Mangalore: Krishna Palemar Warns Nationalisation of Bus Routes


Mangalore: Krishna Palemar Warns Nationalisation of Bus Routes

The Hindu

MANGALORE, Jul 20: The much vaunted private public transport system in Dakshina Kanada faces the prospects of being nationalized in the larger interest of people. This would mean that the State-owned Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation would fill the void to provide public transport system in the district, if the threat held out by Minister for Ports, Inland Water Transport, and Environment J. Krishna Palemar is any indication.

Palemar, also the district in-charge Minister, expressed displeasure about the manner in which private bus operators were indulging in bus permit-related litigation rather than responding to the needs of people. Chairing his maiden Karnataka development programme review meeting here on Saturday, Palemar said that if the situation did not improve soon, nationalisation of routes would be the only solution left. The issue surfaced when senior divisional controller of KSRTC P.B. Karambaiah expressed his helplessness to introduce KSRTC buses from Ullal and Bajal to Mangalore to meet the peak hour rush in the morning and evening. Karambaiah said that KSRTC was ready to comply with the demand, but for a stay obtained by the private operators and a previous notification of the administration. Regional transport officer and secretary of Regional Transport Authority (RTA) D. Sadashiva said the problem was compounded by the fact that the operators were obtaining permits from the State Transport Authority (STA), which was overlooking the recommendations of the RTA. The High Court had upheld the notifications issued by the then chairmen of RTA to stop issuing fresh permits for city buses in 1991 and service buses in 1993.

Deputy Commissioner, M. Maheshwar Rao, also the chairman of the RTA, said the authority had requested the Surathkal-based National Institute of Technology – Karnataka to survey the traffic density in the city. The RTA had recently categorised the buses and regulated their entry to State Bank of India terminus based on their permits. This system needed to be tried out in the long run, he said.

When Palemar said that rules should not come in the way of ensuring proper transport system and that the earlier notifications of District Magistrates be scrapped, Rao said: “Any such move may result in chaos in the city’s traffic system.” The administration was merely regulating the entry of buses in some of the city’s most congested routes, he said.

Sadashiva told the Minister that the STA had issued 243 permits to bus operators to commence and terminate their services at the SBI terminus. Of them, 73 permits had been issued after the two notifications were issued in early 1990s. The colour coding experiment taken up by the RTA had succeeded in regulating the entry of non-permit buses to SBI terminus, he said.

MLA N. Yogish Bhat said that RTA cited rules when it came to helping people. The buses that operated to Sulthan Bathery were forced to idle there at the end of each trip owing to the schedules fixed by the authority. Instead, the buses could be permitted to go up to Lady Hill during that period. This would help people who would otherwise have to commute by autorickshaws, he said.

Palemar said he would have no qualms in taking up nationalisation of bus routes seriously with Transport Minister or Government if the situation so demanded. The KSRTC would be purchasing around 3,000 buses and 300 of them could be allocated to the district, he said.

The RTO the issue would be set right in three months once the NIT-K authorities submitted their survey report.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • suresh, mangalore

    Sun, Jul 27 2008

    they create the rumour

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Anchan, Abu Dhabi

    Sun, Jul 27 2008

    We dont need pretty buses,but safe and comfortable travelling, govt or private busses, it does'nt matter, smooth and systematic transport system we need here in Mangalore

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Edwin, Mangalore

    Sun, Jul 27 2008

    Dear R u just talking about accidents or other recklessness behaviour of those owners, drivers, conductors etc... of private buses. I agree with you about the accidents, but why no one talks about these private buses who bribe the top officials who don't even are bothered about punishing the reckless drivers and conductors troubling the commuters as well as pederestaranians.

