Mangalore: 833 DK Illegal Religious Structures to Go


Mangalore: 833 DK Illegal Religious Structures to Go

Mangalore, Sep 27 (DHNS): The district, known for religious centres, will be losing a huge number of religious structures if the Supreme Court's order to demolish temples, churches, mosques and other religious institutions located in public places, which fall under unauthorised religious construction list, is implemented. 

As per the documents available with Deccan Herald, 833 places of worship in Dakshina Kannada alone have been listed for demolition.

At 640, temples constructed unauthorisedly constitute an overwhelming majority of the 833 constructions identified for demolition, while 151 mosques, 32 churches and 10 Jain temples have also made the first list.

According to the statistics available at Revenue Department's office, approximately 350 acres of land in the district is occupied by illegal religious structures out of which 294 acres of land is occupied by temples or prayer halls.

Bantwal taluk tops the list with 382 unauthorised constructions, while Moodbidri taluk has the least - 23.

After receiving the circular from the DC’s office various religious organisations have started holding meetings and have also submitted plea to the Deputy Commissioner in this regard.

“We are quite apprehensive about the notice received from DC’s office ordering the religious institution authorities to vacate the building with in a week of receiving notice.

As there are lot of temples in the district with a history of 500-600 years, it is a matter of our concern now. We are not even sure about where to relocate the religious centres,” said Hindu Jana Jagruti Vedike Co-ordinator Ramesh Nayak.

When contacted Deputy Commissioner V Ponnuraj he said the State Government had directed the district administration to complete all the process i.e. removing, relocating and regularising the unauthorised constructions before December 31, 2010.

Ponnuraj said the fate of the religious structures will be decided based on certain parameters. Further he added that the committee will start its process within next 15 days and the case study work will be finished at the earliest.

“As we are required to study each construction case by case, it would take more than the allotted time to complete the work. However, the decision to demolish construction will be taken after the study, based on certain guidelines,” he said.

To study the cases, a District Level committee has been formed comprising the Deputy Commissioner, MCC Commissioner, district and taluk pachayat officers, Superintendent of Police, PWD Executive Engineer and Assistant Commissioner among others.

Parameters

*  Structures would be demolished If it is built on major and minor roads, or on drains.
*  Structure will be demolished or relocated if the structure has been troubling the social and religious harmony of the location.
*  If the religious centres belonging to two communities have been set up in near by places and are causing communal problem, they will bedemolished.
 

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Tajuddin, Udupi / Muscat

    Sat, Oct 02 2010

    well said..

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dr. Ramani S., Mangalore/U.S.A.

    Sat, Oct 02 2010

    THE PRAMETERS PROPOSED ARE VERY GOOD WHICH DESERVE PUBLIC SUPPORT IN THE BEST INTEREST OF OUR COUNTRY, PEACEFUL EXISTENCE, RESPECTING OUR LEGAL SYSTEM WHICH IS INDIA'S ONLY SURVIVING AND THE BEST INSTITUITION IN THE DEMOCRATIC SYSTEM.

    LET US, PLEASE, KEEP POLITICS AWAY FROM RELIGION AND LET US SHOW THAT WE ARE MATURED AND PROUD TO BE IN THE 21ST CENTURY

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Gilbert D'Souza, Madanthyar, B'lore

    Sat, Oct 02 2010

    The question here is about un-authorised constructions and not about religion. As a Catholic, I appeal to the Church and Catholics to remove all un-authrised constructions without waiting for the geverment to pull it down. We can also take action, to remove any obstruction on the road, footpath or any other public place, errected in the past, to honour any saint or otherwise. Let us be ' Catholics ' forebearers of a new thought without looking at what other religions do. It is their look out, no christian need to comment on their way of thinking or belief. Every Parish may be authorised by the Bishop to take appropriate action. There is enough at home, to be put in order, by following the teachings of the LORD.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • M.Bhat, Mumbai

