If Cabinet says No, Governor Cannot Order CM’s Prosecution: Nariman
From Our Special Correspondent
Daijiworld Media Network - Bangalore
Bangalore, Jan 24: Governor H R Bhardwaj’s decision to accord sanction to the two city-based advocates of Justice Lawyers’ Forum to launch criminal proceedings against Chief Minister B S Yeddyurappa on the land scams and other alleged corruption charges against the specific advise of the Council of Ministers was improper, according to noted Constitutional expert Fali S Nariman.
''The Governor has no power to order prosecution of a Chief Minister if the Council of Ministers has advised him not to do so, he said pointing out that the Governor was a constitutional head and must act on the aid and advice of his Council of Ministers.
In a Constitution Bench decision of the Supreme Court in 2004, the court had unequivocally said that unless the Council of Ministers disabled or disentitled itself to take a decision about whether the Chief Minister should or should not be prosecuted, the Governor "may not have any role to play,” Nariman contended.
Even if the Governor invokes some residual power in himself, he must then offer to resign and the things will take care of themselves. The courts will then decide whether he has the power to order such a prosecution on his own.
''This is the only way in which Governors can keep out of politics,” he said pointing out that the Governor must leave the political parties to go to court for a direction that he is empowered to sanction prosecution of the Chief Minister even though he is a constitutional head and the Chief Minister and the Council of Ministers are responsible to the Legislative Assembly.
According to Nariman, the Chief Minister was responsible to the Legislative Assembly and it is for the Legislative Assembly to show a lack of confidence in him if it so chooses on the ground of his corrupt act.
Nariman said the petitions of the advocates seeking the Governor’s sanction for prosecuting the Chief Minister pertaining to the matter that was to be determined by Karnataka Lokayukta Justice Santosh Hegde and it does not appear that he has recommended to the Assembly that the Chief Minister should be prosecuted.
''If he (Justice Hegde) had done so, then technically speaking, as the appointing authority, he (Governor) could, perhaps, relying on the recommendation of the Lokayukta, have ordered the sanction to prosecute the Chief Minister,” Nariman said.
However, there may be some scope for the Governor on some notions of his own residual power to grant sanction. But in the absence of such a recommendation from the Lokayukta, it would be improper and not constitutional for the Governor to act on his own, Nariman said.
Complete Coverage:
- Governor Should Go, Says Yeddyurappa
- Yeddyurappa Not to Seek Stay of Bhardwaj's Order
- Yeddyurappa Likely to Move High Court on Jan 24
- Karnataka Chief Minister Must Quit, Says Karat
- Bangalore: Losses Due to BJP Shutdown Put at Rs 2,000cr
- Yeddyurappa Rules out Resignation, says will Fight till End
- Complaints Filed against Yeddyurappa over Corruption Charges
- Karnataka: A Long Legal Battle Ahead, And The Options
- Mangalore/Udupi: BJP District Units Hold Protest
- Bandh Turns Violent, 29 Buses Burnt Across the State
- Mangalore: State-wide Bandh Call Evokes Total Response in City
- 'Daylight Murder of Democracy, Justice,' says Yeddy
- Governor Sanctions Yeddyurappa's Prosecution
- Governor Rejects Plea to Cancel Proceedings for CM's Prosecution
- BJP Core Committee to Chart out Plans Against Governor
- Decision on Yeddyurappa's Prosecution in Two Days, Says Bhardwaj
- Yeddy Meets Karnataka Congress Chief Dr Parameshwara in Delhi
- Yeddyurappa Rushes to Delhi for Consulting BJP High Command
- Governor Studying Request for Prosecuting CM, Minister