    If you take the cause of trouble to authorities the answer is you just adjust because they get sufficient from them while from government buses they don't get anything and its from their own section. Please do evaluate all the facts and put the idea. I am totally with you of the pathetic condition of government services but on other side what good our common man get from private buses?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Austin, Mangalore

    Tue, Jul 22 2008

    I suggest to all those who are for nationalisation, to travel by the government buses, in districts, like Mysore, Hasan, Karwar etc. I have travelled in these places and the experience is not worth of talking of . I agree that private bus drivers are reckless and cause accidents. Does it mean that there are no accidents by the government buses. Can nationalisation stop accidents? If accidents can be stopped by nationalisation, then why dont we nationalise gas tankers and iron ore lorries.

    They too cause fatal accidents. The reason drivers continue to rash driving, because the police department which should have been controlling them, is not penalising them. If they take appropriate action, like cancelling license, the problem will stop. While we are talking about the attitude of the bus staff, how better is the attitude of KSRTC staff ? . You go and ask them for some information, they dont even look at you. I also like to remind them about the days when NH48 was nationalised and people used to travel like packed sardines in those ambassador taxis. Do we want those days again

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • George, Mangalore/ Germany

    Tue, Jul 22 2008

    Please consider building a Metro rail from Udupi to Mangalore and improve the roads for buses like we have BEST in Mumbai. God bless Mangalore and the politicians who make this happen.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ramesh, Mangalore/ Singapore

    Tue, Jul 22 2008

    It's high time the Govt of Karnataka and India should consider developing Metro Rail in Mangalore just on the lines of Delhi Metro.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ananda, Udupi/USA

    Tue, Jul 22 2008

    Don’t worry either private and/or KSRTC supporters. Nothing is going to change in Mangalore and Udupi which can improve service to the public. All these are flaw..….for trigger the inflow of …….. This is going fetch the one who spend to reach their seat.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Harsha, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 21 2008

    Its not Good,Nationalisation of bus routes in Mangalore is a bad idea

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Raj, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 21 2008

    Buses should be nationalised. The way private buses are run on Mangalore is a shame for Mangaloreans, No respect for the Passengers travelling on it. Imagine about the poor old aged people, it could be any one of our family member. Conductor will force them to push out if they fail to get down faster. The trip will be cancelled if there are less customers and they will force you to catch alternative bus.

    Since there are hell lot of vendors they are competitive but not good for customer. They fight with each other if they fail to maintain time abuse with bad words without caring passenger. But they will be united to rise the prices. They drive so rudely that they don't care for other vehicles.. What's really good with them?? I agree everyone is allergic to the red dirty vehicle,, but look at Bangalore they are improved a lot. They have better service now. Even I hope Mangalore gets same service if it is nationalised or even privatised but to limited vendors which can provide better service.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Roshan, middle east

    Mon, Jul 21 2008

    Not good, many families depends upon private buses for their daily bread. It is not going to happen....

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rakesh Fernandes, udyavara

    Mon, Jul 21 2008

    Please do not do such mistake.  Our private buses are more clean,because of that we dont want private vehicle to travel in the city. Nationalisation buses will increase prrivate vehicles leads to traffic jam dont take our fortune from us.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Purushottama, Byndoor

    Mon, Jul 21 2008

    Shubhasya Sheegram. But will it be done ? The KSRTC has come a long way from its earlier dirty Red Bus syndrome. Today in Bangalore the BMTC has various systems of Daily, Weekly and Monthly passes. You can buy the daily passes from any bus conductor who will be too eager to issue it. A daily pass costs just Rs.30/- per day and can be used to travel in any of the 4500 buses from anywhere to anywhere- you can change buses any number of times from morning till midnight.In Mysore also similar facility exists for Rs.20/-.This is only one example of the City bus facility run by KSRTC/ BMTC.

    Can we imagine in Mangalore where the conductor will be frowning if students hold genuine passes, throws a piece of slip called ticket in your face and fares are too high and arbitrary! If the Busses in Bangalore were run the same way the Drivers drive here in Mangalore, Bangalore would not have that much living population!Many would have joined obituary columns. The KSRTC/ BMTC unions employees have unions but not Mafias like here.