    Thu, Sep 30 2010

    Dinesh Devadiga, Mangalore, Sharjah
    I want to know who is hiding behind dinesh devadiga's name. I have not insulted any religion as you have presumed to be, but have highlighted the virtues and glory of hinduism to public and hinduism teaches to its followers etc. Read it again if you have understood it. please at least be bold to write using your own name

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Dinesh Devadiga, Mangalore, Sharjah

    Wed, Sep 29 2010

    I sincerely feel that donfrank's comments are correct. It is true that Mr. M. Bhat has insulted the Non-Hindu religions. All religions are great but of some followers are bad. If All Hindus were good, then there should not have any communal disturbance in our country. Why did the Hindu fanatics destroy he Babri Masjid in 1992? Why did they attack Christian Churches in the Coastal districts of Karnataka in 2008. Why are the Hindu fanatics creating terror? We Hindus should feel ashamed about these criminal acts. First of all let all people live in harmony and peace.

    But the ground reality is different. Some fundamentalist fores have brainwashed the peace loving people of some major religions in India to go for violence. I blame the RSS/VHP/BD groups for bringing bad name to Hindu religion. Unfortunately, many people believe these monsters and that is why there is so much of hatred in our country.

    We live in a civilized world. Just because we are a majority religion, we should not force our ideology/religion/mythology on others. Let us live in a peaceful atmosphere. By glorifying a particular ideology,we can not reach anywhere. I want everyone to say this following prayer 'Eshwar Allah tere nam, sabko sanmathi de bagvan'

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Don, Mangalore

    Wed, Sep 29 2010

    All this talk about God and religion is not from God but people's own imagination. God has created life and bestowed us to live the life to the full extent and enjoy the same ofcourse without harming the other fellow beings. God doesn't need prayers and prayer halls. He just wants us to be fair to each other. Do not waste your time and money in worshipping something which you yourselves created. Use your intelligence, money and resources to make peoples life comfortable. Don't bother about comfort after death which no one has seen and will ever see. It is just the imagination and stupidity. Crowd behaviour of the highest order.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Marie, Mangalore

    Tue, Sep 28 2010

    Anamika has given the right explanation to Mr. Bhat's comments. Well done Anamika.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Fills, Mangalore/Dubai

    Tue, Sep 28 2010

    @ M.Bhat, Mumbai ha ha ha…Ur comment rocks!!. u r a kool dude..

    Just clarify one thing.. which are those religions teach to pray only for the people of their own religion!!?? FYKI there are many reasons to think that all the religions teach the same thing. First, they all believe in God and that God created all the human beings. Second, all the religions believe in Hell and Heaven. They are also teaching the same rules about prayer, forgiving people and giving to poor people.

    @ nagesh nayak, Bangalore.. ha ha ha.. could’nt control my laugh reading your comment.. u need a break.. seriously..

    How can anyone comment so much crap?

    M.bhat aur Nagesh mamu kiiii JAIIIIIII

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rajesh, Mangalore

    Tue, Sep 28 2010

    donfrank, Mangalore, UAE
    Does your comment about Mr.M.Bhat Mumbai make any sense?. Grow up wise before writing useless things here. you need to learn more about your relgion than others about theirs. you lack wisdom

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Renny Lobo (Rodrigues), Gurpur Kaikamba/ Abu Dhabi

    Tue, Sep 28 2010

    Satish- Wish all humans in general and readers on this website in particular, have broad minded views like you so that peace and harmony may prevail.Few like Nagesh, who only knows to spit venom.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • RR, Mangalore

    Tue, Sep 28 2010

    Mr.Bhat,Mumbai always comments rightly.Only secularist pretenders can't digest his words.There are few half baked comnetors write here for the sake of writting.Face is index of mind like-wise one's writtings are reflexion of his mindset! Nothing could be done.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • kc, Mangalore

    Tue, Sep 28 2010

    Mr. Nagesh Nayak,
    Its very sad that U being a Indian dont have any respect our Supreme Court decision's. Shame to you being an Indian.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Satish Kunder, Mangalore/Kuwait

    Tue, Sep 28 2010

    Faith and religion should be a private matter and there is no need to make it an emotive issue. Now the worship places are not created by god but by the human beings themselves.If some worship places are coming on the way of development it can always be shifted to another place.

