Daijiworld Media Network - Kundapur (MS)
Kundapur, Jan 28: The police department has a filed a case against a lady, whose video of her argument with traffic policemen during the vehicle check at Hemmady has gone viral on social media.
On January 21, ASI Tharanath was conducting vehicle check in his highway patrol vehicle on the national highway near Hemmady. During this check, they stopped a car driven by Shanti Picardo, who was going from Kundapur to Byndoor as she was not wearing the seat belt. She was asked to pay a fine of Rs 500 for not wearing the seat belt. However, instead of paying the fine, Shanti Picardo argued with the traffic cops of taking bribe and did not allow the cops to check her vehicle documents.
In the complaint filed by the police against Shanti Picardo they have alleged that she did not allow her vehicle to be checked and thereby caused obstruction to the duty of government personnel. She did not even accept the notice, which was served on her under the Motor Vehicles Act. In addition, the whole episode, including her abuse to the police and accusing them of trying to mint money is videographed and made viral on the social media, thereby making the police to lose their self-confidence and morale.
Comment on this article
Flora Dsouza, kalmady/Jerimeri-Mumbai
Tue, Jan 28 2020Well done my friend Shanti... Hats off to you..... you have handled the situation boldly... Come on keep it up... You are a role model to many now..... Dont worry.. I pray for you....
DisAgree [2] Agree [15] Reply Report Abuse
Kudla Stories, Kudla
Tue, Jan 28 2020This is absolute hypocrisy from the police department. If the cops were right why didnt they object and clarify right on the spot. They too had mobile phones to shoot a video. These guys are known for taking bribes. Even in padubidre there is one such gang of coos making money from truckers and it is a well known secret. Oh God where are we headed. So the cops are free to ask for bribe but we arent free to protest or videograph them. And moreover if taken to task, file a false case on us. Wow. Exemplary case of dictatorship.
DisAgree [3] Agree [25] Reply Report Abuse
Sha, Udupi
Tue, Jan 28 2020In UAE no one will argue with police. If anyone argues than immediately they will show the photos of which place,what time you committed the crime. Here you can't say lady is completely wrong. In court also they want proof. Does police caught her red handed. Just they stopped the car and asked her money. Policemen is busy sitting in car giving penalty Bill's.
DisAgree [1] Agree [24] Reply Report Abuse
prem, moodbidri
Tue, Jan 28 2020It is simple... if Shanthi Madam was at fault, she wouldn't have recorded video. She would have just paid fine or argued with police and disappeared from there without paying fine!
People commit mistake, don't dare to take video or photo, which can be used as proof at later stage!
Here, it clearly looks, she is right and hence while seeing at mobile camera, police looks nervous! To avoid further shame from video going viral, police now trying for action, to save face!!!
DisAgree [1] Agree [31] Reply Report Abuse
Arunkumar, Kundapur
Tue, Jan 28 2020Its the 100% Gundagiri by police man trying to loot the common people. Police man are always well prepared to these kind of situations. They know how to trap innocent people. We common people sometimes find it difficult to prove our self that we are following all traffic rules. And now the police case against the lady - kind of additional burden to her.
DisAgree [6] Agree [83] Reply Report Abuse
ummar, mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020in video its clear that lady wear seat belt even police accepted in video, this is regular practice of police so need to stop this type illegal collecting money for people
now police will create some story now and case file against her.
DisAgree [7] Agree [87] Reply Report Abuse
Sudesh pai, MANIPAL
Tue, Jan 28 2020Biggest proof she has not shown photo of her wearing seat belt this will surely reflect her
DisAgree [15] Agree [6] Reply Report Abuse
Shan, Udupi
Tue, Jan 28 2020In future we have sit in car take selfies when you are seat belt, than show that selfies to public and police that you are wearing seat belt.
DisAgree Agree [10] Reply Report Abuse
sundeep, Mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020I agree with you satya, apart from paying lakhs of rupees to secure the job. They also have to achieve a target from each police station , which has to be given to the ministry of home ETC.
DisAgree [5] Agree [60] Reply Report Abuse
Nelson Dsouza, Mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020Hard to say whos at fault since either could be making a story here
DisAgree [8] Agree [27] Reply Report Abuse
Oliver, Udupi
Tue, Jan 28 2020I think the police are at fault for the following reasons
1) If she wasn't wearing a her seat belt, the police can give her a ticket and she does not have to pay it on the spot. that is definitely considered a bribe. In this case the police were forcing her to pay the ticket on the spot.
2) She was stopped for a seat belt violation, why are they searching her car? that is how the police harass civilians all the time.
