Udupi: 'Alexander Wasn't 'Great' but a ‘Robber'


Daijiworld Media Network - Udupi (SP)

Udupi, Jun 30: State Finance Commission vice-president D H Shankaramurty told the students of Volakadu government high school here that it would be wrong to refer to Alexander as ‘the Great’. In fact, he should be called 'Alexander the Robber', he felt. This happened during his visit to the said high school on Monday June 29. It may recalled that Murty had kicked up a controversy by trying to set right history by throwing light on the alleged dark side of Tippu Sultan, when he was the minister for higher education in the state.

"The British termed the emperor as the Great. That is distorted history. Alexander defeated our ancestors by using the brute force of soldiers. We should never accept him to be 'Great'. It would be apt to call him a Robber," Shankaramurty asserted.

Speaking after inaugurating the student government at the high school, he recollected that when he was a ninth standard student, he had objected to Alexander being referred as 'Great' and he had insisted on calling him a 'Robber'. Rather than the riches of the country like diamonds, gold and gems, he was more inclined towards the rich treasure of knowledge found here, he said.

Shankaramurty also held himself strongly against calling the first freedom struggle of 1857 as 'Sepoy Mutiny'. There should a debate on this issue. If the patriots had come together, they would have won independence then. "We have no unity and that is the reason we remained bonded for a thousand years. The theories expounded by Pythagoras and Newton’s Law were already present in India long before. But we have failed in our duty to put forth these facts while teaching history," he felt.

In-charge president of the zilla panchayat Jerald Fernandes presided. Municipal councillors Shyamprasad Kudva and Geeta M Shet, and deputy director of public instruction K Anand participated as chief guests. Headmaster Ashok Kamath administered the oath. Rashmishree welcomed.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • W.V Dsouza, Moodbidri/ Doha, Qatar

    Wed, Jul 01 2009

    I wonder who has given the authority to Mr Shankaramurthy to change or interpret history.He must stick to his line of work i.e the State Finance Commission. Throughout history there have been invasions and usurption of lands so that by that virtue they should all be robbers? Nowadays we have robbers amongst our own public service persons. Mr Shankaramurthy would be commended if he can stop the blatant robbery of govt money by these type of people.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Arnold, Mangalore

    Wed, Jul 01 2009

    Mr.Shankar murthy i tell u why Alexander was great, He was great Bcoz he served 12 years in a jail after loosing a battle, He didn''t committ suicide. Once again he regained his glory by his own strength.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • JOBA ALVA, UDUPI/DUBAI

    Wed, Jul 01 2009

    WHO IS GIVEN THE STATEMENT HE IS HITLERS NATURE HISTORY IS HISTORY YOU CANNOT CHANGE THE HISTORY THAT IS GREAT OR ROBBER BETTER TO DO YOUR WORK SINCERELY

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • abubakar uk, ubar/abudhabi

    Wed, Jul 01 2009

    don''t u have any good thoughts towards the society rather than trying to devide the society and eager to be in (bad) news through stupid statements? do some good advices to children rather confusing them...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Jyothi. , Mumbai/ Doha

    Tue, Jun 30 2009

    Instead of wasting your energy to change the history about Alexander, why can’t you do some good work and prove yourself "Great" or else the students whom you are trying to teach your history may call you "Robber"

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Arshad Kadli, Bhatkal / Al Khobar

    Tue, Jun 30 2009

    Our leaders should follow Sher Shah Suri who did wonders by constructing a road from Assam to Peshawar in record two years. This will benefit the citizens. A debate on Alexander and Tipu Sultan will serve no purpose.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Esther, Mumbai

    Wed, Jul 01 2009

    Greatness of Alexander is in leading a mighty army across continents at a very early age, almost in his teens. He captured a such a vast kingdom that after his death no one could hold it together. In Egypt a city is named after him. Robbing of the vanquished by the winners was the norm at that time of history. Lets not forget, winners get to write history. Currently, he should spend his energies to uplift the society rather than trying to rewrite history.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rafique, Kanhangad