    We can find god everywhere and let us look for it in other human being. As Gandhiji said “Jana Seveye Janardhana Seve” . Let us help the society with a bit we can and God will be happier than worhipping him in the middle of road creating inconvenience to the mankind.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • M.Bhat, Mumbai

    Tue, Sep 28 2010

    @ Donfrank Dubai - My knowledge about hindusim is limited as said by you. But no wonder this is the religion most democratic, do not hate any other religion or anything in the world. This is basically peace loving,non-aggressive, open to external criticism with open mind, WITHOUT BEING easily provocated. its ready to accept any " Good" from any corner of the universe without hesitation. ("Aa noo bhadhraaha kratavoo .............vishwathaha") and accepts every one and everything with love,may be believers, non believers, friends or foes equivally - " Samaha shatrau cha mitre cha ......... Samam savEshu UtEshu .........etc) it also teaches effectively all the branches of spirituality, main being "JNYANA, BHAKTHI, VAIRAAGYA. This is probably only religion to teach with vast explanations about "Sanyasa" and so on much more. on the flip side this religion is politically most exploited very freely in India almost with no resistance and has been victim of false propaganda elsewhere, especially among the people of other religions. You have not mentioned that Hinduism not only cares about human beings but about all creations of GOD in universe. Hindus always pray for well being of all the things including flora and fauna. This point is overlooked by many scholars.

    You are right. However It is inherently hidden in "Samam ServEshu bhUthEshu" "Bhuta" broadly means every thing that has taken birth or visible or evrything which has incarnated from invisible form to visibl

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Jaimini P.B., Manipal,Sharjah

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Mr.Keshav Puttur,Yes..I am not so good in History.But I know that my knowledge about heart and minds of different religion is better.Babri Masjid demolition changed the face of India.It gave a breakthrough for Pakistan to brainwash Indian Muslims.And you know some fanatic relgious people joined hands with pakistan and bombed in railway,bustand and market..finally Mumbai Taj.If VHP ,RSS OR Shivsena had not demolished Babri,then it would have been impossible for PAK to divide Indian Muslims mind. Hope you understand.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Michael, Mangalore/Bantwal

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Firstly, I agree what Mr. Bhat has written. Those who oppose it, seem to be ignorant. Please read. You will wonder!!(Please don't believe those who write something here in their comments).

    Secondly, the judgement by Supreme court is good and need to be implemented. But I am 100% sure that our politicians will demolish churches and temples. But not other structures!! That is for sure. Wait for the drama to unfold. This is our India!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • donfrank, Mangalore, UAE

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Mr. M.Bhat does not have proper knowledge of any religion, including Hinduism. Let him come to any Mosque, Gurudwara and Church, and see how people pray there. His narrow mindedness about Non-Hindu religions will increase hatred among the followers of different religions. As far as the Supreme Court's order for removing the illegal religious structures is concerned, as true citizens of India, we have to accept it. Secularism and democracy do not mean you can do whatever you want. Everyone has to respect the Law of the Land.You have got to follow rules and regulations. Jai Hind.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Nicholas, Niddodi/U.A.E.

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Welcome to the good move, any place of worship disturbing the public or objecting to roads which are meant for public should be demolished. Let us accept the decision of government to whom we elected. Every faithful person should give their consent to Govt's rules & regulations. Let them go a head. We want to see rather straight n wide roads, greenery n flower plants at road side, and a good infra structure. If we want to make south canara a model district, everyone of us has to work together giving hand in hand. Please follow government's decision who are for general public's welfare, remember that no elected government go against the public for sure. Unless we prepare our hearts to be temple of God, it is useless to worship God within a structure build by human being. For that reason it is important to follow certain rules set by the Goverment for social to meet general public's welfare. Let goverment do their duty and the public will see the beauty, of South Canara District may be after a decade. Please don't object the decision of Government.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • AMAR NATHAL, MANGALORE

