk... He has done his level best to save the patient. .. Please do not talk bad about such great person

    DisAgree [2] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • shettru, ujire

    Mon, Feb 10 2014

    i just want one Q max as , did anyone pull u and take u that hospital , u went there by urself ..if u didnt find it good enough u might have gone to some good hospital or may BE WENLOCK ..that hospital is not for those who can afford manipal or some corporate hospital , it too is for the middle class who cant afford corporate , and the doc was right , whatever he could do , has done his part !!! Reply if u find any mistake in my comment max as !!

    DisAgree Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • prem, Mangalore

    Mon, Feb 10 2014

    First of all without getting to know what has actually happened, it's very immature for ppl behaving like that pelting stones and all....it's soo unacceptable....people should should show some maturity.... And over that This hospital is present there from very long time serving the people...people should not forget the service it has provided.....it has done so many deliveries and just because of this one incident without even knowing what has actually happened people do such stuffs
    Please we should give some respect to this medical profession.
    Not to forget they provide medical services 24\7 and they always want to give their best
    This hospital has always provided their best....

    DisAgree [1] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • ANIL, MANGALORE

    Mon, Feb 10 2014

    Well, this is a case of AMNIOTIC FLUID EMBOLISM and clearly NO ONE IS TO BE BLAMED FOR.THIS IS VERY RARE CAUSE WERE MOST OF THE DOCTORS ARE UNABLE TO DO ANYTHING . "PLEASE NOTE THAT".
    AND DR SOMAYAJI AS I KNOW WAS NOT THE DOCTOR FOR THIS PATIENT AT ALL AND BY PERSON HAS CONDUCTED CLOSE TO "9000 DELIVERIES OVER LAST 23 YRS" AND "HAS NO MATERNAL DEATHS UNDER HIM" ." HE IS CLEAN IN THIS CASE".
    THE HOSPITAL HAS BEEN THERE SINCE 23 YRS WITH OVER 17 SPECIALITY DOCTORS AND HAS TREATED THOUSANDS OF PATIENTS SUCCESFULLY. THE HOSPITAL HAS HAD OVERALL ONLY 2 MATERNAL DEATHS THAT TO THE CAUSE IS AMNIOTIC FLUID EMBOLISM AND THIS IS THE SECOND ONE IN OVER "15000 DELIVERIES".
    AS FAR AS WHAT I HAVE HEARD IS THE PATIENT WAS FINE SINCE THE ADMISSION AND WAS PROGRESSING WITH STABLE VITALS . AND PITOCIN WAS GOING ACCORDING TO THE STANDARD DOSE (WHICH IS GIVEN NORMALLY ). AS SOON AS THIS COMPLICATION CAME UP ALL THE DOCTORS CAME TO RESCUE DID THE NECESSARY RESUCUTATION CALLED UP FATHER MULLER HOSPITAL ARRANGED A TEAM OF DOCTORS THERE KEPT THEM READY AND DOCTORS INCLUDING ANAESTHETIC AND OBG SPECIALIST WHO WAS TREATING THIS PATIENT WENT IN THE AMBULANCE AND WAS RESUCUITATING ON THE WAY TILL THEY REACHED THE HIGHER CENTRE, WERE SHE WAS RESUCITATED FOR ABOUT 15 MIN AND D DEATH."THE PRIORITY IS ALWAYS GIVEN TO THE MOTHER OVER THE BABY".
    PEOPLE PLEASE KNOW WHAT IS THE CASE AND THAN TALK BAD ABOUT ANY DOCTOR ITS THE SAME HOW YOU FEEL WHEN SOMEONE ELSE TALKS ABOUT YOU WITHOUT KNOWING ANYTHING ABOUT YOU.
    I RESPECT DR SOMAYAJI AND HIS HOSPITAL FOR THEIR GREAT SERVICE OVER THE YEARS.