    They pay their employees well and as per law. The KSRTC runs even on loss making routes as a social concern in many places.They give time to board and alight the buses and dont throw you down at Bus stops as in Mangalore . Wherever KSRTC is there they invest in bus stands whereas in our entire district good Bus stand is not visible due to the self serving private operators.

    Does it mean that KSRTC is the Best? Not exactly but it is far far better and the public have a say in the matters related to bus routes, running of buses, behaviour of staff , and more than anything they do not have lobbies that can deprive us of Trains for decades , they dont maintain roll call of officials to curb customer rights and we can expect cheap and convenient travel.

    Therefore I feel in the present scenario Nationalisation is a better if not the best option since hopes of private operators mending their ways are remote.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Valy, Mulki/Canada

    Mon, Jul 21 2008

    As much as I dislike the BJP's communal agenda, I like the way they identify the problem and do something positive for the place/country. Nationalization however should be the last option. The government should first find a way to improve current system by talking / enforcing rules effectively without giving in to the vested interest.

    Driving/traveling in Mangalore is one of the most dangerous things I have experienced I simply do not understand why the people are quite about it.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Roshan Pais, Mangalore

    Mon, Jul 21 2008

    First of all I agree with with what Bhat has said. There is this lobby and it is powerful.The lobby stops at nothing- example accidental death of Murari Ballal(he was a strong critic of private bus mafia in DK). Mr Palemar should dispell the false accusations by people that money will change hands by going ahead with the introduction of Govt buses in peak routes in a phased manner. Let them both run. This is the only way to keep check on the service by private operators. By the way Minister can also expedite the Mangalore Bangalore rail traffic .

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Kadengodlu Shankara Bhat, Peruvai vil,Bantwal Tq / Kazakhstan

    Sun, Jul 20 2008

    Btw, is this minister sincere? Or is this statement is only to get more "maamul" from the UNETHICAL PRIVATE BUS OPERATORS MAFIA as all other previous politicians of coastal Karnataka have done earlier?

    Can he really fight against this Rowdy mafia & the RTA which is under the pay-roll of this mafia? Anyway, I am quite happy that there is some public statement/admission from the minister about the ill-treatment of passengers by these operators with the support of RTA & police. I would like to correct his statement slightly as below: Mangalore & UDUPI DISTRICTS [not just m'lore city] are the only DISTRICTS [not places] in the state where passengers were treated as cattle by the transport operators. They are abused, pushed and even nudged out of the private run public transport buses. When entire Karnataka came under KSRTC during my school days more than 30 years ago [I don’t remember exact month/year, DP saab can help me], why DK district got exemption to be ruled by this mafia? This shows the rowdy clout of this mafia. Even during my last visit to M'lore, I boarded a pvt. bus to Manipal with ensured seat [sitting], bought ticket to Manipal with my small airbag from Jyothi and was forced by the rude conductor at Udupi city bus-stand to get down and board a crowded city bus to travel to Manipal STANDING with my bag. Is this what the so-called well-educated public of these 2 coastal districts deserve? Is there any RTO or civic awareness NGO to fight against this UNETHICAL PRIVATE BUS OPERATORS MAFIA from the exploitation of hapless fare-paying commuters? Anyway, I wish all the best for the minister if he is really sincere.

    One more issue reg. public transport in M'lore-Udupi: M’lore-Udupi Mono rail promise in budget: When we can't complete 10% of the 4-lane Manipal-BC Road in last year or more, why these foolish unviable mono-rail proposals? Will the UNETHICAL PRIVATE BUS OPERATORS mafia/lobby allow any such proposal?