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Nagesh Nayak seem to suggest law of the gungle. Why speak about churches and mosques? If we don't respect the judiciary, then we can not uphold democracy. May be Nagesh does not believe in democracy but in goodagiri. Jai Ho!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Clara Lewis, Kemmannu/Dubai

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Supreme court should not demolish the illegal religious structures, but they should prevent future illegal religious structures by implementing strict law. Incase any of the present religious structure obstruct the infrastructure, then Government should provide them suitable place to move. God, religion, worship places, religious leaders are very sensitive matters to handle.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Felix F.,, India/Ksa

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    If a day comes when there will be common prayer houses irrespective of one`s religion, it can be said people are civilised and people can be said to have understood the message of God.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rajesh, Barbados

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Looking at the numbers, I feel its destruction of Hindu culture and prayer halls relatively other religious places are safe as recently constructed at a safer place. Nepal was the first and now India. Every time it was by an outsider but now us. we will see a lot more, but you and me have a place to place our god either a prayer hall at home or with in ourself. ….that’s why we defer from others by having a heart of gold!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Edward R. Monteiro, Kulshekar, mangalore

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Sheldon Pinto, Mangalore/Dubai: You being in Dubai and making comments show that you have not understand the contents of the matter. The order of the Supreme Court is welcome and Final and has to be accepted by all. Supreme Court is only the succor to the common citizen of this Country. The Supreme Court Order is to demolish the unauthorized constructions of religious places in public places and not all and everything. This order has to be accepted by all in India and binding and the respective State Governments have to implement it. Secularism of this Country does not mean that you can do anything and everything by causing obstructions, nuisance and hindrance to the public and public property. Religion is a private affair of the individual. Even the Fundamental Rights enshrined in the Constitution of India are not Absolute and they are subject to reasonable restrictions. You should know this. Let us not make comments on Supreme Court Order, instead understand the context in which the order has been passed by the Apex Court which is the highest Judicial Authority in India. Jai Hind.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • francis w lobo, Mangalore/Kuwait

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    They will demolish such religious centers, after some time the same land will alloted to some political leaders sons name or builders by some currupt minister.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • A.S.Mathew, U.S.A.

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Other countries have zoning laws,
    and the public can't build whatever
    they want to do without
    proper permission from the county
    of city authorities.

    But in India, since we are perhaps
    the most religious people in the
    world, the tendency to build
    religious monuments by the roadside
    and every street corner became an
    obsession for all to establish
    their religious influence.

    There is an underlying catch in
    every religious placemoney
    collecting bag in a safe place.

    So, in a lot of small temporary
    sheds of religious places, some
    business minded individuals played
    the trick to establish their
    business through the diguise of
    "religion".

    The destruction of religious places
    is going to be a hot issue for some ultra religious people.

    Many roadside religious places create accidents, so these places
    are turning like butcher shops of
    human beings? Is God interested
    in killing the human beings?

    All religious places must be
    put in the right location without
    causing problems to the public,
    also, it should't be in in the
    public property. Let the government allocate the vacant
    public property to the homeless
    people to build their shelter
    through government or private
    support.

    If a person found happiness to have
    a religious place in his or her
    own property, let them do so, but
    it should not create traffic
    bottleneck and death.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Peter Pereira, Pune

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    M.Bhat, Mumbai has vast knowledge of his religion. However, he has forgotten one basic princile of his religion - religious tolerance. In his comments, he tries to degrade other religions. Mr. Bhat, no religion is bad, but, the followers of religion may be bad. Better approach some religious scholars for more knowledge Mr. Bhat.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • aboobaker uppala, uppala/Holy Makkah

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    SHREEMAN BHAT,SHALL I TAKE YOUR COMMENT AS A BIG JOKE? THERE IS A FAMOUS SAY OF GHALIB IN HINDI"HINDUSTHAN MEIN JAAHILON KI KOI KAMI NAHIN..EK DOONDO HAZAAR MILENGE". SINCE YOU ARE IN BOMBAY, I DONT THINK IT NEED ANY EXPLAINATION. IF YOU ARE NOT EDUCATED ENOUGH ABOUT THE OTHER RELIGION.PLEASE DONT COMMENT ON IT.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • felix, Mangalore, Karnataka

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Mr. Nayak, now dont tell this has done by the Madam............

