Mumbai: Church demands ban on play for hurting religious sentiments


Mumbai, Oct 3 (PTI): Catholic Church in India has demanded ban on the play 'Agnes of God', an adaptation of American playwright John Pielmeier's drama about a nun giving birth to a dead child, alleging it is a "wrongful portrayal" of priests and nuns committed to a life of celibacy and hurts the sentiments of the Christians.

According to the Catholic Bishops Conference of India (CBCI), the play "is the wrongful portrayal of the character of lakhs of clergy, who are committed to a life of celibacy".

"We have written to Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis and also other Chief Ministers to ban the play as it hurts religious sentiments," Catholic Secular Forum (CSF) general secretary Joseph Dias told PTI here today.

He, however, said the CSF has no plan to obstruct the upcoming performance of the play in Mumbai.

"There is no question of halting that performance as it is to be staged before an invited audience at the National Centre for the Performing Arts (NCPA, though it was originally planned at Sophia hall," Dias said.

"The play has been made by a group whose earlier work was 'Vagina Monologues'. They are not Christians and they did not involve or consult the Church. The play questions the sacrifice of nuns. Now, they will sell the tickets for hundreds of rupees," Dias said.

The CBCI, the body of Catholic bishops in the country, has written to Union Home Ministry seeking a countrywide ban on the play holding that it was "misrepresentation of the religious belief of the Christian community".

"The reason why the Catholic Church is against such a play is that it is the wrongful portrayal of the character of lakhs of our clergy, who are committed to a life of celibacy," the CBCI letter said.

Director of the play, Kaizaad Kotwal, has approached police to pursue his plea seeking protection for himself and the lead cast including thespian actor Mahabanoo Mody-Kotwal.

The play is an adaptation of a 1982 Broadway production by Pielmeier, reportedly based on a true incident in the US, narrating the story of a novice nun who gives birth and insists that the child was the result of a virgin conception.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • ANIKETH, mumbai

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    Anything which hurt the sentiments of the people should be stopped. But unfortunately with hindu society this is not happening. If they talk against they will be called harsh. People like to make fun of hindu people sentiments.

    DisAgree [6] Agree [6] Reply Report Abuse

  • diago, Mumbai/Mangalore

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    Jossey,

    For the first time i agree with you. If we do it these people will coming running at us.

    DisAgree [5] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • John, Udupi

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    If my catholic church and faith can be destroyed by just a single film, then be it!. I am not interested to be associated with such a weak faith. We should not follow religions that thrive on ban's and violence!.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • sam, world

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    @John, Udupi
    "If my catholic church and faith can be destroyed by just a single film, then be it!"
    - The Church cannot be destroyed because Our Lord instituted it.
    - The problem with watching, reading heretical movies, novels, etc. is that it promotes sin, impure thoughts, etc.
    - Can one remain in the state of grace if we allow sin to remain within us?
    - Pray for those (this includes Christians and non-Christians) who offend Our Lord and Our Lady and for their hearts to change

    DisAgree [4] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • oliver, udupi

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    it must be banned.

    DisAgree [4] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • Aam Indian, Mlore/Bahrain

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    I fail to understand why anyone should ban anything. The ban gives extra publicity to the movie or play. No adverse publicity against Christian faith has ever survived because this faith was created by God Himself. Nothing can influence or shake a true follower of Christ and if it does, he cannot be one. Therefore I think these plays followed by bans are only helping the producer and directors themselves and they are the one who are creating these controversies and the media is adding fuel to this fire for they get a good masala to cover these stories.please ignore this play and most of all ignore the channels who are running this news. I feel the church should not involve themselves in this silly matters. More you protest, better it works for the play.

    DisAgree [3] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • Alphonsa Rodrigues, Udupi

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    Its just a play, lets not make it an issue.

    DisAgree [3] Agree [9] Reply Report Abuse

  • Anirudh P, Bangalore

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    Bryan, Bahrain

    You don't have to do so much of chest thumping saying you have forgiven them.

    When an opposite person is 100% correct and you have realised that you're not left with anything to counter it so keep quiet. This act cannot be called as forgiving....

    DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

  • Jossey Saldanha, Mumbai

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    Tum kare tho Chamatkar...

    DisAgree [12] Agree [11] Reply Report Abuse

  • Vinod Climes, Mumbai

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    Hum kare to Chamatkar woh kare to Balatkar. Jossy you are Chatur Ramalingsm of Daiji readers

    DisAgree [1] Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse

  • Anirudh P, Bangalore

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    Jossey Saldanha, MumbaiSunday,

    Are you not doing balatkaar on the produces and director of the play by demanding the ban on play ?

    And You expect us to call it Chamtkaar ?