    DisAgree [6] Agree [17] Reply Report Abuse

  • Sachin, Mangalore

    Mon, Feb 10 2014

    Everyone blames private hospitals. Why doesn't anyone go to government hospitals? Because you dont have any hope of getting treated there and you will rather spend some money and get treated in private hospitals. you know what is sad? people throwing stones and blaming the doctor who has delivered God knows how many babies day and night . and even the government, including the health minister is blaming him. if you want to blame someone or throw stones go do it to the health ministry. People who did this have no idea whatsoever. and the media is so focused on sensationalizing the news it will go beyond limits to sell it. go ask the nurse or ambulance driver or the anesthetist or any hospital staff about the truth. dont just play blame game without knowing what "amniotic fluid embolism" is.

    DisAgree [5] Agree [11] Reply Report Abuse

  • vijaya,

    Mon, Feb 10 2014

    Well said

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rita, Germany

    Mon, Feb 10 2014

    When I hear the Explanation of doctors ,I feel very sad.previously they said she was given an injection to induce delivery or not?now they are saying gave s Pitocin .Pitocin is a drug to induce delivery so far I know and given with drip.is it new now giving oral?Of course women start vomiting with it.second now they are saying as soon as her blood pressure ed Doctors rushed to the Hospital and examined.when you think they examined her after pressure is fallen.Then who ordered Pitocin? .Looks like to divert things. Now we cant bring her back.why cant they take a good lawyer who knows medical cases and just not leave These People further lie? Some justice must be there.

    DisAgree [5] Agree [9] Reply Report Abuse

  • ssk, mangalore

    Mon, Feb 10 2014

    Medically induced labor. Limited research suggests that certain labor induction methods are associated with an increased risk of amniotic fluid embolism. Research on this link, however, is conflicting.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rudolf, Mumbai

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Doc, if the immediate diagnosis was that of AFE why a "sincere" attempt was not done to save the fetus with an emergency bedside Cesarean"???????? Why was Pitocin (labor inducing agent) administered on a very normally pregnant woman on the first day of admission????? Was informed consent taken?????? YOUR ANSWERS WILL BE HIGHLY APPRECIATED!!!

    DisAgree [2] Agree [8] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dinesh , Bantwal/Bengaluru

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    The value of precious life is only understood by immediate members of family(husband, parents and etc). I am saddened by the loss of lives.

    I blame on the so called category that our nation created is the middle class who are neither poor nor rich. Its difficult for the people to accumulate 40 to 50K rupees to enter private sophisticated hospitals in Mangalore. To save money,reduce delivery expenses, innocent patients get admitted to these kind of hospitals and take big risks of life. They just believe in doctor(s) like most of us do. This hospital may not be having sophisticated ICU, pediatric N-ICI(for infants) etc.
    In emergency situations, Mangalore reach is 25km far from Bantwal and 40-45 minute drive in the ambulance. Let God Only Save Patients!!!
    In recent years, there has many complaints on those hospital, which(s) are very poorly maintained, no doctors in nights available etc.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [12] Reply Report Abuse

  • M VIJAY KULAL, MODANKAP

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Dr.Somayaji, You can't cheat public saying some disease name. Dr Bharati shetty asked for saving baby at least in the last moment. But you have not given permission to operate. Please clarify what is the reason? That baby's life was in your hand Mr. Somayaji!! Do not play with other's life.

    DisAgree [6] Agree [12] Reply Report Abuse

  • rajesh, mangalore

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    The doctor who conducted the delivery was someone else. Dr somayaji is the owner of the hospital and in no way connected to the delivery. Then why blame and involve him at all. Will all the hospital owners in Mangalore go behind bars if there is a death in the hospital during a procedure done by some doctor ?

    DisAgree [11] Agree [11] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr. Shankarnarayan, Abu Dhabi/Mangalore

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    May be amniotic embolism has caused death of the woman. This is one of the rare complications of delivery. I know it is a big loss for the bereaved family. The public should maintain peace and should wait for the full report of the investigation. It cannot be dealt with as a criminal case as per the law. Dr.Somayaji is very good and experienced doctor and he is giving an excellent service for more than two decades to the whole taluk and the surrounding area.