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • STALIN MISQUITH, MANGALORE/BAHRAIN

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    JUST MONEY MAKING SCAMS....BJP GOVT SHOULD START TO COUNT THEIR DAYS.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Bulsam, Mangalore

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    All the religions are surviving based on truth and not on false foundation. Those illegal religious structures had come up out of nothing. They identify a strategic spot in a locality and slowly start erecting structure in that spot. Later they will keep a Hundi-box to generate income thro’ donations from god-fearing people in that locality. If you are true believer of any faith then you should support the Govt proposal to demolish such public obstructions in the name religion. Create a strong belief in your heart and fear God before doing anything wrong. That is what religion is all about and not by attacking a fellow human being, his religious structure or hurting his religious sentiments in the name of religion for the religious supremacy. Pseudo protector of religion like Hindutva of India, Al-Qaida of Pakistan and ADRIAN of Michigan (USA) are cheating the people in the name of religion.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • anamika, Mangalore

    Mon, Sep 27 2010


    Hi,Mr.Bhat Mumbai..are you serious or just joking?? If serious then i need to say some thing. The sarve jano sukhino bavanthu and vasudha eva kutumbakam are just in the sripture and vedas and not practiced in the real life. The meaning of these phrases are correct. But who wishes Sarve jano sukhino bhavanthu now a days?? If any one really wishes this phrase then there wouldn't have existed Nityananda swami, vajranada swami nitya chaithnya yathi etc.. these so called people prefered to enjoy their life by misusing the trust of other innocent hindus.. Even the great god mans of your community are not ready to wish "Sarve Jana sukhino Bhavanthu" how you can expect from other ordinary people. Now comes your second point Vasudha eva kutumbakam "this phrase sounds very nice.But remember, where this phrace took birth and in which community it took birth, a lot of caste system, creed system and untouchability prevails. Are you ready to invite a dalit to your pooja room to have a common pooja? or can a brahmin will sit along with so called un touchables?? so where is your vasudhaa eva Kutumbakam?? my friend all these are in your vedas and puranaas.Your accusation about other religion is mere reflection of your poor knowledge of it's teachings. If any person not following the real teachings of the religion, then the particular person has to blame and not the religion or community in whole.A car is not responsible for an accident but the driver who droves it.Think positively

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Keshava, Puttur

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Jaimini, I believe you are in your teens or else you lack knowledge in history. You know only what happened 20years earlier. You do not know what was the cause for that incident. So better learn history first.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sameer, M'lore/Bahrain

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Well said Mr.M.Bhat,correctly said Hindu religion is the greatest of all.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Salim, Dubai / Udupi

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    This I have to see to believe it, No way this is going to happen. Places of worship are the biggest source where money can be laundered without any hassles, Every major Temple, Mosque, Gurdwara, and church is backed by some powerful Politicians or local goon who use it as a front for laundering money. Implementation of this ruling is next to impossible, God might give a audience to us, but cleaning up of this mess. NO WAY.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Peramogaru Mammadaka , Nellyady

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    human broke one.god brokes 833.this is real jadgement for think all the people who fights about God.unfortunately rhis people not obey & follow to gods rules.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sheldon Pinto, mangalore /dubai

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    I dont think the order is good enough India is known for its Secular Diversity India is represented by its culture and religious faith and destroying these places of worship will harm it a lot South Canara undivided it self is a religious hub the fact says 833 Places to demolish so how many place are there in total, and these places also represent our History for eg-: temples that are 600 years old or Churches that are 200 years old by distroying these places we are also destroying our history, people development doesnot happen by destroying the past. I hope the the SC will think about there Parameters before taking anysteps and hurting our history our culture and yes Sentiments

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Kiran D'Souza, Mangalore/Paris

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Sadly, we dont have space for our gods in our hearts............therefore our gods need temples, bastis, mosques and churches...........

