Udupi: Free Eye Camp Proves Costly - Eight Lose Vision After Surgery


Udupi: Free Eye Camp Proves Costly - Eight Lose Vision After Surgery

Sheeja Moodubelle
Pics: Silvester D'Souza
Daijiworld Media Network – Udupi
 
Udupi, Aug 21:
A free cataract surgery eye camp organized by Charmakki Narayana Shetty Lions (CNSL) Eye Hospital at Kota in Udupi district in the first week of August, has resulted in as many as eight persons getting infected and losing their vision. One of them even lost his life due to cardiac arrest reportedly brought about as a result of the surgery.
 
The deceased is Narasimha Shetty (72), a resident of Airody village. Shetty passed away on August 2 at KMC, Manipal.

Dr Ramachandra Bairy, DHO, said that stress caused owing to evisceration surgery might be one of the reasons for the cardiac arrest. "However, the surgery cannot be directly accounted for the death, as it is an operation done to remove the dead tissues from the eye balls to prevent the spreading of the infection to the brain tissue," he explained.
 
He added that contamination of the solution used for the surgery or eye drops used during post-operative care may have caused the infection in all 8 patients. As many as 38 patients were operated in the free medical camps.
 
All the eight patients were diagnosed with serious eye infections and admitted to KMC Manipal. One of them was shifted to Prasad Nethralaya in Udupi. There are few chances that they would recover their vision completely, the DHO said.
 
"When we inspected the operation theater where the 38 people were operated, it was clean and infection-free, the same hospital has operated as many as 15 patients for cataract problems on August 6. All are recovering and there are no problems," he added.
 
"We have sent our eye surgeon of the Mobile Ophthalmic Unit to visit the patients in KMC. Besides, samples of the solution will be sent to KMC and also to the district hospital lab for cross checking, he added.
 
DHO also said that as the operation had taken place more than 15 days ago, it is hard to find the causes of infection and the result of the cross-checking of the eye solution used may not be accurate.

Whatever the case or the cause, the ultimate losers are the patients. One of them who only had blurred vision before undergoing cataract surgery at the camp has now become completely blind in the left eye. His son said that he had visited the camp because his glasses broke, and he was told to undergo the surgery. The son of another patient told daijiworld that his mother developed pain after the surgery, when the hospital examined her, they said everything was normal. However, at night she developed severe pain again and was later shifted to KMC, where it was found that she was infected.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Max, Mangalore/Bahrain

    Wed, Aug 22 2012

    Dear Mr. Luis/Kuwait,

    If one of your family member have gone through this situation have reacted the same way?, a person had lost his vision and blind for life can you imagine that? just put yourself in the shoes then write a comment, may be for you eyes are not so important like a mole, but for these workers that is thier bread and butter more than a mountain!!!! First analyze the seriousness then wirte, doing good for less money doesn,t compensate with blindness dear!!!!!!!

    DisAgree Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • Louis, Kuwait

    Wed, Aug 22 2012

    This hospital gives good service for the poor people. Once in blue moon such things happens. Shout not be a big issue. It's run by Lions club. Operation costs are low compared to other hospitals, who are minting money. No need to make mountain out of a mole.

    DisAgree [9] Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse

  • satish, Kota

    Wed, Aug 22 2012

    Fourth, management succeeded in keeping the local newspaper (Udayavani) publishing this article in the front page.
    Dear friends, we all support this kind charitable organization and good intention behind that. The way the management and doctors handled this incident was reprehensible and disheartening. Truth should be revealed and culprits should be punished. Most of the victims are old and poor and they should be properly compensated with transparency. Real question we should ask ourselves is “what if it was my eye”?