    DisAgree [8] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • Jossey Saldanha, Mapusa

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Leading Doctors have left behind the needles, knife blades, safety pins, scalpels, clamps, scissors, sponges, towels, surgical adapters, tweezers, forceps, suction tips, tubes, scopes, ultrasound tissue disruptors, asepto bulbs, cryotomes, cutting laser guides, measuring devices inside the patient's body after the operation...

    DisAgree [3] Agree [18] Reply Report Abuse

  • A.P., Mlore

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Jossy we are human. .....
    But blame the person who has left a streak of madness in anyone !

    DisAgree Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr Kusuma Kumari G, Nellore/kodydka

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Public anger will usually against the Doctor is understandable. But we should not blame good Doctors for no reason. I think there must be a good inquiry before blaming the Doctor.

    DisAgree [8] Agree [14] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr Sequeira, Mangalore/UK

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Septicemia is unlikely to be the cause. She was fine until 6.30 pm without any signs or symptoms of sepsis and more over the unborn baby was alive for some time even after the death of the mother. Its likely that Pitocin might have caused the over contractions of the uterus eventually rupturing it and the lady might have gone into shock with amniotic fluid embolism. Only the post mortem examination and a proper enquiry into this would reveal the actual truth.

    Even in a super specialty hospital the prognosis for this case remains very poor and this hospital is not certainly anywhere near in managing these complications. Complications are expected in any medical procedures which at time can prove to be fatal. But ownership of actions by the doctors is needed in such cases and an honest explanation of the facts with evidence based literature would normally pave a way for mutual dialogue and settlement of the issue. In any case the lost life cannot be brought back, but lessons must be learnt to minimize such cases in the future as preventing them completely is not within the reach of any doctor, as they are also human beings. But sadly these behaviors are not seen in Indian doctors, which leads to a conflict whenever a procedure has gone wrong.

    DisAgree [4] Agree [25] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dev, Mangalore

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Dr Sequeira,Mangalore, UK, your assumption is right cause of death, if the child was alive as claimed by the doctors, as chances of rupture is most likely cause for the symptoms & the eventual death of both.
    As explained by you post mortem only can solve the mystery.
    Thank you very much for enlightening us about the most likely cause.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [16] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rudolf, Mumbai

    Mon, Feb 10 2014

    Doc, why was Pitocin "hurriedly" administered in a normal gravid woman, with no previous history of "complications"??????

    DisAgree Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr Kusuma Kumari G, Nellore/kodydka

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Dr Somayaji who has delivered thousands of women and saved many women shouldn't be treated this way. Respect Dr Somayaji for i know hes a good Doctor. The public must understand in anger they should not destroy a doctor's career.

    DisAgree [9] Agree [13] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rudolf, Mumbai

    Mon, Feb 10 2014

    Doc even "midwifes" so called in earlier days "Dayis" can do this job of delivering a baby, Where is the accountability when they charge you through the NOSE?????????

    DisAgree Agree [9] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rakesh Dsouza, Mangalore, Dubai

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    In this case Dr. Somayaji may be correct on his view on this case. But if the women is fine since morning till 6.45pm what happened suddenly.?

    It is a known fact from history that None of the hospitals / doctors has accepted any such deaths as their mistake or negligence. These people will never accept even if it is the fault from their end. Moreover, we cannot understand their medical terms.

    Here true fact is for the deceased family, they lost their family member. But for the hospital it is one of their patient so it will not make them no difference at all. For them so many such cases happen and it doesn't make any difference for them.