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Salim, Dubai / Udupi

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Mr.Bhat Mumbai your knowledge about other religion is very poor,get educated yourself first.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ananth Shenoy, Mysore

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    The Govt should go ahead with demolition of illegal temples, darghas and other religious structure that obstruct free movement of citizens. I've always wondered if any sufi or a saint died in a road accident which prompted the fanatics to construct a mosque/temple (or is it called templet!) in the middle of the road/footpath! we can spare small structures and shrines below banyan trees as it acts as a guardian to the nature. should make Banyan tree as our heritage tree.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • John Tauro, Mangalore / Kuwait

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Please confirm whether Moodbidri is now a taluk. A few months back there was agitation that Mulki should be given taluk status but the issue is still pending.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Lawrence Saldanha, Kanajar/Kuwait

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Dear friends,

    All religious books must be converted to religious Text Books governed by a body of religious intellectuals (not blind theologians) after deleting the unsceintific & irrational content from it and all places of worship must be converted to public religious schools. Whoever wants to join whichever school for his spiritual education can do so at ease.

    Let him or her be free to take a doctorate in any religion while those who want to know the basics of any religion for the purpose of aligning their lives, let them attend elementary classes and start perusing their lives. This is the ideal way forward for the mankind.

    It is absolutely wrong to believe that God can be influenced by our volatile stereotype worship or by glorifying him publicly through road shows. Also it is wrong to ask God for personal favors. That is the way one can worship Satan, who may be able to grant your desires in this world. The Almighty God can only give you eternal life provided that you have lived upto his expectations in this short preparatory life. Amen.

    Regards
    Lawrence Saldanha, Kanajar

    Idol worship, unsceintific beliefs, irrational faith, distinct religious identities, road shows and stereotype worship are some of the universal evils existing in different religions perhaps at varying proportions causing the friction in the society. Unless we resolve to remove some of these evils from our own religion, we will never get anywhere close to Almighty God.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • RTN MICHAEL MATHIAS SHIRVA ROTARY, PILAR SHIRVA

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    This is the order of court .  We should abide byt the law

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Tasmeer, Mangalore

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Think Logically,Temples are more because the population of hindus are more in india.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • anamika, Mangalore

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Hi,Mr.Bhat Mumbai..are you serious or just joking?? If serious then i need to say some thing. The sarve jano sukhino bavanthu and vasudha eva kutumbakam are just in the scripture and vedas and not practiced in the real life. The meaning of these phrases are correct. But who wishes Sarve jano sukhino bhavanthu now a days??

    If any one really wishes this phrase then there wouldn't have existed Nityananda swami, vajranada swami nitya chaithnya yathi etc.. these so called people prefered to enjoy their life by misusing the trust of other innocent hindus.. Even the great god mans of your community are not ready to wish "Sarve Jana sukhino Bhavanthu" how you can expect from other ordinary people. Now comes your second point Vasudha eva kutumbakam "this phrase sounds very nice.

    But remember, where this phrase took birth and in which community it took birth, a lot of caste system, creed system and untouchability prevails. Are you ready to invite a dalit to your pooja room to have a common pooja? or can a brahmin will sit along with so called un touchables?? so where is your vasudhaa eva Kutumbakam?? my friend all these are in your vedas and puranaas.Your accusation about other religion is mere reflection of your poor knowledge of it's teachings.

