Divakar Nayak , Manipal

This is an brave step
There is no second openion that it is right or wrong because we shoul first of all respect our culture, our mother land.
Wether we worship cow or not that is secondary
What is our culture we have given so much importance for the cow.
See the use how it is so closely or impotant for our daily life.
We shoul thank who ever responsible for this.

DisAgree [1] Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

Glynus Miranda, Kavoor

I am advised by my doctor not to eat beef because it is fattening. I need a second advise

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Greesh Kumar, Mumbai/Bangalore

Franklin Monteiro, president, District Minority Morcha of Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) IF YOU ARE EATING DOG SO DO YOU WANT OTHERS TO EAT DOG TOO?

DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

Bulsam, Mangalore

Every year on November 24, about one million people gathered in a small village in Bariyapur, Nepal, they witness a large-scale sacrifice ceremony, tens of thousands of animals are slaughtered and the festival was widely criticized. Followers travel long distances to attend this traditional Gadhimai festival, some of the devotees who come from neighboring India. Gadhimai Festivals worship Goddess symbol of power, it hold in southern Nepal every five years

 
It is the world's largest animal slaughter festival, in the past each time, hundreds of thousands of cattle, pigs, sheep, chickens and other animals were killed in two days, this year the number is as high as 300,000. Then the crowd flock to the ground near the temple Gadhimai, there are 250 butchers waiting for the ceremony. Followers take approximate 20000 buffalo and then the animal was slaughtered.
Animal organization alleging such cruel activities ceremony is unnecessary, but the Government of Nepal refuses to prohibit this religious tradition which has already lasted for several centuries.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

VIMLA, MANGZALORE

You are right its better Mr Franklin keeps the cow in the place of altar n worship but for your kind information when he doesnt have a roof to stayhow can he have a altar. Let him clear his family politics rather than commenting on useless matters.

DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

shahnawaz kukkikatte, dubai/udupi

I very sincerely call upon my actual neighbour Mr Holla to respond and rebut my statement. The Holla who responded here is a fake one as I can make out from his statement. Secondly there are many of my hindu and muslim neighbours who witnessed this incident who will surely vouch for my statement.

For the public and press, about police complaint as stated by this proxy Holla, they can call Udupi Police Station on (0820) 2520444 to check and verify the arrest or this complaint. Please go ahead and do it now. I once again ask real Mr Holla to respond to my comments. If any one wants further authentication about my statement, which happened in the past, I shall give the phone nos of owner of the cow and persons involved in the brawl.

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

fayaz ahmed, MANGALORE/DUBAI

mr.shanwaz well said.its the fact that many of my hindu friends also have beef in my house.brahmins also have eggs,fish,chicken....here its the matter of choice and not religion....so y fight for this.let people eat what they like.DONT SNATCH FOOD FROM THE PLATES...MR.YEDDI AND HIS PARTY

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

Dave, Mangalore

Vera Alvares-mumbai- I've already made the point u have mentioned in my previous comment itslef. It proves how much every christian values this puppetry.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Raj, Udupi

Ronald, Mangalore/Ras Al khaima.......Mr. Poojary was rejected by is own caste..........only people like you who support this Congress party becuase of Sonia are saying that he is good politician........vote politics

DisAgree [1] Agree Reply Report Abuse

Dev, Mangalore

Thank u daiji for letting us read both the versions from Shahnawaz & R. Holla. If Holla hadn't done it then he would've published the thing done by shahnawaz first on this forum-'cos all Hindutva people are waiting (for him) to malign his name. But Shahnawaz seems to be on the right side of the law this time. Otherwise the police would've made the whole issue public by now if his son was arrested as R Holla claims. Please stop these personal attacks atleast on this forum-wash your dirty linen in your own backyard.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Clifford Fernandes, Mangalore

Franklin will be dumped by BJP once his usefulness is finished and they realise that he is hated by christians.

DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

Swaraj, Mangalore

Mr. Shahnawaz , Dont think all readers here are illitrates , dont create false stories and try to entertain people here. I thought you made some sense earlier ...By the way Poojary if you continue speaking like this you will never be a MP ever in your life again. Your views are really hurting us thats y the margin was 40,000 last time. Ithink u wil never realize, Bad luck

DisAgree [1] Agree Reply Report Abuse

abba, abudhabi

Mr.franklin is not representing all minorities and dalits.he is perfoming his duty.(swamy nishte) slaughtering of all animal must be banned.wether it is cow or goat or even chicken.not in karnataka but allover the world.cruelty must be stoped.

DisAgree [1] Agree Reply Report Abuse

ISMAIL K PERINJE, PERINJE/YANBU-KSA

Wait a minute!!!Who cooked the story, Mr Shanawaz Kukkikatte or Mr Holla????

Mr Franklin.M.better you convince your christian brothers rather than other monorities.You are agent of Sanghparivar and better work for upliftment your party rather than wasting time on the issue of cow slaughter.

DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

Ronald, Mangalore/Ras Al khaima

Dear Monteiro worship cow by keeping up in altar in your house . Dont advise Moily & Poojary to apoloze thier stament because they are matured in politics .Moily is honorable law minister & Poojary we really missed another union minister for that mangloreans are regreating.He is successfull ex rajya saba member, president kpcc & ex union minister. .

DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

The Guru , Mangalore

shahnawaz kukkikatte, dubai/udupi

I see in few of ur comments
your neighbour is highlight of the topic, i guess its a fake story., just to make ur comments appealing..

I feel minorities are poor people who dont have food to eat and not muslims or christian . U say u r not secular but ur comments says everything..

Actually which religion terrorise the whole world knows it afganistan , pakistan , iraq are already paying for thier acts...

I think a bill should be passed to protect all the animals not only cow..

we people speak about enviornment all those stuffs, when we cant protect the enviornment (trees , animals) then we will not be able to save this world.

No one has given us the RIGHT to destroy the things which is created by god.

DisAgree [1] Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse

Raghavendra Holla, udupi

@shahnawaz - Just wanted to clarify couple of things here regarding shahnawaz comments. First of all it wa not me who hurt the pregnant cow but shahnawaz himself. He just came from dubai for a vacation and see this cow wandering in the road. He and his son and some relatives goes out and try to drag the cow inside their compound. Meantime his son has a sickle and he try to chop the cow's leg and that's when the cow started mooing. We all came out(i am actually 5 houses across) and seeing the bleeding animal we took shahnawaz to task and questioned him. Mean time some of his neighbours had seen the whole thing and they called police who came and arrested his son and took the cow to a hospital..right now shahnawaz has gone hiding fearing the wrath of RSS/BD

DisAgree [1] Agree Reply Report Abuse

Vera Alvares, Mumbai

Every word Mr. Shahnawaz Kukkikatte says it true! Why is BJP unconcerned about the backlash it receives from the Minorities regarding its anti-Minority policies? Because this party believes in enticing one specimen from the Minority community with wealth and power and uses him as a puppet on a string to mouth the word that its masters utter! And the poor puppet like the Muslim face of BJP, truly believes that HE is on his way to power and riches! How foolish can one get? In India the 'Divide and Rule' policy has been used from ancient times. And ONE CHRISTIAN or MUSLIM DOES NOT represent all community. It is a strtegy by that one disgruntled element from the community either to get into limelight, which he never hopes to get otherwise or to get back at members of his parent community which he cannot do otherwise!!
Do not get me wrong! Some of us Christians voted for aBJP candidate in one election becaus e the Congress candidate( the party we normally vote for ) was CORRUPT beyond limit. In comparison this BJP candidate was people-friendly, with a good track record of service to all, kept away from any persecution of Minorities....like some said" a right person in the wrong party" ! But we need to have a clear perception and differentiate between the party's riff-raff persecuting Minorities and the sane elements in the party disownng the fringe groups and their activites.... have you ever heard the BJP top brass endorsing Violenc eagainst Minorities?NO?

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

shahnawaz kukkikatte, dubai/udupi

Mr Montorio only represents BJP and not christians and other minorities. He is not the representative of dalits. He is an undercover agent of BJP who has sold himself. His statement has no value or appeal. He is just making irresponsible statement only to create controversy and stay in limelight. Mr Monterio, can you please tell me are you eating beef. I think your parents too must have fed you beef dishes. I have seen a brahmin neighbour of mine, who performs daily pooja, circumblates tulasi, chants vedic mantras daily morning, has chooped of the leg of a pregnant cow. The offence is it has grazed inside his compound. I heard the yelling sound of cow and ran out of my house only to find the bleeding cow in pain. I questioned him, why he is so cruel to the dumb animal and he is supposed to worship it, he told me "sahebre, dana shastriya devaru aadare vastyavadalli adu ondu prani, nanna garden thinda pranige nanu shikshe koduthene. After some time there was a fight between the owner of the cow and this bhat. (Raghavendra Holla). The cow slaughter ban is nothing but political hindutva and not actual hindutva. With the help of this ban, sangh parivar wants to terrorise and touble muslims, christians and dalits of this state. A murderer gets punishment of 2-4 years with Rs 2-3000 fine. But a fine of Rs 50000 and 7 years jail for consuming beef. Just look at the motive. I am sure we may have to build new jails to accommodate offenders who are mostly from major community.Disgusting

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Eric Coelho, Mangalore/Ajman

The BJP Political Leaders are jumping on their seat after passing the Anti Cow Slaughter in Assembly. We need to see whether the Governor will accept it as many organisations have met the Governor not to accept the Bill. Lets wait and watch.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Valson Mendonsa, Mangalore/USA

What this PEANUT is talking about, probably his NUT is too loose. It happenes when COCKROACHES get new wings it try to fly like EAGLE but Eagle eats up cockroaches moment it sees it.Take it easy.. these are all petty things.

DisAgree Agree [1] Reply Report Abuse