    DisAgree [9] Agree [13] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rudolf, Mumbai

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Very tragic and unfortunate incident, RIP!! In another news report elsewhere, it is claimed that she suffered from Amniotic Fluid Embolism (if it indeed was), this AFE is a very rare condition and occurs in one in 21000 cases and AFE is an unpredictable, unpreventable, and, for the most part, an untreatable obstetric emergency and mostly fatal both for the mother and the unborn infant!! But in most cases a serious attempt is done to save the fetus by emergency Cesarean section!! It is another thing that in most cases the child born in such cases will have serious residual neurological and other problems later on in life!! The fact will be out after the post mortem report is received!!

    Professional counseling and clear communication is very very important in such sudden tragic deaths to bring the family members to accept it and come out of sudden shock and anguish.

    It is very natural for a family to be not be able to absorb this sudden shock and get hyper emotional and charged, but to resort to physical force and uncivilized way is not desirable both ethically or lawfully!! There is a procedure to claim that it was a medical negligence, which should be followed!! And some doc asking to employ bouncers is really shocking and taking the medical profession down to the pub/dance bar level!! This is just a personal viewpoint!! Let justice prevail!!!

    DisAgree [1] Agree [23] Reply Report Abuse

  • Shankar, Mangalore

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    We should understand that doctors are too human beings. Negligence of course is condemnable if the doctor refrained from treating his/her patient in order to attend a party. But medical misjudgment and errors can not be considered as doctor's fault. It can happen in every profession. As lawyer's error can lead someone to the gallows, doctor's errors can lead to death.

    Logically, every doctor would try hard to save his patient because it is the question of his professional credibility and career. If we start to throw stones at doctors for each of these incidences, the doctor is put under extreme stress in his next treatment and the risk of misjudgment increases. or the doctor may refrain himself from accepting any emergency cases at all.

    The hospitals in rural areas, though lack in facilities, surely would have saved many lives by providing initial treatments.

    DisAgree [3] Agree [16] Reply Report Abuse

  • Lydia Lobo, Kadri

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Professionals encode their work area with titles commonly known to specific fraternity. This is called jargon or idioms. A common man is left to fiddle with a dictionary (or seek linguistics' help) to find out what a particular word means, by when the bus may have left long ago.

    Nothing different happens when a death of a patient occurs due to medical negligence. Have any of us even once in life, heard a medical institution accepting that the death occurred because of their fault ? Their report contains so many twisted explanations, that by the time we find out the meaning of all of them, its too late to contain the mortal remains, hence the family simply says 'Amen' and does away with the rituals.

    Well, this applies to all professions - may it be legal, scientific, social and all. What would one do with the compensation when so precious 'lone child' or for that matter 'lone spouse' (because there can't be many as applies to children) is swallowed by malpractice ?

    We, by discussing this matter, are increasing the pain of those who suffered the loss than alleviating it.

    May the souls of the departed rest in peace.

    DisAgree [6] Agree [19] Reply Report Abuse

  • Sharan, mangalore

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Please google amniotic fluid embolism and enhance your knowledge.as an obstetrician not only me, but all of us in the profession are afraid of this dreaded complication which is so difficult to anticipate, happens and progresses dramatically fast and fatality in the best of centres is v.v.high despite BEST EFFORTS.till then u wait for P-M report and pray that the cause of death would be as per your fancy.don.t come to conclusions on your own.if you have no faith in docs don,t go to them for treatment.they are a bunch of negligent,wanting to deliberately kill kind of humans as per most of the commentators on this forum.it,s people like you all who will make medical profession v.difficult to practice, who first blame docs..the easiest thing to do.docs will henceforth practice defensive medicine,,do lots of tests, like some fool said, allergy test was not done for this patient.,,.you have every right to seek second opinion or ask questions to a doc ,but u have no right to call a doc negligent until proved.

    DisAgree [5] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • K.Fernandes, Mangalore

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Dear Dr. Prakesh,in last week "daiji weekly" newspaper I have read that,at Jodpur, a doctor who was conducting the endoscopic examination, found the camera broke down inside the stomach of the patient and left the patient for 6 hours and later he asked to shift the patient to other hospital.Patient was lucky by conducting surgery broken things were removed and is safe..DR. Prakesh Harischandra, will you pls advise your sensible comments for these type of doctors?
    If the mother was fine sine morning till 6.45PM under the super car of the hospital, so the responsibility lies on the hospital.As others commented "Septicemia" cannot be ruled out. If so it is again hospitals' responsibility.