    DisAgree [8] Agree [19] Reply Report Abuse

  • alwin, mangalore

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    All religious heads pinpoint others.All religious heads improve your life style and change according to religious dogmas. Even wild negative publicity will not impact any one.The god and principles one and same to whole mankind.There is no religion but one god.The religious leader for their sake create religions.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [6] Reply Report Abuse

  • sid, mangalore

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    When it comes to others these guys love it and can make movies out of it , now they cant take it . so much for secularism

    DisAgree [9] Agree [28] Reply Report Abuse

  • Anirudh P, Bangalore

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    That's called pseudo-secularism

    DisAgree [9] Agree [16] Reply Report Abuse

  • vidisha, Mumbai

    Mon, Oct 05 2015

    What movies are you talking about? Name one of them, so that I can refresh my memory. So sic, don't comment just for the sake of commenting and create negativity.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Akarshad, England

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    Common its just a movie guys. there is a lot of difrence between a movie and a real life, take it as a movie. You guys cant be so mean!It must be very diffrent than PK movie. its not Indian Direction its American Direction.

    DisAgree [8] Agree [21] Reply Report Abuse

  • Jossey Saldanha, Mumbai

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    Can I also make a play and hurt ...

    DisAgree [22] Agree [15] Reply Report Abuse

  • Vinod Climes, Mumbai

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    Where is the need for a play when you habitually post to hurt? Don't play with anyone sentiments while posting.

    DisAgree [10] Agree [36] Reply Report Abuse

  • Anirudh P, Bangalore

    Sun, Oct 04 2015


    Jossey Saldanha, Mumbai

    By all means.....

    When you hurt it will be called "Freedom of Expression", "an excellent piece of art", "Liberal / rational thinking", you will be called as "BUDDI JEEVI" of this great nation.

    Entire media and SICKular brigade will stand behind you.You don't have to spend much on publicity of your play.

    Last but not the least. ... you might get an award from Karnataka Govt and Kannada Sahitya Parishat despite your play is in English.

    Please go ahead....

    DisAgree [7] Agree [24] Reply Report Abuse

  • Anirudh P, Bangalore

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    Hahaha..

    Where are our great Freedom of Expression crusaders ? You were preaching a lot to others on progressive society. Now what happened ?
    These people are truly deserve to be called as dongis, pseudo secular, Fekus & extremists.

    DisAgree [9] Agree [29] Reply Report Abuse

  • Jeevan, Mangalore/UAE

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    Why we r opposing play when its nothing about our religion nor can change our faith... Just ignore it... Take it as art not as an religion.. God Bless All

    DisAgree [8] Agree [25] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rajesh, mulky

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    to all those searching for freedom of expression supporters pls read 4th and 5 th para.the staging won't be stopped but it's content which is supposedly based on one persons account is challenged through democratic way so that lacs of clergy who lead a life of sacrifice are not insulted

    DisAgree [7] Agree [8] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rajesh, mulky

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    this is the right way to protest..,not by giving death threats or bringing mobs

    DisAgree [13] Agree [12] Reply Report Abuse

  • RSRB, Kundapura / Singapore

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    Rajesh, mulky

    When VHP gives press conference, you did no like it too...
    Please go and see your earlier comments for the peaceful protest and press conferences of VHP, RSS or even BJP...
    Stop your double standards...

    DisAgree [7] Agree [13] Reply Report Abuse

  • Charles D'Mello, Pangala

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    O.K we have to respect priests and Nuns. Many live devoted life but there are exceptions, which can not be denied...!!!??

    DisAgree [8] Agree [12] Reply Report Abuse

  • Declan, Mumbai

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    Dear Charles,
    What about 'exceptions' in other faiths too. Will they be so tolerant if sentiments of their faith were offended.
    What is this beef ban happening in one State after another ? In looking after the sentiments of your own faith do not trample upon the sentiments of the faith of others in the society.
    Respect should be mutual and not one sided.
    It is good to be forgiving but in being forgiving one should not sell their own 'self respect'.
    Remember "Love your neighbour AS YOUR SELF" !!!!!!!!!!!

    DisAgree [7] Agree [16] Reply Report Abuse

  • sam, world

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    @Declan, Mumbai
    "In looking after the sentiments of your own faith do not trample upon the sentiments of the faith of others in the society. Respect should be mutual and not one sided."
    - A given faith will always trample upon another, because the faiths contradict.
    - In the long term seeking mutual respect will not work because one cannot serve God and Mammon.
    - We pray for those (this includes Christians and non-Christians) who offend Our Lord and Our Lady and for their hearts to change.

    DisAgree [3] Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Bryan, Bahrain

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    If it was a play on a Hindu or Muslim God, by this time the director would be shot... We Catholic like to forgive, this is also freedom of speech.

    DisAgree [21] Agree [19] Reply Report Abuse

  • Don, Udupi

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    There is no reason to ban this play in a faith where Jesus Christ was crucified.
    In India, it should be banned for the reason being, it will give fodder and signal to the communal minds and vandals to go one step ahead to create more damage..

    DisAgree [6] Agree [14] Reply Report Abuse

  • JOY CASTELINO, MOODUBELLE/DUBAI

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    The Catholic Church indirectly giving publicity for the play. By demanding ban, play will not be stopped. In fact more people will get curiosity & watch play. Same thing has happened earlier like movie "SIN"!!!!!!.