    They won't allow even natioanlisation of the routes ! This mafia hand-in-gloves with RTO doesn't allow KSRTC to get permit for its Sleeper AC buses to ply to B'lore, as informed by my cousin in KSRTC. Is BJP govt trying to fool the public of coastal Karnataka? As long as we have this selfish greedy mafia in M'lore-Udupi, we can't expect to have a good public transport here.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Lancelot Norbert Tauro, Manglore - Doha qatar

    Sun, Jul 20 2008

    No No Please spare DK and Udupi districts, Manglore and Udupi looks pretty with beutiful private buses.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sidda, Shankerpura

    Sun, Jul 20 2008

    Good news,please keep it up.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Charles Lobo, Mangalore/Mumbai

    Sun, Jul 20 2008

    It would be a great begining.I only suggest to maintain buses properly.Some(many) times private bus drivers thinks that they are owners of the roads.so,lets support this thing and best wishes

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ajay, UK

    Sun, Jul 20 2008

    I think that will never happen and should not happen. Private bus operators have been the back bone of South Kanara's transportation and there have been companies like CPC,Shankar vittal,Ballal,Manjunath etc in the yesteryears who were principled in their operation . They were then replaced by single bus owners.Nationalisation of bus services in South Kanara would be the biggest mistake and history will never forgive us.

    We all know how the KSRTC functions or atleast functioned in the past . Their buses would be dirty,ill maintained and I am sure the accident rates would not be any lower. It is not the first time a politician has spoken over nationalisation of services in Udupi and DK districts and I would take that comment with a pinch of salt.

    What the politicians and administration needs to do is to sit with the concerned private bus operators or organisations and decide on how best to move forward with the existing set of rules.Bharatlal Meena our previous DC was a man of long vision and had excellent plans for Mangalore but unfortunately he was transferred before he could do anything.What Mangalore currently needs is a proper,clean modern bus terminus ,not just one a few ,one in the north ,one at Pumwell and another one at some other place.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Parvez ali, Mangalore/Riyadh

    Sun, Jul 20 2008

    Excellent suggestion from Mr. Palemar. Let us stop "kambula" and accident in the street. As I know Mr. Palemar for many years, he is a man of action. He is not like other politicians, He does what he says. Good wishes to Mr. Palemar.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rajendranchan, Mangalore

    Sun, Jul 20 2008

    What nonsense is this. Even to build a road the government talks of PPP, what does nationalisation mean in this context? first nationalise and then have a PPP agreement with VOLVo or TATAs to run the urban transport system?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ali Haroon, Mangalore / Jeddah

    Sun, Jul 20 2008

    A very thoughtful and interesting suggestion from the honourable minister and he deserve appreciation from all. Can this be applied to Mangalore-Udupi route where competition from operators have killed many people and the route is unsafe.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Royston, Valencia,kuwait

    Sun, Jul 20 2008

    Wow.. that is a great idea.. but .. add more govt busses in peak hours.. let the private buses continue ... we need them.. ya add few goverment buses for healthy competition.... so that people get better service..

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Jude, Mangalore Dubai

    Sun, Jul 20 2008

    It would be a step in the right direction. The drivers of private buses seem to think that our present roads are race tracks. They do not seem to care for public safety. Everyday you witness scenes that seem to be straight out from a Mad Max movie. One has to think twice before embarking on a journey in our city buses. Nationalization will stop this nonsense as there will be better regulation of routes and public safety will improve.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Austin, Mangalore

    Sat, Jul 19 2008

    We should strongly oppose this menance of nationalisation. Just compare the services offered by KSRTC and the private bus operators, (or for the matter any nationalised entity and the private entity (Telecoms, airlines, hospitals) and the difference is evident. Nationalisation helps only politicians and government official and in no way helpful to the people. It will lead to more corruption and people will be the sufferers.

    While I agree, there are problems with the private operators, nationalisation is not the solution. While the central governement has been privatising PSU's and encouraging privatisation, the state government is going backwards with the nationalisation mantra first with the mines and now with the buses. Let the state government not make people to their advantage

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Moosa Kunhi, Kakkinje/Dammam

    Sun, Jul 20 2008

    A good step from Mr Palemar,Nationalisation of roots is the only solution for this problem.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Mangalore: Krishna Palemar Warns Nationalisation of Bus Routes



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.