    Tue, Jun 30 2009

    Why should we call Alexander as great. He looted our country and took the riches to his country. He may be great in his country.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Manjunatha Bangera, Kasaragodu/Bengaluru

    Tue, Jun 30 2009

    Mr. Shankaramurthy is right. Alexander was a robber.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Eric Coelho, Mangalore/Ajman

    Tue, Jun 30 2009

    For the moment let me accept Shankarmurthy words to be true. Whatever happened during Alexander Time history speaks and we have to believe what history says. Whatever happened during our time i.e., Gujarat Riots, Kandhamal Riots, Church and Pub Attack, Sikh Riots etc will all be history over the years to come.

    Now considering Alexander to be a Robber, do we have less Robbers nowadays. The Government system is Corrupted and the exchequer is robbed or sucked every day, the Bellary mines report by Lok Ayukta the Govt has not taken up and how the Mines were looted, the Municipal Corp., of Delhi where money is drawn as Salary of Bogus or non-existent employees and many more - Are these not bigger robbers.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Hariprasad Hedge, Mangalore/Udupi

    Tue, Jun 30 2009

    So now, what should be this person called??? if Alexander was a robber...

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ronald D.F.D''SouzaB, Bondel/Mangalore/Bahrain

    Tue, Jun 30 2009

    Today i am fully ashamed to read a comment from a responsible person state finance commiossion vice president shankaramurthy calling "alexander Great as Robber" The history is history can not be ereased and even 1857 sepoy mutiny is the beginning of our independence.This shows how a government in Karnataka handles education ministry .

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Vijay Prabhu, Kundapur/Canada

    Tue, Jun 30 2009

    It is a known fact that most of the politicians and ministers are uneducated persons and state ''off-the cuff'' remarks as if they are the smartest ''know-all'' people in the world! Guess whou are to balme! Just we the silly people who elected them or put them in high places and garland them profusely! Guess it happens only in India (sand some Asian countries)

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ronald D, Udupi

    Tue, Jun 30 2009

    How can this man talk nonsense? That too infront of high school students? Personal opinion with friends is fine! Officially he should not! Unacceptable....

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Aryan, Mangalore

    Tue, Jun 30 2009

    As per mostly accepted theory of genetics we know that human race originated somewhere in Africa and migrated to rest of the world. All people in India including austics (so called tribals), dravidians, aryans came to India through different routes. Let us not divide our society further along aryan non-aryan line.

    As such what Alexander has done to India so that Indians have to call him great? Ashoka, Akbar have done useful works for people of India and earned the fame. Alexender may be great in Greek if he has done some good work there with the money looted from other regions. Businessmen who are exploiting people to enjoy in pubs and bars can definitely be compared with invaders. Thankfully there are many entrpreneures who have successfully generated opportunities to lead a better life for others also.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ashraf, Mangalore/Alkhobar

    Tue, Jun 30 2009

    whether Alexander was a ''Robber'' or ''Emperor'' that is nothing to do with Indian people since we are living in a independent India.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Francis Lobo, Bejai,Mangalore

    Tue, Jun 30 2009

    We can interpret the history as we like. But facts are facts. Alexander Invaded India like other invaders. They took advantage of the lack of unity between the native people. Today people talk about Aryans and Aryan descent. Is the entry of Aryan was not a invasion. Only the natives who ruled the place can be called the true people of indian origin. Is the present government of india or state are not invaders today by forcibly taking the land of the tribal or dalit in the name of development. Are the rich businessman who forcibly threaten people in the name of Special economic zone and take away their land invade into the privacy. Why go back into history and take meaning out of the words. I have seen people in North Kanara who are proud of their Greek origin and say their color and beauty is special to Greeks!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Kiran, Udupi

    Tue, Jun 30 2009

    Person who passes such kind of comments now is a real joker

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Udupi: 'Alexander Wasn't 'Great' but a ‘Robber'



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.