DisAgree Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse
AM, Mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020Why police raise complaint after the video goes viral. If the law has been respected by the lady they should have take action that day itself. By the way to inspect the lady driven car there should be lady cop on duty. It looks like face off action by the police to save their respect which is in the wind these days
DisAgree [1] Agree [67] Reply Report Abuse
Satya, Mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020In western countries they have an internal affairs department to investigate corrupt officers within the force. The Police there are more scared of Internal affairs than any outside agency. In India we have nothing of that kind. When any corrupt act takes place another corrupt officer is appointed to hush up matters on the pretext of investigating. There is a huge rush for the posts of inspectors and lakhs are paid as bribes to get appointed. Therefore one can guess how honest a person can be who has paid a huge bribe to get the post in the first place. We often hear of police reforms but no politician is interested in working towards reforms in the police department. Presently our police officers are poorly paid and poorly trained. The conditions of their living quarters is pathetic and it is difficult for most of them to make ends meet with the salaries they are paid. Until all these issues are addressed our police forces will remain so, despised by the public and abandoned by the political masters.
DisAgree [1] Agree [41] Reply Report Abuse
Mohit, Mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020These irresponsible police should be stripped off from their duty and put behind bars for demanding bribe and harrassing a woman driver in the middle of the Road.
Mera Desh Badal Raha hai for a Good Reason.
DisAgree [7] Agree [62] Reply Report Abuse
peshu, Manipal
Tue, Jan 28 2020Madam, Shanti Pikardo... everything is fine but you missed to document one thing.
You Should have documented a with pic with Seat Belt on... in my opinion, you would have benefited with solid proof..
DisAgree [8] Agree [42] Reply Report Abuse
Cynthia Goveas, Karnataka
Tue, Jan 28 2020These Police should have Shame they cannot handle silly matter I feel they have their guilty attitude made them to raised the complaint
DisAgree [8] Agree [76] Reply Report Abuse
Anil, Dubai
Tue, Jan 28 2020Police knew that its their mistake … hence they filed the fake care against that lady … !!
(first off all where is lady police ..?… if you want to inspect/ check the ladies driven vehicle lady police should be on duty…)
“its happening very often in kundapura region …harassing of vehicle owners without no reason in some incidence”
The police are standing some corner of HN 66 (in kundapura division), even they stand inner road of state highways (namely few.... towards from hemmady to kollur road, mullikatte junction, talluru junction, towards from moorukai to siddapura road, towards from koteshwara to halady road, near kumbashi etc)
DisAgree [9] Agree [83] Reply Report Abuse
Anil, Dubai
Tue, Jan 28 2020*Police knew that its their mistake … hence they filed the fake "case" against that lady … !!
DisAgree [5] Agree [62] Reply Report Abuse
Rao, Udupi
Tue, Jan 28 2020Lady should file a case against police for demanding bribe.
It looks lady was right in arguing.
DisAgree [6] Agree [118] Reply Report Abuse
Jossey Saldanha, Mumbai
Tue, Jan 28 2020Policeman's Mistake ...
DisAgree [13] Agree [95] Reply Report Abuse
KR, Mangaluru
Tue, Jan 28 2020Cooked up story by Police.
DisAgree [6] Agree [93] Reply Report Abuse
ramesh, mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020I feel the lady was right on her part... in the video it clearly shows...need proper judgement.
DisAgree [11] Agree [101] Reply Report Abuse
Ivan D'Souza, Chikmagalur/Muscat
Tue, Jan 28 2020why police filed a case against her ?
Reason : they knew that the lady filmed the entire show of what had happened , that's why before it goes viral , they have files case against her . Shame on you police . if you the see the video , all the police out there had nothing to say , and we can hear her saying i have given you all the documents, then whats issue . i feel the police at fault not the lady.
DisAgree [7] Agree [94] Reply Report Abuse
moshu, mangaluru
Tue, Jan 28 2020We are discussing hypothetically which is unfair.
DisAgree [4] Agree [27] Reply Report Abuse
Cynthia, Kirem
Tue, Jan 28 2020I too saw the video... Habbbaaa😆😆
DisAgree [2] Agree [46] Reply Report Abuse
JC, Mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020If you see in the video, the Lady has come to the Police Vehicle and given the documents. I believe if any checking is to be done, the police has to go to the vehicle which he has stopped and check all the documents as done in the Gulf and Other Countries.
DisAgree [1] Agree [43] Reply Report Abuse
Ahmed K. C., Mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020Does anybody know if the Highway Patrol vehicle have duty on the inner roads ????
