Bantwal: Is Shambhoor on Way to Become Another Neerakatte?


Bantwal: Is Shambhoor on Way to Become Another Neerakatte?

News and Pics from Mounesh Vishwakarma
for Daijiworld Media Network - Bantwal (RD/CN)

Bantwal, Aug 20:  With memories of the Neerakatte hydel plant tragedy still fresh, residents living along the embankment of Shamboor Madimugeru, are concerned for their safety since the vented dam under construction across the Netravati River in their locality, has already developed cracks.

Portions of the vented dam have even collapsed. Cracks have been found at Neerakatte and also at the site of the Shamboor power project where barrier walls erected at two locations, have been washed away. Fortunately, there has been no loss of life due to this.

Just a few days ago, six workers perished in the flood waters which invaded the turbine room at Neerakatte. Work here stalled after incessant rains lashed Dakshina Kannada and Udupi districts over the past few weeks. Construction labourers have been temporarily relocated to safer areas.

The Shamboor power project began three years ago, despite opposition from the locals who had no information about the project. They expressed their anguish over the execution of the project, in a gram sabha held at Narikombu gram panchayat auditorium, recently. Several houses in the vicinity of the project were damaged as the contractors used dynamites to blast the boulders at the site.

Project officers had surveyed the damage in the presence of locals, at the insistence of MLA Ramanath Rai. The survey report revealed that the blasts had damaged over 200 houses, bore wells, places of worship, and agricultural holdings.

Poor quality of work is thought to have caused portions of the vented dam to collapse. Although three quarters of the work on the vented dam with a height of around 18 metres and length of 300 metres has been completed, the quality of work seems deplorable. The dam has 30 vents of six metres height each and a major tragedy has been averted as these vents were kept open.

Also Read:

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • sunil, bantwal

    Thu, Aug 21 2008

    The great Visveshrayya built great KRS dam and still its serving without any problem.with serious note I am mentioning not only the dam underquality work.the construction of fly over on NH 48 also going to be disastourous when it will  be  ready.

    You can see every where on nh 48 incompleatet work which is contributing rusting of steel.which can cause serious damage to the ductility of the pillars. This is the time for the officials to wake up and save the country.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • vincy, Shamboor/Bangkok

    Fri, Aug 22 2008

    It is true that the Shamboor hydel power project began three years ago and on the process of completion now. The results affecting the ecology and the village is visible in the pictures here. The land was acquired without revealing the features of the project.The major portion of land they bought was totally agricultural. The land owners where called for a meeting at local panchayat office and then for a so called negotiations where the price was decided the by the influential people who made these land owners as scapegoat.

    Each land owner was given money and two houses built by the project developers to move them from the project area. The people who attend the meeting for the compensation was not represented by any expert in the damage repair control measuers.They were invited to come and sign the documents to claim the value of the land. Till date, the people of shamboor have no information about the features of this power project. And no such court orders passed to approve the deal to acquire the agricultural land. The Hydel project owners were authorized from the central government who acquire, build and transfer or sell the project are totally a business affair between the big players from Andhra Pradesh who came to shamboor and acquired hundreds of acres of agricultural farms and started polluting this village. They used dynamites to break the rocks beneath sacred nethravati river. The tremors have damaged houses, temples, church and the ecology of the nature. On this process of construction, they used the single narrow road from NH48 at Pane-Mangalore to shamboor which further goes to Balthila and connect NH 48 at Dasakodi near Borimar.

    The entire stretch from Pane-Mangalore-to shamboor was ruined due to the heavy trucks and engines moved to the site through this road. The local political parties did noting but only showed enemity each other on silly issues and never interested in looking at the basic issues of safety of the project and safety to people who reside nearby the Hydel project. During Mid of June 2008, there was no bus transport possible on this road and people suffered a lot as the chikengunia was spread all over and people could not go the city to take medication on time. There are reports that, the company who built this Hydel project will be selling it to the highest bidder and the people of shamboor have to run from pillar to pillar if anything goes wrong with their safety in the village.

    There could be excess floods and can damage the crop in the monsoons and no such provisions available to claim damages. The state and central government will come up with strange projects now and then because they are approached by influential rich businessmen who want to invest in our villages with less compensation .They get approvals to pay minimum price for the land at the value fixed by the corrupt officials at the land and revenue departments.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • vincy, Shamboor/Bangkok

    Thu, Aug 21 2008

    It is true that the Shamboor hydel power project began three years ago and on the process of completion now. The results affecting the ecology and the village is visible in the pictures here. The land was acquired without revealing the features of the project.The major portion of land they bought was totally agricultural. The land owners where called for a meeting at local panchayat office and then for a so called negotiations where the price was decided the by the influential people who made these land owners as scapegoat.

    Each land owner was given money and two houses built by the project developers to move them from the project area. The people who attend the meeting for the compensation was not represented by any expert in the damage repair control measuers.They were invited to come and sign the documents to claim the value of the land. Till date, the people of shamboor have no information about the features of this power project. And no such court orders passed to approve the deal to acquire the agricultural land.

    The Hydel project owners were authorized from the central government who acquire, build and transfer or sell the project are totally a business affair between the big players from Andhra Pradesh who came to shamboor and acquired hundreds of acres of agricultural farms and started polluting this village. They used dynamites to break the rocks beneath sacred nethravati river. The tremors have damaged houses, temples, church and the ecology of the nature.

    On this process of construction, they used the single narrow road from NH48 at Pane-Mangalore to shamboor which further goes to Balthila and connect NH 48 at Dasakodi near Borimar. The entire stretch from Pane-Mangalore-to shamboor was ruined due to the heavy trucks and engines moved to the site through this road. The local political parties did noting but only showed enemity each other on silly issues and never interested in looking at the basic issues of safety of the project and safety to people who reside nearby the Hydel project. During Mid of June 2008, there was no bus transport possible on this road and people suffered a lot as the chikengunia was spread all over and people could not go the city to take medication on time.

    There are reports that, the company who built this Hydel project will be selling it to the highest bidder and the people of shamboor have to run from pillar to pillar if anything goes wrong with their safety in the village. There could be excess floods and can damage the crop in the monsoons and no such provisions available to claim damages. The state and central government will come up with strange projects now and then because they are approached by influential rich businessmen who want to invest in our villages with less compensation .They get approvals to pay minimum price for the land at the value fixed by the corrupt officials at the land and revenue departments.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Robert Mathias, Mangalore/Kuwait

    Thu, Aug 21 2008

    It always happens in india they build brdges and dams with good intentions but due to corruption these projects die in the birth stage itself, and no action is taken against the corrupt officials involved in such disasters

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Wolly James, Mangalore/Germany

    Thu, Aug 21 2008

    There should be some panel who could check these big blunders. India at one side wants to boast become a super power by 2025 but are not able to construct a damm of a small size. How are we to master huge projects.

    There should be someone to investigate this blunder and take the responsible constructers/politicians who mis-uses the taxpayers money for their own benifits. Thank you, Wolly James

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Theo D'Silva, kadri, mangalore/Toronto

    Thu, Aug 21 2008

    I Still beleive that these projects are better than allowing the flow of water(Natural Resource) to sea. But build the damms with Good Steel/Concrete and Good Engineers. and Build Resorvoirs to divert the excess water. Thanks, Theo.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Wilson Pinto, Shamboor/Bangkok

    Thu, Aug 21 2008

    Good news coverage from Daijiworld.. with pictures .really appreciated .

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Bantwal: Is Shambhoor on Way to Become Another Neerakatte?



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.