    DisAgree [6] Agree [13] Reply Report Abuse

  • K.Fernandes, Mangalore

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Dear Dr. Prakesh,in last week "daiji weekly" news paper I have read that,at Jodpur, doctor who was conducting endoscopic examination, found the camera broke down inside stomach of patient and left the the patient for 6 hours and later he asked to shift the patient to other hospital.Patient was luck by conducting surgery broken things were removed and is safe..DR. Prakesh Harischandra, will you pls advise your sensible comments for these type of doctors?
    If the mother was fine sine morning till 6.45PM under super car of the hospital, so responsibility lies on the hospital.As others commented "Septicemia" can not be ruled out. If so it is again hospitals' responsibility.

    DisAgree [7] Agree [8] Reply Report Abuse

  • Well wisher, Manama,Kingdom of Bahrain

    Sun, Feb 09 2014


    Education and health have become highly merchandisable commodities in India as a result rapid fall in ethical values!




    DisAgree [1] Agree [19] Reply Report Abuse

  • Surendra Poojari, Mangalore

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Whatever you may doctor, we cannot take your view points. This is not the first case at Somayaji hospital. A few weeks back, there was another death of a pregnant woman as well. When a series of death continues, definitely general public will get panic. There is no surprise when Dr Prakash Harischandra supports the hospital as he too belong to the same paternity. Those who have lost someone dear will understand what it means losing near and dear one due to negligence of the hospital. Dr. Prakash suggestion to appoint bouncers is just weird and unwarranted. Is it to mean that the hospital charge the patients to meet the cost of bouncers as well?? My only point is doctor's negligence is responsible for many deaths in hospitals and strict action should be taken against these hospitals.

    DisAgree [9] Agree [21] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr Prakash Harischandra, Surathkal

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Please also be aware as per Karantaka Government Act 2009 Gazette Notitification THE KARNATAKA PROHIBITION OF VIOLENCE AGAINST MEDICARE SERVICE PERSONNEL AND DAMAGE TO PROPERTY IN MEDICARE SERVICE INSTITUTIONS ACT , 2009 All hospitals and staff are protected under the law. Hence All hospitals are requested to prominently display the Notification in red in Bold to discourage such Actions.ALso learns to hire Bouncers like in Delhi.. its not enough to welcome patients all the time.. Learn to repulse goons it applies to hospitals of all communities.

    DisAgree [23] Agree [13] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dev, Mangalore

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    The symptoms described by doctors point the most likely cause could be "Septicemia" in the mother.
    I think the child might have been dead, causing infection throughout the mothers' blood which resulted in her death.
    Post mortem by expert doctors with lab reports only can solve the case.
    But the fact remains, this hospital lacks modern facilities or care that could have saved two lives.

    DisAgree [4] Agree [19] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr Prakash Harischandra, Surathkal

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Absolutely , you get what you pay.. todays world is market driven the government is unable to provide to all so the poor will suffer at such facilities .. this facility is below par. no doubts.

    DisAgree [6] Agree [15] Reply Report Abuse

  • Max, Belthangady

    Sun, Feb 09 2014

    Dear Dr.Prakash, could you please this hospital once and see what kind of facility they have it.once i had a bad experience there and they requested me not tell anything. Because now a days few doctors lacking honesty, sincerity in their work. Because of these things happens everywhere. Thank you

    DisAgree [2] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • rajesh, mangalore

    Mon, Feb 10 2014

    How can one be sincere. If he has 2 crores for the md seat in these big popular 'charitable'(profitable) institutions?

    DisAgree Agree [3] Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Bantwal: No negligence in pregnant woman's case - Dr Somayaji



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.