    DisAgree [1] Agree [12] Reply Report Abuse

  • Satish, Kota

    Wed, Aug 22 2012

    Living in suburb of Kota and having seen this incident very closely, I would say the article title is misleading. First the cataract surgery offered by the facility neither was free nor it was a camp. It is a fully equipped eye hospital which was donated by C.N Shetty and managed, operated by Kota Lions club. Hospital has performed many surgeries successfully with minimum cost to patients. With that reputation, hospital has attracted many patients from costal Karnataka became very famous eye hospital in short period of time.
    With the recent change in the management and their lack of knowledge in field of medicine and surgery has created conflicts with Doctors. Due to that reason, founding surgeon left this institute and the hospital was left with incompetent and ignorant doctors. After the surgery, everyone called the hospital reporting itchiness, fever and red eye problem, doctors responded to them saying it is normal and told them to wait for week. When the problem persisted more than a week and infection starting to spread to brain, doctors started panicking and directed the patients to nearby hospitals.
    Though the reason the eye infection after surgery is still a speculation, management has done a good job in damage control. First, they directed to patients to different nearby hospitals so that patient could feel that it is an individual case rather than a victim of a malpractice. Second, when many patients admitted to Manipal, they started talking to individual patients and started offering them monetary compensation (to cover hospital bills) and told them not to disclose the issue to media and other people. Third, they try to stop government health officials who insisted to conduct an enquiry on this matter with the political influence. Management team met our minister Srinivas Poojary, and requested him to stop all further enquires and reinstate the hospital normal operation. continue reading...

    DisAgree [3] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • Satish, Kota

    Wed, Aug 22 2012

    Living in suburb of Kota and having seen this incident very closely, I would say the article title is misleading. First the cataract surgery offered by the facility neither was free nor it was a camp. It is a fully equipped eye hospital which was donated by C.N Shetty and managed, operated by Kota Lions club. Hospital has performed many surgeries successfully with minimum cost to patients. With that reputation, hospital has attracted many patients from costal Karnataka became very famous eye hospital in short period of time.

    With the recent change in the management and their lack of knowledge in field of medicine and surgery has created conflicts with Doctors. Due to that reason, founding surgeon left this institute and the hospital was left with incompetent and ignorant doctors. After the surgery, everyone called the hospital reporting itchiness, fever and red eye problem, doctors responded to them saying it is normal and told them to wait for week. When the problem persisted more than a week and infection starting to spread to brain, doctors started panicking and directed the patients to nearby hospitals.

    Though the reason the eye infection after surgery is still a speculation, management has done a good job in damage control. First, they directed to patients to different nearby hospitals so that patient could feel that it is an individual case rather than a victim of a malpractice. Second, when many patients admitted to Manipal, they started talking to individual patients and started offering them monetary compensation (to cover hospital bills) and told them not to disclose the issue to media and other people. Third, they try to stop government health officials who insisted to conduct an enquiry on this matter with the political influence. Management team met our minister Srinivas Poojary, and requested him to stop all further enquires and reinstate the hospital normal operation. continue reading...

    DisAgree [1] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • Juliet Mascarenhas, Bejai/Mangalore

    Wed, Aug 22 2012

    Most Unfortunate.
    If these persons had taken paid treatment and faced the same problem whom they would have blamed?
    Their fate, god, Doctors, Nurses ,Hospital ?

    DisAgree [1] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • Evans Christopher Sumitra, Udupi/New York, USA

    Wed, Aug 22 2012

    I am surprised how this happened. These days cataract surgery is a minor one and it takes less than 30 minutes for the whole procedure. I had cataract surgery on both eyes and I am fine. With this kind of incident other people who have cataract will be scared to go for surgery.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • Esthela Vaz, Pangala/London

    Wed, Aug 22 2012

    While the fact stands that every surgery has complications, something like contamination of a solution is unacceptable.

    However, this camp was completely free to help out the poorest of people, and to have a 78% success rate is amazing nonetheless.

    I wish good luck to this camp, and feel that the good that has been done has been overlooked due to some unfortunate incidents, despite the pros far outweighing the cons.

    DisAgree [4] Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Leslie fernandes, Brahmagiri, Udupi

    Wed, Aug 22 2012

    DEAR MR. QUADROS,
    I AGREE WITH YOUR VIEWS.
    THIS IS VERY UNFORTUNATE TO HAPPEN.
    PEOPLE LOOSING EYESIGHT IS A VERY SAD NEWS AND MY SYMPATHIES TO ALL THOSE SUFFERED.
    POST OPERATION CARE WHICH NORMALLY HAPPENS IN THE HOMES OF PATIENTS IS OF PARAMOUNT IMPORTANCE FOR THE RECOVERY AND STABILIZATION OF SIGHT.
    WE CAN NOT BLAME THE OPERATION PROCEDURE WHICH IS OFTEN BRIEF AND METICULOUSLY PERFORMED.
    WE MUST ALL ENCOURAGE THIS SELFLESS INSTITUTION TO KEEP GOING AND PERFORM EYE SAVING OPERATIONS IN DAYS AND YEARS TO COME.