    If any person not following the real teachings of the religion, then the particular person has to blame and not the religion or community in whole.A car is not responsible for an accident but the driver who droves it.Think positively

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • William, Bantwal

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    We will wait and see which churches, temples and other religious places. If really disturbs people then Ok,else we have to file a petition against it.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Jaimini P.B., Manipal,Sharjah

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    One DEMOLITION of a religious place divided the heart of Indians 20 years ago. Injury mark is still there and will be there forever.Now 833 religious structures ..ABBAA !!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Vincy, Shamboor/Bangkok

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    The need of the hour is wide roads, developments and jobs for people.These temples, churches and mosque should go. They can be demolished and built on mountains any time. The religions cannot solve the problems of unemployment and poverty. This is 2010 and we are on globalization era and we have crores of people who can’t afford a meal. But what is the point in Supreme court order?, who will implement them? Instead our political parties will create a new issue on the saving the structures.
    All you people who support old structures should drive once from Moodbidri to Alangar, the hundred years old buildings are just on the middle of highway.

    I don’t mean that they should be demolished. I don’t mean to hurt your sentiments but do you think the Gods will be angry if you move them inside and make way for the roads?

    We should follow the example of china in making roads for the public and we should see how fast they created roads and moved the old structures and compensated the temples by building new temples with good road margin.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • William, Bantwal

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Living a good life is the main motive of all people.We depend on God's mercy & love. So we live with our brothers & sisters. Our goal & destiny is going back from where we have come.Killing or doing any harm to anybody is foolishness.We are unnecessarily endangering our own souls.No one has right to kill anybody because his blood is crying to God.Terrorists,Jihadis,Gay, Lesbians,prostitutes, adulterers,divorcees,murderers,robbers/thieves,atheists,suiciders, will go to hell. 60-70 years life is nothing compared to eternal death with suffering in hell. Now is the time to read relious books and live accordingly.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Peter Pereira, Pune

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Mr. M. Bhat, I advocate your view. Hinduism is very beautiful religion. I wish Hindus will practice what is taught instead of cutting the belly of pregnant woman and burning of foetus, as was in Godhra case.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Annapoorna Kamath, Mannagudde

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    India is a great example for unity among diversity. People of all religions have lived together peacefully for centuries. The religious hatred is of recent origin started some political parties for their selfish ends. People should not get carried away with religious fanaticism. Be it hindus, christians, muslims or sikhs, we are all Indians. Religion and states should not matter to us.

    Let us live peacefully without disturbing peace and one another. It goes without saying that temple bells, church bells, mosque loud speakers, late night religious functions should be monitored so that they do not disturb others. We don't have to fight for this, there has to a peaceful solution. Please note fights will not have any end and does not benefit anyone except the politicians.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Shoukath Hussain, Surathkal

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    People, lets not fight among ourselves. No one is referring to temples or churches. The law is referring to illegally built religious institutions. Let us not be narrow minded fanatics. Let the law take its course.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • azeez, azeez vorkady

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Very  good order by supreme court,another thing,all public carrier vehicles remove such symbols...all Indians are my brothers and sisters

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • M.Bhat, Mumbai

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Whenever I passby any Temple or Church i get the feeling of existence of GOD at such religious places. Hindu is the only religion to pray for the whole universe irrespective of any religion cast or creed for living and so called nonliving things too. "LOkaa Samastaa Suhkinoo Bhavanthu" Here "Lokaa" means every plannets of the universe.
    2. Hindu is the only religion to say "Vasudhaa Eva Kutumbakam" - this is an advice to treat the whole earth as a family.

    On the other hand - some other religions pray no doubt, but only for the people of their own religion. Still some other religions believe that "OTHER THAN THEIR RELIGIONS" do not have any right to live in this earth. That is not the end, even they believe to kill, butcher, and eliminate all other religions is their duty, and by doing so they are blessed by their GOD !.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Harold D'cunha, Mangalore, India

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Wessel, the question these tress or place of worship on the road side is hindering the infra structure or not. If it hinders then it should be relocated. So it has to be handled wisely.
    In our state while widening the road what the contractors know is to cut the existing trees.
    When something happens to others we donot get pain but when it happens to oneself it is painful as one has sentiments attached to it.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Wessel, singapore/mangalore

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Most of the road side Banyan trees were turned into place of worship, I hope while demolishing the these structures, they wont cut those trees.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • SATHISH, mangalore