DisAgree [4] Agree [61] Reply Report Abuse
Ahmed K. C., Mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020But, the police in the video looks bit nervous.
DisAgree [9] Agree [107] Reply Report Abuse
Ina Carmelita D'Souza, Mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020The way shanthi Picardo is defending herself looks she is true to her word. Nobody will get such courage and high pitch without a reason. The Police Dept. ruined her peaceful nature .
DisAgree [11] Agree [105] Reply Report Abuse
Kiran, Mangalore/ Delhi
Tue, Jan 28 2020Good initiative madam ... we all have to fight against corruption but it’s not that easy in India especially Mangalore and Udupi .
Police officials act as those are Rule Makers . Surprising is IAS and IPS are won’t take any action against these none of these officials are aware about to CMVR /AI norms and standards .
DisAgree [2] Agree [36] Reply Report Abuse
SBM, Mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020Reminds me of "ELU NEENU" incident
DisAgree [7] Agree [27] Reply Report Abuse
Sanjay, Hebri
Tue, Jan 28 2020Even i have seen that vedio, i think the lady didn't violate any laws or obstruct duty police...fining people with all correct documents and no violation is wrong, the inspector should be transferred to records division permanently.
DisAgree [8] Agree [100] Reply Report Abuse
Rehna, Mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020The police should take a photograph whether the seat belt is worn or not or how they can prove. There are chances of making money by simply saying seat belt if not worn and fleecing money from the vehicle owners. Here we can't trust the cops. Some lawyers should go to the court and bring an order to prove specific proof against not wearing seat belts and using mobile while driving.
DisAgree [4] Agree [77] Reply Report Abuse
Sanjay, Hebri
Tue, Jan 28 2020Problem is we have to prove it in court that we were wearing seatbelt, not speeding above limit....if we argue with judge, he will impose more and more fine.....we live in British raj judiciary even after so many years of independence.
DisAgree Agree [21] Reply Report Abuse
James, Bendur
Tue, Jan 28 2020I don't see any mistake from the lady.
DisAgree [12] Agree [96] Reply Report Abuse
Sanjay, Hebri
Tue, Jan 28 2020Only hope...you are the judge in who's court this case will come...
DisAgree [10] Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse
Dev, Mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020The video shows she arguing with them why they didn't come & inspect her car after she stopped it, how come they cut a challan of not wearing seat belt....etc.
She asked the police to hand over her documents back & they said they have given it back to other person with her, which proves they have filed a fake case.
The intention of police is to harass her by filing this case which always takes many appearances in court & if video evidence is taken police case will fall through.
Time our police vehicles & police too carry a video camera recording all interaction with traffic as well as the arguments to present to the court in case such a situation arises.
If anybody argue for wrong penalty then it is not obstruction of duty but harassment of vehicle owners which many videos exposing with camera phones with all.
DisAgree [6] Agree [81] Reply Report Abuse
Eliyas, Mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020Common people very difficult to have vehicle and drive on road and peace of mind because of this kind scared situation...simply she could pay 500 ,now see how difficult with out any mistake she have to suffer...Court to home home to court instead making vedio should pay 500 is Better ..now we running with money not perfection of rules....only money make's peace of mind.....two month back I was traveling with my family Balehonnur to Mangalore in forest police people standing and all document with seat belt all is clear they asked me to pay 500 I questioned they said pay for co passenger not weard seat belt I am not paid they given receipt and I paid in court its horrible waiting in court oh god....then after I decided if any police catch what they give and come simply..better
DisAgree [18] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse
Richard, India
Tue, Jan 28 2020Our country has become so corrupt because of selfish people who just want to pay and save trouble for themselves. What they fail to understand is that by paying they are becoming a part of the corrupt system. Fighting corruption is not easy, there is always a price to pay but each time a person fights he adds value to the noble cause.
Shame on people who just pay and keep quite and also promote those tactics.
DisAgree Agree [15] Reply Report Abuse
Avinash, Ksd/Bluru
Tue, Jan 28 2020She should have allowed the cops to check the vehicle documents. Secondly, if she was not wearing the seat belt then its her mistake.
Now she need to roam around the court.
DisAgree [40] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse
Rakesh Dsouza, Mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020Watch the video again sir!
DisAgree [1] Agree [37] Reply Report Abuse
Anand R, Mangalore
Tue, Jan 28 2020India is a land of much such nonsense who never wants a law to abide.
DisAgree [11] Agree [12] Reply Report Abuse
Jossey Saldanha, Mumbai
Tue, Jan 28 2020Police will get in trouble ...
DisAgree [5] Agree [44] Reply Report Abuse