    DisAgree Agree [6] Reply Report Abuse

  • SIMON, KUWAIT / MLORE

    Tue, Aug 21 2012

    Very sad news.
    I would request people not to save on money thus risking their eyes. DR. KISHORE KUMAR OF MANGALORE Nursing Home is really very good. Hopefully he can still restore sight into the blind.

    DisAgree Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • Jeevan, Kallianpur

    Tue, Aug 21 2012

    Even my grandmother got operated in same hospital and had same problem.

    DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • Jossey Saldanha, Mangalore/Mapusa/Mumbai

    Tue, Aug 21 2012

    Check the credentials of these doctors...........

    DisAgree [1] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • A.QUADROS, KUNDAPUR

    Tue, Aug 21 2012

    It's quite unfortunate that we hear such sad news relating to Kota Lions Eye Hospital. Being a local resident and I know this Eye Hospital has done yeomen service to the poor over a decade without a single incident of misfortune in their procedure through qualified Doctors and Nursing staff. The staff of this hospital has traveled to remote villages where eye care felicities are beyond poor peoples reach, just to conduct eye camps and restore eye sight to such less privileged people. Those who needed urgent attention were brought to the hospital for free cataract surgery including glasses and were sent back home paying their traveling and food expenses.

    When someone does good work, devil always finds way to tarnish the image. It may have so happened from someone from some where.

    May God Bless this institute.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [16] Reply Report Abuse

  • P Shirish Hosabettu, Muscat, Mangalore

    Tue, Aug 21 2012

    Be careful,most of such medical camp are just a training camp for Medical students. One of my relatives wife lost her voice due to removal of Teeth in free medical camp & later she lost her life.

    Always when ever you go for free treatmetn or free food samples think twice before try.

    Organisers never accept their mistakes.

    DisAgree Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • Max, Mangalore/Bahrain

    Tue, Aug 21 2012

    Dear Dr. Ramchandra, I dont know about surgery and Medical, one thing you tell me you have taken the vision of these people, they would have lived without operation but now dying or completely blind with your surgery.Is any one check the authenticity of his medical certification? lot of bogus doctors are in the market and the results are visible. He sould be punished eye for eye, lets make him blind! Ye camp nahi hota to kitna acha hota?

    DisAgree Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr Kiran VSA, Udupi

    Tue, Aug 21 2012

    Its sad to note this unwanted side effect of surgery. Probably lack of sterile conditions during the camp. Eye surgeries are dangerous of precautions are followed. Dr Modi was infamous for these kind of camp surgeries.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [21] Reply Report Abuse

  • Arun, dubai

    Tue, Aug 21 2012

    Nowdays Doctors only aim is to make money..they dont care about peoples health...Old doctors where far better than new once...

    DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • Richard, Mangalore

    Tue, Aug 21 2012

    There are many natural and safe methods available today to treat eye problems. One can try these alternative treatment methods to avoid surgery.

    DisAgree Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • ISMAIL.K.PERINJE, PERINJE-YANBU/KSA

    Tue, Aug 21 2012

    Very unfortunate incident.Since it is free EYE CAMP, hard to accuse any particular charity institution or particular EYE Doc.Some are some thing terribly gone wrong which should be documented for the future service of EYE related medical services.Important thing is the solution(contaminated) or eye s (expired?)used in the process.Therefore, in this angle, action could be taken for the negligence.When mas medical service made available to the public by NGOs,they should make sure every precaution was taken for the safety of the patients and every thing is in order.

    DisAgree Agree [3] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dinesh Poojary, Kundapura/Bengaluru

    Tue, Aug 21 2012

    Heart breaking news..

    I had taken my father to this hospital for eye check up in 2010. But it was not for free. We were happy with their treatment.

    Now people should be careful about free eye camp, blood donation camp (who knows if they change the syringe), health check up etc.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Udupi: Free Eye Camp Proves Costly - Eight Lose Vision After Surgery



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.