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Alwyn , Mangalore - USA i agree with you .even the church bells and temple bells ringing should stop every sunday it spoils my sleep :)

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Harold D'cunha, Mangalore, India

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Good order by the Supreme Court. But people are first and then the law. Wish DC will use the wisdom before tackling the situation.
    Unless it affect the roads and infra sturcture, please donot hurt the sentiment of the people.
    Trees which block the infra sturcture should be demolished but religious places of worship request to relocate.
    Let's everybody come and live in harmony. All structure existed before 1st November 1956 should be made legal provided they are not blocking the infra sturcture.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Jason, mangalore

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Excellent order! The law should be same for everyone. All illegal structures breed illegal sources of income and twisted knowledge. All illegal structures need to come down - hindu, muslim, christian or jain.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • GEORGE PAIS, URWA

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Removing or demolishing is ceratinly a ticklish one.
    Deputy commissioners concernd should again convene a public meeting of all religions and emphsize on them to remove all the d illigal structures or places on their own and give them a reasonable time instead of using government machinery to do so.
    This will earn the goodwill of the people at large and avoid opposition from public.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Altaf Mohammad, Mangalore/KSA

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Good order by Supreme Court. It should be implemented strictly without politicising the issue and relevent community should be taken into confidence while uting the plan. Hope the list includes the structures which are in the middle of the road in many places.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Santhosh Bhandary, surathkal/Dubai

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    This will uphold our democratic principles and the secular fabric of our country. No one should obstruct the decision of the judiciary. All religions are equal as per law and all are equally responsible if encroachment has been done. There is no place for fear or favour. We should stand by the supreme court order and also support our DC in its implementation.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ISMAIL K PERINJE, PERINJE/YANBU-KSA

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    JUSTIFIABLE PARAMETERS.IN THE EYES OF LAW ALL ARE EQUAL.WHAT THE RULE OF LAND SAYS THAT IS JUSTICE.LAW WILL TAKE IT'S OWN COURSE.DC SAHEBA IMPLEMENT WITH OUT FEAR OR FAVOR.

    BY THE BY I HAVE NO CLEAR IDEA WHEN MOODBIDRI BECAME A 'TALUK'??

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • shahnawaz kukkikatte, dubai/udupi

    Mon, Sep 27 2010

    Supreme court thinks, acts and rules supreme. The govt land belongs to public and no public property is to be allowed to build any places of worship. All illegal and encroached land must be made vacant and only clear titled places of worship are to be allowed. Nowadays, people build places of worships on road sides not out of love or piety, but to generate funds and fool the innocent followers. A very great decission by the supreme court.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • prasanna, mangalore

    Sun, Sep 26 2010

    plz people why build more places of worship, when there are enough already? if u do want to get some blessings then donate to some orphanage or buy some poor kid books.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • nagesh nayak, bangalore

    Sun, Sep 26 2010

    THIS IS NOTHING BUT TARGET ON HINDU TEMPLES. IF NUMBER OF CHRUCHES & MOSQUES ARE MORE NO ONE TALKAS ABOUT ILLEGAL STRUCTURES .

    HINDUS SHOULD UNITE & NOT TO ALLOW ANY DEMOLITION SINCE TEMPLES ARE THERE SINCE MORE THAN 500 YEARS OLD ALSO.

    JAI SHRI RAM.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Alwyn , Mangalore - USA

    Sun, Sep 26 2010

    Good order by Supreme Court. It should be implemented very strictly and sincerely. Religious or worship places should not be disturbed to the publics. Many places religious activities are taking place with out permission of the authorities, which was leading many riots. Even loud speakers should be banned in residential areas and if any one wants to keep for some vocation or religious celebration, they must get permission from authorities. Peace, Law and Order can be maintained only when there is No Partiality, NO Favors and NO Bribes. Hope our D.C. will do the good job in this matter.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Mangalore: 833 DK Illegal Religious Structures to Go



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.