    DisAgree [2] Agree [12] Reply Report Abuse

  • Rudolf Rodrigues, Mangalore/Mumbai

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    If this is a 'true life story' based on an early drama/film I 'PERSONALLY' do not think it should offend anyone, then why this DRAMA???

    IT IS HIGH TIME WE BECOME AS 'TRANSPARENT' AS POSSIBLE LEAVING ASIDE RELIGIOUS ALLEGIANCE and bring to the fore before the masses what is actually going, isn't' it!!!

    DisAgree [1] Agree [8] Reply Report Abuse

  • KRPrabhu, B'luru

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    I hail 'freedom of expression' enshrined in the Constitution.All have great respect for it and let us live with it come what may!!!
    Jai ho....murgi....
    Jai ho...,Panchasara....
    Lastly jai ho...Sab kaa Bhagavan!!!
    Yellara maneya dose tote!!!

    DisAgree [14] Agree [27] Reply Report Abuse

  • Jossey Saldanha, Mumbai

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    You can hurt my sentiments but ...

    DisAgree [7] Agree [8] Reply Report Abuse

  • Neeth, mangaluru

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    Silence of intellectuals, liberals, rationalists,seculars(are they really????) in this issue is deafening. No one asking a very popular question of the present time"Is India becoming Intolerant?"

    DisAgree [1] Agree [5] Reply Report Abuse

  • JS, Mlore

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    Banistan ????

    DisAgree Agree [4] Reply Report Abuse

  • Vikas G, Udupi

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    Activists and voices for Freedom of expression PK Amir Khan supporters ....anyone!

    DisAgree [11] Agree [44] Reply Report Abuse

  • Ramesh S, mangalore

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    ..they are angry about defaming clergy, where as several BUDDIJEEVI's openly defame Hindu GOD & call for burn book!!..and our Ministers,Celebrities share stage/give award for their creativity!!..i think there is uneasiness spreading everywhere in INDIA on duplicity/ differention by the Govt/Politicians on religious sentiments of different faith..its reaching a dangerous level..

    DisAgree [3] Agree [7] Reply Report Abuse

  • Ramakrishna Bhat, Mumbai

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    Where are those liberals who clicked yes against the false compaint by poremlata against Raghveshwara Bharathi without knowing he was framed.Agree with all liberlas moments. Please have same yardstick to clergymen of other community too. Don't write comment without knowing the topic.

    DisAgree [22] Agree [35] Reply Report Abuse

  • Shankar, Mangalore

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    WHERE ARE ALL 'PK' SUPPORTERS?

    DisAgree [17] Agree [72] Reply Report Abuse

  • krishna, canada

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    How dare u ask that.... sickularism is only for others. ...

    DisAgree [3] Agree [11] Reply Report Abuse

  • RequiemWorld, World

    Sun, Oct 04 2015

    I am Catholic,,, But i agree with ur statements.. We have dual standards....

    DisAgree [2] Agree [14] Reply Report Abuse

  • jeevan, mangalore

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    What about freedom of expression ??

    DisAgree [48] Agree [54] Reply Report Abuse

  • santhosh, mangaluru

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    Freedom of expression, liberal or rational thinking???

    DisAgree [13] Agree [64] Reply Report Abuse

  • Ramesh S, mangalore

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    .."The reason why the Catholic Church is against such a play is that it is the wrongful portrayal of the character of lakhs of our clergy, who are committed to a life of celibacy, so ban it" ..hmmm..waiting for the comments from supporters of BAGWAN/PK/SHOBHA DE/FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION/CREATIVITY so on..one thing is sure BAGWAN/SHOBHA DE like people knows that how far they may intimidate, Hindus cant be provoked easily..so they keep on saying/writing how their tongue rolls, not what their mind says..

    DisAgree [20] Agree [57] Reply Report Abuse

  • R.Bhandarkar, Mangaluru

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    "The play is an adaptation of a 1982 Broadway production by Pielmeier, reportedly based on a true incident in the US, narrating the story of a novice nun who gives birth and insists that the child was the result of a Virgin conception."
    Virgin Conception or not but must say it's 'Virgin Conceptualization'.
    For good to be known there should be bad. Simple as that.
    Do not give undue publicity to the event. You will be doing the playwright's work...
    Got the gist?

    DisAgree [15] Agree [59] Reply Report Abuse

  • R.Bhandarkar, Mangaluru

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    Whoever ..please read and understand ..o.k.It is serious.
    Don't scratch somewhere as usual and press disagree for the heck of it.

    DisAgree [13] Agree [44] Reply Report Abuse

  • Asha , Mangaluru

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    I think they are a bit late and will have to use a lot of influence to remove the same "Agnes of god" from the internet and UTUBE .

    DisAgree [8] Agree [46] Reply Report Abuse

  • Elias, Mumbai

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    Money makers even sell what ever is there. shame on them

    DisAgree [33] Agree [49] Reply Report Abuse

  • Anirudh P, Bangalore

    Sat, Oct 03 2015

    Does this apply to all those siculars and freedom of expression fighters (only when something is said against Hinduism) ?

    DisAgree [8] Agree [9] Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Mumbai: Church demands ban on play for hurting religious sentiments



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.